History YMMV / MajiDeWatashiNiKoiShinasai

24th Feb '17 7:28:28 AM Kervinle2500
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Thelma herself manages to beat Lisa and Segrun for the 9th place, whereas her own boss is the first place.
17th Feb '17 10:46:50 AM Kervinle2500
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** In the male's side of the poll, ''Shakadou'' of all people managed to beat both Cap and The Prime Minister for the 5th place.
** Yoichi manages to take 4th place in the poll while Gen and Jun take 3rd and 2nd respectively.
** Of course the person who secures first place in the poll is Yamato Naoe himself.
17th Feb '17 10:36:51 AM Kervinle2500
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** There was a popularity poll in summer 2014 that finished at the end of August. Only three of the original heroines placed in the top ten with the highest being Wanko in fifth.

to:

** There was a popularity poll in summer 2014 that finished at the end of August. Only three of the original heroines placed in the top ten with the highest being Wanko in fifth. Another popularity vote took place in late January 2017 and ended in Febuary 12th.



*** Benkei made it to fourth place, giving her triple the votes of her boss, who only made it into the top twenty.

to:

*** Benkei made it to fourth place, giving her triple the votes of her boss, who only made it into the top twenty. She makes it third in the top twenty in the 2017 popularity votes.



** Lisa Brinker, a member of Margit's Hound unit, is gaining attention thanks to Minato-soft's website showing who will appear in Margit's Afterstory route. Since then, fans wanted her to have her own route. In fact, most of her info was translated in TheOtherWiki while the others have yet have theirs. Plus she already became popular ''before the game even came out''. Currently unknown if she'll gain her own route. A lesser degree occurs with the rest of the team however, with the exceptions of Segrun and Thelma.

to:

** Lisa Brinker, a member of Margit's Hound unit, is gaining attention thanks to Minato-soft's website showing who will appear in Margit's Afterstory route. Since then, fans wanted her to have her own route. In fact, most of her info was translated in TheOtherWiki while the others have yet have theirs. Plus she already became popular ''before the game even came out''. Currently unknown if she'll gain her own route. A lesser degree occurs with the rest of the team however, with the exceptions of Segrun and Thelma. She makes it the 18th place within the poll while Segrun takes the 21st place.



** Aki became this after appearing in A5 in Yoshitsune's route. So much that she is currently being voted high in the 2017 popularity poll and already has merchandise. The fact that that she was received so well means a route for her is likely to happen.
* GermansLoveDavidHasselhoff: You'd be hard-pressed to know that the ''German heroines'' would be the reason why fans would want to pick up A5 just to play Margit's Afterstory.

to:

** Aki became this after appearing in A5 in Yoshitsune's route. So much that she is currently being voted high in the 2017 popularity poll and already has merchandise. The fact that that she was received so well means a route for her is likely to happen. \n She secures 2nd place in the poll.
* GermansLoveDavidHasselhoff: You'd be hard-pressed to know that the ''German heroines'' would be the reason why fans would want to pick up A5 just to play Margit's Afterstory. Lisa and Segrun being the two making the top 30 in the popularity poll.
9th Feb '17 9:46:29 AM Kervinle2500
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

** Aki became this after appearing in A5 in Yoshitsune's route. So much that she is currently being voted high in the 2017 popularity poll and already has merchandise. The fact that that she was received so well means a route for her is likely to happen.
30th Jan '17 9:27:13 AM BlackSunNocturne
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** Margit placed first in the summer 2014 character poll despite being only a supporting character with a short route.

to:

*** Margit placed first in the summer 2014 character poll despite being only a supporting character with a short route. Her route in ''Append'' also bumped her to first in the character popularity poll again.
28th Oct '16 6:54:22 PM Kervinle2500
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Lisa Brinker, a member of Margit's Hound unit, is gaining attention thanks to Minato-soft's website showing who will appear in Margit's Afterstory route. Since then, fans wanted her to have her own route. In fact, most of her info was translated in TheOtherWiki while the others have yet have theirs. Currently unknown if she'll gain her own route. A lesser degree occurs with the rest of the team however, with the exceptions of Segrun and Thelma.

to:

** Lisa Brinker, a member of Margit's Hound unit, is gaining attention thanks to Minato-soft's website showing who will appear in Margit's Afterstory route. Since then, fans wanted her to have her own route. In fact, most of her info was translated in TheOtherWiki while the others have yet have theirs. Plus she already became popular ''before the game even came out''. Currently unknown if she'll gain her own route. A lesser degree occurs with the rest of the team however, with the exceptions of Segrun and Thelma.
17th Sep '16 6:22:49 PM FateStayWho
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* AmericansHateTingle: Tsubame is significantly less popular with Western readers than Japanese ones. While she placed second in the 2014 poll on Minatosoft's website, she has a divided audience at best among English readers. They believe that she has poor chemistry with Yamato by making him uncharacteristically submissive, that the story hypes her too much and that she's far too easily forgiven for her deceptive and selfish behavior.



* CrazyAwesome: Momoyo. She is a GodModeSue that pulls out NewPowersAsThePlotDemands, but manages to make both of these tropes work because of how hilariously one-sided her fights are and how silly the powers she pulls out are, including a self-destruct attack which has its side effects negated by a HealingFactor.



* AmericansHateTingle: Tsubame is significantly less popular with Western readers than Japanese ones. While she placed second in the 2014 poll on Minatosoft's website, she has a divided audience at best among English readers. They believe that she has poor chemistry with Yamato by making him uncharacteristically submissive, that the story hypes her too much and that she's far too easily forgiven for her deceptive and selfish behavior.
17th Sep '16 11:59:49 AM Arha
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* CreatorsPet: The Itagaki siblings certainly seem to be this since they keep appearing in routes that they otherwise have nothing to do with. It's also fair to call Tatsuko's route the "Itagaki route" since Yamato ultimately ends up hooking up with all three of the sisters. (In fact, he spends more time having sex with ''Angel'' than Tatsuko)
17th Sep '16 11:50:51 AM Nick7689
Is there an issue? Send a Message

Added DiffLines:

* CreatorsPet: The Itagaki siblings certainly seem to be this since they keep appearing in routes that they otherwise have nothing to do with. It's also fair to call Tatsuko's route the "Itagaki route" since Yamato ultimately ends up hooking up with all three of the sisters. (In fact, he spends more time having sex with ''Angel'' than Tatsuko)
1st Aug '16 6:44:40 AM HailMuffins
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* {{Sequelitis}}: Some would argue that the original Majikoi is the only good one ([[FirstInstallmentWinsor at the very least the best one]]), but setting that aside, the A-4 fandisk is generally considered to be the weakest installment. It has less content than earlier releases, one heroine was rather minor, of little interest to most fans and had a short and overall quite subpar route. The second heroine, while popular and highly anticipated, also had an overall disappointing route with wonky plot direction, romance and writing.

to:

* {{Sequelitis}}: Some would argue that the original Majikoi is the only good one ([[FirstInstallmentWinsor ([[FirstInstallmentWins or at the very least the best one]]), but setting that aside, the A-4 fandisk is generally considered to be the weakest installment. It has less content than earlier releases, one heroine was rather minor, of little interest to most fans and had a short and overall quite subpar route. The second heroine, while popular and highly anticipated, also had an overall disappointing route with wonky plot direction, romance and writing.
This list shows the last 10 events of 55. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=YMMV.MajiDeWatashiNiKoiShinasai