Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / Lincoln

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

-->'''Lincoln:''' What did Hawkins get?
-->'''John Nicolay:''' Postmaster of the Millersburg Post Office.
-->'''Lincoln:''' He's selling himself cheap, ain't he?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Democrats who vote for the amendment get some of these from their fellow Democrats, if not worse.

to:

** Democrats who vote for the amendment get some of these from their fellow Democrats, if not worse. Pendleton shoots Yeaman one on his way out of the House chamber after the vote, though Yeaman doesn't appear fazed by it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Alexander Stephens proposes peace in exchange for Lincoln's written assurance that the Southern states will be readmitted to the Union in time to block ratification of the 13th Amendment. Lincoln responds that even if he gives that assurance, he expects the Amendment to be ratified if most of the Northern states and at least two of the Southern states vote in its favor, and he already expects Tennessee, Louisiana, and Arkansas to do so. In fact, Virginia and Louisiana were the first Southern states to ratify the Amendment in February, 1865, followed by Tennessee and Arkansas in April. The Carolinas, Alabama, and Georgia followed suit in November and December, while Florida, Texas, Kentucky, and Mississippi did not do so until after the Amendment had been formally ratified and incorporated into the Constitution.

Added: 225

Changed: 102

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Robert Lincoln says, ''"I won't be you, Pa!"'', but says he won't be nothing at all. Robert was a successful lawyer and eventually a Justice of the United States Supreme Court, but chose not to follow his father into politics.

to:

** Robert Lincoln says, ''"I won't be you, Pa!"'', but says he won't be nothing at all. Robert was a successful lawyer and eventually a Justice of served the United States Supreme Court, U.S. government as Secretary of War and later as Ambassador to Great Britain, but chose not to follow his father into politics.



-->'''Abraham''': I couldn't tolerate you grieving so for Willie because I couldn't permit it in myself, though I wanted to, Mary. I wanted to crawl under the earth, into the vault with his coffin. I still do. Every day I do.



* RunningGag: Lincoln keeps trying to get rid of his dress gloves, complaining they never fit right. His butler is always there to make him put or keep them on.
* SadisticChoice:

to:

* RunningGag: Lincoln keeps trying to get rid of his dress gloves, complaining they never fit right. His butler valet is always there to make him put or keep them on.
* SadisticChoice: SadisticChoice:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OutlivingTheOffspring: The Lincolns have never recovered from the loss of their middle son Willie. Mary's grief was such that her husband thought of having her committed to an asylum, and she swears that he'll have to if their eldest son Robert is killed in the war.

to:

* OutlivingTheOffspring: OutlivingOnesOffspring: The Lincolns have never recovered from the loss of their middle son Willie. Mary's grief was such that her husband thought of having her committed to an asylum, and she swears that he'll have to if their eldest son Robert is killed in the war.

Added: 368

Changed: 240

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HumansAreBastards: Both Seward and the Radical Republicans believe that it will be much easier to pass the amendment after the end of the year, when the newly-elected Congressmen take their seats and the Republicans have an overwhelming majority in both the House and Senate; Asa Litton decries Lincoln's push to pass the amendment now as an empty gesture to frighten the Confederacy into ending the war, or else a feeble attempt to show "support" from the Democrats in the House. But Lincoln is painfully aware that while a majority of the Union supports abolition for various reasons, only a small minority (including Stevens and the Radical Republicans) believe in true equality for blacks, and he can easily foresee enthusiasm for the amendment fading away in the new house, especially if the war is over by then. He is calculating that outgoing Democrats who have nothing to lose (and much to gain through federal patronage) are actually ''more'' likely to vote in favor of the amendment than incoming Republicans at the start of their new terms. After a short conversation with a couple presenting a petition to the President, who admit that the husband would prefer that ''"some coon didn't come North and take his job"'', Seward starts to see Lincoln's point.
-->'''Seward''': The people... I begin to see why you're in such a hurry to put it through.

to:

* HumansAreBastards: Both Seward and the Radical Republicans believe that it will be much easier to pass the amendment after the end of the year, when the newly-elected Congressmen take their seats and the Republicans have an overwhelming majority in both the House and Senate; Asa Litton decries Lincoln's push to pass the amendment now as an empty gesture to frighten the Confederacy into ending the war, or else a feeble attempt to show "support" from the Democrats in the House. But Lincoln is painfully aware that while a majority of the Union supports abolition for various reasons, only a small minority (including Stevens and the Radical Republicans) believe in true equality for blacks, and he can easily foresee enthusiasm for the amendment fading away in the new house, especially if the war is over by then. He is calculating that outgoing Democrats who have nothing to lose (and much to gain through federal patronage) are actually ''more'' likely to vote in favor of the amendment than incoming Republicans at the start of their new terms. After Seward then has a short conversation with a couple presenting a petition to the President, who admit that they'd be happier if the husband would prefer that ''"some coon didn't come North and take his job"'', Seward starts to see Lincoln's point.
war could be ended ''without'' freeing the Confederacy's slaves:
-->'''Seward''': And why's that?\\
'''Mr. Jolly''': ''[[[AskAStupidQuestion surprised]]]'' N*****s.\\
'''Mrs. Jolly''': If he don't have to let some Alabama coon come up to Missouri, steal his chickens, and his job, he'd much prefer that.\\
''[The Jollys leave their petition letter with the President and leave.]''\\
'''Seward''':
The people... I begin to see why you're in such a hurry to put it through.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SlipperySlopeFallacy: One of the most effective arguments used by Pendleton, Wood, and the other Democratic Representatives in convincing fence-sitting Representatives to vote against the 13th Amendment is that abolition is just the first step towards giving blacks the vote, and eventually full equality with whites, concepts that that few people outside of Stevens and the Radical Republicans can even contemplate, much less make themselves comfortable with. Lincoln addresses this in conversation with George Yeaman:

to:

* SlipperySlopeFallacy: One of the most effective arguments used by Pendleton, Wood, and the other Democratic Representatives in convincing fence-sitting Representatives to vote against the 13th Amendment is that abolition is just the first step towards giving blacks the vote, and eventually full equality with whites, concepts that that few people outside of Stevens and the Radical Republicans can even contemplate, much less make themselves comfortable with. Lincoln addresses this in conversation with George Yeaman:

Added: 1998

Removed: 895

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SlapSlapKiss: A father-son variant occurs when Robert suggests that Abe is more scared of Mary's wrath than losing Robert; subverted when Abe slaps Robert and then attempts a reconciliatory hug, only for Robert to reject his dad's hug.
* SleazyPolitician: Seward is not sleazy in character, but he still maintains his contacts with political operatives who ''are'', whom he sets to rounding up lame-duck Democrats that can be persuaded to vote aye.
* SlidingScaleOfIdealismVersusCynicism: This film is about Honest Abe, but he is the one who orders his Secretary of State to get professional lobbyists to wheel and deal with patronage appointments as much as they can to secure the votes necessary to get the 13th Amendment passed. In Stevens's words concerning himself: "The greatest measure of the nineteenth century was passed by corruption, aided and abetted by the purest man in America."


Added DiffLines:

* SlapSlapKiss: A father-son variant occurs when Robert suggests that Abe is more scared of Mary's wrath than losing Robert; subverted when Abe slaps Robert and then attempts a reconciliatory hug, only for Robert to reject his dad's hug.
* SleazyPolitician: Seward is not sleazy in character, but he still maintains his contacts with political operatives who ''are'', whom he sets to rounding up lame-duck Democrats that can be persuaded to vote aye.
* SlidingScaleOfIdealismVersusCynicism: This film is about Honest Abe, but he is the one who orders his Secretary of State to get professional lobbyists to wheel and deal with patronage appointments as much as they can to secure the votes necessary to get the 13th Amendment passed. In Stevens's words concerning himself: "The greatest measure of the nineteenth century was passed by corruption, aided and abetted by the purest man in America."
* SlipperySlopeFallacy: One of the most effective arguments used by Pendleton, Wood, and the other Democratic Representatives in convincing fence-sitting Representatives to vote against the 13th Amendment is that abolition is just the first step towards giving blacks the vote, and eventually full equality with whites, concepts that that few people outside of Stevens and the Radical Republicans can even contemplate, much less make themselves comfortable with. Lincoln addresses this in conversation with George Yeaman:
-->'''Yeaman''': I hate it, too, sir, slavery, but - but we're entirely unready for emancipation. There's too many questions-\\
'''Lincoln''': We're unready for peace too, ain't we? When it comes, it'll present us with conundrums and dangers greater than any we've faced during the war, bloody as it's been. We'll have to extemporize and experiment with what it is when it is. I read your speech, George. Negroes and the vote, that's a puzzle.\\
'''Yeaman''': No, no, but, but, but... But Negroes ''can't'' vote, Mr. Lincoln. You're not suggesting that we enfranchise colored people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AskAStupidQuestion: When Speaker of the House Colfax breaks tradition to cast a vote, [=McPherson=] asks him how he wants to vote. Colfax gives him a mildly disappointed look and says, ''"Aye, of course!"''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OutlivingTheOffspring: The Lincolns have never recovered from the loss of their middle son Willie. Mary's grief was such that her husband thought of having her committed to an asylum, and she swears that he'll have to if their eldest son Robert is killed in the war.


Added DiffLines:

* ScrewTheRulesIMakeThem: Lincoln is not above using his authority as Commander-in-Chief to block his son's determination to enlist in the Army.

Added: 335

Changed: 201

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CastingGag: Possibly. Creator/HalHolbrook, who plays Francis Preston Blair, is well-known for his Emmy-winning portrayals of Lincoln in TV miniseries such as ''Sandburg's Lincoln'' and ''Series/NorthAndSouthUS''.

to:

* CastingGag: CastingGag:
**
Possibly. Creator/HalHolbrook, who plays Francis Preston Blair, is well-known for his Emmy-winning portrayals of Lincoln in TV miniseries such as ''Sandburg's Lincoln'' and ''Series/NorthAndSouthUS''.


Added DiffLines:

** Creator/BruceMcGill, as Secretary of War Edwin Stanton, is still the [[Film/AnimalHouse organizer of mayhem]] ''par excellence''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Lincoln'' is a historical retelling of the [[UsefulNotes/AbrahamLincoln 16th President of the United States]]'s attempts to get the Thirteenth Amendment passed, directed by Creator/StevenSpielberg and written by [[Theatre/AngelsInAmerica Tony Kushner]], based on the acclaimed biography ''Team of Rivals'' by UsefulNotes/DorisKearnsGoodwin. It stars Creator/DanielDayLewis as Lincoln, Creator/SallyField as Mary Todd Lincoln, Creator/JosephGordonLevitt as their son Robert and has a supporting cast that includes Creator/TommyLeeJones, Creator/DavidStrathairn, Creator/JaredHarris and Creator/JackieEarleHaley.

to:

''Lincoln'' is a historical retelling of the [[UsefulNotes/AbrahamLincoln 16th President of the United States]]'s attempts to get the Thirteenth Amendment passed, directed by Creator/StevenSpielberg and written by [[Theatre/AngelsInAmerica Tony Kushner]], based on the acclaimed biography ''Team of Rivals'' by UsefulNotes/DorisKearnsGoodwin. It stars Creator/DanielDayLewis as Lincoln, Creator/SallyField as Mary Todd Lincoln, Creator/JosephGordonLevitt as their son Robert and has a supporting cast that includes Creator/TommyLeeJones, Creator/DavidStrathairn, Creator/JaredHarris and Creator/JackieEarleHaley.
Creator/JackieEarleHaley. (A pre-stardom Creator/AdamDriver can be seen as the telegraph operator.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** George H. Pendleton was played by Peter [=McRobbie=], who was in his late 60s. The real Pendleton was just shy of 40 at the time the film took place.
** Bill Raymond, who was in his 70s, plays House Speaker Schuyler Colfax, who was only 41 when the 13th Amendment was passed.

to:

** George H. Pendleton was played by Peter [=McRobbie=], Creator/PeterMcRobbie, who was in his late 60s. The real Pendleton was just shy of 40 at the time the film took place.
** Bill Raymond, Creator/BillRaymond, who was in his 70s, plays House Speaker Schuyler Colfax, who was only 41 when the 13th Amendment was passed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Trope was cut/disambiguated due to cleanup


* GutturalGrowler:
** Thaddeus Stevens is Tommy Lee Jones at his deepest and most gravelly.
** Ulysses S. Grant too, as played by Jared Harris, sounds like he ''eats'' those omnipresent cigars after he's done smoking them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* As Lincoln gets up to leave what will turn out to be his last cabinet meeting, he remarks, ''"I suppose it's time to go, though I would rather stay."''

to:

* ** As Lincoln gets up to leave what will turn out to be his last cabinet meeting, he remarks, ''"I suppose it's time to go, though I would rather stay."''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HateSink: The confederate peace delegation, led by Confederate VP Alexander Stephens, is depicted relatively sympathetically, so instead we are given Fernando Wood - a [[LargeHam loud]], [[{{Jerkass}} obnoxious]], [[SmugSnake slimy]] Democratic orator with openly white supremacist views - as a target at which to direct the audience's ire. And for Thaddeus Stevens to [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech hurl gloriously elaborate insults at.]]

to:

* HateSink: The confederate Averted with the Confederate peace delegation, led by Confederate VP Alexander Stephens, is who are depicted relatively sympathetically, sympathetically; so instead we are given Fernando Wood - a [[LargeHam loud]], [[{{Jerkass}} obnoxious]], [[SmugSnake slimy]] Democratic orator with - and his patron George Pendleton, both of whom hold openly white supremacist views - views. More than any representative of the Confederacy, these two men act as a target at which to direct targets for the audience's ire. And for Thaddeus Stevens to [[TheReasonYouSuckSpeech hurl gloriously elaborate insults at.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Abraham Lincoln''': Anyone who thinks that doesn't understand, Molly.

to:

'''Abraham Lincoln''': Anyone who thinks that doesn't understand, Molly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BothSidesHaveAPoint: Lincoln and Stevens butt heads over the fight to pass the 13th Amendment, with Lincoln thinking Stevens needs to tone down his rhetoric to not drive off support and Stevens arguing that Lincoln needs to fight harder to get it passed. Both of them wind up taking each other's advice, and the amendment passes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Lincoln''': When peace comes, it mustn't just be hangings.''

to:

-->'''Lincoln''': When peace comes, it mustn't just be hangings.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EasilyForgiven: In conference with Grant, Lincoln reminds him that none of the Confederate Army's soldiers are to be taken prisoner, and that if the rebel leaders including Jefferson Davis just "happen" to escape Union justice, Lincoln would be just fine with that.
-->'''Lincoln''': When peace comes, it mustn't just be hangings.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* As Lincoln gets up to leave what will turn out to be his last cabinet meeting, he remarks, ''"I suppose it's time to go, though I would rather stay."''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HumansAreBastards: Both Seward and the Radical Republicans believe that it will be much easier to pass the amendment after the end of the year, when the newly-elected Congressmen take their seats and the Republicans have an overwhelming majority in both the House and Senate; Asa Litton decries Lincoln's push to pass the amendment now as an empty gesture to frighten the Confederacy into ending the war, or else a feeble attempt to show "support" from the Democrats in the House. But Lincoln is painfully aware that while a majority of the Union supports abolition for various reasons, only a small minority (including Stevens and the Radical Republicans) believe in true equality for blacks, and he can easily foresee enthusiasm for the amendment fading away in the new house, especially if the war is over by then. He is calculating that outgoing Democrats who have nothing to lose (and much to gain through federal patronage) are actually ''more'' likely to vote in favor of the amendment than incoming Republicans at the start of their new terms. After a short conversation with a couple presenting a petition to the President, who admit that the husband would prefer that ''"some coon didn't come North and take his job"'', Seward starts to see Lincoln's point.
-->'''Seward''': The people... I begin to see why you're in such a hurry to put it through.
** Stevens is a firm believer in this, which is why he's so vehemently opposed to Lincoln's gradualism and his avowed faith that "the people" will do what's right, when they're ready to:
--->'''Stevens''': You claim you trust them, but you know what the people are. You know that the inner compass that should direct the soul toward justice has ossified in white men and women, North and South, unto utter uselessness through tolerating [[SlaveryIsASpecialKindOfEvil the evil of slavery]]. White people cannot bear the thought of sharing this country's infinite abundance with Negroes.

Added: 770

Changed: 384

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Mary Todd Lincoln''': All anyone will remember of me is I was crazy and I ruined your happiness.\\
'''Abraham Lincoln''': Anyone who thinks that doesn't understand, Molly.



* CallForward: Abe and Mary have a heated argument in which they speak of her possibly being thrown into the madhouse because of her grieving processes. She even specifically states that if her son Robert were killed in the war, Lincoln should go ahead and put her in the madhouse. Ten years later, she ''was'' put in the madhouse, by Robert himself (though quickly released).

to:

* CallForward: CallForward:
**
Abe and Mary have a heated argument in which they speak of her possibly being thrown into the madhouse because of her grieving processes. She even specifically states that if her son Robert were killed in the war, Lincoln should go ahead and put her in the madhouse. Ten years later, she ''was'' put in the madhouse, by Robert himself (though quickly released).released).
** Robert Lincoln says, ''"I won't be you, Pa!"'', but says he won't be nothing at all. Robert was a successful lawyer and eventually a Justice of the United States Supreme Court, but chose not to follow his father into politics.



* ComicallySmallBribe: Democrat Clay Hawkins is bribed by Bilbo to vote yes for the amendment in exchange for... becoming the postmaster of Millersburg, Ohio. He initially asks to be the taxman of the Western Reserve, but Bilbo negotiates him down to postmaster. When his fellows Democrats find out, though, they're both amused and disgusted, and Hawkins chickens out of the bribe. [[spoiler:In the end, though, he chooses to vote yes on the amendment anyway regardless of the bribe or his fellows Dems.]]

to:

* ComicallySmallBribe: Democrat Clay Hawkins is bribed by Bilbo to vote yes for the amendment in exchange for... becoming the postmaster of Millersburg, Ohio. He initially asks to be the taxman of the Western Reserve, but Bilbo negotiates him down to postmaster. When his fellows Democrats find out, though, they're both amused and disgusted, and Hawkins chickens out of the bribe. [[spoiler:In the end, though, he chooses to vote yes on the amendment anyway regardless of the bribe or his fellows fellow Dems.]]



** Lincoln himself is susceptible to this; as was pointed out early on, the Republicans had won control of the House in the 1864 elections, which upon their sitting would have made approval of the 13th Amendment a cakewalk. Lincoln, however, was insistent that the amendment bill be passed with the votes of "lame duck" Democrat representatives to show that it was bipartisan.

to:

** Lincoln himself is susceptible to this; as was pointed Seward points out early on, that the Republicans had won control of the House in the 1864 elections, which upon their sitting would have made approval of the 13th Amendment a cakewalk. Lincoln, however, was insistent that the amendment bill be passed with the votes of "lame duck" Democrat representatives to show that it was bipartisan.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArmorPiercingQuestion: Lincoln looks close to tears when Alexander Stephens asks him, ''"how many hundreds of thousands have died during your administration?"''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NobleDemon: Vice-President of the Confederacy Alexander Stephens is a reprehensible white supremacist, [[NiceToTheWaiter but he doesn't view this as good reason to treat blacks poorly.]]

to:

* NobleDemon: Vice-President of the Confederacy Alexander Stephens is a reprehensible white supremacist, [[NiceToTheWaiter but he doesn't view this as good reason to treat blacks black people poorly.]]

Added: 21

Changed: 22

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Foreshadowing}} and ForegoneConclusion:

to:

* {{Foreshadowing}} and ForegoneConclusion:


Added DiffLines:

* {{Foreshadowing}}:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''"There it is, even in that two-thousand year old book of mechanical law: it is a self- evident truth that things which are equal to the same thing are equal to each other. We begin with equality. That's the origin, isn't it? That balance, that's fairness, that's justice."''

to:

->''"There it is, even in that two-thousand year old book of mechanical law: it is a self- evident truth that things which are equal to the same thing are equal to each other. We begin with equality. That's the origin, isn't it? That That's balance, that's fairness, that's justice."''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''"Do we choose to be born, or are we fitted to the times we are born to?"''

to:

->''"Do we choose to be born, or ->''"There it is, even in that two-thousand year old book of mechanical law: it is a self- evident truth that things which are we fitted equal to the times we same thing are born to?"''equal to each other. We begin with equality. That's the origin, isn't it? That balance, that's fairness, that's justice."''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:300: [[DoNotGoGentle Thunder Forth,]] [[ReligiousBruiser God Of War.]]'']]

to:

[[caption-width-right:300: [[DoNotGoGentle Thunder Forth,]] [[ReligiousBruiser God Of War.]]'']]
]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[DoNotGoGentle Thunder Forth,]] [[ReligiousBruiser God Of War.]]''

to:

[[caption-width-right:300: [[DoNotGoGentle Thunder Forth,]] [[ReligiousBruiser God Of War.]]''
]]'']]

Top