A ChristmasEpisode Bart accidentally destroys the family's Christmas presents and blames the disaster on a burglar, resulting in the rest of the town opening its hearts and wallets for them, but when Santa's Little Helper finds the melted wreckage and Bart confesses that he lied, the town turns on The Simpsons and shuns them.
!! Tropes:
* AsHimself: Creator/AlexTrebek, who doesn't take kindly to Marge's -$5200 loss.
* BaitAndSwitchComment: When Marge and Lisa decorate their family's Christmas tree, Lisa comments that she's glad about not using a tree made of aluminum like in the past, suggesting they're using a real tree this time. Marge then reveals that they're using a plastic tree.
* CassandraTruth: Homer tries to warn his coworkers of a poison leak, but they think he's lying to steal their snacks.
* ChristmasEpisode: Probably the most depressing one since "Marge Be Not Proud."
* CruelTwistEnding: Just when it seems the town has forgiven the Simpsons, we see the actual reason why the Springfieldians are at their house: [[spoiler:They're repossessing the Simpsons' belongings.]]
* DownerEnding: [[spoiler:The townspeople make off with all of the Simpson family's possessions (including the cat and dog) just so they can repay the debt]], but the part where The Simpsons play with a lone washcloth and the show's penchant for resetting their continuity (unless it's a character dying) prevented this from being too depressing.
* EpicFail: Marge losing so bad on ''Jeopardy'' that she now owes $5200 to Alex Trebek.
* GameShowAppearance: Marge goes on ''Series/{{Jeopardy}}'' to try to repay Springfield, [[EpicFail but ends up with -$5200 instead]].
* {{Irony}}: Bart sets fire to the Christmas tree with a toy fire truck.
* PresentPeeking: Bart intentionally drinks lots of water to wake up early (but not before going to the bathroom). He goes peeking at the presents before everybody else, and he ends up destroying the tree and the gifts in a fire.
* TheScrooge: When the townsfolk were donating money to the Simpsons, Mr. Burns asked if somebody had change for a ''button''.