Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / MobyDick

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--->“Starbuck, of late I’ve felt strangely moved to thee; ever since that hour we both saw—thou know’st what, in one another’s eyes".

to:

--->“Starbuck, --->"Starbuck, of late I’ve I've felt strangely moved to thee; ever since that hour we both saw—thou know’st know'st what, in one another’s another's eyes".



---> "I see my wife and child in thine eye...the far away home I see in that eye!"

to:

---> "I --->"I see my wife and child in thine eye...the far away home I see in that eye!"



* MemeticMutation: “Moby'''’s''' Dick” can be found in certain memes and webcomics, referring to the fact that a whale’s penis can be 8-10 ''feet'' long.

to:

* MemeticMutation: “Moby'''’s''' Dick” "Moby''''s''' Dick" can be found in certain memes and webcomics, referring to the fact that a whale’s whale's penis can be 8-10 ''feet'' long.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Starbuck is better known as the name of the coffee franchise, or even the Franchise/BattlestarGalactica character.

to:

** Starbuck is better known as the name of the coffee franchise, or even the Franchise/BattlestarGalactica ''Franchise/BattlestarGalactica'' character.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Whaling captains Boomer and Gardiner only make one brief appearance apiece but their characterizations (a {{Foil}} to Ahab who also lost a limb to Moby-Dick and a man suffering from AdultFear) cause both to be quite iconic. Neither of them is absolutely necessary for the story, but it's rare for an adaptation to exclude either of them.

to:

** Whaling captains Boomer and Gardiner only make one brief appearance apiece but their characterizations (a {{Foil}} to Ahab who also lost a limb to Moby-Dick and a man suffering from AdultFear) RealismInducedHorror) cause both to be quite iconic. Neither of them is absolutely necessary for the story, but it's rare for an adaptation to exclude either of them.

Added: 736

Changed: 141

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HesJustHiding: Although Captain Gardiner's son is last seen being dragged to an uncertain fate by Moby-Dick and the last lines of the book suggest that his father's search for him came up empty, it's nice to hope that he might have somehow survived.



* OneSceneWonder: Father Mapple in the film versions, as played by Creator/OrsonWelles (1956), Creator/GregoryPeck (1998), and Creator/DonaldSutherland (2011).

to:

* OneSceneWonder: OneSceneWonder:
**
Father Mapple in the film versions, as played by Creator/OrsonWelles (1956), Creator/GregoryPeck (1998), and Creator/DonaldSutherland (2011).(2011).
** Whaling captains Boomer and Gardiner only make one brief appearance apiece but their characterizations (a {{Foil}} to Ahab who also lost a limb to Moby-Dick and a man suffering from AdultFear) cause both to be quite iconic. Neither of them is absolutely necessary for the story, but it's rare for an adaptation to exclude either of them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RootingForTheEmpire: In modern culture some people will be cheering Moby on as he kills everyone, no matter how sympathetic the crew is. At the time of writing, sperm whales were TheDreaded, believed to be highly aggressive by nature and merely attacking ships without being provoked. The situation shifts, however, with modern obsession with whales and their preservation; as well as the understanding that whales learned what types of ships were likely to hunt them and struck pre-emptively. Today some people don't see Moby Dick as a remorseless monster but as a self-defense mass murderer.

to:

* RootingForTheEmpire: In modern culture some people will be cheering Moby on as he kills everyone, no matter how sympathetic the crew is. At the time of writing, sperm whales were TheDreaded, believed to be highly aggressive by nature and merely attacking ships without being provoked. The situation shifts, however, with modern obsession with whales and their preservation; as well as the understanding that whales learned what types of ships were likely to hunt them and struck pre-emptively. Today some people don't see Moby Dick as a remorseless monster but as a self-defense mass murderer.murderer or even a WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds.

Added: 359

Removed: 357

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PopCulturalOsmosis:
** More people have heard of Captain Ahab than have heard of the Biblical King Ahab from which he got his name. As Captain Peleg points out early on, Ahab did not choose his name, and he shouldn't think too much about it.
** Starbuck is better known as the name of the coffee franchise, or even the Franchise/BattlestarGalactica character.



* WeirdAlEffect:
** More people have heard of Captain Ahab than have heard of the Biblical King Ahab from which he got his name.
*** As Captain Peleg points out early on, Ahab did not choose his name, and he shouldn't think too much about it.
** Starbuck is better known as the name of the coffee franchise, or even the Franchise/BattlestarGalactica character.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "From Hell's heart, I stab at thee!", to much lesser extent.

to:

** "From Hell's heart, I stab at thee!", to a much lesser extent.

Added: 99

Changed: 33

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SignatureLine: The first one. "Call me Ishmael"

to:

* SignatureLine: SignatureLine:
**
The first one. "Call me Ishmael" Ishmael".
** "From Hell's heart, I stab at thee!", to much lesser extent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*SignatureLine: The first one. "Call me Ishmael"
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MemeticMutation: “Moby'''’s''' Dick” can be found in certain memes and webcomics, referring to the fact that a whale’s penis can be 8-10 ''feet'' long.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** To modern readers, the three harpooneers can come across as caricatures of Africans (Daggoo), Native Americans (Tashtego) and Polynesians (Queequeg), respectively. However, Melville makes them all sympathetic characters and Ishmael frequently talks about how they're NotSoDifferent from white men. In fact, he deliberately created them to ''defy'' stereotypes, with Tashtego being gloomy and fatalistic while Queequeg is cheerful and down-to-earth.

to:

** To modern readers, the three harpooneers can come across as caricatures of Africans (Daggoo), Native Americans (Tashtego) and Polynesians (Queequeg), respectively. However, Melville makes them all sympathetic characters and [[NotSoDifferentRemark Ishmael frequently talks about how they're NotSoDifferent from similar to white men.men]]. In fact, he deliberately created them to ''defy'' stereotypes, with Tashtego being gloomy and fatalistic while Queequeg is cheerful and down-to-earth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrazyAwesome: Ahab. It is because of his insane obsession with Moby Dick that he created charts accurately mapping the annual movements of the whales, allowing them to follow the herd, kill as they go and fill their hold in record time. His insanity also wins over his crew and makes them all (save for Starbuck) extremely loyal and invested in the hunt for Moby Dick.

to:

* CrazyAwesome: CrazyIsCool: Ahab. It is because of his insane obsession with Moby Dick that he created charts accurately mapping the annual movements of the whales, allowing them to follow the herd, kill as they go and fill their hold in record time. His insanity also wins over his crew and makes them all (save for Starbuck) extremely loyal and invested in the hunt for Moby Dick.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Shoehorn and Fan Myopia, there's no connection between these two works.


* HilariousInHindsight: Chapter 44 says that sperm whale migrations often match [[Film/MontyPythonAndTheHolyGrail the flight of swallows.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HarsherInHindsight: Ishmael doesn't believe whaling is a threat to the whale as a species since unlike shooting buffaloo, whaling was (at the time) dangerous, time consuming, and it wasn't unknown for ships to spend months at sea only to come back empty handed. The book was published in 1851, the first practical harpoon cannon was invented in 1863. He also used the elephant surviving thousands of years of hunting as an example.

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: Ishmael doesn't believe whaling is a threat to the whale as a species since unlike shooting buffaloo, buffalo, whaling was (at the time) dangerous, time consuming, and it wasn't unknown for ships to spend months at sea only to come back empty handed. The book was published in 1851, the first practical harpoon cannon was invented in 1863. He also used the elephant surviving thousands of years of hunting as an example.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RootingForTheEmpire: In modern culture most people will be cheering Moby on as he kills everyone, no matter how sympathetic adaptations try to make the crew. At the time of writing, sperm whales were TheDreaded, believed to be highly aggressive by nature and merely attacking ships without being provoked. The situation shifts, however, with modern understanding of the high intelligence of whales; sperm whales were not aggressive beasts attacking ships unprovoked, but sapient entities reacting in an entirely reasonable way to the fact that a good number of those big wooden things were killing whales. Today most people don't see Moby Dick as a remorseless monster but as a justified WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds.

to:

* RootingForTheEmpire: In modern culture most some people will be cheering Moby on as he kills everyone, no matter how sympathetic adaptations try to make the crew.crew is. At the time of writing, sperm whales were TheDreaded, believed to be highly aggressive by nature and merely attacking ships without being provoked. The situation shifts, however, with modern obsession with whales and their preservation; as well as the understanding of the high intelligence of whales; sperm that whales were not aggressive beasts attacking learned what types of ships unprovoked, but sapient entities reacting in an entirely reasonable way to the fact that a good number of those big wooden things were killing whales. likely to hunt them and struck pre-emptively. Today most some people don't see Moby Dick as a remorseless monster but as a justified WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds.self-defense mass murderer.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RootingForTheEmpire: In modern culture most people will be cheering Moby on as he kills everyone, no matter how sympathetic adaptations try to make the crew. This is because in modern times with the high intelligence of whales being well known, most people don't see Moby Dick as a remorseless monster but as an innocent victim just defending himself. However, people with this view fail to realize that sperm whales are very aggressive by nature and have been known to attack ships without being provoked, to the point that readers with this knowledge get a good idea of how he became TheDreaded.

to:

* RootingForTheEmpire: In modern culture most people will be cheering Moby on as he kills everyone, no matter how sympathetic adaptations try to make the crew. This is because in At the time of writing, sperm whales were TheDreaded, believed to be highly aggressive by nature and merely attacking ships without being provoked. The situation shifts, however, with modern times with understanding of the high intelligence of whales; sperm whales being well known, were not aggressive beasts attacking ships unprovoked, but sapient entities reacting in an entirely reasonable way to the fact that a good number of those big wooden things were killing whales. Today most people don't see Moby Dick as a remorseless monster but as an innocent victim just defending himself. However, people with this view fail to realize that sperm whales are very aggressive by nature and have been known to attack ships without being provoked, to the point that readers with this knowledge get a good idea of how he became TheDreaded.justified WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Due to the sperm whale being very aggressive by nature and as a result known to attack ships without being provoked the question of whether or not Moby Dick defending himself or attacking ships for no reason is left unanswered. As is the question if he has any idea who Ahab even is.

to:

** Due to This becomes even more complicated when you account for the sperm whale being very aggressive by nature extreme intelligence of cetaceans and as a result known to attack ships without being provoked the question of whether or not fact that Moby Dick defending himself or attacking ships for no reason is left unanswered. As is was inspired by the question if many documented cases of sperm whales that [[TheHunterBecomesTheHunted started hunting and destroying ships]] during the height of large-scale whaling. Whether he has any idea who Ahab even is.specifically is may be questionable, but there's certainly a solid case for seeing Moby Dick as a HeroAntagonist seeking justified vengeance on the [[HumansAreCthulhu cruel otherworldly creatures]] murdering his kind on an industrial scale, with Ahab being the twisted personification of the entire enterprise.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''Ahab:''' (strapped to Moby Dick and stabbing him repeatedly with a harpoon) "From Hell's heart, I stab at thee! For hate's sake I ''spit'' my last breath at thee! ''THOU DAMNED WHALE!''"

to:

-->'''Ahab:''' (strapped to Moby Dick and stabbing him repeatedly with a harpoon) "From From Hell's heart, I stab at thee! For hate's sake I ''spit'' my last breath at thee! ''THOU DAMNED WHALE!''"WHALE!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
He is being hunted by one ship. There is nothing to say that all the ships he attacked were hunting him.


* RootingForTheEmpire: In modern culture most people will be cheering Moby on as he kills everyone, no matter how sympathetic adaptations try to make the crew. This is because in modern times with the high intelligence of whales being well known, most people don't see Moby Dick as a remorseless monster but as an innocent victim just defending himself.

to:

* RootingForTheEmpire: In modern culture most people will be cheering Moby on as he kills everyone, no matter how sympathetic adaptations try to make the crew. This is because in modern times with the high intelligence of whales being well known, most people don't see Moby Dick as a remorseless monster but as an innocent victim just defending himself. However, people with this view fail to realize that sperm whales are very aggressive by nature and have been known to attack ships without being provoked, to the point that readers with this knowledge get a good idea of how he became TheDreaded.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Doesnt really apply to the books as Moby Dick is specifically being hunted here.


* RootingForTheEmpire: In modern culture most people will be cheering Moby on as he kills everyone, no matter how sympathetic adaptations try to make the crew. This is because in modern times with the high intelligence of whales being well known, most people don't see Moby Dick as a remorseless monster but as an innocent victim just defending himself. However, people with this view fail to realize that sperm whales are very aggressive by nature and have been known to attack ships without being provoked.

to:

* RootingForTheEmpire: In modern culture most people will be cheering Moby on as he kills everyone, no matter how sympathetic adaptations try to make the crew. This is because in modern times with the high intelligence of whales being well known, most people don't see Moby Dick as a remorseless monster but as an innocent victim just defending himself. However, people with this view fail to realize that sperm whales are very aggressive by nature and have been known to attack ships without being provoked.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AcceptableTargets: Established albinos as one of them.

to:

* AcceptableTargets: Established albinos as one of them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Through most of ''Moby-Dick'', the sperm whale was a monster, the legendary leviathan to be hunted down and killed for its oil and spermaceti. Melville admonished people not to burn sperm-candles or lamp oil recklessly, not because he wished to spare the whales' lives, but because so many human sailors died every year on whaling expeditions. In the modern world, just about every species of whale is endangered, and whaling was one of the main reasons for their dangerously low numbers in the wild; "save the whales" is a rallying cry more people support than oppose and thus people are more likely now to cheer on Moby defending himself. Yet at the time the story was written, whale populations were much larger, and nothing was known of whalesong or other such indicators of cetacean intelligence.
* HarsherInHindsight: Ishmael doesn't believe whaling is a threat to the whale as a species since unlike shooting buffaloo, whaling was (at the time) dangerous, time consuming, and known for voyages coming back empty handed. The book was published in 1851, the first practical harpoon cannon was invented in 1863. He also used the elephant surviving thousands of years of hunting as an example.

to:

** Through most of ''Moby-Dick'', the sperm whale was a monster, the legendary leviathan to be hunted down and killed for its oil and spermaceti. Melville admonished people not to burn sperm-candles or lamp oil recklessly, not because he wished to spare the whales' lives, but because so many human sailors died every year on whaling expeditions. In the modern world, just about every species of whale is endangered, and whaling was one of the main reasons for their dangerously low numbers in the wild; "save the whales" is a rallying cry more people support than oppose and thus people are more likely now to cheer on Moby defending himself. Yet at the time the story was written, whale populations were much larger, larger (to say nothing of the whaling ships being much less advanced) and nothing was known of whalesong or other such indicators of cetacean intelligence.
* HarsherInHindsight: Ishmael doesn't believe whaling is a threat to the whale as a species since unlike shooting buffaloo, whaling was (at the time) dangerous, time consuming, and known it wasn't unknown for voyages coming ships to spend months at sea only to come back empty handed. The book was published in 1851, the first practical harpoon cannon was invented in 1863. He also used the elephant surviving thousands of years of hunting as an example.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SpecialEffectFailure: The director and cinematographer of the 1956 film deliberately chose a dark look, to evoke old whaling prints. To the unsympathetic eye, it just looks underexposed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Much of the aforementioned examples could be a subtle reflection of Herman Melville's love for Nathaniel Hawthorne, [[https://www.brainpickings.org/2019/02/13/herman-melville-nathaniel-hawthorne-love-letters/ given Melville had wrote him love letters and even wrote dedication to him in his novel]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Clarification of the context of a quote made in the novel.

Added DiffLines:

***This is clearly stated to not be a romantic thing. Ahab says that he is reminded of his family when he looks at Starbuck, because Starbuck has a wife and young son at home, just like Ahab.
---> "I see my wife and child in thine eye...the far away home I see in that eye!"

Added: 70

Changed: 126

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: Captain Ahab -- {{revenge}}-obsessed madman, a TragicHero, or both?

to:

* AlternativeCharacterInterpretation: AlternativeCharacterInterpretation:
**
Captain Ahab -- {{revenge}}-obsessed madman, a TragicHero, or both?




* SugarWiki/AwesomeMoments: After Peleg insults Queequeg, Ishmael jumps in to defend him, but Queequeg calmly pulls him back and shows [[ImprobableAimingSkills just how skilled he is with a harpoon.]]

to:

\n* SugarWiki/AwesomeMoments: SugarWiki/AwesomeMoments:
**
After Peleg insults Queequeg, Ishmael jumps in to defend him, but Queequeg calmly pulls him back and shows [[ImprobableAimingSkills just how skilled he is with a harpoon.]]



* RootingForTheEmpire: In modern culture most people will be cheering Moby on as he kills everyone, no matter how sympathetic adaptations try to make the crew. This is because in modern times with the high intelligence of whales being well known, most people don't see Moby Dick as a remorseless monster but as an innocent victim just defending himself however people with this view fail to realize that sperm whales are very aggressive by nature and have been known to attack ships without being provoked.

to:

* RootingForTheEmpire: In modern culture most people will be cheering Moby on as he kills everyone, no matter how sympathetic adaptations try to make the crew. This is because in modern times with the high intelligence of whales being well known, most people don't see Moby Dick as a remorseless monster but as an innocent victim just defending himself however himself. However, people with this view fail to realize that sperm whales are very aggressive by nature and have been known to attack ships without being provoked.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Starbuck is better known as the coffee franchise, or even the ''Franchise/BattlestarGalactica'' character.

to:

** Starbuck is better known as the name of the coffee franchise, or even the ''Franchise/BattlestarGalactica'' Franchise/BattlestarGalactica character.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** As Captain Peleg points out early on, Ahab did not choose his name, and he shouldn't think too much about it.

to:

** *** As Captain Peleg points out early on, Ahab did not choose his name, and he shouldn't think too much about it.it.
** Starbuck is better known as the coffee franchise, or even the ''Franchise/BattlestarGalactica'' character.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Fittingly, his nemesis. Moby Dick -- normal, aggressive, oddly colored sperm whale, or supernatural AnimalisticAbomination in the shape of one?


Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NightmareFuel: Moby Dick himself. As stated many times across the Moby Dick pages on this very wiki, being a sperm whale he is naturally aggressive and will attack ships without provocation. He has sent who knows how many to their deaths and is treated by whalers as if he is some sort of demon, which probably makes him worse to those whose captains drag them after him. Moby Dick attacking without provocation: scary. Actually giving him a reason to attack you: scarier.

Top