The mystery surrounding Keith's disappearance starts to unravel as he tells Jason and Nikki more details about his time in captivity.
Tropes:
- Not Me This Time: When Keith gets abducted again, Jason and Nikki assume Beth Colt was behind it. But when they show Keith's photograph, she says she never seen him before. Mike then realizes Keith doesn't match the victimology since Keith wasn't homeless.
- The Reveal: "Keith" is Evelyn's son as this entire thing was a scam to make Jason and Nikki think their son was back, then "kidnap" him for a ransom.
- Wham Line: Keith calling Evelyn "mom".
