It's Halloween, the holiday that Scaredy hates. During the annual party, he blends into a monster suit from Papa Smurf's potions and wreaks havoc in the village. However, the Smurfs don't seem to know that it's Scaredy and keep running away from him.
Tropes in "The Scariest Smurf" contains:
- And I Must Scream: Scaredy tries to communicate with his fellow Smurfs in his imprisoned monster form, which only makes his fellow Smurfs more scared.
- Call-Back: Smurfette wears a costume used in "Who's Heftier?".
- For Halloween, I Am Going as Myself: Dimwitty doesn't wear any costumes and instead goes as himself, but with a rubber ducky floatie.
- Halloween Cosplay:
- At the party, two Smurfs have joke boxes, and call themselves Jokey. The real Jokey shows up with his costume, which explodes, causing the cosplaying Smurfs to run away.
- Gargamel cosplays as Brainy.
- Halloween Episode: Clearly.
- Halloween Trickery: Jokey constantly scares his fellow Smurfs with his costume.
-
Ho Yay: Scaredy kisses Brainy three times when the latter agrees to stay with him during the party. - Pumpkin Person: Brainy goes as this for Halloween.
