main index




Topical Tropes

Other Categories

TV Tropes Org
Film: Simon And The Oaks

As the story begins, Simon is a young boy who love to sit and read books in the shadow of the great oak. His father Erik consider this to be disturbing. When Simon beg to be allowed to go to a good school, Erik force him to promise to give up the oak forever.

Shortly after, Simon gets a new friend at school. Isak, a Jewish boy who's family recently fled from Nazi Germany. Erik is very suspicious of Isak's family. Not because they are Jewish, but because they are... bourgeois. Being a proud working class guy, Erik strongly dislike Simon's passion for culture in general and music in particular. Even worse, Simon got talent.

As the story progress, Simon and Isak grow up to adulthood, in the shadow of the second world war. Among other things, Simon need to come to terms with the internal conflict of how he love his parents and ow he hate his parents.

Has examples of:

  • Black and White Insanity: Isak's mother Olga has a very unhealthy worldview, where she seem to regard Nazis as being Evil at an Eldritch Abomination level rather than regular guys who believe in a destructive ideology. Of course, her family is persecuted by Nazis: Just because you're paranoid doesn't mean they're not after you. Because of the persecution, nobody understand how far off the deep end she really is, until it is too late. Just because they're really after you doesn't mean you're not a paranoid schizophrenic... She end up trying to kill her entire family. Premeditated murder, but not out of malice: She believe it to be her only chance to save them from the Nazis.
  • Closer to Earth: Erik manage to fill this role for the poor lost upper-class boy Isak, although not for his own child Simon.
  • Fantasy-Forbidding Father: One of Erik's defining traits.
  • Good Versus Good: Everyone in the story are trying their best to do good, and does a decent job at that. Sadly, their failures are still enough to generate a lot of sorrow and hate. (The Nazis and their local supporters are bad guys, but Erik's and Simon's struggle against them is given less then a minute of the film versions total screentime.)
  • Properly Paranoid: In one way or another, most characters are this... or not. Thether Simon's parents was this or not is one of the main debates of the story. Definitely subverted in the case of Isak's mother Olga - see Black and White Insanity.
  • Troubled Sympathetic Bigot: Simon's parents, especially Eric. Trying their best to be good parents, while being too narrow-minded and too full of pent-up fear & anger to avoid harming him.

Shark NightFilms of the 2010sThe Sitter

alternative title(s): Simon And The Oaks
TV Tropes by TV Tropes Foundation, LLC is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available from
Privacy Policy