Expository Gameplay Limitation YKTTW Discussion
|Expository Gameplay Limitation|
Temporarily limiting the actions the player character can make in a game to allow for exposition
The problem of how to provide exposition to players in Video Games is a difficult one. At one extreme, some studios cut straight to non-interactive cutscenes (possibly tempered by Quick Time Events) or text screens to convey all the relevant plot information needed. This generally ensures that players will get all the information required, but can significantly disrupt the pacing of the game, and many players dislike having control wrested away from them altogether. Other studios take the Half-Life approach of never taking control away from the player and providing exposition within the game's engine. This generally avoids disrupting the pace too much, but can result in players accidentally missing key information if their attention was focussed on something else. This trope takes a middle course: not taking control away from the player, but temporarily limiting the actions the player character is able to carry out so as to better focus the player's attention on the exposition. For example, supposing that in normal gameplay the Player Character can run, fire his or her weapon, jump, toss grenades and crouch. In this trope, the player remains in control of the player character, but during story scenes can do little more than walk around or crouch, such that the player will ideally be concentrating on the plot and characters rather than gameplay. (Forcing the player character to walk slowly can also double as Dynamic Loading.) Note that using this trope does not preclude using the two aforementioned alternatives: it's not uncommon to use two or even all of them. Compare Controllable Helplessness, Exposition Break and Scenic Tour Level for other ways of providing exposition in video games. See also Unexpected Gameplay Change, Gameplay and Story Segregation and Sliding Scale of Gameplay and Story Integration.
- God of War: Ghost of Sparta, when in Sparta or in his flashback sequence, Kratos is unable to run or even use his weapon.
- No More Heroes restricts Travis's moves to walking whenever Sylvia calls him on the phone.
- In Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance, whenever Raiden is making an in-gameplay Codec call, he can walk around, but can't run or attack.
- In Tomb Raider (2013), there are sections where Lara has to make a call with other characters, in which she can only walk, and is unable to do anything else. Additionally, during the ending, the player's normal shoot buttons will get changed to the lower shoulder buttons as opposed to both right shoulder buttonsnote after you get a second pistol from Mathaias.
- Despite popularizing the trend for never breaking gameplay in the original instalment (as per the trope description), Half-Life 2 and its expansions feature a subtle example of this: whenever Freeman is facing a friendly NPC, often while the NPC in question provides exposition, he will automatically lower his weapon, preventing the player from firing.
- At the end of Portal 2, after you fall for Wheatley's trap, you end up immobilized while Wheatley takes the opportunity to monologue. You can still aim and fire the Portal Gun, however, and if you shoot the moon, Wheatley will end up sucked into the vacuum of space.
- The Mass Effect 3 endgame is a longer version of this than most. Shepard's movements are reduced to a slow stagger and all abilities are disabled, courtesy of a near miss from Harbinger's main gun. His/her armor is burned to a crisp and s/he is severely injured.
- In the first mission of Ace Combat 5: The Unsung War, Blaze's lock-on function is disabled so he cannot fire on the enemy planes while his CO tries to hail them on the radio. The reason for this is that Blaze's superiors explicitly forbade him from opening fire, and his CO overrides that order only after the hailing attempts fail.
- Batman: Arkham Asylum forces Batman to walk slowly when communicating with Oracle via his earpiece. This doubles as Dynamic Loading, as noted above. Additionally, whenever Batman enters the Visitors' Centre, in which a Joker mannequin sits loudly mocking him, the game cuts to first person and Batman can do nothing other than walk. The game's intro sequence combines this with Scenic Tour Level, as Batman can only walk forwards while following the Joker through the asylum.
- In Assassin's Creed I, there are several occasions in which Altair is having a scripted conversation with another character and the sequences are functionally cutscenes, but the player is still free to walk around the room in question.
- In the original Condemned, whenever Ethan receives a call on his cellphone the player is slowed down to a walk, cannot attack (as he is holding his phone in his hand) and Invisible Walls appear around Ethan, significantly limiting the player's progress. Normal gameplay resumes once the call is over.
- Spec Ops: The Line slows Walker and his team down to a walk in several instances, generally when they are surveying scenes of carnage and destruction. At other points Walker gets severely injured and is reduced to a shambling, exhausted gait.
- Gears of War limits the player's movement to a slow walk in places to allow dialogue to play out.