History YMMV / Bobsheaux

* WTHCastingAgency: One of his issues with the ''WesternAnimation/FamilyGuy'' ''Franchise/StarWars'' trilogy is how they cast certain characters.

* TheWikiRule: In-Universe, Bobsheaux is baffled with how [[Series/BarneyAndFriends Barney]] of all franchises has one.

* TheWikiRule: In-Universe, Bobsheux is baffled with how [[Series/BarneyAndFriends Barney]] of all franchises has one.

* BrokenBase: Hooo boy, his "Pixar Theory- DEBUNKED" video is easily his most divisive. On the one hand are a large, very vocal groups of opposers, who have come to love the Pixar theory and argue he's trying to ruin their fun. A small subsection of these opposers don't believe the Pixar theory but consider Bob making a debunking video on it to be a complete waste of time. On the other are viewers long sick of the theory and pleased someone finally stood up to it.

** Bob's review of ''Land Before Time 7, 8, 9, and 10'' starts with him talking about the death of his grandmother. He says that the webcamera he used for his earliest reviews was the one she used to keep in contact with the family during her last few months, and he considers the entire show a tribute to her. He says that the last thing she ever told him was "It could always be worse."

** [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wxpn-oqTwcc All of this]]. Not only did Raven lose her mom, suddenly and without any warning, but Raven and her sister are left to pay for the funeral, and her brother, who pretty much inherited all of ''both'' of their parents wealth, contributes nothing. And when they objected, they were vilified by the entire community as ungrateful daughters who wouldn't bury their mother, which forced them to go against their mother's wishes and cremate her to keep the expenses low. And even ''that'' is too much for her to handle, so she is forced to ask the fans for help. Throughout the entire video, she is on the verge of crying, until she finally breaks into tears during the end.
* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: As well as TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter, he has the tendency to either find come up with a better way a movie could've gone, or finding things that would have told a more interesting story. Amongst others, he says that ''WesternAnimation/FlyMeToTheMoon'' would've been better if the flies were adults who had already lived a long, boring life, or that ''Bailey's Billion$'' should've focused on the opera-singing, dog-loving henchman of the main villain.

* CriticalResearchFailure: On his ''An All Dogs Christmas Carol'' review, he states that Belladonna originated from the sequel before, where in fact she came from the television series. He later apologizes for this mistake.
** In his review of '66 Batman Meets Two Face, he claims that this was the first appearance of Dr. Hugo Strange since his apparent death in the 40's comics. However, Strange had made several appearances in both comics and animation prior to this.
** His review of ''WesternAnimation/TheSwanPrincess'' ends with a chiding of films that blatantly disregard their source material, with a brief TakeThat at ''Film/JusticeLeague2017''. Personal opinions aside, it's more or less agreed upon that ''Justice League'' went out of its way to incorporate as many true-to-text elements as possible.
** In his review for ''WesternAnimation/BatmanAndHarleyQuinn'', Bob points out that S.T.A.R. Labs is based in Central City, not Gotham City. S.T.A.R. Labs made its [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/S.T.A.R._Labs debut in a Superman comic]] and has bases all over America.
** A rather interesting example can be found in his review of ''Help! I'm A Fish''. In the review, he brings up that it would make more sense for Chuck to turn into a dolphin, due to him being characterized as the most intelligent of the kids. Many fans had called Bobsheaux out in the comments section, and that would otherwise be a very normal playing of this trope. However, as many other fans and Bobsheaux himself have also pointed out in the comments, jellyfish, which is actually what Chuck turned into in the aforementioned film, aren't actually fish either; they're cnidarians, classified as such for precisely the same reason Bobsheaux hypothesizes as to why Chuck is transformed into one, they lack a spine.

* BrokenBase: Hooo boy, his "Pixar Theory- DEBUNKED" video is easily his most divisive. On the one hand are a large, very vocal groups of opposers, who have come to love the Pixar theory and argue he's trying to ruin their fun. A small subsection of these opposers actually don't believe the Pixar theory but consider Bob making a debunking video on it to be complete waste of time. On the other are viewers long sick of the theory and pleased someone finally stood up to it.

* BrokenBase: Hooo boy, his "Pixar Theory- DEBUNKED" video is easily his most divisive. On the one hand are a large, very vocal groups of opposers, who have come to love the Pixar theory and argue he's trying to ruin their fun. A subsection of these opposers actually don't believe the Pixar theory but consider Bob making a debunking video on it to be completely pointless. On the other are viewers long sick of the theory and pleased someone finally stood up to it.

* BrokenBase: Hooo boy, his "Pixar Theory- DEBUNKED" video is easily his most divisive. On the one hand are a large, very vocal groups of opposers, who have come to love the Pixar theory and argue he's trying to ruin their fun. On the other are viewers long sick of the theory and pleased someone finally stood up to it.

* NightmareFuel: The wall at the end of his ''Tentacolino'' review.

** A rather interesting example can be found in his review of ''Help! I'm A Fish''. In the review, he brings up that it would make more sense for Chuck to turn into a dolphin, due to him being characterized as the most intelligent of the kids. Many fans had called Bobsheaux out in the comments section, and that would otherwise be a very normal playing of this trope. However, as many other fans and Bobsheaux himself have also pointed out in the comments, jellyfish, which is actually what Chuck turned into in the aforementioned film, are actually fish either; they're cnidarians, classified as such for precisely the same reason Bobsheaux hypothesizes as to why Chuck is transformed into one, they lack a spine.

** In his review of ''Film/ThePageMaster'', he acknowledges that WebVideo/TheNostalgiaCritic had already reviewed the movie. A few days later, the Critic reviewed ''Film/GreenLantern'', which Bob had already reviewed.

** During his review of the book [[Film/CoolCatSavesTheKids Cool Cat Stops Bullying]], some fans of Splatoon probably got a kick out of him singing "[[Disney/{{Frozen}} Do You Wanna Build a Sandcastle?]]"[[labelnote:For context]]The Splatfest for March in North America was "Snowman VS Sandcastle", with members of Team Snowman naturally posting references to Frozen all over Miiverse. Then when the Splatfest concluded, it was Team Sandcastle that ended up winning.[[/labelnote]]

** Raven Fox also seems to be this, if some comments are anything to go by. It helps that she is not only Bob's girlfriend, but has helped behind the scenes as well.

* [[SugarWiki/VisualEffectsOfAwesome Visual Effects of]] CreepyAwesome: Any time he tosses a movie into his box and the box shuts itself. The effect is pretty creepy but also really impressive.$

** His views on El Arca.

* UnfortunateImplications: As some have pointed out in this [[https://www.reddit.com/r/GamerGhazi/comments/6ikb01/maleficent_and_someones_idea_of_a_different_scene/ post]] regarding his ''Film/{{Maleficent}}'' review, his re-written scene about Maleficent confronting Stefan ignores the rape analogy of her mutilation, and can come off as Stefan saying "''Sure it was bad when I mutilated you, but at least you were unconscious! I am the real victim here!''"

* UnfortunateImplications:
** At one point, he raises the question of why anyone would arrange for an animal to be a parent if they're biologically inhibited from becoming one. You don't need to be a doctor to know that your competence and worthiness when it comes to raising children has nothing to do with whether you can physically give birth to them.
** As some have pointed out in this [[https://www.reddit.com/r/GamerGhazi/comments/6ikb01/maleficent_and_someones_idea_of_a_different_scene/ post]] regarding his ''Film/{{Maleficent}}'' review, his re-written scene about Maleficent confronting Stefan ignores the rape analogy of her mutilation, and can come off as Stefan saying "''Sure it was bad when I mutilated you, but at least you were unconscious! I am the real victim here!''"

** At one point, he raises the question of why anyone would arrange for a creature to become a parent when biologically, it’s already impossible for them to become one. At the time, he was referring to mules, but since the question itself doesn’t specify that, it’s easy to infer that he thinks infertile people and even other animals are somehow inferior or unworthy of being able to raise children just because of how they were born.

** As some have pointed out in this [[https://www.reddit.com/r/GamerGhazi/comments/6ikb01/maleficent_and_someones_idea_of_a_different_scene/ post]] regarding his ''Film/{{Maleficent}'' review, his re-written scene about Maleficent confronting Stefan ignores the rape analogy of her mutilation, and can come off as Stefan saying "''Sure it was bad when I mutilated you, but at least you were unconscious! I am the real victim here!''"