Inexplicably Amused YKTTW Discussion

Inexplicably Amused
When it looks like one party has won, the other responds in an amused fashion.
Needs Examples Better Name Up For Grabs
(permanent link) added: 2013-03-04 05:06:46 sponsor: streetsahead500 edited by: Arivne (last reply: 2015-03-22 01:49:57)

Add Tag:
Rolling Updates

So the hero has stormed the Big Bad's lair, taken care of his Mooks, and disabled the Doomsday Device. Approaching the cowering villain, he raises his weapon of choice to deliver the Coup de Grāce... and the villain starts laughing. The hero will commonly ask 'what's so funny?', whereupon the full extent of his foe's nefarious scheme will be revealed.

Perhaps it is a case of I Am Not Left-Handed, or maybe the villain has some sort of Dead Man Switch which will blow up the lair if he is killed. Often he will reveal that his death is just the beginning, or that his demise will not further the hero's cause for some other reason.

There are typically three possible responses to such a moment. One is that the situation is totally reversed, and the hero is defeated (common when the villain has some secret weapon or ability he has been keeping secret). The second is that he has prevent himself from dealing the finishing blow to deal with a new threat (maybe his Love Interest is caught in a Death Trap which will activate upon the death of the villain). In the third, he kills the villain anyway in the knowledge that the real battle is yet to start.

Frequently inverted in that it might be the hero who looks on the verge of defeat before revealing that it was All According to Plan, in which case a Big Damn Heroes moment is common.

Literal laughter is not actually necessary for it to be this trope, just any kind of expression dissonant with the situation at hand. Will often overlap with Laughing Mad, Evil Laugh, Xanatos Gambit, "The Reason You Suck" Speech.

Probably Needs a Better Title as this one is kind of vague (also I'm not sure how to get rid of the '/'-sign in the title).


  • The Princess Bride. Happens during the trope-naming scene for I Am Not Left-Handed.
    Inigo: I admit it: you are better than I am!
    Man in Black: Then why are you smiling?
    Inigo: Because I know something you don't know.
  • Predator. After Dutch incapacitates the title creature it activates a device on its wrist and starts laughing at him. Dutch realizes the device is a Self Destruct Mechanism and starts running...
  • Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom. Early in the movie Indiana Jones confronts the villainous Lao Che. After Indy takes a drink Lao Che makes a demand.
    Lao Che: And now, you give me the diamond.
    Indy: Are you trying to develop a sense of humor, or am I going deaf?
    Lao Che: [holds up a vial]
    Indy: What's that?
    Lao Che: Antidote.
    Indy: To what?
    Lao Che: [starts laughing] The poison you just drank, Dr. Jones.

  • In the second Jack Blank book, The Secret War, the heroes successfully stop Speedrazor and his cohorts from attacking a train. While they are discussing their distrust of the Secreteers, Speedrazor laughs uproariously but is spitefully knocked out before he can divulge anything. Later on, it is revealed after interrogating Speedrazor more than half the book later that they were sent to destroy the train by a Secreteer, Obscuro, who had undergone a Face-Heel Turn.

Live-Action TV
  • Played for Laughs in the first paintball episode of Community, where Chang opens his jacket to reveal a paint bomb after being tagged by Jeff.
  • Cheers. When it appears that Harry the Hat has conned Coach, Sam, Norm, Cliff, and another conman out of a bunch of money (including Coach's life savings) Coach has his head in his hands, shaking. Then it turns out that he's not crying, he's laughing. "Coach, what are you laughing at?" Coach responds "That!" and points to the back of the bar, where Harry reappears. He and Coach set up a con within a con within a con in order to con the other con artist out of his money.
  • In Star Trek: The Next Generation, young Picard has to laugh, seemingly without any reason, after a Nausicaan has stabbed his heart. Picard survives, but his heart has to be replaced by an artificial one. Many years later, this artificial heart brings Picard into a potentially lethal situation, and in what may or may not be limbo, Q offers Picard the bargain that he will live if he goes back in time (replacing his younger self) and prevents the situation that got him the artificial heart in the first place. Picard does just that, but discovers that this has steered his live into a completely different path - an unbearable boring path. After Picard has learned his lesson about not regretting your past choices, Q allows him to go back in time once again and restore the original timeline. And this time, Picard actually has a reason to laugh when he gets stabbed...

Newspaper Comics
  • Luann: In the strips for January 8th and January 9th 2013, T.J. grins at Ann Eiffel before telling her that her incriminating admissions (which she thought she had erased) had been backed up elsewhere.

Video Games
  • Some Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney trials go this way. Prove something important and the prosecution will be smiling afterwards. It either means A) that you just screwed yourself over, B) that they already knew this and was toying with you or C) that they still have to reveal their best evidence.

Web Comics
  • Lampshaded in The Order of the Stick #810: Nale and Sabine have Durkon at their mercy, and Nale notices a smile on Durkon's face in spite of Nale's apparent victory. He fails miserably in an attempt to defy the trope by noting that since he knows what Durkon is up to, he is in a better position to counter it. Eventually it turns out that Durkon is expecting to meet Malack, a powerful cleric with a grudge against Nale, who promptly enters the scene and almost kills Nale in the ensuing fight.

Western Animation
  • In Invader Zim, when Zim breaks up with Tak, she starts laughing uproariously before she reveals her Irken appearance.

Replies: 16