Literature: Midnight Sun

"If I tried to write Midnight Sun now, in my current frame of mind, James would probably win and all the Cullens would die."
Stephenie Meyer, unknowingly giving some anti-Twilight fans some ideas

Midnight Sun was originally going to be the fifth novel in the Twilight series. It was basically a Perspective Flip of the first book, showing Edward's side of the story. Depending on your views regarding the series, this may be either an intriguing character study or a cheap rehash. Either way, however, it was not to be; the manuscript was somehow leaked and the author, Stephenie Meyer, apparently felt so betrayed over the whole thing that she scrapped the project. The manuscript, however, lives on.

A Dramatic Reading has been done by Man Without A Body.


Midnight Sun provides examples of:

  • Artistic License Physics: Bella's blood would not actually cool in the five seconds it would take Edward to kill the rest of the class.
    • Edward can run on snow without leaving tracks or indentations, despite weighing the same as a human man his size. Because screw forces being equal and opposite, that's why.
    • He also stays cold regardless of the temperature of the air around him. Clearly one of his vampire powers is immunity to entropy and the Second Law of Thermodynamics.
  • The Atoner: Edward is full of guilt over killing people...
  • Conveniently Coherent Thoughts: Everyone seems to think in (usually) complete, plot-relevant sentences.
  • Does This Remind You of Anything?: Intentionally or not, Edward's inner monologue frequently evokes school shooters. Some have compared it to a stalker/pedophile/rapist/serial killer's how-to guide. His inner monologue on going after Bella when she's at home and her father's away comes off as if he's planning to rape her.
    • Another exchange with a school secretary feels alarmingly like the dialogue scene at the beginning of a porno.
  • Dramatic Reading: Man Without A Body has done one, as stated above.
  • Emo Teen: Half the cast.
  • Hypocrite: Edward constantly complains about how shallow teenagers and humans in general are, constantly looking down at them and calling them silly, and yet he's just as shallow when it comes to his thoughts about Bella. Really he's probably more immature than most of the teens in Forks.
  • Lampshade Hanging: On Edward's stalking factor.
    "Id just admitted to stalking her, and she was smiling."
  • Jerk with a Heart of Gold: Edward is supposed to be one.
  • Perspective Flip: Obviously.
  • You're Cute When You're Angry: Edward Cullen is all about this, repeatedly calling Bella a "furious kitten that thinks it's a tiger" and variants.