Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Recap / StarTrekDiscoveryS1E13WhatsPastIsPrologue

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DoWrongRight: Emperor Georgiou is a ruthless conqueror who enslaves and ''eats'' aliens, and casually executes her own men to prevent the secret of the Prime Reality from getting out-- and that's apparently not evil ''enough'' for Lorca, who thinks that the Terran Empire needs to wipe off every alien species in the universe to preserve the ways of humanity.


Added DiffLines:

* NiceJobFixingItVillain: It's subtly implied that Lorca's coup against Georgiou destabilized the Empire enough to allow Mirror Spock's eventual takeover a decade later, which in turn leads to the Terran Empire reforming to be more like The Federation, only for that experiment to be ruined by the Klingon-Cardassian-Bajoran alliance. In other words, Lorca didn't make the Empire "glorious" again; all he did was bring about its doom because his lust for power got the better of him.

Added: 155

Removed: 156

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Authority Equals Asskicking has been renamed.


* AuthorityEqualsAsskicking: The Emperor proves the better of dozens of Lorca's men, both in gunfights and hand-to-hand combat. Lorca is no slouch himself.


Added DiffLines:

* RankScalesWithAsskicking: The Emperor proves the better of dozens of Lorca's men, both in gunfights and hand-to-hand combat. Lorca is no slouch himself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Up To Eleven is a defunct trope


* HyperspeedEscape: UpToEleven, as ''Discovery'' first jumps to warp to OutrunTheFireball caused by the destruction of the mycelial core, and then they use that energy to spore-jump while at warp.

to:

* HyperspeedEscape: UpToEleven, as ''Discovery'' first jumps to warp to OutrunTheFireball caused by the destruction of the mycelial core, and then they use that energy to spore-jump while at warp.

Added: 588

Changed: 313

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RewatchBonus: Lorca's account about ending up on the prime universe's ''Buran'' suggests the truth about why he destroyed her and killed her crew-- was it to spare them from a FateWorseThanDeath at the hands of the Klingons, or was it to keep them from [[HeKnowsTooMuch figuring out his true identity and spilling the beans]]?

to:

* RewatchBonus: RewatchBonus:
**
Lorca's account about ending up on the prime universe's ''Buran'' suggests the truth about why he destroyed her and killed her crew-- was it to spare them from a FateWorseThanDeath at the hands of the Klingons, or was it to keep them from [[HeKnowsTooMuch figuring out his true identity and spilling the beans]]?beans]]?
** In addition, his belief that he needs Burnham for his plans explains his previous actions regarding her, from arranging her "release" from prison in "Context Is for Kings" to worrying about her safety more than anyone else's during "Magic to Make the Sanest Man Go Mad".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Played with. Lorca makes Mirror Stamets believe that he will be executed by being thrown into the ''Charon's'' mycelial core, saying it's "poetic" that Stamets is killed by his own creation. He then has Mirror Landry just vaporize him with her phaser.

to:

** Played with. Lorca makes Mirror Stamets believe that he will be executed by being thrown into the ''Charon's'' mycelial core, saying that it's "poetic" that Stamets is killed by his own creation. He then has Mirror Landry just vaporize him with her phaser.



* DeathEqualsRedemption: Subverted; Mirror Georgiou decides to stay on the ''Charon'' and buy time for Burnham to escape, pointing out that even with Lorca himself dead, his supporters will still kill her the moment they get their hands on her. While she succeeds in gunning down many of Lorca's men, Burnham ends up grabbing hold of her as the ''Discovery'' starts beaming her on-board, bringing Georgiou with her.

to:

* DeathEqualsRedemption: Subverted; Mirror Georgiou decides to stay on the ''Charon'' and buy time for Burnham to escape, pointing out that even with Lorca himself dead, his supporters will still kill her the moment that they get their hands on her. While she succeeds in gunning down many of Lorca's men, Burnham ends up grabbing hold of her as the ''Discovery'' starts beaming her on-board, bringing Georgiou with her.



* DoNotGoGentle: Mirror Georgiou plans to go out fighting against what's left of Lorca's men, as she'll never be taken seriously as Emperor now that Lorca has proved she's vulnerable. Burnham saves her instead.

to:

* DoNotGoGentle: Mirror Georgiou plans to go out fighting against what's left of Lorca's men, as she'll never be taken seriously as Emperor now that Lorca has proved that she's vulnerable. Burnham saves her instead.



* EvilCannotComprehendGood: This trope ultimately dooms Lorca and his coup. Not only did he completely and utterly misjudge Burnham's true nature and the reason she mutinied against Georgiou, as Burnham pointed out, he misjudged ''Starfleet-Prime's'' true nature, as they would have helped him get back to his own universe had he not played impostor. Instead, the woman he dragged out of jail ruins his coup and indirectly causes his death, and the crew he manipulated kills his surviving loyalists.

to:

* EvilCannotComprehendGood: This trope ultimately dooms Lorca and his coup. Not only did he completely and utterly misjudge Burnham's true nature and the reason that she mutinied against Georgiou, as Burnham pointed out, he misjudged ''Starfleet-Prime's'' true nature, as they would have helped him get back to his own universe had he not played impostor. Instead, the woman that he dragged out of jail ruins his coup and indirectly causes his death, and the crew that he manipulated kills his surviving loyalists.



* GoodIsNotSoft: Lampshaded by Lorca, although he claims the credit for the formidableness of ''Discovery's'' crew. Assuming his claim is accurate, he ends up [[HoistByTheirOwnPetard hoist by his own petard]] as his former crew opens fire, nearly killing Lorca with a phaser blast through the throne room.
* HoistByTheirOwnPetard: The Terran habit of keeping enemies alive to be tortured in agony booths comes to bite the Emperor in the ass since it provides Lorca with a ready source of loyal troops inside the Emperor’s own ship when he makes his move.

to:

* GoodIsNotSoft: Lampshaded by Lorca, although he claims the credit for the formidableness of ''Discovery's'' crew. Assuming that his claim is accurate, he ends up [[HoistByTheirOwnPetard hoist by his own petard]] as his former crew opens fire, nearly killing Lorca with a phaser blast through the throne room.
* HoistByTheirOwnPetard: The Terran habit of keeping enemies alive to be tortured in agony booths comes to bite the Emperor in the ass ass, since it provides Lorca with a ready source of loyal troops inside the Emperor’s own ship when he makes his move.



* ImpaledWithExtremePrejudice: Mirror Georgiou stabs Lorca through the chest with her sword, then dumps his body in the mycelial core for good measure.

to:

* ImpaledWithExtremePrejudice: Mirror Georgiou stabs Lorca through the chest with her sword, then dumps his body in into the mycelial core for good measure.



* MultitaskedConversation: Burnham's statement, "I'm right where I need to be." Lorca believes it means she is going to take his offer. But to Saru, that is the signal she told him to expect for ''Discovery'' to start her attack run.

to:

* MultitaskedConversation: Burnham's statement, "I'm right where I need to be." Lorca believes it means she is going to take his offer. But to Saru, that is the signal that she told him to expect for ''Discovery'' to start her attack run.



** When she is being beamed out by ''Discovery'', Burnham grabs the Emperor to take her along rather than let her go out in a blaze of glory.

to:

** When she is being beamed out by ''Discovery'', Burnham grabs the Emperor to take her along along, rather than let her go out in a blaze of glory.



** Lorca entered the prime universe through a [[TeleporterAccident transporter malfunction]] caused by an ion storm, which means his prime self was presumably swapped into the mirror universe at the same time.

to:

** Lorca entered the prime universe through a [[TeleporterAccident transporter malfunction]] caused by an ion storm, which means that his prime self was presumably swapped into the mirror universe at the same time.



* RewatchBonus: Lorca's account about ending up on the prime universe's ''Buran'' suggests the truth about why he destroyed her and killed her crew -- was it to spare them from a FateWorseThanDeath at the hands of the Klingons, or was it to keep them from [[HeKnowsTooMuch figuring out his true identity and spilling the beans]]?
* RousingSpeech: Saru gives one when the ''Discovery'' crew realize their plan to blow up the mycelial core will either kill them outright or strand them in the mirror universe.
-->'''Saru:''' It is well-known that my species has the ability to sense the coming of death. ''I do not sense it today.'' I may not have all the answers. However, I do know that I am surrounded by a team I trust--the finest a captain could ever hope to command. Lorca abused our idealism. Make no mistake: ''Discovery'' is '''no longer Lorca's'''. She is ours. And today will be her maiden voyage. We have a duty to perform, and we will not accept a no-win scenario.

to:

* RewatchBonus: Lorca's account about ending up on the prime universe's ''Buran'' suggests the truth about why he destroyed her and killed her crew -- crew-- was it to spare them from a FateWorseThanDeath at the hands of the Klingons, or was it to keep them from [[HeKnowsTooMuch figuring out his true identity and spilling the beans]]?
* RousingSpeech: Saru gives one when the ''Discovery'' crew realize that their plan to blow up the mycelial core will either kill them outright or strand them in the mirror universe.
-->'''Saru:''' It is well-known that my species has the ability to sense the coming of death. ''I do not sense it today.'' I may not have all the answers. However, I do know that I am surrounded by a team I trust--the trust-- the finest a captain could ever hope to command. Lorca abused our idealism. Make no mistake: ''Discovery'' is '''no longer Lorca's'''. She is ours. And today will be her maiden voyage. We have a duty to perform, and we will not accept a no-win scenario.



* SpiderSense: {{Inverted}} -- Saru is confident that ''Discovery'' will survive the coming battle because his danger sense is ''not'' tingling.

to:

* SpiderSense: {{Inverted}} -- {{Inverted}}-- Saru is confident that ''Discovery'' will survive the coming battle because his danger sense is ''not'' tingling.



* TimeTravel: ''Discovery'' jumps back to the prime universe, but the ride is bumpy thanks to Stamets having to calculate their jump on the fly and they wind up nine months in the future.

to:

* TimeTravel: ''Discovery'' jumps back to the prime universe, but the ride is bumpy thanks to Stamets having to calculate their jump on the fly fly, and they wind up nine months in the future.



* VillainRespect: Lorca seems to genuinely admire the crew he commanded (and deceived) for the past several months.

to:

* VillainRespect: Lorca seems to genuinely admire the crew that he commanded (and deceived) for the past several months.



** Subverted with the crew of ''Discovery''. Lorca says that he would extend them an offer to join him if he thought they were willing to abandon the Federation's ideals, but knows they won't and agrees to spare them as long as Burnham joins him.

to:

** Subverted with the crew of ''Discovery''. Lorca says that he would extend them an offer to join him if he thought that they were willing to abandon the Federation's ideals, but knows that they won't and agrees to spare them as long as Burnham joins him.



* YouShallNotPass: The Emperor realizes her days are numbered, and elects to hold off Lorca's men while Burnham escapes.

to:

* YouShallNotPass: The Emperor realizes that her days are numbered, and elects to hold off Lorca's men while Burnham escapes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SpiderSense: {{Inverted}} -- Saru is confident that ''Discovery'' will survive the coming battle because his danger sense is ''not'' tingling.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Add example

Added DiffLines:

** The Terrans destroying the mycelial network (and potentially themselves with it) by using it as a power source has obvious parallels to fossil fuels and climate change.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope deprecated per TRS


* FamousLastWords:
** Lorca, after being stabbed InTheBack.
---> '''Lorca:''' We...we could have...
** Georgiou gives Burnham what's supposed to be a FinalSpeech. {{Subverted}}, however, when Burnham chooses to rescue her.
---> '''Georgiou:''' You fought well. For a moment...I thought I had her back with me. ''(hears commotion outside the room)'' Lorca's troops. I will buy you some time. I am a defeated emperor. They've seen my neck. I have no future now. But I will die on my feet as fitting my station. Go, Michael Burnham. Find a way home. Live.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvilCannotComprehendGood: This trope ultimately dooms Lorca and his coup. Not only did he completely and utterly misjudge Burnham's true nature, as Burnham pointed out, he misjudged ''Starfleet-Prime's'' true nature, as they would have helped him get back to his own universe had he not played impostor. Instead, the woman he dragged out of jail ruins his coup and indirectly causes his death, and the crew he manipulated kills his surviving loyalists.

to:

* EvilCannotComprehendGood: This trope ultimately dooms Lorca and his coup. Not only did he completely and utterly misjudge Burnham's true nature, nature and the reason she mutinied against Georgiou, as Burnham pointed out, he misjudged ''Starfleet-Prime's'' true nature, as they would have helped him get back to his own universe had he not played impostor. Instead, the woman he dragged out of jail ruins his coup and indirectly causes his death, and the crew he manipulated kills his surviving loyalists.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Lorca is stabbed in the back by Mirror Georgiou and then dumped into the core himself, playing it straight.

to:

** Lorca is stabbed in the back by Mirror Georgiou and then [[ThrownOutTheAirlock dumped into the core himself, itself]], playing it straight.

Added: 796

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InvisibilityFlicker: Mirror Stamets' holo-camouflage fritzes enough for Lorca to locate and grab him.



* NewEraSpeech: Lorca gives one to his followers.
--> '''Lorca:''' One year, 212 days of torture, of agony, my friends, my followers. But I have returned to give meaning to your suffering. Today is the day we reclaim our empire.

to:

* NewEraSpeech: Lorca gives one two to his followers.
--> '''Lorca:''' One year, 212 days of torture, of agony, my friends, my followers. But I have returned to give meaning to your suffering. Today is the day we reclaim our empire.\\
\\
'''Lorca:''' Hello, Philippa. I've watched for years. You let alien races spill over the borders and flourish in our backyard, then have the gall to incite rebellion. The Terrans need a leader who will preserve our way of life, our race. Try as you might, it's clearly not you. Even Michael knew that. It was her great shame. Well, it's indecorous of me to share pillow talk. To the rest, many of you know me. Some of you served with me. To all, I make this offer. Renounce Georgiou. The Empire is dying in her hands, But you don't have to. Not today. Michael Burnham is not to be touched. She is integral to our future plans. A future where we together will make the Empire glorious again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


---> '''Georgiou:''' You fought well. For a moment...I thought I had her back with me. Lorca's troops. I will buy you some time. I am a defeated emperor. They've seen my neck. I have no future now. But I will die on my feet as fitting my station. Go, Michael Burnham. Find a way home. Live.

to:

---> '''Georgiou:''' You fought well. For a moment...I thought I had her back with me. ''(hears commotion outside the room)'' Lorca's troops. I will buy you some time. I am a defeated emperor. They've seen my neck. I have no future now. But I will die on my feet as fitting my station. Go, Michael Burnham. Find a way home. Live.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* VillainousRespect: Lorca seems to genuinely admire the crew he commanded (and deceived) for the past several months.

to:

* VillainousRespect: VillainRespect: Lorca seems to genuinely admire the crew he commanded (and deceived) for the past several months.

Added: 977

Changed: 86

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FamousLastWords: Lorca, after being stabbed InTheBack.
--> '''Lorca:''' We...we could have...

to:

* FamousLastWords: FamousLastWords:
**
Lorca, after being stabbed InTheBack.
--> ---> '''Lorca:''' We...we could have...have...
** Georgiou gives Burnham what's supposed to be a FinalSpeech. {{Subverted}}, however, when Burnham chooses to rescue her.
---> '''Georgiou:''' You fought well. For a moment...I thought I had her back with me. Lorca's troops. I will buy you some time. I am a defeated emperor. They've seen my neck. I have no future now. But I will die on my feet as fitting my station. Go, Michael Burnham. Find a way home. Live.


Added DiffLines:

* VillainousRespect: Lorca seems to genuinely admire the crew he commanded (and deceived) for the past several months.
--> '''Lorca:''' Mr. Saru. It's good to see you. I'm glad I got a chance to say good-bye to you, and the rest of the crew. I want you to know that my admiration for you was and is sincere. When I look at you, I see the formidable unit of soldiers that I sculpted. If I thought for a second that any of you were capable of relinquishing this cult-like devotion to the Federation, I'd enlist your skills today.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShoutOut: Part of the team has to take down the shields protecting the evil baseship, the other part of the team has to fly into the superstructure of the evil baseship to fire on its core and start a chain reaction that will destroy it completely. [[Film/ReturnOfTheJedi Sound familiar?]]

to:

* ShoutOut: Part of the team has to take down the shields protecting the evil baseship, the other part of the team has to fly into the superstructure of the evil baseship to fire on its core and start a chain reaction that will destroy it completely. [[Film/ReturnOfTheJedi Sound Sound]] [[Film/TheForceAwakens familiar?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SpareAMessenger: Lorca spares one of Mirror Georgiou's officers to deliver a message, then shoots the woman in the back when Georgiou asks what the message is.

to:

* SpareAMessenger: Lorca spares one of Mirror Georgiou's officers Owosekun to deliver a message, then shoots the woman her in the back when Georgiou asks what the message is.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** TheReveal about Lorca's true identity suggests that he pulled this on TheFederation itself. He may have been helping them fight the war against the Klingons, but only until he could execute his plan to take ''Discovery'' into the MirrorUniverse, thus leaving Starfleet without its prime asset or the cloak-breaking algorithm; without them, the Federation is now losing the war.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FamousLastWords: Lorca, after being stabbed InTheBack.
--> '''Lorca:''' We...we could have...

Top