After the end of Be Careful What You Wish For, everyone's going to start wondering what exactly happened to Samantha, since obviously nobody would believe the real story. The police are probably going to get called in, and what will they learn? That Samantha disappeared after a school day where Judith was bullying her particularly badly (since time got reset). People might believe Judith drove her to suicide. Or they might suspect Judith did something to her. Judith's Karma Houdinistatus may actually be short-lived.