Meatball Wants the Mattress

While on their way to Junkyard Kyle-eron's garbage mountain, they encounter Meatball who wants to show them a shortcut to get there and he desperately doesn't want their mattress. Jerromir asks if they should trust him, but Hamdalf points out this is the part of the story where they make a bad decision, so they do and unsurprisingly Meatball leads into a Borc ambush in the mines.

Example of:
Horrible Judge of Character