Dave seems to be an all-take-and-no-give sorta guy, until "Nothing But The Tooth" when Scaredy literally loses a tooth, and needs one to give to the Molar Owl to save himself from her dental wrath. Sally shows up just before he's captured, claiming to have found his tooth at the bottom of the river. Scaredy thanks Sally and goes home. Soon after, it's revealed that Dave actually pulled out his own toothto give to Scaredy so he could avoid the same fate. He never even finds out.