Headscratchers / Battle for Dream Island

---

• Why is there only one of each object?
  • The hosts probably just want a diverse group of objects. When Pin says that "pins sweat ooze" and Eraser says that "erasers don't have brains," that implies that there are multiple of each object.
  • There is. Firey and Firey Jr. are both fire flames (as evidenced by their names). Also there are tons of recommended characters that are variations of existing ones, assuming they are canonical.
• Who won BFDIA?
  • Nobody won BFDIA. The characters are seemingly aware that it was cancelled, given Pencil's line in IDFB of, "Our diary followers have no idea what's happened to us in the last three years. They have no clue who was eliminated in BFDIA 6!" Given that no other BFDIA contestants had been sent to the TLC besides Puffball, it's safe to say that the show in-universe had been scrapped.
    • Yet. BFDIA is continuing for a comeback in 2023.
• If Woody was in Four’s eye, and Death PACT was in Four, shouldn’t BEEP and Death PACT have both be safe and tied with Bleh?
  • Four didn't know Woody was in his eye.
• What is Gem School?
  • Apparently, based on context clues, it is a school for only diamonds to attend.
• How did the TLC prisoners participate in BFB?
  • Tennis Ball and the others took a Wall Teleporter from the science museum in Yoyle City. Maybe they managed to use it to teleport everyone out of the TLC (and LOL)?
• Why did Balloony stick with Four? The only thing he did in BFB 17 was clash with Leafy. If he didn't want anything to do with her after she rejoined, then why join the same group as her?
  • He was recommended by the first person to comment on a BFDI video. Questioned solved.
    • I'm... not sure what that has to do with Balloony continuing to compete on BFB instead of TPOT.
    • Likewise. Bomby was recommended with the same guy and he's in TPOT.
• For that record, why did Blocky stick with Four despite his friendship with Eraser and Pen?
• Why is Announcer planning another season of BFDI with Four, X and Purple Face in the desert after BFB ended? Doesn't he have an team of speaker boxes that moderated BFDI in space where he could plan the next season and bring the other hosts with him there? Sure he had to use the UFO to get there, but where the hell is it?!
  • Maybe the other speaker boxes are fine with him returning to Earth.
• Why do characters sometimes say “Oh my God” instead of something like “Oh my Gardener” or “Oh my place where Tennis Balls are created!”
  • I guess force of habit. In-Universe, I have no idea.
• In BFB 15, the change is to get all members of the team alive to Four. But since DEATH Pact and Beep were inside Four, didn't that technically mean they should have been safe from the start?
• Why does Satomi use a deep voice for some characters?
  • Pretty much everyone who voices several characters uses a deep voice for at least one of their characters.
• What happens if Teardrop loses in TPOT? Does she get eliminated immediately or does she stay in the game if she has more votes than at least one member of the team she goes up with?
  • There probably wouldn’t even be a vote. Teardrop would automatically be eliminated.
    • Confirmed in Balancing P.A.C.T.
• Why did Teardrop want to join TPOT in the first place?
  • While this doesn’t answer the question, rumor has it Satomi wanted her in the game.
• Why did Pencil vote against the rest of her alliance in BFDI 10?
• How did W.O.A.H Bunch survive 3 weeks straight avoiding Evil Leafy with no sleep or anything to eat?
• In BFDIA 8, Yellow Face refused to do anything "purple related" because Bomby, his teammate, was turned purple one episode earlier. Then why was he fine in BFB with being on the same team as Marker, who is purple and white?
  • Given that the only purple entity that he insults in BFB is Lollipop who is a business rival, it's possible that he might have either became more tolerant sometime during BFDIA and BFB or he began to mask his racism because being publicly racist was making his company less popular, with allowing Marker being an attempt to look less racist.
• In TPOT 9, did Puffball and Coiny ever get recovered and sent to the elimination area? The same goes to the Recommended Characters that weren't seen eating the steaks.
• Why did everyone immediately jump to the conclusion that Leafy had stolen Dream Island? They had confronted her to inform that Dream Island was missing, yet when Leafy says that Firey "never received Dream Island at all", they immediately figure out she was behind it. Shouldn't they think that she had just learned this now?
• In BFDIA 6, why did Needle insist they were now “permanent yoyleland residents now” since the only recovery center is glued to the ground in yoyle city, yet they go back to Goiky in BFDIA 8 and all of a sudden there’s a new recovery center? Not just that but the travel to yoyleland feels less and less cared about as the series progresses, all of a sudden BFDIA 10 introduces a highway to get there now. What is up with all this confusion?
• If Flower hates bugs, why does door #3 in "Lots of Mud" have bugs in it? She even ran away from them at the end.