History YMMV / MagickChicks

%%* EvilIsSexy: [=DarkSkye=], for some parts of the fandom.

** There was also speculation about whether Faith was mind-controlling the students at Artemis, in order to seduce them; causing some [[UnfortunateImplications to question whether any of her trysts could be considered consensual.]] It was eventually revealed that her powers had sync'd with the school, due to her subconscious desire to be loved. But since [[ThisCannotBe she hadn't been]] [[http://www.magickchicks.com/strips-mc/even_her_enemies aware of it]], many readers felt it couldn't be rightly held against her.

%%* BrokenBase: The reveal of [[spoiler: [[GenderReveal Rain's true gender]]]] also caused a divide in the forums as well.

* HarsherInHindsight: Remember Sandi's suspicions about [[spoiler: [[http://www.magickchicks.com/strips-mc/way_more_suspicious Skye]]]] and how easily Jacqui dismissed them? I'll bet she's wishing [[spoiler: [[http://www.magickchicks.com/strips-mc/cut_their_heads_off she had listened to Sandi now]]]].
** Cerise's throw away line, [[http://www.magickchicks.com/strips-mc/baconators here]] (about an incident involving a volcano), doesn't seem as funny after she [[spoiler: she claims to have killed Jacqui and the student council [[http://www.magickchicks.com/strips-mc/little_miss_lives_a_lot by teleporting them into one.]]]]

* BrokenBase: The reveal of [[spoiler: [[GenderReveal Rain's true gender]]]] also caused a divide in the forums as well.
* EvilIsSexy: [=DarkSkye=], for some parts of the fandom.
* FridgeBrilliance: Cerise ''did'' overthrow Mel, albeit in [[SpotlightStealingSquad the "meta"]] [[CharacterFocus sense.]]

* AntiShippingGoggles: Tiff/[[Webcomic/EerieCuties Layla]] shippers didn't want to believe Tiffany was attracted to Faith, until the editor[[note]]link to direct quote found in the IfItsYouItsOkay entry, in Tiffany's section of the character sheet[[/note]] and the character herself [[http://www.magickchicks.com/strips-mc/omigawd confirmed it.]]

* MoralEventHorizon: Cerise crossed it in chapter 15, by [[spoiler: exposing Mel and Jacqui as witches]] while they were surrounded by the student council. Then tried to [[spoiler: [[KillEmAll kill all of them]], [[MassTeleportation by teleporting them into a volcano]]]], which included the girl she'd been pretending to date in order to gain popularity. And was too busy [[http://www.magickchicks.com/strips-mc/quite_inspired toasting her success]] to care.

* DarknessInducedAudienceApathy: Some readers didn't care who won between Melissa and Cerise during vol.4's final chapter, since both are shallow, petty, and manipulative. Melissa was simply [[EvilVersusEvil the lesser of two evils]], by virtue of [[NominalHero being the protagonist]] and because of the wand's influence.

** [[TheAce Faith]] eventually became one, herself, after [[spoiler: [[EvilRedhead Cerise]] revealed her popularity was due to [[http://www.magickchicks.com/strips-mc/even_her_enemies Faith's powers syncing with the school]]]]. Which lead her to abdicate her position to Mel. The worse part being, it was unintentional, but she has no way to prove it. So she'll be remembered as the girl who [[spoiler: mindbent the school]], [[NoGoodDeedGoesUnpunished despite pulling a 'hail mary']] [[http://www.magickchicks.com/strips-mc/the_other_half to help save it.]]

* DarknessInducedAudienceApathy: Some readers didn't care who won between Melissa and Cerise during vol.4's final chapter, since both are shallow, petty, and manipulative. Melissa was simply [[EvilVsEvil the lesser of two evils]], by virtue of [[NominalHero being the protagonist]] and because of the wand's influence.

* RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap: Faith is the series' [[BaseBreaker most divisive character]] for several reasons:

* TheScrappy: For those who didn't [[LoveToHate love]] Cerise (noted in the BaseBreaker entry).

* TheWoobie: Callista was [[UnwittingPawn unaware that she was being used]] [[spoiler: by Cerise]], as a stepping stone, on her rise to the [[http://www.magickchicks.com/strips-mc/more_provocative top of Artemis's social ladder.]] So you can imagine how well she took it, when she finally learned the truth. Which happened only moments before [[spoiler: Cerise]] [[YouHaveOutlivedYourUsefulness tried to kill her]], along with the rest of the student council.

* AntiShippingGoggles: Tiff/[[Webcomic/EerieCuties Layla]] shippers didn't want to believe Tiffany was atteacted to Faith, until the editor[[note]]link to direct quote found in the IfItsYouItsOkay entry, in Tiffany's section of the character sheet[[/note]] and the character herself [[http://www.magickchicks.com/strips-mc/omigawd confirmed it.]]

* AntiShippingGoggles: Tiff/[[Webcomic/EerieCuties Layla]] shippers didn't want to believe Tiffany was atteacted to Faith, until the editor[[note]]link to direct quote found in the IfItsYouItsOkay entry, in Tiffany's section of the character sheet[[/note]] and the character herself [[url=http://www.magickchicks.com/strips-mc/omigawd confirmed it.]]

* {{Moe}}: Skye. It's enough that she's a [[WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic Fluttershy]] {{expy}} to begin with but, seriously, [[http://www.magickchicks.com/strips-mc/that_tickles look]] [[http://www.magickchicks.com/strips-mc/taking_a_while at]] [[http://www.magickchicks.com/strips-mc/devoid_of_darkness her!]]

* ShippingGoggles: Tiff/[[Characters/EerieCuties Layla]] shippers didn't want to believe that Tiffany was attracted [[BaseBreaker to Faith]], until the editor[[note]]you can find the quote from Creator/TCampbell in the IfItsYouItsOkay entry in Tiffany's section of the character sheet[[/note]] and the character herself [[http://www.magickchicks.com/strips-mc/forces_of_darkness confirmed it.]]

* RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap: Faith is the series' [[BaseBreaker most divisive character]] for several reaaons:

* BaseBreakingCharacter: Applies to Cerise and Faith, with the latter frequently being [[LoveItOrHateIt the subject of heated debate]] on the comic's official forum.

* BaseBreakingCharacter: Applies to [[EvilRedhead Cerise]] and [[SmugSuper Faith.]], with he latter frequently being [[LoveItOrHateIt the subject of heated debate]] on the comic's official forum.

** Made worse when the series ended with Mel letting her literally get away with [[spoiler: attempted murder]]. You can imagine how well that went with some of the readers.

* BaseBreakingCharacter: ''Magick Chicks'' presents an interesting case between [[EvilRedhead Cerise]] and [[SmugSuper Faith.]]
** Cerise was formerly in this category, starting with [[ChronicBackstabbingDisorder her actions]] in chapter 5. Fans were divided between those who [[LoveToHate loved to hate her]], and those who thought she was a [[SmugSnake smug]] [[ManipulativeBitch manipulative]] backstabber who'd gotten too much focus. But she's become almost [[TheScrappy universally reviled]] after [[spoiler: betraying Mel and Jacqui, by outting them as witches. Then trying to kill them, along with the student council]], [[ItsAllAboutMe all for the sake of]] ''[[EvilIsPetty popularity.]]''
** Then the series ended with Mel letting her literally get away with [[spoiler: attempted murder]]. You can imagine how well that went with some of the readers.