History YMMV / NeuroticallyYours

* FridgeHorror: Foamy apparently had 632 owners over a period of 400 years. He explains that each owner had 10 years to prove themselves worth saving, and those who failed died of their own stupidity or by Foamy having them killed. If each owner had gotten the full ten years, he'd have only had 40 owners. Only four were found worthy of the reboot button, which means that 628 did not get second chances, and we're not told how many (or indeed, if ''any)'' of these leftovers got the full ten years. There's no indication that Foamy ever simply left an unworthy owner without killing them or seeing them die which, if the time is spread out evenly, means that most of Foamy's owners were dead within two years. More than likely the time is not spread out evenly, so some of them died much quicker than that, and for every owner that ''did'' get to the ten-year mark lessens the possible amount of time for the rest of them. One hopes that this is simply a case of WritersCannotDoMath.

* FridgeHorror: Foamy apparently had 632 owners over a period of 400 years. He explains that each owner had 10 years to prove themselves worth saving, and those who failed died of their own stupidity or by Foamy having them killed. If each owner had gotten the full ten years, he'd have only had 40 owners. Only four were found worthy of the reboot button, which means that 628 did not get second chances, and we're not told how many (or indeed, if ''any)'' of these leftovers got the full ten years. There's no indication that Foamy ever simply left an unworthy owner without killing them or seeing them die which, if the time is spread out evenly, means that most of Foamy's owners were dead within a year and a half. If it's not, some of them died much quicker than that. One hopes that this is simply a case of WritersCannotDoMath.

* FridgeHorror: Foamy apparently had 632 owners over a period of 400 years. He explains that each owner had 10 years to prove themselves worth saving, and those who failed died of their own stupidity or by Foamy having them killed. If each owner had gotten the full ten years, he'd have only had 40 owners. Only four were found worthy of the reboot button, which means that 628 did not get second chances, and we're not told how many (or indeed, if ''any)'' of these leftovers got the full ten years. There's no indication that Foamy ever simply left an unworthy owner without killing them or seeing them die which, if true, means that most of Foamy's owners were dead within a year and a half. One hopes that this is simply a case of WritersCannotDoMath.

* FridgeHorror: Foamy apparently had 632 owners over a period of 400 years. He explains that each owner had 10 years to prove themselves worth saving, and those who failed died of their own stupidity or by Foamy having them killed. If each owner had gotten the full ten years, he'd have only had 40 owners. Only four were found worthy of the reboot button, which means that 628 did not get second chances. There's no indication that Foamy ever simply left an unworthy owner without killing them or seeing them die which, if true, means that most of Foamy's owners were dead within a year and a half. One hopes that this is simply a case of WritersCannotDoMath.

* FridgeHorror: Foamy apparently had 632 owners over a period of 400 years. He explains that each owner had 10 years to prove themselves worth saving, and those who failed died of their own stupidity or by Foamy having them killed. If each owner had gotten the full ten years, he'd have only had 40 owners. Only four were found worthy of the reboot button, and it's implied that at least a few others made it the full ten years. There's no indication that Foamy ever simply left an unworthy owner without killing them or seeing them die which, if true, means that most of Foamy's owners were dead within ''less than one year.''

* FridgeHorror: Foamy apparently had 632 owners over a period of 400 years. He explains that each owner had 10 years to prove themselves worth saving, and those who failed died of their own stupidity or by Foamy having them killed. If each owner had gotten the full ten years, he'd have only had 40 owners. Only four were found worthy of the reboot button, and it's implied that at least a few others made it the full ten years. There's no indication that Foamy ever simply left an owner without killing them which, if true, means that most of Foamy's owners were dead within ''less than one year.''

** Germaine in the reboot becoming more sexual and being covered in jizz nearly all the time and in absurd amounts have also split the fans. People either like how insane and absurd it is for Germaine to be constantly masturbating and being splashed with jizz while other fans hate how she became a {{Flanderization}} of her sexual desires.

* WhatCouldHaveBeen: Germaine's road to recovery where she loses weight and gets a better perspective on life was going to be a lot longer through slow progression, but the author decided to rush it and then initiate the reboot because he got sick of the "struggling artist" theme that the series stuck with for so long and was also tired of people that saw Germaine for sex appeal instead of an actual character who goes through problems everyone could relate to.
** The Topical Rants episodes were also going to have their own animations, but due to time constraints, they were scrapped and became just a still image with Foamy's audio playing over them.
** The author also had more scripts planned for the Mutie character, but he axed them once he got sick of people complaining at how useless she was or wanting to see her naked.
** There was some possibilities of the Foamy series appearing on TV, but the author rejected the offers due to disagreement with the policies that he would have to deal with. Who knows what it would have been like to have Foamy on TV for all to see.

* JumpTheShark: What fans and critics felt like the newest Germaine story arc was doing to NY. The Move and it's ArtEvolution doesn't seem to be helping it's case either.

* BrokenBase: Fans are already divided amongst the reboot art style. Some like it, others hate it.

* UnfortunateImplications: In 2006, a movie entitled "iLLegal Immigrant Special" was uploaded to Newgrounds, and featured Foamy ranting about illegal immigrants and labeling some of them as 'burrito munchers'. It caused a storm of controversy on the site, and it was almost awarded Turd of the Week (given to the lowest rated Flash of the week) before illwillpress deleted it. The episode is on one of the [=DVDs=].
** Later, he seems to have tried to make up for it in the episode 'Mexico es muy Buen,' where he says he still doesn't agree with illegal immigration but says he still loves the race as a whole (and the concept of siestas and pinatas. He loves the idea of beating the shit out of something and getting candy for it.) He goes on to point out that when he made the video, people took it as him saying he hates all Mexicans, which he says is not true.
** Child Proof Caps, where Pilz-E objected to being called a retard for his mental disorder, only for Germaine to go on a rant about Political Correctness.
** Given Foamy is often used as an author mouthpiece for Mathers, some are kinda bothered by his apparent stance regarding things like medication meant for balancing out people with mental disorders. People on medication who say it did wonders for them argue that Mathers' doesn't seem to fully understand that people with ADD or worse might seriously need these kinds of medicines in order to just live what they feel is a well adjusted life, and that his "it makes people boring/uncreative" argument is a load of bull. However it should be noted that perhaps Mathers was instead referring to people who take medication but do not need it, i.e. people who self diagnose and do not really have any serious problems.

** Some are saying this about the reboot.

** Those same horny people are now complaining about the fact post-reboot Germaine has gotten a breast reduction and her nipples are no longer permanently erect. Granted her bust size is still a decently big c-cup, and the {{Gainaxing}} is still there as well, but try telling that to horny people who only watched the show for her large DD-cup breasts.

** Given Foamy is often used as an author mouthpiece for Mathers, some are kinda bothered by his apparent stance regarding things like medication meant for balancing out people with mental disorders. People on medication who say it did wonders for them argue that Mathers' doesn't seem to fully understand that people with ADD or worse might seriously need these kinds of medication in order to just live what they feel is a well adjusted life, and that his "it makes people boring/uncreative" argument is a load of bull. However it should be noted that perhaps Mathers was instead referring to people who take medication but do not need it, i.e. people who self diagnose and do not really have any serious problems.

** There was some possibilities of the Foamy series appearing on TV, but the author rejected the offers due to disagreement with the policies that he would have to deal with. Who knows what it would have been like to have Foamy on TV for all to see.
* DoesThisRemindYouOfAnything The page image looks like Invader Zim.

** There was some possibilities of the Foamy series appearing on TV, but the author rejected the offers due to disagreement with the policies that he would have to deal with. Who knows what it would have been like to have Foamy on TV for all to see.

** Later, he seems to have tried to make up for it in the episode 'Mexico es muy Buen,' where he says he still doesn't agree with illegal immigration but says he still loves the race as a whole (and the concept of siestas and pinitas. He loves the idea of beating the shit out of something and getting candy for it.) He goes on to point out that when he made the video, people took it as him saying he hates all Mexicans, which he says is not true.

* FridgeHorror: Foamy apparently had 632 owners over a period of 400 years. He explains that each owner had 10 years to prove themselves worth saving, and those who failed died of their own stupidity or by Foamy having them killed. If each owner had gotten the full ten years, he'd have only had 40 owners. Only four were found worthy of the reboot button, and it's implied that at least a few others made it the full ten years. There's some implication that Foamy never simply left an owner without killing them which, if true, means that most of Foamy's owners were dead within ''less than one year.''

* FridgeHorror: Foamy apparently had 632 owners over a period of 400 years. He explains that each owner had 10 years to prove themselves worth saving, and those who failed died of their own stupidity or by Foamy having them killed. If each owner had gotten the full ten years, he'd have only had 40 owners. Even if each one had only lived one year, he'd have had 400, not 632. Only four were found worthy of the reboot button, and it's implied that at least a few others made it the full ten years. There's some implication that Foamy never simply left an owner without killing them which, if true, means that most of Foamy's owners died/were killed in ''less than one year.''

* FridgeHorror: Foamy apparently had 632 owners over a period of 400 years. He explains that each owner had 10 years to prove themselves worth saving, and those who failed died of their own stupidity or by Foamy having them killed. If each owner had gotten the full ten years, he'd have only had 40 owners. Even if each one had only lived one year, he'd have had 400, not 632. Only four were found worth of the reboot button, and it's implied that at least a few others made it the full ten years. Assuming he never simply left an owner without killing them (which is strongly implied to be the case), ''most of Foamy's owners died in less than one year.''
** Which makes one wonder how awful those people would have had to have been for Foamy to not even stick with them for a year. Cynical and irritable as he is, he seems to have a decent amount of patience in the long run, if one observes his relationship with Germaine.

* FridgeHorror: Foamy apparently had 632 owners over a period of 400 years. He explains that each owner had 10 years to prove themselves worth saving, and those who failed died of their own stupidity or other causes. It's very strongly implied that Foamy is one such other cause. If each owner had gotten the full ten years, he'd have only had 40 owners. Even if each one had only lived one year, he'd have had 400, not 632. Only four were found worth of the reboot button, and it's implied that at least a few others made it the full ten years. What this boils down to: ''most of Foamy's owners died in less than one year.''

* FridgeHorror: Foamy apparently had 632 owners over a period of 400 years. He explains that each owner had 10 years to prove themselves worth saving, and those who failed died of their own stupidity or other causes. It's very strongly implied that Foamy is one such other cause. He only gave the reboot button to four people, which means ''most of Foamy's owners probably died in less than one year.''

* FridgeHorror: Foamy apparently had 632 owners over a period of 400 years. He explains that each owner had 10 years to prove themselves worth saving, and those who failed died of their own stupidity or other causes. It's very strongly implied that Foamy is one such other cause. He only gave the reboot button to four people. When you think about the math, ''most of Foamy's owners probably died in less than one year.''

* LowestCommonDenominator: Averted very hard. The series may look like nothing but a girl and her pet squirrel causing wacky hijinks, but the series has a very deep storyline with character development (mostly for Germaine). The series doesn't get in the face of its viewers when it comes to the story elements, but they're still out in the open for the more observant viewer to find and look into. A good chunk of people don't know that there is a story (or they just outright ignore it) and they watch the cartoons [[JustHereForGodzilla just because it has a hot girl with a foul mouthed squirrel.]]