Really Needs a Better Title
, and I don't know if this trope already exists
. (all signs point to no)
So, there's Band X. Band X has become popular and generally well-received by critics quite a while ago and are known for a certain style.
However, Band X decide to do something completely different
for their next album, for whatever reason. Maybe they're tired and believe they've taken their style to the limit. Maybe they're afraid of being one-trick poneys. Maybe it's Executive Meddling
. Regardless, the result will be a change of style. This can be either a total Genre Shift
, general simplification for bands with highly complex styles (thrash metal, prog rock, etc.), more prog tendencies for simple pop-rock bands, whatever. The point is that they will continue with this style for a period, to either continued success or diminishing returns.
Cue shock and They Changed It, Now It Sucks
from parts of the fanbase, along with a whole spectrum of opinions from others.
The New Sound Album
represents an album where a band generally known for a certain style backs away from its roots and makes a radical change, if not a total Genre Shift
. Reactions to this tend to vary. There's always a segment of the fanbase that says They Changed It, Now It Sucks
and labels them as sellouts
, even ignoring that sometimes the band honestly admits to wanting a change. In other parts there's a whole range of reactions, from mixed to positive. In the worst case the album will divide a fanbase
into Old Guard Versus New Blood
, and in the best case a majority of fans will enjoy both periods of the band's career.
Or to put it shorter: a good New Sound Album
will cause a majority of fans to call it a good Genre Shift
and a minority to go They Changed It, Now It Sucks
, while a bad one will make the majority go They Changed It, Now It Sucks
and a minority will like the Genre Shift
- 90125 by Yes. The first album by a reunited band with a new guitarist (Trevor Rabin), 90125 saw the band reduce their song lengths and simplify their structures, while retaining enough weirdness and instrumental proficiency to remind fans that it was still a Yes album despite its newfound accessibility. It resulted in the band's only #1 hit, "Owner of a Lonely Heart". Some parts of the fanbase went straight for Old Guard Versus New Blood, with the "Troopers" representing the former and the "Generators" (named after the band's followup Big Generator) the latter, but the majority seem to enjoy both periods just fine.
- Metallica and Megadeth simplified their style almost simultaneously, with Metallica (The Black Album) for the former and Countdown to Extinction for the latter. While initially successful, both bands continued with the simplification for the rest of The Nineties, to predictably diminishing returns.
- Queen weren't exactly prog to start with, but were known for highly overdubbed vocal harmonies and guitar work. Starting with The Game they pushed the guitar to the background and focused more on the pop side of their personality instead of rock. This development went hand in hand with Synthesizeritis and reduced songwriting quality, causing them to lose their popularity in America.
- Rush have gradually abandoned really long songs, extended suites, multiple parts and concept albums. Ever since Signals their songs have been of reasonable length, and ever since Counterparts they've also thrown out the synths they used heavily in The Eighties. But they still have the really tricky riffs and drumming (what else do you expect from Rush?).
- The Beatles did it twice. Starting with Revolver they dove headfirst into trippy, catchy psychedelic rock, and then with The White Album they went back to straightforward rock.
- With A Northern Soul, The Verve changed their orientation from their previous spacey psychedelic rock with lots of drug abuse to alternative rock with lots of drug abuse. They continued wth this style on Urban Hymns.
- Starflyer59 moved from their previous shoegazing-influenced guitar-heavy sound to a more pop-influenced sound with keyboards starting with The Fashion Focus.
- Fleetwood Mac started as a moderately successful blues-rock band led by guitarist Peter Green known for hard-rockin' songs with heavy riffs such as "Oh Well" and "The Green Manalishi (with the Two Pronged Crown)". One long complicated history later, including Green and the other guitarist quitting due to mental ilness and joining a cult and other replacements that didn't go much anywhere, Stevie Nicks and Lindsey Buckingham joined the band, now relocated to California. With Fleetwood Mac they changed to a pop/rock style inspired mostly by the Beatles, Beach Boys and the mellow Californian soft rock scene. They refined the formula and obtained massive success with Rumours and Tusk, and never looked back.
- Jars of Clay does one of these every second album or so.
- Green Day in The Nineties used to be a pop-punk band who wrote catchy songs about being lazy, being insane, masturbating, being bored the works. Cue American Idiot and their shift to a more complex style inspired by Rock Opera and The Who.
- Pearl Jam moved towards more experimental waters starting with No Code, and they eventually returned to head-on grunge/hard rock with either Riot Act or Pearl Jam (depends who you ask).
- For now it seems Kanye West pulled this with 808s & Heartbreak, moving from sample-heavy rap to weird bleepy minimalist electro stuff with autotuned singing.
- The Beach Boys evolved pretty gradually away from surf-rock, but fully went baroque pop with what's considered their masterpiece, Pet Sounds (which sadly didn't have "Good Vibrations" on it). They went back to simplicity later due to intra-band conflict and drug abuse.
- AFI started off as a hardcore punk band (a la Black Flag) but switched to some entertaining pop-rock with their 2003 album Sing the Sorrow. They haven't switched back since.
- The Cure started off as a pop-punk group and completely changed their sound with the melancholic tones of Seventeen Seconds, which got them lumped with the gothic rock scene. They continued being bleak for a while, with some poppy bits, until their masterpiece Disintegration. After Disintegration, they increased the pop quotient with Wish, and since then their style is pretty much a mix between bleak goth and upbeat pop, with varying degrees of happiness.
- Urge Overkill started as a crappy noise-rock band ripping off The Jesus Lizard, Big Black and other contemporary Chicago bands. With Americruiser they hit upon their style, a combination of punk, power pop and arena rock. They never looked back and continued perfecting the formula until they struck the jackpot with Saturation.
- Muse's most recent album The Resistance, which has raised cries of They Changed It, Now It Sucks.
- Arctic Monkeys' third album Humbug, which saw a shift from the slice of life indie of their previous albums to a much darker, harder sound and has provoked much They Changed It Now It Sucks from the fans.
- Bob Dylan (Acoustic to Electric with Bringin' it All Back Home) as above
- Bone Thugs-n-Harmony (just about every new release?)
- David Bowie (Let's Dance)
- Electric Light Orchestra (Discovery)
- Jewel (can't tell you which, but her article says it keeps happening "to varying success").
- Linkin Park (Minutes To Midnight) (yet again see above)
- Radiohead (Kid A)
- The Decemberists (The Crane Wife then again on Hazards of Love)
- Tori Amos ("her last three albums" from the page, The Other Wiki says American Dollhouse was "a drastic departure for Amos.")
- Village People ("The Renaissance Album")
- 5150 by Van Halen. After 6 albums defined mostly by the combination of Eddie Van Halen's guitar wizardry and David Lee Roth's comic persona, Roth left the band. He was replaced with Sammy Hagar, Eddie started including more and more synths, and their songs became poppier. Cue Broken Base, which endures to this day despite Roth having returned.
- Napalm Death: Harmony Corruption onwards, when they started to take on death metal influences (and later industrial and black metal).