Line #19 YMMV/Othello


1	----
2	!!The Shakespearean play
3	* AccidentalAesop: Don't believe everything you hear.
4	* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation:
5	** Iago's motives for his plot against Othello. He offers several different ones in the course of the play that get discarded and contradicted.
6	*** PassedOverPromotion: Iago was slighted when Othello promoted Cassio to lieutenant instead of him.
7	*** EmasculatedCuckold: Iago heard a rumor that Emilia cheated on him with Othello. There's no indication that this is true, and most readers agree that it's probably not, but Emilia ''does'' have a speech where she claims that adultery can be (and often is) justified, particularly if a woman cheats on her abusive husband. Iago is certainly awful to Emilia, and Emilia overall demonstrates a far more cynical and "practical" outlook on marriage (and life in general) than Desdemona. It's not too far-fetched to think that she may have sought companionship elsewhere -- if not with Othello, then with ''somebody''.
8	---->'''Iago:''' I hate the Moor: / And it is thought abroad, that 'twixt my sheets / He has done my office: I know not if't be true; / But I, for mere suspicion in that kind, / Will do as if for surety.
9	*** Iago is classist. This is the only motive he expresses with any consistency.
10	*** ForTheEvulz: He didn't actually have a motive, and was doing it just because.
11	---->'''Othello:''' Why he hath thus ensnared my soul and body?\
12	'''Iago:''' Demand me nothing. What you know, you know. / From this time forth I never will speak word.
13	*** Iago has homosexual feelings for Othello and thus is jealous of Desdemona. (See HoYay below.)
14	*** One 2015 performance in Stratford had Iago being played by a black actor, adding some fascinating new dimensions to his rants against Othello.
15	*** Was Iago in a GambitPileup? He originally messes with Othello under the motivation of demoting Cassio by allying with Roderigo who wants to get with Desdemona, Othello's wife. After that, could Iago really just be working to cover his tracks and keep his head above water? By the time he's engineered Cassio's demotion, he's already gotten what he wanted, leaving Roderigo as the loose end, which necessitated sabotaging him in the former's fight with Cassio. He clearly didn't plan on Cassio surviving, or that his wife would reveal his teacher to his king, who would later commit suicide (for murdering Desdemona in a blind rage because of Iago's deception), [[HoistByHisOwnPetard resulting in Cassio being in charge of deciding his fate]]. Looking at the plot like that, Iago comes across less like a ManipulativeBastard schemer and more like a TooCleverByHalf liar who bit off more than he could chew.
16	** Desdemona
17	*** [[TheIngenue An innocent, young woman]] or just ObfuscatingStupidity? Remember that she did manage to "seel her father's eyes" and elope with Othello amongst other not so innocent acts.
18	*** Racist interpretations of the play sometimes see Desdemona as am empty-head strumpet who only marries Othello because she can't control her libido and condemn her for "miscegenation". See the quotation from John Quincy Adams below. Of course, Adams' frothing about Desdemona's "betrayal" of duty, race, sex, and country also stems from his ideas about everything women should be striving for -- to be the perfect consorts of men like their own families (and betraying one's own sex presumably meaning not keeping women of one's own station an exclusive commodity to men of one's own status or preferably higher, therefore presumably degrading their value), and churning out sons in the image of one's own people. Desdemona's relationship with Othello is in this respect behaving as if she's her own individual person, rather than a conduit for Venetian sons -- something unforgivable for misogynists.
19	*** According to Othello, Desdemona once said that "she wished that heaven had made her such a man" that could go on the adventures Othello's described. The obvious, and indeed, most common interpretation is that Desdemona wishes God had made her a man ''to marry'', since it's established that Othello's strength and bravery are [[WomenPreferStrongMen are a huge part of what won her over]]. However, others have suggested that Desdemona means she wishes God had made ''her'' a man, so that ''she'' could go on these adventures herself. The former is probably what was meant, but it's interesting to think about, and potentially throws Desdemona's character in a different light. (And, Shakespeare being Shakespeare, the double-meaning may not have been an accident.)
20	** Othello
21	*** Hero, fool or downright monster? The critic John Sutherland noted that in the original story, Shakespeare's source material, the unsympathetic Othello-equivalent plotted with the Iago-equivalent about how to [[MakeItLookLikeAnAccident kill his wife in a way that wouldn't leave a mark/would look like natural causes]], so that he could escape punishment and could maintain his position. While Shakespeare's Othello is [[AdaptationalHeroism way more sympathetic overall]], there's [[TheArtifact a few lines that indicate that he too attempted such a plan]], putting him in a worse light. Sutherland also discusses how despite making grandiose claims about his handkerchief, in other instances, Othello treats it like a normal handkerchief, and his later obsession with it has elements of BelievingTheirOwnLies.
22	*** At one point, Othello has a seizure [[UnreliableNarrator according to Iago]]. If Othello truthfully has epilepsy, then it's one more obstacle that makes him different from the Venetians and might feed into his insecurity.
23	* CommonKnowledge: [[ProtagonistTitleFallacy Many people believe Othello is the main character]], and that the dynamic between him and Iago is that of a protagonist and antagonist. While Othello is universally considered a leading role, he's not the main character, Iago is, as he's the one who drives the action and has the most lines. Because of this, Iago is not the antagonist, [[VillainProtagonist as even when you're a villain, you're still the protagonist when you're the main character]]. In recent years, more people view Iago as the main character, likely due to a combination of seeing the show and it being made clear, but also because now he's regularly played by a bigger name than Othello's actor.
24	* CompleteMonster: [[IronicNickname Honest]] Iago is one of the most famous examples of this trope to ever appear on the English stage. A bitter Venetian officer who resents the promotion of another man over him by his commander, the Moor Othello, Iago schemes for revenge by [[ManipulativeBastard ingratiating himself with Othello and driving him to madness]] with insinuations his beloved wife Desdemona is having an affair with the officer Michael Cassio. Iago undermines Othello while [[FalseFriend acting as his friend]]. Iago murders his accomplice Roderigo and [[TilMurderDoUsPart his own wife Emilia]] to cover for himself, and at the end, convinces Othello to murder Desdemona. At the end, Iago displays no remorse and refuses to speak one word more in his whole life. Throughout the play, Iago has various motives proposed for his evil--racism; envy; suspicion that Othello is sleeping with Emilia--but concludes he has no reason behind his cruelties beyond the fact that [[ForTheEvulz he simply enjoys them]].
25	* CryForTheDevil: Roderigo is not a very sympathetic character. He's racist, quite creepy towards Desdemona, and engages in plenty of amoral actions throughout the show. But the audience may feel something for him when he reveals to Iago he wishes he could stop loving Desdemona, but isn't strong enough to do so. It doesn't excuse his scummy behavior, but it does show that he's suffering in his own way. Additionally, some viewers may feel a bit bad for him being so damn stupid, given Iago is so easily able to manipulate him into a grave.
26	* DracoInLeatherPants: Modern productions tend to be more sympathetic towards Iago, perhaps [[MisaimedFandom overly so]]. The fact that he was once played by Kenneth Branagh--and more recently by Ewan [=McGregor=]--doesn't help.
27	** In ''Film/{{O2001}}'', [[HighSchoolAU the modern update set in High School]], Iago is played by [[MrFanservice Josh Harnett.]]
28	** And in a modern update ''not'' set in high school, he's played by Creator/ChristopherEccleston, who already had an unsettling tendency to make even a horrible villain at least a bit sympathetic.
29	* EnsembleDarkhorse: Emilia, Iago's wife and Desdemona's maid, has been extremely popular throughout much of the play's history for the way she excoriates unfaithful husbands in a touching monologue in the fourth act, chews out Othello for his crime, and delivers the fatal blow to her own husband's EvilPlan, gets stabbed, and then ''[[{{Determinator}} keeps going]]''. She's even ''triumphant'' about being stabbed, as the act shows Iago up for the criminal he is. In fact, it was not uncommon at certain points for her to be billed above her mistress, the play's [[DesignatedHero ostensible heroine]].
30	* EveryoneIsJesusInPurgatory: The idea that Iago is {{Satan}} (allegorically, if not [[DevilInDisguise literally]]). He's a manipulator and tempter who [[FlawExploitation plays on everyone's flaws and fears]] while appearing to be an honest ManOfWealthAndTaste, and he talks Othello into renouncing God.
31	* EvilIsCool: Iago's a monster, but the way that he manages to control all those around him through sheer wit is quite impressive.
32	* FairForItsDay:
33	** In the original story on which ''Othello'' is based, the Moorish character doesn't even have a name, and it ends with Desdemona [[AuthorFilibuster lecturing the audience on why interracial marriage is evil.]] In his adaptation, Shakespeare gives the Moor a name and fully fleshes out his character into a sympathetic war hero. In fact, the only overtly racist elements of the play are spoken by unsympathetic characters.
34	** In regards for how the play treats women, it's not quite as cut-and-dried as one may think. It is true that the play revolves around SlutShaming, and Emilia tolerates a ''lot'' of horrific treatment from her husband (and later, after Othello goes full GreenEyedMonster, Desdemona does as well). ''However'', Emilia is remarkably resilient and proactive, and is the one who ensures Iago gets his just deserts at the end, and Desdemona isn't quite the one-dimensional pushover people remember. (She's admittedly quite placid, but she also willingly went behind her racist father's back to marry the man she loved, which is a rather gutsy move.) It's also pretty clear that the aforementioned slut-shaming is ''wrong''; it ultimately gets an innocent woman killed, and Cassio's poor treatment of Bianca (a [[HookerWithAHeartOfGold perfectly nice courtesan he's been seeing]]) solidifies him as a bit of a {{jerkass}}. Emilia also has a rather impressive monologue where she says that, yes, some women do cheat, but we shouldn't be so quick to judge them, since [[DoubleStandard men cheat, too]], and many women are driven to cheat because their husbands abuse them. So while the play isn't exactly pro-feminist, it's still got some interesting points where the treatment of female characters are concerned.
35	* FandomEnragingMisconception: Several fans don't care for it when people try to say this is a racist play, given the POC titular character is portrayed sympathetically, and the only overtly racist characters are unsympathetic villains.
36	* HoYay: Some scholars -- and many a high school English teacher -- have proposed that Iago's true motivation is unrequited love for Othello. You can find evidence for this in his dialogue. Then again, you can find evidence for at least a dozen, often conflicting, motivations in his dialog. He also says he has no reason at all. See also ForTheEvulz. In any case, it might be a case of a deliberate MultipleChoicePast, to emphasize that Iago is an unrepentant liar.
37	** An oft-cited piece of evidence for this possible motivation is the scene wherein Iago and Othello initiate a [[MetaphoricalMarriage pseudo-wedding ceremony]]. To each other.
38	--->'''Othello:''' ''[kneels]'' In the due reverence of a sacred vow / I here engage my words.\
39	'''Iago:''' Do not rise yet. ''[kneels]'' / Witness, you ever-burning lights above, / You elements that clip us round about, / Witness that here Iago doth give up / The execution of his wit, hands, heart, / To wrong'd Othello's service! Let him command, / And to obey shall be in me remorse, / What bloody business ever.\
40	''[they rise]''\
41	'''Othello:''' I greet thy love, / Not with vain thanks, but with acceptance bounteous, / And will upon the instant put thee to't: / Within these three days let me hear thee say / That Cassio's not alive.\
42	. . .\
43	'''Iago:''' I am your own for ever.
44	** For some, Iago's description of Cassio in bed with him and "sleep humping" might fit this.
45	* LoveToHate: Iago is one of the most famously monstrous characters in all of fiction, but he's a truly fascinating and hugely entertaining VillainProtagonist, and his sheer evilness only contributes to that.
46	* MemeticMutation: Everyone trusts Iago. Except Emilia, but who asked her?
47	* MisaimedFandom: Like ''Theatre/TheMerchantOfVenice'', racist interpretations of this play have been offered, such as this one from John Quincy Adams:
48	-->'''UsefulNotes/JohnQuincyAdams:''' Who can feel sympathy for Desdemona? A woman who, born and educated to a splendid and lofty station in the community, betrays her race, her sex, her duty and her country, and makes a runaway match with a blackamoor!
49	* MoralEventHorizon:
50	** Iago crosses it by putting his horrifically petty revenge plot into action.
51	** He may be a sympathetic character who's manipulated into doing so, but Othello murdering Desdemona is still a horrific action, and once Othello gets the clear picture of events afterwards, it's clear he himself believes he's crossed it.
52	** Brabantio's initial demeanor, while racist and violent, could be somewhat defended by [[PapaWolf him being so upset about his daughter's well being]]. But once it’s been made clear to him that Desdemona is perfectly fine and happy with Othello, he disowns her for marrying a Moor, which makes it clear that he's a cruel bigot who could care less about his daughter if her ideals go against his.
53	** Roderigo crosses it by trying to take Desdemona for his own and ruin Othello alongside Iago, even though it's clear that the two of them are [[HappilyMarried happy together]].
54	* {{Narm}}:
55	** Desdemona having a few last words ''after'' being strangled to death. Considering how hard it is for death by strangulation to work, it's perhaps a case of RealityIsUnrealistic, and her final words where she refuses to blame Othello for her death, elevates her above someone fridged.
56	** In the Olivier film, the make-up used to make Olivier look black more often makes him look blue or grey.
57	** At one point Iago says to Roderigo a statement that's basically meant to say "Good lord". Sounds pretty straightforward. Unfortunately, the phrase he uses is "Blessed pudding".
58	* NightmareFuel: The whole show, really. So many lives are ruined by one man's hatred. Iago sets off the chain of events that does all this damage with a well-placed handkerchief, and ''rumors''. Over the course of ''less than a week'', one man manages to drive a previously devoted husband to murder his wife, and indirectly causes the death of three others, without a hint of remorse. [[MultipleChoicePast And we don't even really know]] ''[[UnreliableNarrator why]]''. The best we can figure is that [[ForTheEvulz he just thinks it's fun]].
59	* ParanoiaFuel: There is something deeply unsettling about the character Iago. The idea that someone you trust implicitly could be so sociopathic that the first minor, unintentional slight you perpetrate against them could lead them to utterly destroy your life for kicks is very creepy. Stabbing his own wife without the slightest hint of regret or reluctance.
60	* RescuedFromTheScrappyHeap: As feminism began to seriously kick off in the twentieth century, new attention was paid to the traditionally-disdained character of Desdemona. The especial turning point is usually seen as Dame Creator/MaggieSmith's tough, angry SilkHidingSteel performance in 1964, which encouraged later productions to put much more fight and sexuality in their Desdemonas after a long period of passive, chaste bowdlerisation. Even the more demure versions since then have become more prominent and central more often, with their tragedy being emphasised rather than being sidelined to better serve the interplay of Othello and Iago.
61	* RootingForTheEmpire: While a good production should make you feel for and hope in vain that Iago's victims don't fall for his tricks, the combination of his stylish villainy and cunning nature makes watching his monstrous actions quite engaging, which means you'll likely want to see where all his plotting is going, even if you know the outcome is anything but good for the decidedly more sympathetic characters. Creator/IanMcKellen even said that when filming the 1990 stage version, he was accused by Willard White (who played Othello) of trying to get the audience on his side, and replied that he didn't have to try due to Shakespeare writing Iago as the central character.
62	* TheScrappy: Starting in the eighteenth century, Desdemona's character was heavily bowdlerised to remove the more subversive elements and make her nothing other than a demure, passive, innocent victim with all the personality of a damp piece of paper. This characterisation stuck for most of the next 300 years, and made her exceedingly unpopular amongst both actors and the audience. The actor William Macready warned Fanny Kemble thusly before she took on the role (and actually turned out to be one of the more successful and spirited Desdemonas of the time):
63	-->'''William Macready:''' ... there is absolutely nothing to be done with (the part of Desdemona), nothing; nobody can produce an effect in it; and really, Emilia's last scene can be made a great deal more of. [[EnsembleDarkhorse I could understand your playing that]], but not Desdemona.
64	* SignatureLine:
65	-->'''Iago:''' Oh beware, my lord, of jealousy! / It is the green-eyed monster, which doth mock / the meat it feeds on!
66	* ValuesDissonance: Some readers won't understand that when Othello gives up Christianity, he super-damns himself to Hell; that's even worse than just being a pagan.
67	** More obviously: these days, a black man marrying a white woman would not raise many eyebrows. Back then, not so much.
68	** In keeping with that idea, given what a beloved and classic villain Iago is, the fact that so many big stars of the past would prefer to darken up their skin and play his {{Deuteragonist}} instead of him just makes this even more noticeable, particularly because nowadays, Iago is usually played by the bigger name than Othello.
69	** In a more meta-example, Othello has been historically played by white people who artificially darkened their skin for the role. Nowadays, most production would just get a black person to play Othello.
70	* ValuesResonance: On several points.
71	** The play's main message (interracial marriage can be a loving one and racism can bring severe consequences) is still, if not more, relevant in today world of global traveling easier than Shakespeare's time. Likewise, relationships are difficult and messy, and the play's rather overt criticism of the MadonnaWhoreComplex, and its portrayal of how a loving husband can become domineering and abusive, and make it hard for the wife to resist, makes it a pretty realistic work.
72	** This following exchange just keeps getting funnier as the years go by.
73	--->'''Brabantio:''' Thou art a villain!\
74	'''Iago:''' You are a senator!
75	** Cassio's blithe dismissal of Iago's misogynistic remarks as TooFunnyToBeEvil (and the way that it is shown as a clear mistake on Cassio's part that allows Iago to go on to ruin many people's lives) also resonates with modern audiences, who tend to take such red flags more seriously a la "when people show you who they are, believe them the first time."
76	* VindicatedByHistory: Even more than usual for Shakespeare -- he subverted a lot of {{Forgotten Trope}}s at a time when a ClicheStorm was expected. Thomas Rymer's ''Short View of Tragedy'' in 1693 summed up the response to, for instance, a soldier as a villain rather than an honest man, and a dropped handkerchief leading to multiple murders rather than a comical misunderstanding.
77	* TheWoobie:
78	** Desdemona has a [[BreakTheCutie very]], ''[[KillTheCutie very]]'' bad week. She just wants to spend some time with her husband, and for her trouble, gets MistakenForCheating, humiliated, abused, and ultimately smothered in her own bed. And she dies ''refusing to name Othello as her killer''.
79	** Othello himself, sometimes bordering on JerkassWoobie, depending on the actor. Yeah, he's got a jealous streak a mile wide, and he can be a bit self-centered, but the guy's obviously got some internalized racism, as well as some major insecurities in his marriage to Desdemona, unable to see that she really does love him. Throw in a ManipulativeBastard and you've got a recipe for a tragedy. Specifically, this one.
80	** Emilia, Iago's wife, mostly on the grounds of being ''[[TheSociopath Iago]]'s [[DomesticAbuse wife]]''. She tries to please him, to no avail, and one of these attempts ultimately gets her best friend murdered. And then when Emilia finally outs Iago as the bastard he is, he kills her, too.
81
82	----
83
84	!!The manga
85	* {{Anvilicious}}: Almost all chapters transmit the message that bullying is bad and that you should stand against it. Also, one chapter is centered exclusively on reporting train sexual harassers while barely apporting to the plot itself.
86	* CatharsisFactor: Nana while dancing on the school roof beats up all of Megumi's henchmen, before stealing a skateboard to chase Megumi.
87	* TheWoobie: Yaya. She lives without a mother, her father is too strict with her, she's never had any friends and her only emotional support is following a (already disbanded) VisualKei band. Wow.
88

Context YMMV / Othello