History YMMV / GLEE

* DieForOurShip: After Artie started dating Brittany, he earned quite a {{Hatedom}} among certain sections of the fanbase (lesbians, [[YuriFan Yuri Fans]]) for whom Brittana is the FanPreferredCouple. It can get [[http://www.afterellen.com/tv/recaps/glee/209?page=0,6 pretty bad.]]

* NarmCharm: The unabashedly cheery ChristmasEpisode [[spoiler: aside from the Rachel/Finn subplot]] should have by all means been a non-stop {{Glurge}} fest, and yet it was one of the sweetest episodes of the series, especially [[spoiler: when ARtie stodd up.]

* DieForOurShip: After Artie started dating Brittany, he earned quite a {{Hatedom}} among certain sections of the fanbase (lesbians, [[YuriFan Yuri Fans]]) for whom Brittana is the FanPreferredCouple.

** Blaine shooting down Kurt's solo audition, and to a greater extent trying to squash his entire attitude in "Special Education" and then singing lead on the entire Sectionals number casts him in a much less sympathetic light than previous episodes.

*** Or a [[spoiler: tortured soul]] who nonetheless [[spoiler: forced himself on Kurt.]]

* ShipToShipCombat: After "Never Been Kissed", battle lines are being drawn between [[spoiler: Kurt/Karofsky and Kurt/Blaine fans.]]
* SickeninglySweethearts: [[spoiler: Kurt and Blaine]] showed shades of this in "The Substitute," particularly if you're a [[spoiler: Kurt/Karofsky]] shipper.

** In the second episode, Puck says of Santana's Cheerios uniform skirt: "It's so high I can see her ''ovaries''". Possibly he picked up at least ''one'' anatomy term from science class (if Puck was going to pay attention in anything, [[FridgeBrilliance it would likely be female or male anatomy]]). [[RuleOfFunny Or it was joke]]. Hard to say.
** It's possible Santana wasn't wearing her bloomers (the panty-like things that are the same colour as the skirt and are worn over regular underwear), but assuming she was, Puck couldn't have seen anything taboo no matter how high her skirt was.

** Sex with [[BrawnHilda Lauren]] afterwards might count too, except he enjoyed it.

* NightmareFuel: Puck getting locked in a port-a-potty in the freezing cold for six hours.
** Sex with [[BrawnHilda Lauren]] afterwards would count too, except he enjoyed it.

** "Finnkenstein" due to his inability to cheer.

** Will Schuester - a great teacher with a heart of gold, who devotes his time to teach kids the value of friendship or a self-absorbed, biased jerk, for whom Glee is nothing more than an attempt to live his own dreams through his students.

** Meanwhile, shippers for the actors who play them dub them "[=McHalowitz=]".

** Holly Holliday classes are likely a in-universe example of this.

** Due to the events of "Never Been Kissed" [[spoiler: [[IncrediblyLamePun "Karommel"]] has been offered for Karofsky/Kurt]].

** The Finn/Kurt subplot in "Theatricality" has sparked quite a hot debate over which character was more in the wrong (Finn for calling Kurt's decor "faggy" or Kurt for the stalking and harassment which led to Finn's outburst?). Eventually bled over into the show itself.

** Kurt wants to lock Rachel in his basement. Okay. Until one remembers that his basement is also his bedroom. That doesn't have sexual undertones due to his sexuality, but one does have to wonder why he'd want to lock someone he has so many issues with in the place where he sleeps.

* SpotlightStealingSquad: Rachel and Finn get hate for this, especially in the first season. "Never Been Kissed", in the second season, is perhaps the first episode in the series where neither of them significantly factor into the plot.