History YMMV / SilentHillRevelation3D

** The "poptart jumpscare". To elaborate, it's a strange moment of editing where after Heather's NightmareSequence at the start it suddenly cuts to a close-up of a poptart inside a toaster. Needless to say, WebVideo/{{Phelous}} has made this into a RunningGag in his reviews.

** The "poptart jumpscare". To elaborate, it's a strange moment of editing where after Heather's NightmareSequence at the start it suddenly cuts to a close-up of a poptart popping out of a toaster. Needless to say, WebVideo/{{Phelous}} has made this into a RunningGag in his reviews.

** The "poptart jumpscare". To elaborate, it's a strange moment of editing where after Heather's NightmareSequence at the start it suddenly cuts to a close-up of a poptart popping out of a toaster. Needless to say, WebVideo/Phelous has made this into a RunningGag in his reviews.

** The Missionary, in the game, is a creepy blob-headed monster somewhat akin to Pyramid Head. In the movie, it's essentially a [[{{Hellraiser}} Cenobite]] for no apparent reason.

* EsotericHappyEnding: [[spoiler:Yes, Heather saved her father, apparently defeated the order for good, and got to leave with Vincent...but out in the real world, she's still considered a murder suspect, so it's unlikely she'll get a warm welcome when she comes back home]].
*** [[spoiler: Who says she's going back home? She and Vincent are probably going to run away somewhere, like her father and her did the last time. Plus, it's hinted she may retain some of Alessa's powers...]]

* HilariousInHindsight: SeanBean [[GameofThrones (Ned Stark)]] Plays Harry Mason in both movies. Guess who Vincent is played by in Revelations. The same guy who plays Jon Snow.

* CriticalDissonance: The Critic ratings on Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic are dismally low (6% and 15/100 respectively), but the User Reviews are slightly higher (42% and 5.6/10 respectively).

* OneSceneWonder: MalcolmMcDowell as Leonard.

** Well, Vincent [[spoiler: was branded as a traitor by Claudia right in front of Harry, and helped Heather save Harry while PH and the Missionary were fighting. There's really no reason not to trust him by the end of the film.]] Doesn't make the romance any less unnecessary.

* {{Sequelitis}}: The first film was generally regarded as a successful adaptation, silly plot direction aside. This one was universally panned by critics and even within the average movie going audience it can claim very very few fans.

* {{Sequelitis}}: The first film was generally regarded as a successful adaptation, silly plot direction aside. This one was universally panned by critics and there's a SoBadItsGood entry for a reason.

** Well, Vincent [[spoiler: was branded as a traitor by Claudia right in front of Harry, and helped Heather save Harry while PH and the Missionary were fighting. There's really no reason not to trust him by the end of the film.]] Doesn't make the romance any less unnecessary.
* {{Sequelitis}}: The first film was generally regarded as a successful adaptation, silly plot direction aside. This one was universally panned by critics and there's a SoBadItsGood entry for a reason.
* SoBadItsGood: To some viewers. It is to Silent Hill what Michael Bay was to Transformers.

* DarthWiki/SoBadItsHorrible: It is to Silent Hill what Michael Bay was to Transformers.

* SoBadItsGood: It is to Silent Hill what Michael Bay was to Transformers.

* VideoGameMoviesSuck: While some people may [[NarmCharm enjoy]] [[SoBadItsGood it,]] most agree that it's slow, unrealistic (the characters and the acting), and has a lot of cheap scares.
* VoodooShark: For every question this movie supposedly answers (or tries to) it simply raises a dozen other questions.

* VideoGameMoviesSuck: While some people may [[NarmCharm enjoy]] [[SoBadItsGood it,]] most agree that it's a pretty terrible movie.

* DarthWiki/SoBadItsHorrible: The general consensus of viewers with standards and taste.

* VideoGameMoviesSuck: While some people may [[NarmCharm enjoy]] [[SoBadItsGood it,]] most agree that it's a pretty terrible movie.

* VideoGameMoviesSuck: While some of people may [[NarmCharm enjoy]] [[SoBadItsGood it,]] most agree that it's a pretty terrible movie.

* SoBadItsHorrible: The general consensus of viewers with standards and taste.

* VideoGameMoviesSuck: While a lot of people may [[NarmCharm enjoy]] [[SoBadItsGood it,]] most agree that it's a pretty terrible movie.