"See? Being defeated by the Mazaku was precisely the cathartic jolt he needed to resolve his inner turmoil and pay off his guilt."
Let's face it. Sometimes a villain's (and occasionally even a hero's) great big, all-encompassing master plan can be... a little convoluted. It might not even make complete sense even after it's finally been thoroughly explained, often through a series of flashbacks, at the end of the day.
But it's a special kind of "fuck you" when a plan is so incredibly obtuse that it hinges on the planner's own defeat or demise, and is liable to fail if this condition is not met. Somehow, some way, someone has managed to twist the plot completely on its ass to the point that the only way to win is to lose, and the only way to lose is to win.
This presents an especially dangerous situation to their opponent, because he or she is usually out of the loop on this grand master plan. After all, what can the unwitting hero do when beating the bad guy means ending the world, and losing means saving it? Sometimes a character seeks to become a political martyr (see Zero Approval Gambit
and Thanatos Gambit
) in order to inspire others to take action after his or her death (Inspirational Martyr
), others he might be tied to some ultimate power which will unleash itself upon his death (My Death Is Just the Beginning
). Still others don't seem to make any sense until after the plan has played out successfully—surprise! Turns out that death was all he needed to transcend the mortal coil and become a god.
The bottom line is, this is what you get when a character secretly sets out to fail... and succeeds. The failure of such a plan results in a Springtime for Hitler
. Note that a scheme which has a beneficial outcome for the schemer whether he/she succeeds or
fails is not an example of this trope, but of a Xanatos Gambit
. In order to qualify here, the plan must be thought of well in advance, and it must completely hinge on failure. Without the threat of the plan failing if one fails to fail, it fails to qualify.
The success of such a plan can often result in a Pyrrhic Victory
for the opposing party. The plan usually relies to some extent on a Batman Gambit
, and often one's only hope of overcoming the plan is to Sheathe Your Sword
... or occasionally Take a Third Option
Often overlaps with I Let You Win
. A character seeking to end his or her own life with such a plan falls under Suicide by Cop
, as well as Thanatos Gambit
WARNING: This trope is an Ending Trope, and thus its examples will contain many spoilers. Expect unmarked spoilers ahead.
Anime and Manga
- Code Geass. The ending of the series is an example of this, as well as Thanatos Gambit and Zero Approval Gambit, as Lelouch, now emperor of Britannia, intentionally makes himself the enemy of the world and then dies a martyr's death at the hands of Suzaku, who is disguised as Zero, the hero of the people. This plan—the "Zero Requiem"—results in most of the world's strife being blamed on the tyrannical Lelouch, and ultimately unites humanity, just as Lelouch had hoped to do.
- Liar Game. Players of the Liar Game Tournament are forced to participate and pay an enormous debt if/when they lose. At first, the goal appears to be to win each round and move on to the next round with large amounts of money as winnings. However, the real way to win the game is to deliberately lose and drop out of the game while hauling in a profit. But because it's a zero-sum game (one person winning means another person loses), Nao and Akiyama's goal is to win and move on to the next round while shouldering an enormous debt, using all of their winnings to zero out the debt of their teammates and/or opponents so that they can all safely drop out of the game.
- Naruto. Itachi Uchiha had planned for his brother Sasuke to kill him in order to make Sasuke a hero of Konoha village in a Thanatos Gambit. Unfortunately for him, further manipulation by Tobi just manages to make Sasuke hate Konoha.
- Paranoia Agent. Though it's never fully explained why, the only way that Lil' Slugger/Shonen Bat is finally thwarted and life restored to some semblance of normalcy is for the giant wave of paranoia that Slugger has become to devour EVERYTHING, resulting in the utter annihilation of the city and a strange inner-world revelation by Tsukiko that results in Slugger's ultimate erasal. The ending is so incredibly vague that it's impossible to determine if Slugger had planned this outcome, but given that he and Maromi are functionally the same entity in Tsukiko's mind, it could be argued that they both wanted only for Tsukiko to find inner peace.
- Slayers. While his defeat in the first season of the Slayers anime was not necessarily intentional or foreseen, in Slayers Evolution-R, the villain Rezo reveals that he intentionally set up a situation in which he would be defeated by Lina and the evil lord Shabranigdo sealed inside of him would be released. In true Heroic Sacrifice style, he realized that this was the only way for the mighty demon lord to be erased from existence once and for all, making Rezo less of a villain at the end of the day.
- YuYu Hakusho's villains have a habit of relying on these, usually in conjunction with Suicide by Cop. Toguro, as Genkai's former teammate, seeks his own death at the hands of Yusuke, her student, for reasons only speculated in the series—perhaps as a form of atonement, or to prove to himself that the decision he made to abandon his humanity was a mistake. The second Big Bad, Sensui, sought to go to the Demon World simply so that he could intentionally die there after seeing the world inhabited by the creatures he felt remorse for over formerly hunting and killing. The fact that Yusuke, a human-demon hybrid, killed him, was a bonus.
- Dodgeball: A True Underdog Story. Before the final playoff between Average Joe's and Globo Gym, Peter signs over ownership of the Average Joe's gym to White after being bribed with $100,000. Even though Average Joe's win the game, White boasts that Peter has nothing now that his gym has been absorbed by Globo Gym. However, between the $100,000 bribe and the $50,000 prize money, Peter is able to invest in and gain control of Globo Gym as a publically-owned company, which White can do nothing about. How long Peter was planning this scheme is debatable.
- In Law Abiding Citizen, a regular Disproportionate Retribution training film, Clyde Shelton confesses to a murder because he wants to be imprisoned, as that becomes key in his plan, while ironically giving him more freedom than he would have had otherwise.
- Metal Gear Solid. In the first installment, Solid Snake's goal is to shut down Metal Gear REX using a special key delivered to him by Otacon. Liquid Snake and his forces had, at this point, spent much of the game trying to retrieve this key from Solid Snake in order to prevent him from shutting down REX. In actuality, the key is the device that launches REX, and Liquid had counted on Solid Snake to make it through his forces and attempt to shut down REX, thus activating it.
- In an episode of South Park, Satan fights Jesus, and intentionally takes a dive after the people of the town have all bet on his victory. He then reveals that he made a fortune by being the one and only person to bet on Jesus winning, all according to plan.