History YMMV / PostmodernJukebox

* SugarWiki/FunnyMoments:
** The Creator/WayneBrady cover of [[Music/MichaelJackson "Thriller"]] ends with [[spoiler: a random werewolf hurrying on stage, striking a triangle out of nowhere, getting a baffled "What the hell?" from Brady, and then running off again.]]
** At the end of the 70's soul cover of [[Music/NineInchNails "Closer"]], Kenton Chen accidentally whips off his glasses, and feels around the floor for them, with the backup singers trying to point him towards them.

** Kenton Chen first appeared singing backup for Sara Niemietz in the "Hey Ya!" cover, and quickly gained a fanbase within the Website/YouTube comments. Come "[=MMMbop=]," he's one of four lead vocalists, and his solo during the bridge as well as his impressive falsetto and range left many fans desiring a solo video from him. He eventually got two: "Closer" by Music/NineInchNails and "Closer" by Music/TheChainsmokers.

* FaceOfTheBand: For a long time, Robyn Adele Anderson was this. However, she's been working with the group rather infrequently lately, having chosen to focus on other projects (though she certainly hasn't left the group behind). The group rotates vocalists so often that there isn't really an obvious candidate for the band's face anymore, except maybe Scott Bradlee himself.
** Though, going by sheer views and recognition, you could probably make a case for Haley Reinhart being the band's (second) biggest name, overall.

* TheFaceOfTheBand: For a long time, Robyn Adele Anderson was this. However, she's been working with the group rather infrequently lately, having chosen to focus on other projects (though she certainly hasn't left the group behind). The group rotates vocalists so often that there isn't really an obvious candidate for the band's face anymore, except maybe Scott Bradlee himself.

** Kenton Chen first appeared singing backup for Sara Niemietz in the "Hey Ya!" cover, and quickly gained a fanbase within the Website/YouTube comments. Come "[=MMMbop=]," he's one of four lead vocalists, and his solo during the bridge as well as his impressive falsetto and range have left many fans desiring a solo video from him.

* BizarroEpisode: Arguably, their cover of "Barbie Girl," which invokes UncannyValley by having its vocalists look and act like dolls, and has [[spoiler: Morgan James doing a theremin imitation ''with her voice'', complete with a surprise Tambourine Guy appearance]].

* BaseBreakingCharacter: A lot of their vocalists get this reaction.
** Morgan James. Some people love her soulful, powerful voice where others think her singing style is too modern for the group's vintage sound. It doesn't help that she started recording heavily with PMJ around the time TheFaceOfTheBand Robyn Adele Anderson was largely OutOfFocus.
** Haley Reinhart. Her singing style is very much a matter of polarizing - and then there's her rather vocal fanbase.
** Puddles Pity Party. Few people deny he has a great voice, but a given fan's ability to enjoy his songs is very dependent on whether or not they are scared of clowns!

* BaseBreaker: A lot of their vocalists get this reaction.

* CrowningMomentOfFunny:
** The Creator/WayneBrady cover of [[Music/MichaelJackson "Thriller"]] ends with [[spoiler: a random werewolf hurrying on stage, striking a triangle out of nowhere, getting a baffled "What the hell?" from Brady, and then running off again.]]
** At the end of the 70's soul cover of [[Music/NineInchNails "Closer"]], Kenton Chen accidentally whips off his glasses, and feels around the floor for them, with the backup singers trying to point him towards them.

** Kenton Chen first appeared singing backup for Sara Niemietz in the "Hey Ya!" cover, and quickly gained a fanbase within the YouTube comments. Come "[=MMMbop=]," he's one of four lead vocalists, and his solo during the bridge as well as his impressive falsetto and range have left many fans desiring a solo video from him.

** Though, going by sheer views and recognition, you could probably make a case for Haley Reinhart being the band's (second) biggest name, overall.

* BizarroEpisode: Arguably, their cover of "Barbie Girl," which invokes UncannyValley by having its vocalists look and act like dolls, and has [[spoiler:Morgan James doing a theremin imitation ''with her voice'', complete with a surprise Tambourine Guy appearance]].

* TheFaceOfTheBand: For a long time, Robyn Adele Anderson was this. However, she's been working with the group rather infrequently lately, having chosen to focus on other projects (though she certainly hasn't left the group behind). The group rotates vocalists so often that there isn't really an obvious candidate for the band's face anymore, except maybe Scott Bradlee himself.

** The Creator/WayneBrady cover of [[Music/MichaelJackson "Thriller"]] ends with [[spoiler:a random werewolf hurrying on stage, getting a baffled "What the hell?" from Brady, and then running off again.]]

** Morgan James. Some people love her soulful, powerful voice where others think her singing style is too modern for the group's vintage sound. It doesn't help that she started recording heavily with PMJ around the time {{The Face of the Band}} Robyn Adele Anderson was largely {{Out of Focus}}.

* BizarroEpisode: Arguably, their cover of "Barbie Girl," which invokes UncannyValley by having its vocalists look and act like dolls, and has [[spoiler: Morgan James doing a theremin imitation ''with her voice'', complete with a surprise Tambourine Guy appearance]].

** Haley Reinhart. Her singing style is very much a matter of {{Love It or Hate It}} - and then there's her rather vocal fanbase.

** Haley Reinhart. Her singing style is very much a matter of {{Love It or Hate It}}.

* BizarroEpisode: Arguably, their cover of "Barbie Girl," which invokes UncannyValley by having its vocalists look and act like dolls, and has [[spoiler: Morgan James doing a theremin imitation ''with her voice.'']]
* EnsembleDarkhorse: The tambourine guy (Tim Kubart) who is adored for his unrelenting enthusiasm despite the fact he is only featured on a few songs.