Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekTheNextGenerationS5E5Disaster

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* YouAreInCommandNow: Troi is forced into command on the bridge after Lt. Monroe is killed. Despite her rank as Lieutenant Commander, she has no idea what she's doing. Neither does she seem to understand the basics of how the ship works. As a medical professional, she was never trained to take command of the ship. She later takes the initiative in expanding her qualifications and passes a bridge officer exam, precisely because of what happened in this episode.

to:

* YouAreInCommandNow: Troi is forced into command on the bridge after Lt. Monroe is killed. Despite her rank as Lieutenant Commander, she has no idea what she's doing. Neither does she seem to understand the basics of how the ship works. As a medical professional, she was never trained to take command of the ship. She later takes the initiative in expanding her qualifications and passes a bridge officer exam, precisely because of what happened in this episode.episode (though in a bit of CharacterDevelopment, it's not just about being prepared in case something like this happens again; Troi realizes after the scary parts are over that part of her ''liked'' being in charge).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheChainsOfCommanding: Troi gets a taste of the big chair and the pressure that goes along with it. She makes a big decision that could either save everyone aboard the ''Enterprise'' or doom them all. Though she stands by it in the face of Ro's criticism, she privately looks aware that she made a very big gamble and like she's thinking about the consequences. In the end, she freely admits that Ro could've just as easily been right.

to:

* TheChainsOfCommanding: Troi gets a taste of the big chair and the pressure that goes along with it. She makes a big decision that could either save everyone aboard the ''Enterprise'' or doom them all. Though she stands by it in the face of Ro's criticism, she privately looks aware that she made a very big gamble and like likely she's thinking about the consequences. In the end, she freely admits that Ro could've just as easily been right.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NarratingTheObvious: When the turbo lift suddenly starts falling, Picard yells, "We're falling!" There's really no reason for Picard to do this except to let the audience know why the camera went haywire and everyone dropped to the ground.

to:

* NarratingTheObvious: When the turbo lift suddenly starts falling, Picard yells, "We're falling!" There's really no reason for Picard to do this except to let the audience know why the camera went haywire and everyone dropped to the ground. He may have said it out of shock, or to let the kids know what was going on.



* YouAreInCommandNow: Troi is forced into command on the bridge after Lt. Monroe is killed. Despite her rank as Lieutenant Commander, she has no idea what she's doing. Neither does she seem to understand the basics of how the ship works.

to:

* YouAreInCommandNow: Troi is forced into command on the bridge after Lt. Monroe is killed. Despite her rank as Lieutenant Commander, she has no idea what she's doing. Neither does she seem to understand the basics of how the ship works. As a medical professional, she was never trained to take command of the ship. She later takes the initiative in expanding her qualifications and passes a bridge officer exam, precisely because of what happened in this episode.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BigShutUp: While climbing the turbolift shaft, this is Marissa's response to Paterson's panic and Jay's constant pessimism.


Added DiffLines:

* TheChainsOfCommanding: Troi gets a taste of the big chair and the pressure that goes along with it. She makes a big decision that could either save everyone aboard the ''Enterprise'' or doom them all. Though she stands by it in the face of Ro's criticism, she privately looks aware that she made a very big gamble and like she's thinking about the consequences. In the end, she freely admits that Ro could've just as easily been right.


Added DiffLines:

* FailedASpotCheck: Averted. Once in engineering, Riker notices how the monitors are still working, despite the general lack of power in the room. He can tell there's something that someone on the bridge needs them to know about.


Added DiffLines:

* GodzillaThreshold: Despite Riker's protests, Data offers to short out the electrical current with his own body because, as the Commander himself said, there are no other options to get around it.


Added DiffLines:

* HiddenDepths: Worf is actually somewhat qualified to assist in a delivery, due to previously taking Starfleet's emergency course. Of course, a computer simulation can't exactly prepare him for all that comes with the real thing.


Added DiffLines:

* OhCrap: Riker, upon getting a look at the system and seeing the current state of the containment field.
* OverlyNarrowSuperlative: Because Paterson's science project involved radishes, Picard dubs him executive officer in charge of radishes when handing out assignments. The kid very much appreciates this.


Added DiffLines:

* RaceAgainstTheClock: The containment field falling to 15% means a warp core breach, so O'Brien and Ro's arguments both note this trope. O'Brien is against rushing into separating the ship, saying they still have two hours before things go critical. Ro counters that the power coupling was damaged and any overheating could severely reduce that amount of time to the point where they couldn't even begin separating the saucer section. A later surge that O'Brien only narrowly manages to deal with ends up highlighting her concern. By the time Riker and Data are set up in engineering, the field has fallen to 18%, and they just barely prevent the collapse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Data and Riker venture out to the reach Engineering to see if they can restore power. When they encounter an impassable arc of electrical current, Data uses his body to short out the hazard. Riker detaches Data's head to finish the journey and plugs him into the ship's system. Data realizes that the warp core is about to explode and hastily guides Riker to make the proper connection so he can stop it. They succeed.

to:

Data and Riker venture out to the reach Engineering to see if they can restore power. When they encounter an impassable arc of electrical current, Data uses his body to short out the hazard. Riker detaches Data's head to finish the journey and plugs him into the ship's system. Data realizes that the warp core is about to explode and hastily guides Riker to make the proper connection so he can stop it. They succeed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
expand somes


* TheComplainerIsAlwaysWrong: Ro for wanting to separate the ship. The writers admitted they sort of shortchanged her by having her in this position in what was her second appearance.

to:

* TheComplainerIsAlwaysWrong: Ro for wanting to separate the ship. The writers admitted they sort of shortchanged her by having her in this position in what was her second appearance. At least they threw her a bone at the end, by having Troi admit that "[[JerkassHasAPoint you could just as easily been right]]."



* ExplosiveInstrumentation: Scratch one RedShirt.

to:

* ExplosiveInstrumentation: Scratch one RedShirt. And not just any RedShirt, but [[FromBadToWorse the ranking bridge officer]].

Added: 781

Changed: 436

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CharacterDevelopment: A subtle example. Picard has some trouble interacting with his three young charges, but he's also come a long way from the first episode (where he thought he was wholly incapable of dealing with children). In particular, he doesn't throw a fit over there being children on TheBridge like he did with Wesley. The development then continues through the episode, as the shared danger makes Picard more comfortable with the kids at the end.

to:

* CharacterDevelopment: A subtle example. CharacterDevelopment:
**
Picard has some trouble interacting with his three young charges, but he's also come a long way from the first episode (where he thought he was wholly incapable of dealing with children). In particular, he doesn't throw a fit over there being children on TheBridge like he did with Wesley. The development then continues through the episode, as the shared danger makes Picard more comfortable with the kids at the end.end.
** Troi is a Lt. Commander by rank but had never been placed in an actual command position before. She had to step up to the plate to get the job done, arguing with Ro over the matter, but learned to take charge and make the hard decisions. This would be an instigation for her seeking proper bridge crew certification the following season in "Thine Own Self."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MrExposition: Ro and O'Brien alternate this role when Troi is struggling with the details about the disaster when she takes over. This includes Ro having to explain what happens when there is a "containment breach" in Main Engineering. [[CaptainObvious The ship blows up.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CallBack: When Ro describes the "quantum filament" to Troi, the counselor asks if it's like the "cosmic string" from "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS4E10TheLoss The Loss]]," but she's told that they're nothing alike.

to:

* CallBack: When Ro O'Brien describes the "quantum filament" to Troi, the counselor asks if it's like the "cosmic string" from "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS4E10TheLoss The Loss]]," but she's told that they're nothing alike.

Added: 1022

Changed: 891

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FishOutOfWater: Nearly everyone is faced with a situation beyond their expertise and comfort zones: Troi, a psychologist, must make life-or-death command decisions; ChildHater Picard must comfort and guide three scared children; and ProudWarriorRaceGuy Worf must... deliver a baby. Crusher and La Forge find themselves trapped in a cargo bay, away from their vitally important posts in Sickbay and Engineering respectively; at least La Forge is somewhat in his element, devising an outside-the-box engineering solution to his problem. Riker, usually most at his element in dealing with people by supporting and commanding them, is teamed solely with the member of the crew who has no need for emotional support and is left crawling around the ship's guts trying out technical solutions. Data, normally capable of doing almost everything himself, has to rely on Riker for locomotion and, moreover, has to give guidance and instruction to someone who's not entirely familiar with the subject.

to:

* FishOutOfWater: Nearly everyone is faced with a situation beyond their expertise and comfort zones: Troi, zones:
**Troi,
a psychologist, must make life-or-death command decisions; ChildHater decisions.
**O'Brien is on the bridge instead of his normal role as the Transporter Chief. Additionally, he is used to a fully functioning, highly qualified command structure giving him well reasoned orders. Here he has to delicately provide both Troi & Ro the benefit of his experience without stepping on the toes of the officers.
**Ro, who is command qualified and in the command division, has to let Troi take charge due to her seniority.
**ChildHater
Picard must comfort and guide three scared children; and ProudWarriorRaceGuy children.
**ProudWarriorRaceGuy
Worf must... must deliver a baby. Crusher baby.
**Crusher
and La Forge find themselves trapped in a cargo bay, away from their vitally important posts in Sickbay and Engineering respectively; at least La Forge is somewhat in his element, devising an outside-the-box engineering solution to his problem. Riker, usually most at his element in dealing with people by supporting and commanding them, is teamed solely with the member of the crew who has no need for emotional support and Engineering.
**Riker
is left crawling around the ship's guts trying out technical solutions. Data, solutions.
**Data,
normally capable of doing almost everything himself, has to rely on Riker for locomotion and, moreover, has to give guidance and instruction to someone who's not entirely familiar with the subject.

Top