Created By: Bisected8 on October 28, 2012 Last Edited By: Bisected8 on November 18, 2012
Troped

Unintentionally Notorious Crime

A criminal accidentally commits a much more notable crime than they intended

Name Space:
Main
Page Type:
Trope
Needs More Examples Needs a Better Name

Launching Sunday the 18th of November at 21:00 (GMT)

Alternative Names:

Crime doesn't (always) pay; you never know who your victim might be. Just because your victim didn't turn out to be a superhero, alien assassin or a fellow crook doesn't mean you've got away with it. You might find that things went a little bit too well and you've committed a crime that'll get you far more attention that you want; an Accidentally High Profile Crime. You might discover that the random woman you've just robbed is The Cape's wife, and now his Hero Secret Service is on your tail, or that bag you're running away with might carry the MacGuffin or perhaps you tried to steal a car and ended up "kidnapping" the kid in the back seat. Either way, you're in over your head.

The crime might escalate either because of the victim (either because they're rich, important or famous, getting a lot of unwanted attention or the media just happens to pick up on it) or because of the payoff (usually by stealing something more valuable than expected, either because everybody wants it or it's worth more than it appears). Note that the intended crime itself doesn't have to be minor; a Serial Killer drawing unwanted attention by picking a victim who happens to be important also fits, for example.

If it focuses on the criminals then it'll either focus on how in over their head they are (as they flee from the law and possibly other criminals) or be played as a case of Can't Get Away with Nuthin' (especially if it's the "important victim" variant).

When the story focuses on detectives (or other law enforcement) investigating this trope it's often either revealed as a humorous twist (the "master criminal" turns out to be some lowlife in the wrong place at the wrong time) or a red herring (if a crime appears to be this trope it'll usually be subverted). When the trope is in effect from the start and played straight to the end, it's usually so that there's a reason the detectives will be under pressure to solve the case.

Sister trope to Accidental Murder (which may or may not be the result of a more minor crime). Stupid Criminals are especially prone to this trope. For other cases of things going so well they go badly see Gone Horribly Right. Compare Robbing the Mob Bank, Mugging the Monster and Bullying a Dragon, where the crime is foiled because the crooks are in over their head and Colliding Criminal Conspiracies when it's foiled because they're caught up in another crime.

Examples;

Multiple
  • Just about anyone who threatens Lois Lane in any incarnation of Superman (except for continuities where it would be a case of Mugging the Monster).

Anime and Manga
  • In the Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex episode "Embraced by a Disguised Net CAPTIVATED", a member of an Organ Legging gang accidentally kidnaps the daughter of a politician who was denying their existence. The team are able to take advantage of this trope by having the politician denounce the gang to make the kidnapper panic (they know she's a professional who won't kill the girl). It turns out that a rival had given her a list which included the politician's daughter so she'd be branded a traitor.

Film
  • In Murder in the First, the main character stole money from the till of a shop out of desperation. Because the shop in question had a post office he was charged with a federal crime and ended up being punished as if he was a bank robber.
  • In The Bank Job the criminals rob a bank which while fairly high profile, should not have gotten them into the trouble it did. Turns out the bank was used by various shady characters to store their valuables and incriminating documents. The bank robbers quickly become the target of corrupt cops, drug dealers and and a murderous porn baron. However, the trope is actually subverted since there was nothing 'accidental' about the mess. It is a gambit by MI-5 to retrieve politically embarrassing photographs.
  • In Office Space, the characters create a software program which will take the rounded-off fractions of pennies from financial transactions from their employer and deposit it in a bank account they created- an idea they stole from Superman III. The money would never be missed by Initech, the company they work for. But when they check the account, due to a misplaced decimal point in the program, it has deposited over $300,000, which definitely would be missed.
  • In Stealing Rembrandt, some low life thugs plans to steal some painting by a relatively unknown artist for some easy cash. Only to grab the only Rembrandt, in their country, by accident. Causing a nation-wide police search, deals with foreign mobsters and overall chaos for the petty thugs, as they try to act like the professional thieves, the pressed described them to be.
  • In Harley Davidson and the Marlboro Man, the protagonists steal bags of what they think is cash from a bank which belongs to the corporation that is trying to build an airport on their favorite bar; When they open the bags, they find nothing but a highly addictive and lethal new drug. The corperation wants it back and sends their best assassins after them.
  • The Chase: Kidnapping a girl and taking her car would just be another notch on the getaway list of Jack Hammond...had the girl not been the daughter of the wealthiest man in California. Thus The Chase ensues.
  • Toy Story. Woody is jealous of the attention Andy pays to Buzz Lightyear. He schemes to knock Buzz down behind a desk, which would inconvenience him but not hurt him. Instead, because of a series of accidents, Buzz is knocked out the room's window and the other toys want to lynch Woodie because they think he intended to knock Buzz out the window.
  • Absolute Power: Luther Withney, a burglar, breaks into a house to steal jewels, but witnesses a murder (by the President, no less) for which he is suspected.

Literature
  • In one of Labyrinths of Echo sequels; a forest witch who was feeling lonely enchanted and effectively kidnapped some likeable strangers... who happened to be the King Incognito with his entourage. After the problem was resolved, she said something to the effect of "Why Didnt You Just Say So -- I'm crazy, not stupid".
  • In Retribution Falls, Darian Frey raids the Ace Of Skulls, believing it to be a freighter transporting gemstones, but when it explodes after taking one shot and bodies fall out, it becomes clear that it was a liner; Darian Frey later learns that one the passengers was the son of a duke.
  • In the book Holes, Zero steals a pair of shoes. Little did he know that they were owned by a famous baseball player and were being sold for charity - after he took them, he heard lots of people exclaiming, "The shoes are gone!" and shortly afterward, he heard police sirens and threw them away ( accidentally framing the protagonist in the process).
  • In True Talents, Trash wants to buy some art supplies, but is strapped for cash. While at the bank, he gives in to temptation and uses his telekinesis to steal a wad of bills from a trolley. After leaving, he looks through them and realizes that they're all hundred dollar bills -- meaning he just walked off with thousands of dollars.
  • In Judge Dee, an influential criminal tries to kill the judge by trapping him and his deputies under a huge bell, nearly suffocating them. When they manage to prove he was the culprit, he admits to it but tries to pass it off as a prank gone wrong, finally setting on the charge of assault, hoping his connections will let him go free... only for Dee to remind everyone that as a judge in office he represents the state and the will of the Emperor - and as such, assaulting him constitutes high treason, punishible by Cruel and Unusual Death (getting pulled apart by four buffalos)

Live Action Television
  • In the pilot of Vegas2012 a woman is murdered and her body dumped in the desert. The local sheriff is corrupt and the murder might be linked to the mob. Given this, the case would have probably been left unsolved except the woman was the governor's niece. The governor threatens to send in the National Guard if Las Vegas cannot get a grip on its rising crime. This gives the mayor the political clout to appoint Ralph Lamb as the new sheriff.
  • In Copper a thief breaks into a house and discovers the body of a dead child inside. He is Genre Savvy enough to know that this makes the crime high profile enough that the corrupt police will not be able to ignore it but not high profile enough for the police to bother with a proper investigation. Rather than becoming a Fall Guy and hanging for a murder he did not commit, he signs up on the next ship to leave port and does not come back to New York City for more than a year.
  • The Killer of the Week in one episode of CSI was a meth-head who killed an off-duty cop because he thought the cop was sleeping with his girlfriend. Cop killers get an all-out manhunt in any jurisdiction.
    • In one of the season finales of CSI: New York the team are drinking in a bar when the place is shot up in a drive by. The first episode of the next series reveals that the attackers were just planning an elaborate extortion plot and didn't know there were police in the bar.
  • On Sons of Anarchy this is a recurring problem for the eponymous biker gang. Their various illegal operations are highly profitable but require them to keep a low profile and avoid undue attention from law enforcement. This can be easier said than done for a bunch of violent bikers with anger issues.
    • When they decide to sell some illegal guns to an old army buddy of Piney's, it turns out that his group of 'gun enthusiasts' are actually Right Wing Militia Fanatics and the weapons are used to kill two sheriff's deputies during a prison break.
    • When the Sons go to confront some neo-Nazis, they end up storming into a fundraising dinner for a right wing political party. They are recorded threatening dozens of women and children while holding highly illegal weapons. They were actually set up by the leader of the neo-Nazis who likes to provoke his enemies into doing stupid crimes and then having them arrested for it.
    • When Tig is led to believe that a rival gang leader tried to kill Clay, he embraces Revenge Before Reason and opens fire on the gang leader in public place in front of dozens of witnesses. He misses but he accidentally kills the daughter of the most powerful and ruthless drug dealer in Los Angeles.
  • There is an episode of CHiPs where someone steals a car that had the owner's baby still in the car. Escalating their crime from joyriding to kidnapping.
  • A frequent event on Law & Order: Criminal Intent. The victim will turn out to be a judge or a cop (or the relative of a judge or a cop), the victim or suspect will have mafia ties, or the case will draw a lot of media attention. This is necessary to keep the crime in the Major Case squad, instead of being reassigned to another division.

Print Media
  • Games Magazine once ran a crime story where a cashier had only intended to steal seven bucks for a dinner date--only to find that she'd stolen several grand by accident. Making a desperate getaway she breaks into a funeral procession--that turns out to be for a cop killed in the line of duty. Busted!

Video Games

Western Animation
  • In the Batman: The Animated Series episode "The Man Who Killed Batman", a petty criminal trying to score big, Sid the Squid, participates in a small-time robbery but (apparently) accidentally kills the Caped Crusader himself.
  • In one episode of The Batman, a watchmaker steals a rare watch from his shop, setting off the alarm. In the confusion he causes a major traffic accident. He's sentanced to 20 years and plans revenge after discovering he has the ability to rewind time for a few seconds. At the end, he realizes his plan killed his son, and this somehow supercharges his power, returning him to just before he took the watch. He leaves it there this time.

Real Life
  • There have been many incidents where somebody steals a car without realizing there is a child in the back seat and thus accidentally becomes a kidnapper.
Community Feedback Replies: 50
  • October 29, 2012
    nielas
    • In the pilot of Vegas2012 a woman is murdered and her body dumped in the desert. The local sheriff is corrupt and the murder might be linked to the mob. Given this the case would have probably been left unsolved except the woman was the governor's niece. The governor threatens to send in the National Guard if Las Vegas cannot get a grip on its rising crime. This gives the mayor the political clout to appoint Ralph Lamb as the new sheriff.
  • October 29, 2012
    TBeholder
    • In one of Labyrinths Of Echo sequels a forest witch who didn't have a good company for too long enchanted and effectively kidnapped some likeable strangers... who happened to be the King incognito with minimal secret entourage. After the problem was resolved, she commented to the effect of "Could just tell me so -- I'm crazy, not stupid".
  • October 29, 2012
    Koveras
    • In the Batman The Animated Series episode "The Man Who Killed Batman", a petty criminal trying to score big, Sid the Squid, participates in a small-time robbery but accidentally kills the Caped Crusader himself.
  • October 29, 2012
    captainpat
    It's best to remove the Example As Thesis and just explain the trope.
  • October 29, 2012
    BOFH
    • In Retribution Falls, Darian Frey raids the Ace Of Skulls, believing it to be a freighter transporting gemstones, but when it explodes after taking one shot and bodies fall out, it becomes clear that it was a liner; Darian Frey later learns that one the passengers was the son of a duke.
  • October 29, 2012
    Mozgwsloiku
    Do all the examples of robbery ending in unplanned murder count?
  • October 29, 2012
    Bisected8
    @captainpat: Example As Thesis is writing a story instead of a description. Excluding the fact that they're discouraged, not forbidden, as far as I can tell there isn't one in the description (I've followed my usual pattern of; [Description] [Clarification of types] [ways the trope is played] [related tropes] [example list]). ^^;

    @Mozgwsloiku: As a rule; if the complication gets the criminals more "heat", it's this trope. If they kill someone by accident but it just makes a robber feel guilty or something (and doesn't touch on how much more serious it's made their crime) then it isn't.
  • October 29, 2012
    nielas
    I would think that the 'accidentality' of the crime also plays a big role. A bank robber might not plan to kill someone but there is nothing really accidental about it if he is a trigger happy psycho to begin with. So Reservoir Dogs would probably not fit this trope.
  • October 29, 2012
    Bisected8
    I've added a Better Name tag (hmm, have they made them unremovable now?). If you have any suggestions for something less clunky than the current title, I'm all ears.
  • October 30, 2012
    nielas
    • In The Bank Job the criminals rob a bank which while fairly high profile, should not have gotten them into the trouble it did. Turns out the bank was used by various shady characters to store their valuables and incriminating documents. The bank robbers quickly become the target of corrupt cops, drug dealers and and a murderous porn baron. However, the trope is actually subverted since there was nothing 'accidental' about the mess. It is a gambit by MI-5 to retrieve politically embarrassing photographs.
  • October 30, 2012
    Chabal2
    In one episode of The Batman, a watchmaker steals a rare watch from his shop, setting off the alarm. He panics, running into a cop, and then into a hotdog stand, which rolls into the street and causes a truck to turn over, resulting in a massive explosion with untold dead. He gets sent to prison for twenty years planning revenge, and discovers his ability to rewind time for a few seconds. At the end, he realizes his plan killed his only son, and this somehow supercharges his power, returning him to just before he took the watch. He leaves it there this time.
  • October 30, 2012
    TrollBrutal
  • October 30, 2012
    Earnest
  • October 30, 2012
    Dawnwing
    Literature:

    • In the book Holes, Zero steals a pair of shoes. Little did he know that they were owned by a famous baseball player and were being sold for charity - after he took them, he heard lots of people exclaiming, "The shoes are gone!" and shortly afterward, he heard police sirens.
  • October 31, 2012
    nielas
    • In Copper a thief breaks into a house and discovers the body of a dead child inside. He is Genre Savvy enough to know that this makes the crime high profile enough that the corrupt police will not be able to ignore it but not high profile enough for the police to bother with a proper investigation. Rather than becoming a Fall Guy and hanging for a murder he did not commit, he signs up on the next ship to leave port and does not come back to New York City for more than a year.
  • October 31, 2012
    StarSword
    The Killer of the Week on last night's CSI might count, as a meth-head who killed an off-duty cop because he thought the cop was sleeping with his girlfriend. Cop killers get an all-out manhunt in any jurisdiction.
  • November 2, 2012
    Bisected8
    So, does anyone have any suggestions for a better name?
  • November 2, 2012
    nielas
    I actually like Accidentally High Profile Crime as it fairly accurately describes what the trope is about.
  • November 3, 2012
    Bisected8
    Well it works, but I was hoping someone could come up with something snappier.
  • November 4, 2012
    Bisected8
    Since someone added a Description Needs Help tag, does anyone have any thoughts on it? Is it clear what the trope is?
  • November 5, 2012
    nielas
    The third paragraph could be rewritten to make it clearer as I find it a bit confusing as to when exactly it applies to detectives.

    • On Sons Of Anarchy this is a recurring problem for the eponymous biker gang. Their various illegal operations are highly profitable but require them to keep a low profile and avoid undue attention from law enforcement. This can be easier said than done for a bunch of violent bikers with anger issues.
      • When they decide to sell some illegal guns to an old army buddy of Piney's, it turns out that his group of 'gun enthusiasts' are actually Right Wing Militia Fanatics and the weapons are used to kill two sheriff's deputies during a prison break.
      • When the Sons go to confront some neo-Nazis, they end up storming into a fundraising dinner for a right wing political party. They are recorded threatening dozens of women and children while holding highly illegal weapons. They were actually set up by the leader of the neo-Nazis who likes to provoke his enemies into doing stupid crimes and then having them arrested for it.
      • When Tig is led to believe that a rival gang leader tried to kill Clay, he embraces Revenge Before Reason and opens fire on the gang leader in public place in front of dozens of witnesses. He misses but he accidentally kills the daughter of the most powerful and ruthless drug dealer in Los Angeles.
  • November 5, 2012
    nlpnt
    I seem to remember an episode of C Hi PS where someone steals a car that had the owner's baby still in the car. Joyriding -> kidnapping.
  • November 5, 2012
    Bisected8
    ^^ I've tried rewording that paragraph. How's that?
  • November 5, 2012
    JoeG
    • Real Life: There have been many incidents where somebody steals a car without realizing there is a child in the back seat and thus accidentally becomes a kidnapper.
  • November 7, 2012
    ZarbiNerada
    Literature:

    Games Magazine once ran a crime story where a cashier had only intended to steal seven bucks for a dinner date--only to find that she'd stolen several grand by accident. Naturally she now wants to make a desperate getaway and breaks into a funeral procession--that turns out to be for a cop killed in the line of duty. Busted!
  • November 7, 2012
    fulltimeD
    I feel like this is almost every single episode of Fringe from Season 1-4, before the show's setting was changed to the future instead of Present Day.
  • November 7, 2012
    fulltimeD
    @Dawnwing: Wasn't that the main character who stole the shoes, not Zero? I forget the main character's name, it's been a long time since I read the book.
  • November 7, 2012
    Bisected8
    I only saw the first half of the movie (long story), but from what I've got by reading wikipedia and this very wiki; the protagonist found the shoes and got blamed for the theft. Zero turned out to be the one who stole the shoes (and threw them away, whereupon the protagonist found them).
  • November 8, 2012
    Bisected8
    So, no suggestions for the name?
  • November 9, 2012
    Twiddler
    ^^ That's right.

    • In True Talents, Trash wants to buy some art supplies, but is strapped for cash. While at the bank, he gives in to temptation and uses his telekinesis to steal a wad of bills from a trolley. After leaving, he looks through them and realizes that they're all hundred dollar bills -- meaning he just walked off with thousands of dollars.
  • November 9, 2012
    broc7
    Film:

    In Office Space, the characters create a software program that will take the rounded-off fractions of pennies from financial transactions from their employer and deposit it in a bank account they created- an idea they stole from Superman III. The money would never be missed by Initech, the company they work for. But when they check the account, due to a misplaced decimal point in the program, it has deposited over $300,000, which definitely would be missed.

    The My Cousin Vinny example doesn't fit this trope- they didn't accidentally commit a more serious crime. They accidentally confessed to a more serious crime. More like a Three's Company misunderstanding.

  • November 9, 2012
    TheNinth
    A frequent event on Law And Order Criminal Intent. The victim will turn out to be a judge or a cop (or the relative of a judge or a cop), the victim or suspect will have mafia ties, or the case will draw a lot of media attention. This is necessary to keep the crime in the Major Case squad, instead of being reassigned to another division.
  • November 9, 2012
    Bisected8
    @broc7: Good point, removed.
  • November 11, 2012
    Mozgwsloiku
    Tell me if this one counts as an example:

    • In Judge Dee, an influential criminal tries to kill the judge by trapping him and his deputies under a huge bell, nearly suffocating them. When they manage to prove he was the culprit, he admits to it but tries to pass it off as a prank gone wrong, finally setting on the charge of assault, hoping his connections will let him go free... only for Dee to remind everyone that as a judge in office he represents the state and the will of the Emperor - and as such, assaulting him constitutes high treason, punishible by Cruel And Unusual Death (getting pulled apart by four buffalos)
  • November 11, 2012
    DracMonster
    Unintentionally Notorious Crime is a little less clumsy. Not perfect but I can't think of anything better.
  • November 11, 2012
    Bisected8
    ^^ Sounds like an invoked version.
  • November 13, 2012
    xboxington
    Video Games:

    In Saints Row the Third, the main cast robs a bank that they don't know is owned by the Syndicate. The Syndicate becomes the game's main antagonist.
  • November 13, 2012
    Bisected8
    @xboxington: Don't edit the OP (or at least say when you do). It makes it hard to keep track of what changes are being made.
  • November 13, 2012
    Chernoskill
    • In Harley Davidson And The Marlboro Man, the protagonists steal bags thought to be cash from a bank that belongs to the corporation that tries to build an airport on our heroes' favorite bar; When they open the bags, they find nothing but a new highly addictive and lethal drug which the corporation wants back more than anything, sending their best assassins after them.
  • November 13, 2012
    IlGreven
    The Chase: Kidnapping a girl and taking her car would just be another notch on the getaway list of Jack Hammond...had the girl not been the daughter of the wealthiest man in California.
  • November 13, 2012
    StarSword
    I like Unintentionally Notorious Crime. Nice work, DracMonster.
  • November 14, 2012
    Bisected8
    Well, that's two tropers agreeing on a name (not counting myself). Anyone else?
  • November 15, 2012
    Arivne
    Film
    • Toy Story. Woody is jealous of the attention Andy pays to Buzz Lightyear. He schemes to knock Buzz down behind a desk, which would inconvenience him but not hurt him. Instead, because of a series of accidents, Buzz is knocked out the room's window and the other toys want to lynch Woodie because they think he intended to knock Buzz out the window.
  • November 16, 2012
    duralict
  • November 16, 2012
    Bisected8
    Could you elaborate on what she was trying to do?
  • November 18, 2012
    Bisected8
    Any more thoughts on the name?
  • November 18, 2012
    pixelScientist
    Never Really Got Away With It, Never Really Got Away From It
  • November 18, 2012
    Nithael
    Absolute Power: Luther Withney, a burglar, breaks into a house to steal jewels, but witnesses a murder (by the President, no less) for which he is suspected.
  • November 18, 2012
    Koveras
  • November 18, 2012
    Bisected8
    That's three tropers agreeing on the title.

    I'll leave this up for a few more hours (just in case someone has anything else to add) and launch it at 9 o'clock (4 hours from now).

Three days must pass before this YKTTW is Launchworthy or Discardable

http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/discussion.php?id=hxq9qro7j6ywykgak74z31ls&trope=UnintentionallyNotoriousCrime