History YMMV / TheMrMenShow

** Miss Whoops is a glasses-wearing klutz who wants to help others, her nasally US voice is more pleasing.

** Many fans see Mr. Tickle as having a tickle fetish, Mr. Bump as a masochist, and Mr. Persnickety/Fussy having OCD.

* AluminumChristmasTrees: Many of the dishes Mr. Grumpy and Mr. Fussy say in the show may sound obscure to younger viewers (eg. Mashed Swede and yams, crepe suzette, bangers and mash), but they are real foods.

** Mr. Rude has gotten this treatment from the fanbase. He's either liked for having some of the funniest lines, or disliked for being a [[FlatCharacter soulless]] [[FrenchJerk French]] [[EthnicScrappy stereotype]] whose entire schick is [[{{Gasshole}} fart]] [[ToiletHumour jokes]].
** Characters like Miss Naughty and Miss Scary can be either seen as characters who make the show enjoyable, or characters who don't get any comeuppance for their ruthless actions.

** Mr. Funny not being able to speak, contrast to his book counterpart, which some fans were turned off as they would've liked hear him speak. Though there's some that think it's probably a good thing he didn't, as it would've clashed with Mr. Scatterbrain (Mark Risley stated this was the reason they changed him).
* BetterOnDVD: The series is better on DVD, as the footage is in 16:9, compare to how it's shown on television. This is also the case with the British version, which aside from what the American version has to offer, doesn't have the audio high pitched and contains the missing segments!

** Some fans of the ''Mr. Men'' franchise hate this show for being unfaithful and InNameOnly to the books and [[WesternAnimation/MrMenAndLittleMiss previous adaptions]] (the redesigns of several characters, the very different Americanised setting and the DenserAndWackier tone for instance), other people don't really mind and see the show good in its own right.

* CrackPairing: Despite them only having two segments together and ultimately hating each other, fans love to ship Mr. Rude and Mr. Stubborn.

* DesignatedMonkey: Mr. Bump tends to suffer this a lot, especially in the second season. Although it's [[MeaningfulName clearly in his name]], some fans tend to dislike this.

* FridgeBrilliance: In "Flying", Mr. Grumpy says that he started working as a flight attendant 30 years ago. 30 years before the episode premiered was 1978, when Mr. Grumpy's book was released.

* UnnecessaryMakeover: Mr. Persnickety /Pernickety was redesigned from the character Mr. Fussy, but by the time the second season happened, he was given a drastic change in terms of looks. He was repainted dark green and renamed like his book counterpart due to Chorion wanting the show be more like the books. Some fans that grew up watching the show since the first season thought the makeover was uneeded for a few reasons. For one, his original name from the first season made him more high class sounding as compare to "Fussy" which sounds more childish. While fans like his skin color to be more darker compare to the other brightly colored green characters, some thought he should've kept the green hair color like in the first season. The last major complaint from fans was him being more one noted. While Mr. Fussy had his moments in the first season being a neat freak, he does try to be friendly with the other characters. But the second season makes him more meaner as the show focuses more on him being uptight (worse in the comics by Viz where he is strict about the rules) compare to him being fleshed out from the first season.

* AdaptionDisplacement: In America at least, the original books aren't as known there as they are in their native UK.

** Miss Whoops is a glasses where klutz who wants to help others, her nasally US voice is more pleasing.
** Mr. Nervous is a glasses wearing coward who is huggable whenever he is scared.

* AuthorsSavingThrow:
** The writers for both Mr. Strong and Miss Sunshine's comics added Miss Calamity after the fan reactions that she was removed in the show.
** Mr. Tall was given more screentime in Miss Daredevil's comic since he was hardly used in the show.

*** His UK voice actor even voiced a character [[NamesTheSame with the same name as a character on this show]] - Mr. Small. He left after the first season, though.

** When the show first came out, various fans of both this and ''[[WesternAnimation/ThomasAndFriends Thomas & Friends]]'' did parody clips depicting several ''Thomas'' characters as the Mr. Men and Little Misses. A year later, some of the UK and Israeli voices from the show would play characters for ''Thomas''. (Though Mr. Tickle and Stubborn's VA for the Hebrew dub already voiced Thomas in ''WesternAnimation/ThomasAndTheMagicRailroad'').

* SeasonalRot: While not considered outright bad, season 2 is seen as weaker then the first for several reasons, such as Miss Calamity being removed, Mr. Bump and Mr. Fussy's increased ButtMonkey nature, the reduced amount of shorts and the new characters not having enough screen time.

* ViewerGenderConfusion: Little Miss Scary, due to her deep, boyish voice (in the American dub) and spiky hair.

* {Adorkable}: Miss Whoops is a glasses where klutz who wants to help others, her nasally US voice is more pleasing. Mr. Nervous is a glasses wearing coward who is huggable whenever he is scared.

** Miss Calamity, despite being loved by many, is disliked by some for her annoying voice and [[UncannyValley character design]] having a more human-like hairstyle.

* UncannyValley: The Miss Calamity statue from "Trees", as it looks realistic compared to the rest of the show because it’s actually an edited photo of a blind-bag toy of her.

** Speaking of ''Thomas'', Mr. Fussy's catchphrase "Sweet Henrietta!" become more funny since Rob Rackstraw voices Toby, who owns a carriage named Henrietta.

* UnexpectedCharacter: Mr. Tall playing a semi-prominent role in the first plot of "Travel" with no foreshadowing he'd appear. Considering he rarely does anything outside of cameos, the fans may have been just as surprised to see him as Mr. Fussy was.

* DarknessInducedAudienceApathy: The show can be seen as this to some, as many of the characters who are oblivious (or downright jerks) harm others who might have not deserve this (Mr. Bump suffering the most during the second season).

%%* AccidentalInnuendo: The lyrics for "Tickle it Out" is about tickling a cow to get milk out. %%ZCE