Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / TheHuntersGuildRedHood

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MagnificentBastard: Ludwig Geppetto, also known as Heck Horlock, was once a respected member of the Hunters Guild and the second Red Hood. Growing disillusioned with the Guild’s use of the True Book to manipulate the world and entertain the eldritch beings who created it, he swore to destroy the book and MercyKill the whole world. He tore two pages from the book and erased all records of his existence, before taking a new identity and joining the Red List. Ludwig combines his magic with the magic of the stolen pages to create the power to negate the book’s effect, before working with Cinderella to create Velou as a vessel for that power. He becomes the mayor of Kasoka Village, raising and secretly training Velou to be ready and determined to become the hunter. Ludwig lures the hunter Grimm to the village with werewolf attacks, before faking his death and orchestrating village’s destruction. Keeping the eye on Velou until he comes to Guild’s headquarters, Ludwig reveals himself and takes the boy to the book’s room so his mere presence will unravel its influence. As the world is being erased, he keeps Velou’s allies at bay before comforting Velou and being convinced to let the boy kill him so the world will continue to exist free from the book’s influence.

to:

* MagnificentBastard: Ludwig Geppetto, also known as Heck Horlock, was once a respected member of the Hunters Guild and the second Red Hood. Growing disillusioned with the Guild’s use of the True Book to manipulate the world and entertain the eldritch beings who created it, he swore to destroy the book and MercyKill the whole world. He tore two pages from the book and erased all records of his existence, before taking a new identity and joining the Red List. Ludwig combines his magic with the magic of the stolen pages to create the power to negate the book’s book's effect, before working with Cinderella to create Velou as a vessel for that power. He becomes the mayor of Kasoka Village, raising and secretly training Velou to be ready and determined to become the hunter. Ludwig lures the hunter Grimm to the village with werewolf attacks, before faking his death and orchestrating village’s village's destruction. Keeping the eye on Velou until he comes to Guild’s Guild's headquarters, Ludwig reveals himself and takes the boy to the book’s room so his mere presence will unravel its influence. As the world is being erased, he keeps Velou’s Velou's allies at bay before comforting Velou and being convinced to let the boy kill him so the world will continue to exist free from the book’s influence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MagnificentBastard: Ludwig Geppetto, also known as Heck Horlock, was once a respected member of the Hunters Guild and the second Red Hood. Growing disillusioned with the Guild’s use of the True Book to manipulate the world and entertain the eldritch beings who created it, he swore to destroy the book and MercyKill the whole world. He tore two pages from the book and erased all records of his existence, before taking a new identity and joining the Red List. Ludwig combines his magic with the magic of the stolen pages to create the power to negate the book’s effect, before working with Cinderella to create Velou as a vessel for that power. He becomes the mayor of Kasoka Village, raising and secretly training Velou to be ready and determined to become the hunter. Ludwig lures the hunter Grimm to the village with werewolf attacks, before faking his death and orchestrating village’s destruction. Keeping the eye on Velou until he comes to Guild’s headquarters, Ludwig reveals himself and takes the boy to the book’s room so his mere presence will unravel its influence. As the world is being erased, he keeps Velou’s allies at bay before comforting Velou and being convinced to let the boy kill him so the world will continue to exist free from the book’s influence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Flamebait.


* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: The series picked up a lot of interest at the beginning due to the interesting premise of hunting monsters in a grimm-fantasy setting. However, after the introductory arc, the story moves the focus on a standard exam arc that turned off many readers, leading to the series' early cancellation.
* WhatAnIdiot: Rather than just attack and eat the hunters when he has the chance, Dodou decides to [[{{Exposition}} exposit]] about werewolves' regenerative abilities, and demonstrate exactly how to kill one by ripping Naraoia's heart out. Because of this, the hunters are able to escape, and they now outnumber him 2:1 when they go after him again.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: The series picked up a lot of interest at the beginning due to the interesting premise of hunting monsters in a grimm-fantasy setting. However, after the introductory arc, the story moves the focus on a standard exam arc that turned off many readers, leading to the series' early cancellation.
* WhatAnIdiot: Rather than just attack and eat the hunters when he has the chance, Dodou decides to [[{{Exposition}} exposit]] about werewolves' regenerative abilities, and demonstrate exactly how to kill one by ripping Naraoia's heart out. Because of this, the hunters are able to escape, and they now outnumber him 2:1 when they go after him again.
cancellation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GermansLoveDavidHasselhoff: Much like [[Manga/Samurai8TheTaleOfHachimaru certain]] [[Manga/TimeParadoxGhostwriter other]] [[Manga/PhantomSeer series]], ''Red Hood'' gained an overnight following on western social media sites such as Website/{{Reddit}} and WebSite/YouTube, its subreddit reaching 1000 members when the series had only 3 chapters. Sadly the same couldn't be said in its home nation, where it bled readership in the middle of its run until it was unfortunately cancelled.

to:

* GermansLoveDavidHasselhoff: Much like [[Manga/Samurai8TheTaleOfHachimaru certain]] [[Manga/TimeParadoxGhostwriter other]] [[Manga/PhantomSeer series]], ''Red Hood'' gained an overnight following on western social media sites such as Website/{{Reddit}} and WebSite/YouTube, its subreddit reaching 1000 members when the series had only 3 chapters. Sadly Sadly, the same couldn't be said in its home nation, where it bled readership in the middle of its run until it was unfortunately cancelled.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GeniusBonus: "Wolfonium" may actually be tungsten, which has the Latin name ''wolframium''

to:

* GeniusBonus: "Wolfonium" may actually be tungsten, which has the Latin name ''wolframium''''wolframium''.



** Especially early on, the series [[https://youtu.be/NgKbs49ayNg tends]] [[https://youtu.be/0hybLhaHfnc to]] [[https://youtu.be/r62EsCqyzLg get]] [[https://youtu.be/A9aMO_3ZyDw compared]] to ''[[Manga/DemonSlayerKimetsuNoYaiba Demon Slayer]]'' due to the similar premise of hunting down cannibalistic monsters that [[WasOnceAMan were once human]]

to:

** Especially early on, the series [[https://youtu.be/NgKbs49ayNg tends]] [[https://youtu.be/0hybLhaHfnc to]] [[https://youtu.be/r62EsCqyzLg get]] [[https://youtu.be/A9aMO_3ZyDw compared]] to ''[[Manga/DemonSlayerKimetsuNoYaiba Demon Slayer]]'' due to the similar premise of hunting down cannibalistic monsters that [[WasOnceAMan were once human]]human]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
uuh this trope is about being hated outside the nation it comes from, literally the opposite of what is written


* AmericansHateTingle: Loved outside of Japan, but in it's nation not so much. It was seen as a bog standard action series and couldn't get much readers onboard, leading to it's cancellation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AmericansHateTingle: Loved outside of Japan, but in it's nation not so much. It was seen as a bog standard action series and couldn't get much readers onboard, leading to it's cancellation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GermansLoveDavidHasselhoff: Much like [[Manga/Samurai8TheTaleOfHachimaru certain]] [[Manga/TimeParadoxGhostwriter other]] [[Manga/PhantomSeer series]], ''Red Hood'' gained an overnight following on western social media sites such as Website/{{Reddit}} and WebSite/YouTube, its subreddit reaching 1000 members when the series had only 3 chapters. Sadly the same couldn't be said in it's home nation where it bled readership in the middle of it's run until it was unfortunately cancelled.

to:

* GermansLoveDavidHasselhoff: Much like [[Manga/Samurai8TheTaleOfHachimaru certain]] [[Manga/TimeParadoxGhostwriter other]] [[Manga/PhantomSeer series]], ''Red Hood'' gained an overnight following on western social media sites such as Website/{{Reddit}} and WebSite/YouTube, its subreddit reaching 1000 members when the series had only 3 chapters. Sadly the same couldn't be said in it's its home nation nation, where it bled readership in the middle of it's its run until it was unfortunately cancelled.



* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: The series picked up a lot of interest at the beginning due to the interesting premise of hunting monsters in a grimm-fantasy setting. However, after the introductory arc the story moves the focus on a standard exam arc that turns off many readers, leading to the series' early cancellation.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: The series picked up a lot of interest at the beginning due to the interesting premise of hunting monsters in a grimm-fantasy setting. However, after the introductory arc arc, the story moves the focus on a standard exam arc that turns turned off many readers, leading to the series' early cancellation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GermansLoveDavidHasselhoff: Much like [[Manga/Samurai8TheTaleOfHachimaru certain]] [[Manga/TimeParadoxGhostwriter other]] [[Manga/PhantomSeer series]], ''Red Hood'' gained an overnight following on western social media sites such as Website/{{Reddit}} and WebSite/YouTube, its subreddit reaching 1000 members when the series had only 3 chapters.

to:

* GermansLoveDavidHasselhoff: Much like [[Manga/Samurai8TheTaleOfHachimaru certain]] [[Manga/TimeParadoxGhostwriter other]] [[Manga/PhantomSeer series]], ''Red Hood'' gained an overnight following on western social media sites such as Website/{{Reddit}} and WebSite/YouTube, its subreddit reaching 1000 members when the series had only 3 chapters. Sadly the same couldn't be said in it's home nation where it bled readership in the middle of it's run until it was unfortunately cancelled.



* TheyWastedAPerfectGoodPlot: The series picked up a lot of interest at the beginning due to the interesting premise of hunting monsters in a grimm-fantasy setting. However, after the introductory arc the story moves the focus on a standard exam arc that turns off many readers, leading to the series' early cancellation.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectGoodPlot: TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: The series picked up a lot of interest at the beginning due to the interesting premise of hunting monsters in a grimm-fantasy setting. However, after the introductory arc the story moves the focus on a standard exam arc that turns off many readers, leading to the series' early cancellation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I guess this is probably what you wanted to say, They Wasted A Perfect Good Polt is a criticism I've read quite often

Added DiffLines:

* TheyWastedAPerfectGoodPlot: The series picked up a lot of interest at the beginning due to the interesting premise of hunting monsters in a grimm-fantasy setting. However, after the introductory arc the story moves the focus on a standard exam arc that turns off many readers, leading to the series' early cancellation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
yes, but the cause is not the length of the training arc, is, as you said, the lack of monster hunting (plus the fact it suddenly focused on new characters that haven't been properly introduced). Arc Fatigue is when an arc is seemingly too long (and 7 chapters is pretty fair for an initial arc, actually), not an unbrella for every criticism


* ArcFatigue: The manga suffered heavily from an overly long training arc where Velou and a gaggle of new characters played "Cops-And-Robbers" to test them for entry into the eponymous Hunting Guild. This tanked ratings and drove a number of readers to drop the series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Re-adding Arc Fatigue because the lack of monster hunting is what led to the book getting canned far earlier than intended.

Added DiffLines:

* ArcFatigue: The manga suffered heavily from an overly long training arc where Velou and a gaggle of new characters played "Cops-And-Robbers" to test them for entry into the eponymous Hunting Guild. This tanked ratings and drove a number of readers to drop the series.

Top