History YMMV / JusticeLeagueXRWBYSuperHeroesAndHuntsmen

** When Part 2's trailer was released, many were glad to see the greater emphasis on action and bigger urban set-pieces, but a lot of people couldn't overlook how bad Team RWBY's outfits look in the DC world, especially in stark comparison to the ''{{ComicBook/DCRWBY}}'' mini-series. Blake stands out the most out of everyone else, losing her trademark Faunus ears which are a major part of her character and backstory. Many feared that the movie would either downplay her response to the change, ignore its (lack of) presence, or give Blake an "IJustWantToBeNormal" character arc to reflect Bruce's "IJustWantToBeSpecial" in the first part, all of which would be seen as a betrayal to the character. Even DC-savvy fans think this doesn't make much sense either, considering there are ''several'' characters within the universe that bear animal traits, such as Cheetah and Beast Boy, meaning it she wouldn't have been out-of-place. This feeling only got worse when the final film reveals this change affects ''nothing'' to Blake or the overall story, which again made many wonder what was even the point of removing her ears in the Justice League world.

** Vixen is a superheroine no one expected to be in the main cast. While she is a member of Justice League, she isn't one of the well-known founding members and her character was never in the ''ComicBook/RWBYJusticeLeague'' comic.

** [[spoiler: In Part 2, a very unexpected appearance is ''Killer Croc'', who seems to have [[EnemyMine decided to help out against the Grimm alongside Batman.]]]] Joining him are [[spoiler:Weather Wizard and Mirror Master, who Yang and Black Canary are incredibly unimpressed by.]] Finally, [[spoiler:''Watts'' makes a return as the mastermind, which may come as a surprise considering he ''died''. Turns out, he planned for that and made a backup of his consciousness.]]

* SoOkayItsAverage: The overall reception to the films by fans. While both films aren't seen as cinema, at the end of the day they are still enjoyable to an extent, and they do have their moments. Just don't expect many RWBY fans to recommend it to newcomers.

** The entire concept of these crossovers. One one hand, some fans are excited for such an event and were hoping for more crossovers with other Creator/WarnerBros IPs in the future (if WB didn't shutdown Rooster Teeth), while some believe that an crossover with Creator/DCComics is fine, but question why they chose the Justice League over more fitting teams like the Franchise/TeenTitans. And there's a third camp who wish that theses crossovers were never made, seeing as these are the final RWBY projects made by Creator/RoosterTeeth before it and DC's parent company Creator/WarnerBrosDiscovery shut them down, with some speculation that the company wasn't impressed with the film's performance, seeing as they [[https://deadline.com/2024/03/rooster-teeth-shut-down-warner-bros-discovery-roost-podcast-continue-1235847264/amp/ plan]] to sell off the ''RWBY'' IP instead of inheriting it.

** Whether or not these crossovers should be canon. On one hand, fans point to part 2 as having scenes where Ruby needs to learn a lesson in leadership, while some do like like the possibility of the DC Universe being a necessary part of the RWBY mythos. Not helping matters is CRWBY's [[FlipFlopOfGod stance on the crossovers' place in the main show's canon]], as main writer and the person who pitched the crossovers Kerry Shawcross [[https://www.cbr.com/justice-league-rwby-kerry-shawcross-interview/ has stated]] that the crossovers are "canon-adjacent" akin to ''Anime/RWBYIceQueendom'' [[note]] meaning that while the crossovers cound fit in the show's timeline, it wouldn't have any impact on the main storyline.[[/note]]. Meanwhile around part 2's release, [[https://www.reddit.com/r/RWBY/comments/17ecw6s/reminder_jlxrwby_is_not_canonical_crwby_has/# many on the staff]] have said that the crossovers are not canon at all. Ultimately, it remains to be seen if the crossovers [[ExiledFromContinuity lose their canonical status]] if RWBY were to be sold to another company, with the films themselves potentially getting ScrewedByTheLawyers due to WB no longer owning RWBY.

* FanficFuel: What would the other RWBY and DC characters, dead or alive, would look like in their respective universes?

** The entire concept of these crossovers. One one hand, some fans are excited for such an event and we're hoping for more crossovers with other Creator/WarnerBros IPs in the future, while some believe that an crossover with Creator/DCComics is fine, but why they chose the Justice League over more fitting teams like the Franchise/TeenTitans. And there's a third camp who wish that theses crossovers were never made, seeing as these are the final RWBY projects made by Creator/RoosterTeeth before it and DC's parent company Creator/WarnerBrosDiscovery shut them down, with some speculation that the company wasn't impressed with the film's performance, seeing as they [[https://deadline.com/2024/03/rooster-teeth-shut-down-warner-bros-discovery-roost-podcast-continue-1235847264/amp/ plan]] to sell off the ''RWBY'' IP instead of inheriting it.
** Whether or not these crossovers should be canon. On one hand, fans point to part 2 as having scenes where Ruby needs to learn a lesson in leadership, while some do like like the possibility of the DC Universe being a necessary part of the RWBY mythos. Not helping matters is CRWBY's [[FlipFlopOfGod stance on the crossovers' place in the main show's canon]][[note]] Main writer Kerry Shawcross [[https://www.cbr.com/justice-league-rwby-kerry-shawcross-interview/ has stated]] that the crossovers are "canon-adjacent" akin to ''Anime/RWBYIceQueendom'' meaning that while the crossovers count fit in the show's timeline, it wouldn't have any impact on the main storyline. Meanwhile around part 2's release, [[https://www.reddit.com/r/RWBY/comments/17ecw6s/reminder_jlxrwby_is_not_canonical_crwby_has/# many on the staff]] have said that the crossovers are not canon at all.[[/labelnote]]. Ultimately, it remains to be seen if the crossovers [[ExiledFromContinunity their canonical status]] of RWBY were to be sold to another company.