Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / Lincoln

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


** Creator/AdamDriver, a.k.a [[Franchise/StarWars Kylo Ren]], appears as a telegraph operator that Lincoln has a conversation about equality with.

to:

** Creator/AdamDriver, a.k.a [[Franchise/StarWars Kylo Ren]], appears as a [[WesternUnionMan telegraph operator that operator]] with whom Lincoln has a conversation about equality with.equality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Much is made in the movie of the family's coping with the recent death of middle son Willie. History buffs will know that adorable Tad himself lived only six more years after the events of the film.
** Mary says Abraham will have to have her committed to an asylum if Robert is killed in the war. After the President's death, Robert will be forced to do just that.

to:

** Much is made in the movie of the family's coping with the recent death of middle son Willie. History buffs will know that adorable Tad himself lived only six more years after the events of the film.
film. Coupled with the deaths of Willie and their second son Eddie in 1850 (at the age of only four), Robert was the only one of the Lincolns' four sons to survive into adulthood.
** Mary says Abraham will have to have her committed to an asylum if Robert is killed in the war. After the President's Her relationship with Robert degraded after Abraham's death, and in 1875, Robert will be forced initiated a court proceeding to do just that.have her committed. She AttemptedSuicide, then shamed her son with enough negative publicity that he allowed her to leave the asylum and retire to live with her sister.

Added: 550

Changed: 207

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HarsherInHindsight: Much is made in the movie of the family's coping with the recent death of middle son Willie. History buffs will know that adorable Tad himself lived only six more years after the events of the film.

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: HarsherInHindsight:
**
Much is made in the movie of the family's coping with the recent death of middle son Willie. History buffs will know that adorable Tad himself lived only six more years after the events of the film.film.
** Mary says Abraham will have to have her committed to an asylum if Robert is killed in the war. After the President's death, Robert will be forced to do just that.



** Hal Holbrook, who plays Francis Preston Blair, played Lincoln in the miniseries' ''Lincoln'' (1976) and ''North and South, Book II'' (1986).

to:

** Hal Holbrook, Creator/HalHolbrook, who plays Francis Preston Blair, played Lincoln in the miniseries' ''Lincoln'' (1976) and ''North and South, Book II'' (1986).


Added DiffLines:

** Much is made of Robert's determination to serve in the Union Army over his parents' objections. In RealLife, Robert became U.S. Secretary of War to Presidents Garfield and Arthur.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Creator/DavidOyelowo as Cpl. Clark, two years before headlining ''Film/{{Selma}}''.

Changed: 30

Removed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


----



* AwardSnub: ''Lincoln'' was expected to be the heavyweight of the 85th Oscars, leading with twelve nominations, but it only ended up winning two, Best Production Design and Best Actor. And even then, the Production Design win was seen as more of a slight surprise, compared to other lavish period pieces like ''Literature/AnnaKarenina'' and ''Film/LesMiserables2012''. Some were also disappointed that Tommy Lee Jones didn't win Best Supporting Actor for his fiery, scene-stealing performance as Thaddeus Stevens, and there's a sizable contingent of fans who were quite cranky that Creator/SallyField didn't win for Best Supporting Actress[[note]]though the fact that she ''already'' has two Oscars did dampen the crankiness a bit[[/note]].

to:

* AwardSnub: ''Lincoln'' was expected to be the heavyweight of the 85th Oscars, leading with twelve nominations, but it only ended up winning two, Best Production Design and Best Actor. And even then, the Production Design win was seen as more of a slight surprise, compared to other lavish period pieces like ''Literature/AnnaKarenina'' and ''Film/LesMiserables2012''. Some were also disappointed that Tommy Lee Jones Creator/TommyLeeJones didn't win Best Supporting Actor for his fiery, scene-stealing performance as Thaddeus Stevens, and there's a sizable contingent of fans who were quite cranky that Creator/SallyField didn't win for Best Supporting Actress[[note]]though the fact that she ''already'' has two Oscars did dampen the crankiness a bit[[/note]].



* GeniusBonus: Possibly. In the scene where Robert returns, he is greeted enthusiastically by Tad, who starts chattering away at him while somebody shoves a petition at him about his insolvency proceedings, asking if the President can look at it. What Tad is saying is almost completely incomprehensible but listening closely you can tell he's talking about Charles Darwin and the ''Origin of Species''. [[note]] This may have been intended as a brief nod to the fact that Abraham Lincoln and Charles Darwin were born on the same day.[[/note]]

to:

* GeniusBonus: Possibly. In the scene where Robert returns, he is greeted enthusiastically by Tad, who starts chattering away at him while somebody shoves a petition at him about his insolvency proceedings, asking if the President can look at it. What Tad is saying is almost completely incomprehensible but listening closely you can tell he's talking about Charles Darwin UsefulNotes/CharlesDarwin and the ''Origin of Species''. [[note]] This may have been intended as a brief nod to the fact that Abraham Lincoln and Charles Darwin were born on the same day.[[/note]]



** It also serves as one to ''Film/AmazingGrace'', a biography of William Wilberforce, and his similar efforts to outlaw the slave-trade in the English Parliament.

to:

** It also serves as one to ''Film/AmazingGrace'', a biography biopic of William Wilberforce, and his similar efforts to outlaw the slave-trade in the English Parliament.



Added: 224

Changed: 223

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SpiritualSuccessor: Tony Kushner said that he and Spielberg saw this film as a delayed sequel to Creator/JohnFord's 1940 ''Film/YoungMrLincoln''. That film showed Lincoln near the start of his career, this film shows Lincoln at the very end.

to:

* SpiritualSuccessor: SpiritualSuccessor:
**
Tony Kushner said that he and Spielberg saw this film as a delayed sequel to Creator/JohnFord's 1940 ''Film/YoungMrLincoln''. That film showed Lincoln near the start of his career, this film shows Lincoln at the very end.

Removed: 1291

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
A flamebait trope.


* UnfortunateImplications:
** [[http://carpetbagger.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/02/07/mr-spielberg-connecticut-objects/?_r=0 There was significant outcry from the state of Connecticut]] after the film depicted most of its House reps voting against the amendment when in actuality all of them voted for it. Modern-day Connecticut Rep. Joe Courtney was even among the protesters, writing to Dreamworks urging them to change this for the film's Blu-Ray release. Screenwriter Tony Kushner defended the decision by saying the scene represented both the early opposition to the amendment for dramatic tension (Connecticut is the first state to vote in the scene) and Connecticut's then-ambivalence towards Lincoln (he only received 51% of vote there come reelection.)
** A New York Times piece [[http://www.nytimes.com/2012/11/13/opinion/in-spielbergs-lincoln-passive-black-characters.html?pagewanted=1 protested the film's few, mostly passive black characters]], making it seem [[WhiteMansBurden as though they contributed nothing to their own freedom]] (other than the black soldiers at the beginning and at the first scene with Stephens). This stands out considering an early draft for the film was about Lincoln's friendship with Frederick Douglas (who does not appear nor is mentioned in the film.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** The film emphasizes this from the beginning. The first faces you see in close-up and the first voices you hear belong to black soldiers talking to Lincoln, who is seen only vaguely from behind. The entire focus is on these men, Harold Green and Ira Clarke, and what they're telling him (and you). Ira speaks of income inequality between black and white regiments (which had just been reformed) and suggests, now that white people have gotten used to black men bearing arms, maybe in a few years they'd be able to accept black commanding officers, and "maybe in 100 years, [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_suffrage_in_the_United_States the vote]]." [[note]]Black men's right to vote was affirmed in 1870. [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/African-American_women%27s_suffrage_movement Black women could vote]] in many states, but it was not in the Constitution until 1968.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AwardSnub: ''Lincoln'' was expected to be the heavyweight of the 85th Oscars, leading with twelve nominations, but it only ended up winning two, Best Production Design and Best Actor. And even then, the Production Design win was seen as more of a slight surprise, compared to other lavish period pieces like ''Literature/AnnaKarenina'' and ''Film/LesMiserables2012''. Some were also disappointed that Tommy Lee Jones didn't win Best Supporting Actor for his fiery, scene-stealing performance as Thaddeus Stevens.

to:

* AwardSnub: ''Lincoln'' was expected to be the heavyweight of the 85th Oscars, leading with twelve nominations, but it only ended up winning two, Best Production Design and Best Actor. And even then, the Production Design win was seen as more of a slight surprise, compared to other lavish period pieces like ''Literature/AnnaKarenina'' and ''Film/LesMiserables2012''. Some were also disappointed that Tommy Lee Jones didn't win Best Supporting Actor for his fiery, scene-stealing performance as Thaddeus Stevens.Stevens, and there's a sizable contingent of fans who were quite cranky that Creator/SallyField didn't win for Best Supporting Actress[[note]]though the fact that she ''already'' has two Oscars did dampen the crankiness a bit[[/note]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It also serves as as one to ''Film/AmazingGrace'', a biography of William Wilberforce, and his similar efforts to outlaw the slave-trade in the English Parliament.

to:

** It also serves as as one to ''Film/AmazingGrace'', a biography of William Wilberforce, and his similar efforts to outlaw the slave-trade in the English Parliament.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: After [[spoiler: the passage of the 13th Amendment its supporters]] start singing the "Battle Cry of Freedom" in the Capitol and on the streets. The congressmen actually start doing it while still inside the Capitol.

to:

* SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: After [[spoiler: the passage of the 13th Amendment its supporters]] [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v582kPp43Mg start singing singing]] the "Battle Cry of Freedom" in the Capitol and on the streets. The congressmen actually start doing it while still inside the Capitol.

Top