History YMMV / SilentHillRevelation3D

* SoBadItsGood: It is to Silent Hill what Micheal Bay was to Transformers.

* CriticalDissonance: Holds an 8% on RottenTomatoes and a 7.3/10 on IMDB.
** It's now dropped to 6% on RottenTomatoes and a 6/10 on IMDB.
* [[spoiler:EsotericHappyEnding: Yes, Heather saved her father, apparently defeated the order for good, and got to leave with Vincent...but out in the real world, she's still considered a murder suspect, so it's unlikely she'll get a warm welcome when she comes back home]].

* VideoGameMoviesSuck: While a lot of people may [[NarmCharm enjoy]] [[SoBadItsGood it,]] most agree that it's a pretty terrible movie.
** Please note the CriticalDissonance above.

* VideoGameMoviesSuck: While a lot of people may [[NarmCharm enjoy]] [[SoBadItsGood it,]] most agree that it's a pretty terrible movie.

* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: Complaints over Vincent's age and relation to the plot have been a major complaint from fans, not to mention [[spoiler: killing off Douglas in Harry's place, mitigating the formers role in the story and neutering a large part of Heather's appeal as a character.]]

* AuthorsSavingThrow: Pyramid Head is stated to be [[spoiler: Alessa/Heather's guardian and executioner, in a sense taking Valtiel's role from [[SilentHill3 SH3]]]], largely [[VooDooShark justifying]] complaints of his [[BigLippedAlligatorMoment unexplained presence]] in the first movie.

* AlternateCharacterInterpretation: Uses this to justify [[spoiler:Pyramid Head's]] existence in the movie continuity.

* ItsNotSupposedToWinOscars: The common defense for the movie whenever anyone tries to point out it's countless flaws and systematic raping of the source material.

* SoBadItsGood: It is to Silent Hill what Micheal Bay was to Transformers. Depending on how much you're willing to forgive, it's either this or DarthWiki/SoBadItsHorrible.

* {{Narm}}: The dialogue writing [[HamAndCheese and]] [[DullSurprise acting]] in this movie are just about as bad as they were in the first game, which came out over two decades ago, and were dramatically improved by the PS2 era to create an effective mood of unease. Here it's just bad acting.

* SoBadItsGood: It is to Silent Hill what Micheal Bay was to Transformers. Depending on how much you're willing to forgive, it's either this or SoBadItsHorrible.

* SoBadItsGood: It is to Silent Hill what Micheal Bay was to Transformers. Depending on how much you're willing to forgive, it's either this or SoBadItsAwful.

* SoBadItsGood: It's basically an extended Silent Hill cutscene with [[ActionizedSequel extra, unnecessary action,]] (which as anyone who played the first three games knows, [[{{Narm}} isn't good]]) without much left of the crushingly despairing atmosphere of the original games that made them so terrifying. However, [[VideoGameMoviesSuck despite what this implies,]] [[DoingItForTheArt it's clear whoever made the film]] [[ShownTheirWork was a big fan of the games;]][[note]]Much of the film is spent making the changes of the first movie's plot from the game fit into the Silent Hill universe, such as the names of the characters, and Chris/Rose's replacement of Harry, and some of the locations look like exact replicas of locations in SilentHill3.[[/note]] they just went for the NarmCharm filled cutscene atmosphere instead of the crushing despair of the main gameplay atmosphere. [[CanonDefilement And as]] ridiculously {{OOC}} as it is, some people still think seeing [[spoiler:[[ImplacableMan Pyramid]] [[CompleteMonster Head]] [[CoolVersusAwesome fighting Claudia to protect Alessa]]]] [[NarmCharm is pretty awesome,]] if you're into completely pointless mindless action for the sake of action that clashes with the established motifs of the series and the rest of the movies contained ridiculousness itself.
** [[spoiler: Whether or not it's in character depends on your interpretation of Pyramid Head in the games (i.e. whether or not he's James Sunderland's demon, or Silent Hill's), but he has always helped the PlayerCharacter in some way or another.]]

* NarmCharm: The dialogue writing [[HamAndCheese and]] [[DullSurprise acting]] in this movie are just about as bad [[ShownTheirWork as they were in the original games.]]

* SoBadItsGood: It's basically an extended Silent Hill cutscene with [[ActionizedSequel extra, unnecessary action,]] (which as anyone who played the first three games knows, [[{{Narm}} isn't good]]) without much left of the crushingly despairing atmosphere of the original games that made them so terrifying. However, [[VideoGameMoviesSuck despite what this implies,]] [[DoingItForTheArt it's clear whoever made the film]] [[ShownTheirWork was a big fan of the games;]][[note]]Much of the film is spent making the changes of the first movie's plot from the game fit into the Silent Hill universe, such as the names of the characters, and Chris/Rose's replacement of Harry, and some of the locations look like exact replicas of locations in SilentHill3.[[/note]] they just went for the NarmCharm filled cutscene atmosphere instead of the crushing despair of the main gameplay atmosphere. [[CanonDefilement And as]] ridiculously {{OOC}} as it is, some people still think seeing [[spoiler:[[ImplacableMan Pyramid]] [[CompleteMonster Head]] [[CoolVersusAwesome fighting Claudia to protect Alessa]]]] [[NarmCharm is pretty awesome.]]

* TheyChangedItNowItSucks: Complaints over Vincent's age and relation to the plot have been a major complaint from fans.

* AuthorsSavingThrow: Pyramid Head is stated to be [[spoiler: Alessa/Heather's guardian and executioner, in a sense taking Valtiel's role from [[SilentHill3 SH3]]]], largely addressing complaints of his [[BigLippedAlligatorMoment unexplained presence]] in the first movie.

* SoBadItsGood: It's basically an extended Silent Hill cutscene with [[ActionizedSequel extra, unnecessary action,]] (which as anyone who played the first three games knows, [[{{Narm}} isn't good]]) without much left of the crushingly despairing atmosphere of the original games that made them so terrifying. However, [[VideoGameMoviesSuck despite what this implies,]] [[DoingItForTheArt it's clear whoever made the film]] [[ShownTheirWork was a big fan of the games;]][[note]]Much of the film is spent making the changes of the first movie's plot from the game fit into the Silent Hill universe, such as the names of the characters, and Chris/Rose's replacement of Harry, and some of the locations look like exact replicas of locations in SilentHill3.[[/note]] they just went for the NarmCharm filled cutscene atmosphere instead of the crushing despair of the main gameplay atmosphere. [[CanonDefilement And as]] ridiculously {{OOC}} as it is, you have to admit, seeing [[spoiler:[[ImplacableMan Pyramid]] [[CompleteMonster Head]] [[CoolVersusAwesome fighting Claudia to protect Alessa]]]] [[NarmCharm is pretty awesome.]]

* SoBadItsGood: It's basically an extended Silent Hill cutscene with [[ActionizedSequel extra, unnecessary action,]] (which as anyone who played the first three games knows, [[{{Narm}} isn't good]]) without much left of the crushingly despairing atmosphere of the original games [[AdaptationDecay that made them so terrifying.]] However, [[VideoGameMoviesSuck despite what this implies,]] [[DoingItForTheArt it's clear whoever made the film]] [[ShownTheirWork was a big fan of the games;]][[note]]Much of the film is spent making the changes of the first movie's plot from the game fit into the Silent Hill universe, such as the names of the characters, and Chris/Rose's replacement of Harry, and some of the locations look like exact replicas of locations in SilentHill3.[[/note]] they just went for the NarmCharm filled cutscene atmosphere instead of the crushing despair of the main gameplay atmosphere. [[CanonDefilement And as]] [[AdaptationDecay ridiculously]] {{OOC}} as it is, you have to admit, seeing [[spoiler:[[ImplacableMan Pyramid]] [[CompleteMonster Head]] [[CoolVersusAwesome fighting Claudia to protect Alessa]]]] [[NarmCharm is pretty awesome.]]

* SoBadItsGood: It's basically an extended Silent Hill cutscene with [[ActionizedSequel extra, unnecessary action,]] which as anyone who played the first three games knows, [[{{Narm}} isn't good.]] However, [[VideoGameMoviesSuck despite what this implies,]] it's clear whoever made the film was a big fan of the games;[[note]]Much of the film is spent making the changes of the first movie's plot from the game fit into the Silent Hill universe, such as the names of the characters, and Chris/Rose's replacement of Harry, and some of the locations look like exact replicas of locations in SilentHill3.[[/note]] they just went for the NarmCharm filled cutscene atmosphere instead of the crushing despair of the main gameplay atmosphere. As ridiculously {{OOC}} as it is, you have to admit, seeing [[spoiler:[[ImplacableMan Pyramid]] [[CompleteMonster Head]] [[CoolVersusAwesome fighting Claudia to protect Alessa]]]] [[NarmCharm is pretty awesome.]]

* TheyChangedItNowItsucks: Complaints over Vincent's age and relation to the plot have been a major complaint from fans.