Maya recalls her side of things since Kenneth's dethronement and finding the remaining puzzle cube.
Tropes:
- All for Nothing: Maya no longer has the puzzle cube - she tossed it into the creek after Omar's accusation.
- Brick Joke: In the previous episode, Kelsey and J.P. got stuck following Craig and Omar to Maya's house. At the end of this episode, the two appear behind Craig and Omar after Maya slams the door on them, with J.P. commenting that they missed something.
- Call-Back: The episode shows Maya's story immediately following "Capture The Flag Part 5 The Game" up to "War of the Pieces."
- A Day in the Limelight: Maya is the focus of this episode.
- Disappeared Dad: We see Maya’s mother but there is no mention of her father.
- Hidden in Plain Sight: Maya happened to find her puzzle cube hidden in her old cape when she was Xavier's enforcer.
- Impact Silhouette: Last time Maya tried out for the baseball team, she slid to home base, sending the plate into Coach Booker and sending him through the dugout wall.
- Jaw Drop: Craig, Omar, and Xavier have a collective one when they hear that Maya threw the last cube into the creek.
- Once More, with Clarity: We see how Maya got ahold of the last puzzle piece, and we're shown that she intended to give it to Omar before he accused her of being the Red Poncho.
- The Reveal: Three years had passed since Omar and Maya's falling out in "Into the Overpast", and her old cape had one of Kenneth's puzzle cubes tied to it.
- Shout-Out: The episode title card is based on A League of Their Own.
- Something We Forgot: When Randy passed on his title of the King's BFF to Maya, he had forgotten to tell her about the puzzle cube piece that was left hidden behind the pin.
