Follow TV Tropes

Following

History UsefulNotes / TheAmericanCivilWar

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed ZCE and Misused examples


* ''VideoGame/NoGreaterGlory'' is a TurnBasedStrategy in which you try to bring victory to either of the sides of this conflict. [[NintendoHard The key word being 'try.']]

to:

* ''VideoGame/NoGreaterGlory'' is a TurnBasedStrategy in which you try to bring victory to either of the sides of this conflict. [[NintendoHard The key word being 'try.']]



* ''VideoGame/WarOfRights'' is a multiplayer first-person shooter being developed by Danish company Campfire Games. Set during the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maryland_campaign Maryland campaign of 1862]], the game is notable for its meticulous attention to detail when it comes to rendering uniforms, weapons, and battlefields based on how they looked during the era. It's also notorious for its [[NintendoHard heavily grounded]] yet competitive gameplay.

to:

* ''VideoGame/WarOfRights'' is a multiplayer first-person shooter being developed by Danish company Campfire Games. Set during the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maryland_campaign Maryland campaign of 1862]], the game is notable for its meticulous attention to detail when it comes to rendering uniforms, weapons, and battlefields based on how they looked during the era. It's also notorious for its [[NintendoHard heavily grounded]] grounded yet competitive gameplay.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The Confederacy still engenders sympathy in certain states, generally those that rebelled and in some (but not all) border states (Delaware and most of Maryland, for instance, [[OldShame would prefer that you even forget that they were ever seen as Southern]],[[note]]Delaware in particular hates being reminded of this, and Delawareans (all five of them) like to distract people from this historical fact by stressing that when the NAACP ran its full-court press against racial segregation in schools in the series of cases that eventually led to ''Brown v. Board of Education'', the Delaware courts were the only state courts to agree that the practice was unconstitutional.[[/note]] while Kentuckians are perfectly comfortable as firm Southerners; Missouri is more mixed, in keeping with its reputation as a nether-here-nor-there Southern-Midwestern hodgepodge). The American Civil War [[IHaveManyNames carries many names]] partially as a result of this mixed memory: it is "The War of the Rebellion", the "War Between the States", the "Second American Revolution",[[note]]An Unsuccessful one[[/note]], the "War of Southern Treason", the "War of Northern Aggression",[[note]]Which is a strange name for the war considering that the Confederates ''fired the first shot'' in a blatantly aggressive move on Fort Sumter. But then, [[https://deadconfederates.files.wordpress.com/2011/06/googletrendswarofnorthernagression.png it is a comparatively new name, having only gained popularity since the 1950s]] - coincidentally when the UsefulNotes/CivilRightsMovement started making very successful traction. Make of that what you will.[[/note]] "Lincoln's War", the "Slaveholders' Revolt", "The War for Southern Independence", and the "Late Unpleasantness"[[note]]This one is usually tongue-in-cheek[[/note]]-- though rarely, if ever, referred to by any of those names while the war itself was being fought.[[note]]At the outset some Secessionists referred to their cause as the Second American Revolution, a term later used by others for the entire era of the Civil War and Reconstruction. Outside the United States, the preferred term is usually the American Civil War or, in France and Germany, the (American) War of Secession.[[/note]] For much of the 20th century the most popular narrative (especially in the South) was that the war was a misguided but in some ways noble fight for a "Lost Cause" for "Freedom from the Tyranny of Central Government". That narrative was politically useful for purposes of reconciling the two sides and for maintaining white supremacy, but it has increasingly been criticized by scholars, activists, and storytellers who point out that the "freedom" the Confederacy fought and killed for was the "Freedom to Own, Use, and Abuse People as They Saw Fit".\\\

to:

The Confederacy still engenders sympathy in certain states, generally those that rebelled and in some (but not all) border states (Delaware and most of Maryland, for instance, [[OldShame would prefer that you even forget that they were ever seen as Southern]],[[note]]Delaware in particular hates being reminded of this, and Delawareans (all five of them) like to distract people from this historical fact by stressing that when the NAACP ran its full-court press against racial segregation in schools in the series of cases that eventually led to ''Brown v. Board of Education'', the Delaware courts were the only state courts to agree that the practice was unconstitutional.[[/note]] while Kentuckians are perfectly comfortable as firm Southerners; Missouri is more mixed, in keeping with its reputation as a nether-here-nor-there Southern-Midwestern hodgepodge). The American Civil War [[IHaveManyNames carries many names]] partially as a result of this mixed memory: it is "The War of the Rebellion", the "War Between the States", the "Second American Revolution",[[note]]An Revolution"[[note]]An Unsuccessful one[[/note]], the "War of Southern Treason", the "War of Northern Aggression",[[note]]Which is a strange name for the war considering that the Confederates ''fired the first shot'' in a blatantly aggressive move on Fort Sumter. But then, [[https://deadconfederates.files.wordpress.com/2011/06/googletrendswarofnorthernagression.png it is a comparatively new name, having only gained popularity since the 1950s]] - coincidentally when the UsefulNotes/CivilRightsMovement started making very successful traction. Make of that what you will.[[/note]] "Lincoln's War", the "Slaveholders' Revolt", "The War for Southern Independence", and the "Late Unpleasantness"[[note]]This one is usually tongue-in-cheek[[/note]]-- though rarely, if ever, referred to by any of those names while the war itself was being fought.[[note]]At the outset some Secessionists referred to their cause as the Second American Revolution, a term later used by others for the entire era of the Civil War and Reconstruction. Outside the United States, the preferred term is usually the American Civil War or, in France and Germany, the (American) War of Secession.[[/note]] For much of the 20th century the most popular narrative (especially in the South) was that the war was a misguided but in some ways noble fight for a "Lost Cause" for "Freedom from the Tyranny of Central Government". That narrative was politically useful for purposes of reconciling the two sides and for maintaining white supremacy, but it has increasingly been criticized by scholars, activists, and storytellers who point out that the "freedom" the Confederacy fought and killed for was the "Freedom to Own, Use, and Abuse People as They Saw Fit".\\\

Added: 549

Changed: 45

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* Charles Frazier's ''Literature/ColdMountain'', which was also made into a movie.

to:

%%* * Charles Frazier's ''Literature/ColdMountain'', which was also made into a movie.movie, follows a Confederate deserter going home.
* Written in 1863 and set in 1861, ''Literature/CudjosCave'' is a novel of UsefulNotes/TheAmericanCivilWar written during the war by anti-slavery author John Townsend Towbridge. At the outbreak of the war, those who oppose secession and slavery in a small Tennessee community find themselves being victimized by those who favor it. An odd quartet of allies, two white and two black, find themselves hiding in a mountain cave as circumstances gradually give them a chance to rally some like-minded neighbors and strike a blow against the Confederacy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/{{Manhunt}}'' follows the manhunt for UsefulNotes/JohnWilkesBooth following his assassination of UsefulNotes/AbrahamLincoln, with several flashback scenes taking place during the war.

to:

* ''Series/{{Manhunt}}'' ''Series/Manhunt2024'' follows the manhunt for UsefulNotes/JohnWilkesBooth following his assassination of UsefulNotes/AbrahamLincoln, with several flashback scenes taking place during the war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/{{Manhunt}}'' follows the manhunt for UsefulNotes/JohnWilkesBooth following his assassination of UsefulNotes/AbrahamLincoln, with several flashback scenes taking place during the war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup, Natter


** Director John Ford subverted many tropes, though. For instance, the loyal slave servant (Althea Gibson—yes. ''[[UsefulNotes/{{Tennis}} that]]'' Althea Gibson) [[{{Irony}} ends up]] [[spoiler:shot dead by a Confederate bushwhacker]] for her pains) and the SouthernBelle trope turns into comedy where the ladies of Newton Station throw dirt at the Yankee cavalrymen, dirtying themselves in the process. It also turns out that one of Marlowe/Wayne’s men (played by Ford stalwart Hank Worden) knows the area from the time before the war when he helped slaves escape on the Underground Railroad, and a couple of Confederate deserters (who by their very existence counter the trope of always honorable Southern soldiers) boast about their shooting prowess and then mention the time when one of them shot a female runaway slave right between the eyes. The [[ChildSoldiers schoolboys’ action]] is played not as heroic, but equal parts tragedy (there’s a real TearJerker moment when a mother begs the commander to spare her one surviving son and not take him into battle with him) and comedy (the little drummer boy then runs away from home[[note]]Does this imply that [[AnAesop only ignorant children would want to seek martial glory]]?[[/note]] to rejoin his comrades, but is captured by the Northerners who let him go after giving him a spanking). Also, the briefing with Grant and Sherman at the beginning makes it clear that the Marlowe/Wayne’s raid is part of the operations that resulted in one of the great victories of the North, the taking of Vicksburg, and the brigade handsomely wins the two fights against grownup Confederates that it cannot avoid.

to:

** Director John Ford subverted many tropes, though. For instance, the loyal slave servant (Althea Gibson—yes. ''[[UsefulNotes/{{Tennis}} that]]'' Althea Gibson) [[{{Irony}} ends up]] [[spoiler:shot dead by a Confederate bushwhacker]] for her pains) and the SouthernBelle trope turns into comedy where the ladies of Newton Station throw dirt at the Yankee cavalrymen, dirtying themselves in the process. It also turns out that one of Marlowe/Wayne’s men (played by Ford stalwart Hank Worden) knows the area from the time before the war when he helped slaves escape on the Underground Railroad, and a couple of Confederate deserters (who by their very existence counter the trope of always honorable Southern soldiers) boast about their shooting prowess and then mention the time when one of them shot a female runaway slave right between the eyes. The [[ChildSoldiers schoolboys’ action]] is played not as heroic, but equal parts tragedy (there’s a real TearJerker moment when a mother begs the commander to spare her one surviving son and not take him into battle with him) and comedy (the little drummer boy then runs away from home[[note]]Does this imply that [[AnAesop only ignorant children would want to seek martial glory]]?[[/note]] home to rejoin his comrades, but is captured by the Northerners who let him go after giving him a spanking). Also, the briefing with Grant and Sherman at the beginning makes it clear that the Marlowe/Wayne’s raid is part of the operations that resulted in one of the great victories of the North, the taking of Vicksburg, and the brigade handsomely wins the two fights against grownup Confederates that it cannot avoid.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In the North, there is industry and patriotism, and abolitionists decry the evils of slavery from every pulpit. Abraham Lincoln is a pretty popular guy in these parts — he spends most of his time in the Oval Office, brooding over battle maps and writing deep historical speeches on stovepipe hats. Ask him why he’s fighting the war and he’ll tell you it’s to free the slaves. Never mind that this runs contrary what he actually ''said'' when asked during the war[[note]]"My paramount object in this struggle is to save the Union, and is not either to save or to destroy slavery. If I could save the Union without freeing ''any'' slave I would do it, and if I could save it by freeing ''all'' the slaves I would do it; and if I could save it by freeing some and leaving others alone I would also do that."[[/note]]; this is HollywoodHistory, where heroes are pure and their motives always perfectly clear.[[note]]Historians still debate whether this reflects Lincoln's genuine motivations or was pragmatic rhetoric meant to win broader support for the war; even those in the latter camp still agree that "racial equality" was never something Lincoln had in mind. Even among the most strident abolitionists (and Lincoln was a more moderate abolitionist), ''very'' few believed in racial equality. Most agreed with the slaveowners that blacks were a "lower race" than whites, but felt that even the "lowest" of humanity still deserved better than slavery.[[/note]] You’re lucky if you see portrayals of black persons ''at all'' in the North, especially in older media, even though they made up a disproportionate 10% of the Union army by war's end (''Film/{{Glory}}'' being a notable depiction thereof).

to:

In the North, there is industry and patriotism, and abolitionists decry the evils of slavery from every pulpit. Abraham Lincoln is a pretty popular guy in these parts — he spends most of his time in the Oval Office, brooding over battle maps and writing deep historical speeches on stovepipe hats. Ask him why he’s fighting the war and he’ll tell you it’s to free the slaves. Never mind that this runs contrary what he actually ''said'' when asked during the war[[note]]"My paramount object in this struggle is to save the Union, and is not either to save or to destroy slavery. If I could save the Union without freeing ''any'' slave I would do it, and if I could save it by freeing ''all'' the slaves I would do it; and if I could save it by freeing some and leaving others alone I would also do that."[[/note]]; this is HollywoodHistory, where heroes are pure and their motives always perfectly clear.[[note]]Historians still debate whether this reflects Lincoln's genuine motivations or was pragmatic rhetoric meant to win broader support for the war; even those in the latter camp still agree that "racial equality" was never something Lincoln had in mind. Even among the most strident abolitionists (and Lincoln was a more moderate abolitionist), ''very'' few believed in racial equality. Most agreed with the slaveowners that blacks were a "lower race" than whites, but felt that even the "lowest" of humanity still deserved better than slavery. It is worth noting that the Emancipation Proclamation only applied to slaves still in Confederate-controlled territory. That meant slaves in the slave states of Maryland and Kentucky that never left the Union and in mostly reconquered Tennessee were NOT freed by Lincoln's proclamation. Technically it did not free a single slave within Federal territory. It did mean that any slave that managed to escape to Federal territory instantly became free.[[/note]] You’re lucky if you see portrayals of black persons ''at all'' in the North, especially in older media, even though they made up a disproportionate 10% of the Union army by war's end (''Film/{{Glory}}'' being a notable depiction thereof).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/TheRaid1954'': A group of Confederate prisoners escape to Canada and plan to rob the banks and set fire to the small town of Saint Albans, Vermont.

Top