Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / FunkyWinkerbean

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArcFatigue: Les Moore has been mourning the death of his beloved wife Lisa since 2007. And it took her eight years before that to die of cancer. Recurring plot lines include books about Lisa, movies about Lisa (two separate attempts), tape-recorded messages from Lisa, Lisa appearing as a ghost (including one time where she called in a bomb threat), and annual "legacy run." To put it mildly, it's getting tiresome.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AmericansHateTingle: Like with most other U.S. plot-based comic strips, ''Funky Winkerbean'' has pretty much zero European readers. Perhaps more surprisingly, it never took hold in Canada either, where it's also almost completely unknown. Part of the reason, no doubt, is the difficulty that new readers would have in understanding new strips without access to the decades of old strips that have piled up.

to:

* AmericansHateTingle: Like with most other U.S. plot-based comic strips, ''Funky Winkerbean'' has pretty much zero European readers. Perhaps more surprisingly, it never took hold in Canada either, where it's also almost completely unknown. Part of the reason, no doubt, is the difficulty that new readers would have in understanding new strips without access to the decades of old strips that have piled up. (Of course, it's ''also'' pretty obscure even in America, despite having run there for 50 years.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: 2019 saw a months-long arc around Cindy and Jessica filming a documentary about Butter Brinkel, a 40s Hollywood star whose career was ended after he was charged for the murder of an actress he dated, and who was a close friend of ''Starbuck Jones'' actor Cliff Anger. After the long period of pre-production and exploring the case's drama and peculiarities, Cliff ends his interviews for the documentary with an odd recollection: Brinkel's actor-chimpanzee pet Zanzibar, who he recalls once pointed a prop gun at him and ''spoke'' (in English, which is impossible for real chimps!) to demand where his "father" was when Cliff looked after the monkey, suggesting that ''he'' killed the actress in a fit of misplaced jealousy! The arc comes to an end mere days after this bizarre revelation, with no further comment on the absurdity of it all.

to:

* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: 2019 saw a months-long arc around Cindy and Jessica filming a documentary about Butter Brinkel, a 40s Hollywood star whose career was ended after he was charged for the murder of an actress he dated, and who was a close friend of ''Starbuck Jones'' actor Cliff Anger. After the long period of pre-production and exploring the case's drama and peculiarities, peculiarities (including that Brinkel refused to testify for himself), Cliff ends his interviews for the documentary with an odd recollection: Brinkel's actor-chimpanzee pet Zanzibar, who he recalls once pointed a prop gun at him and ''spoke'' (in English, which is impossible for real chimps!) to demand where his "father" was when Cliff looked after the monkey, suggesting that ''he'' killed the actress in a fit of misplaced jealousy! jealousy, and that Brinkel let himself be charged to cover for him! The arc comes to an end mere days after this bizarre revelation, with no further comment on the absurdity of it all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BigLippedAlligatorMoment: 2019 saw a months-long arc around Cindy and Jessica filming a documentary about Butter Brinkel, a 40s Hollywood star whose career was ended after he was charged for the murder of an actress he dated, and who was a close friend of ''Starbuck Jones'' actor Cliff Anger. After the long period of pre-production and exploring the case's drama and peculiarities, Cliff ends his interviews for the documentary with an odd recollection: Brinkel's actor-chimpanzee pet Zanzibar, who he recalls once pointed a prop gun at him and ''spoke'' (in English, which is impossible for real chimps!) to demand where his "father" was when Cliff looked after the monkey, suggesting that ''he'' killed the actress in a fit of misplaced jealousy! The arc comes to an end mere days after this bizarre revelation, with no further comment on the absurdity of it all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Though Harley's role as the school janitor had been established in Act 1, he had largely faded into the background in the following Acts, making his final appearance have the vibe of RememberTheNewGuy for later readers. That he's revealed to be a time-traveling observer whose mission has been to guide the timeline in the proper direction just to HandWave away the strips many, many, ''many'' [[ContinuitySnarl Continuity Snarls]] and the gap with the ''ComicStrip/{{Crankshft}}'' timeline certainly didn't help either.

to:

** Though Harley's role as the school janitor had been established in Act 1, he had largely faded into the background in the following Acts, making his final appearance have the vibe of RememberTheNewGuy for later readers. That he's revealed to be a time-traveling observer whose mission has been to guide the timeline in the proper direction just to HandWave away the strips many, many, ''many'' [[ContinuitySnarl Continuity Snarls]] and the gap with the ''ComicStrip/{{Crankshft}}'' ''ComicStrip/{{Crankshaft}}'' timeline certainly didn't help either.

Added: 2492

Changed: 460

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AssPull: After Batiuk announced he would be ending the strip in late 2022, he introduced the character of Mr. Davidson, the school janitor, as a time-traveling observer whose mission has been to guide the timeline of the town of Westview in the proper direction. Because... why not, apparently. (In reality, it was to HandWave away the strips many, many, ''many'' continuity snarls and plot breakdowns -- they were all the work of the time traveler, messing up the timestream.)

to:

* AssPull: After Batiuk announced The directions of some storylines have been received as this for many snarkers:
** Adeela's arrest and attempted deportation by ICE being solved by Funky calling UsefulNotes/BillClinton himself to intervene, even though it was based on past storylines where
he would be was on good terms with Montoni's, came off as contrived in this manner for many reasons. It was a CallBack that had not been referenced in many years (namely an Act 2 storyline where Bill had ensured Montoni's sign became a historic landmark), was seen as implausible by many given the then-current political administration that supported ICE and was in conflict with the Clintons in particular, and ruined any nuance the RippedFromTheHeadlines story could say about an ongoing issue by relying on a fantastical solution out of reach of actual victims of aggressive ICE deportation. The story ending on the ICE agents having [[PunchClockVillain become friendly due to loving Montoni's pizza]] also came off as insult to injury for those who felt the organization didn't deserve sympathy.
** Montoni's closing with the end of the strip, with the blame being put on the UsefulNotes/COVID19Pandemic for "wiping out [their] thin-crust profit margins" didn't make sense for many who observed that when
the strip in late 2022, he introduced had addressing the character pandemic (after ignoring it for some time due to the month-long advanced writing of Mr. Davidson, the strip), Funky had mentioned being overwhelmed with business via their delivery service (something that many pizza-serving restaurants saw a large boom in profits at the time in RealLife). The fact that such an important cornerstone of the strip coming to an end[[note]]Which was even confusingly contradicted by the Montoni's crew using delivery cars with "new" snow tires on Christmas Eve, long after the strips announcing the shop's closure[[/note]] wasn't even a prime focus of the final months (with the storyline quickly shifting to Summer's Westview book and Harley's past and future revelations connected to it) felt disingenuous to ''Funky's'' overall legacy for many
** Though Harley's role as
the school janitor, as janitor had been established in Act 1, he had largely faded into the background in the following Acts, making his final appearance have the vibe of RememberTheNewGuy for later readers. That he's revealed to be a time-traveling observer whose mission has been to guide the timeline of the town of Westview in the proper direction. Because... why not, apparently. (In reality, it was direction just to HandWave away the strips many, many, ''many'' continuity snarls [[ContinuitySnarl Continuity Snarls]] and plot breakdowns -- they were all the work of gap with the time traveler, messing up the timestream.) ''ComicStrip/{{Crankshft}}'' timeline certainly didn't help either.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Pretty much everything regarding Lisa's death, but especially when she makes a video for Summer.
** Bull Bushka's illness, from his initial diagnosis of having a degenerative brain disorder (the result of repeated concussions while playing football), to the aftermath (retirement from coaching and later teaching at Westview High) to seeking treatment but being denied insurance coverage to his decision to take his own life (fearing bankruptcy, suffering from ravaging headaches, unable to explain increasingly bizarre behavior and knowing his family and friends will likely watch him devolve into a dementia-type vegetative state) … the storyline of the onetime superjock and super-tormenter of Les Moore who overcame his past to be one one of Westview's most beloved coaches and teachers (and one of Les' closest friends) into a man truly suffering and tortured by his predicament and knowing there was nothing he could do was one of the strip's most heartbreaking storylines.

to:

** Pretty much everything Certain elements regarding Lisa's death, but especially when she makes a video for Summer.
Summer. Typically though, Batiuk overplayed his hand on this, and then spent literally ''years'' unveiling more and more videos Lisa made, seemingly micromanaging Les's life from beyond the grave. What was a one-time genuine and bittersweet moment eventually became cringe-inducing (inadvertent) self-parody.
** Bull Bushka's illness, from his initial diagnosis of having a degenerative brain disorder (the result of repeated concussions while playing football), to the aftermath (retirement from coaching and later teaching at Westview High) to seeking treatment but being denied insurance coverage to his decision to take his own life (fearing bankruptcy, suffering from ravaging headaches, unable to explain increasingly bizarre behavior and knowing his family and friends will likely watch him devolve into a dementia-type vegetative state) … the storyline of the onetime superjock and super-tormenter of Les Moore who overcame his past to be one one of Westview's most beloved coaches and teachers (and one of Les' closest friends) into a man truly suffering and tortured by his predicament and knowing there was nothing he could do was one of the strip's most heartbreaking storylines.



* TooBleakStoppedCaring: It's a little hard to care about these people, either from the sheer number of bad things or how much it gets hammered in your face.

to:

* TooBleakStoppedCaring: It's a little hard to care about these people, either from because of the sheer number of bad things that happen to them (and their resigned fatalism and utter unwillingness to ''do'' anything about their situations) or because of how much it gets hammered in your face.face.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AssPull: After Batiuk announced he would be ending the strip in late 2022, he introduced the character of Mr. Davidson, the school janitor, as a time-traveling observer whose mission has been to guide the timeline of the town of Westview in the proper direction. Because... why not, apparently.

to:

* AssPull: After Batiuk announced he would be ending the strip in late 2022, he introduced the character of Mr. Davidson, the school janitor, as a time-traveling observer whose mission has been to guide the timeline of the town of Westview in the proper direction. Because... why not, apparently. (In reality, it was to HandWave away the strips many, many, ''many'' continuity snarls and plot breakdowns -- they were all the work of the time traveler, messing up the timestream.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
True Art Is Angsty is not YMMV; while this seems to be In Universe, it lacks context to be moved to the main page.


* TrueArtIsAngsty: According to Batiuk anyway. He really takes it personally.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AudienceAlienatingEra: In its early years, the comic was simple enough – a wacky gag-per-day strip that took place in a high-school. Years later, after a few in-universe timeskips, it became one of the most dark and depressing comics ever syndicated. Constant mention of cancer, death, suicide, characters trapped in a miserable world, and even a story arc of one of the major characters getting cancer and slowly dying from it for the reading public to follow. And yet, for some reason, it still retained its silly name. Even its sister comic Crankshaft (which is in the same continuity) can't escape the constant gloom that all the characters suffer from. This isn't a dramatic exaggeration either; read Funky Winkerbean's trope page.

to:

* AudienceAlienatingEra: In its early years, the comic was simple enough – a wacky gag-per-day strip that took place in a high-school. Years later, after a few in-universe timeskips, it became one of the most dark and depressing comics ever syndicated. Constant mention of cancer, death, suicide, characters trapped in a miserable world, and even a story arc of one of the major characters getting cancer and slowly dying from it for the reading public to follow. And yet, for some reason, it still retained its silly name. Even its sister comic Crankshaft (which is in the same continuity) can't escape the constant gloom that all the characters suffer from. This isn't a dramatic exaggeration either; read Funky Winkerbean's trope page.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AudienceAlienatingEra: In its early years, the comic was simple enough – a wacky gag-per-day strip that took place in a high-school. Years later, after a few in-universe timeskips, it became one of the most dark and depressing comics ever syndicated. Constant mention of cancer, death, suicide, characters trapped in a miserable world, and even a story arc of one of the major characters getting cancer and slowly dying from it for the reading public to follow. Even its sister comic Crankshaft (which is in the same continuity) can't escape the constant gloom that all the characters suffer from. This isn't a dramatic exaggeration either; read Funky Winkerbean's trope page.

to:

* AudienceAlienatingEra: In its early years, the comic was simple enough – a wacky gag-per-day strip that took place in a high-school. Years later, after a few in-universe timeskips, it became one of the most dark and depressing comics ever syndicated. Constant mention of cancer, death, suicide, characters trapped in a miserable world, and even a story arc of one of the major characters getting cancer and slowly dying from it for the reading public to follow. And yet, for some reason, it still retained its silly name. Even its sister comic Crankshaft (which is in the same continuity) can't escape the constant gloom that all the characters suffer from. This isn't a dramatic exaggeration either; read Funky Winkerbean's trope page.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AudienceAlienatingEra: In its early years, the comic was simple enough – a wacky GagPerDay strip that took place in a high-school. Years later, after a few in-universe timeskips, it became one of the most dark and depressing comics ever syndicated. Constant mention of cancer, death, suicide, characters trapped in a miserable world, and even a story arc of one of the major characters getting cancer and slowly dying from it for the reading public to follow. Even its sister comic Crankshaft (which is in the same continuity) can't escape the constant gloom that all the characters suffer from. This isn't a dramatic exaggeration either; read Funky Winkerbean's trope page.

to:

* AudienceAlienatingEra: In its early years, the comic was simple enough – a wacky GagPerDay gag-per-day strip that took place in a high-school. Years later, after a few in-universe timeskips, it became one of the most dark and depressing comics ever syndicated. Constant mention of cancer, death, suicide, characters trapped in a miserable world, and even a story arc of one of the major characters getting cancer and slowly dying from it for the reading public to follow. Even its sister comic Crankshaft (which is in the same continuity) can't escape the constant gloom that all the characters suffer from. This isn't a dramatic exaggeration either; read Funky Winkerbean's trope page.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AudienceAlienatingEra: In its early years, the comic was simple enough – a wacky GagPerDay strip that took place in a high-school. Years later, after a few in-universe timeskips, it became one of the most dark and depressing comics ever syndicated. Constant mention of cancer, death, suicide, characters trapped in a miserable world, and even a story arc of one of the major characters getting cancer and slowly dying from it for the reading public to follow. Even its sister comic Crankshaft (which is in the same continuity) can't escape the constant gloom that all the characters suffer from. This isn't a dramatic exaggeration either; read Funky Winkerbean's trope page.

Removed: 1052

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Per TRS, this was renamed to Falsely Advertised Accuracy and moved to Trivia. (Plus, it was never YMMV.)


* DanBrowned: In 2020, Batiuk had an arc involving a wildfire that broke out in LA. Despite Batiuk proudly posting on his blog photos of a trip he took to Los Angeles specifically to 'research' the story, he got almost every geographic detail totally wrong. The fire (as described) stretched from Point Dume to at least Bronson Canyon -- which would wipe out Malibu, Pacific Palisades, Brentwood, Westwood, Bel Air, Beverly Hills, West Hollywood, Hollywood, and possibly Los Feliz. It would be a Hurricane Katrina-level disaster (or worse) that would leave hundreds of thousands, potentially millions, homeless. He also has characters escape the fire by driving "north along the coast" from West Hollywood (which makes no geographical sense whatsoever), and has people who are practically in the middle of the blaze completely unaware of it. In reality, the massive amount of smoke this sort of fire would spew out would be visible for miles around, and would immediately (and very noticeably) affect the air quality over a very wide area of LA county.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The character has in fact been around since the early years, so his existance in itself wasn't an Ass Pull. The sudden sci-fi elements were, though.


* AssPull: After Batiuk announced he would be ending the strip in late 2022, he introduced the character of Mr. Davidson, the school janitor, as a time-traveling observer whose mission has been to guide the timeline of the town of Westview in the proper direction. This reveal might have worked had the character of the janitor been seen in the strip even once before.

to:

* AssPull: After Batiuk announced he would be ending the strip in late 2022, he introduced the character of Mr. Davidson, the school janitor, as a time-traveling observer whose mission has been to guide the timeline of the town of Westview in the proper direction. This reveal might have worked had the character of the janitor been seen in the strip even once before.Because... why not, apparently.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
"What an Idiot!" is now Flame Bait.


* WhatAnIdiot: Lisa was accidentally retconned into being one in a recent arc involving Darin's father Frank. Her journal reveals that after Frank had hit her in the past and pressured her into having sex with him she intended to break up with him. And she told him she wanted to break up while they were alone, at night and in an alleyway away from any people. Not in the daytime, at somewhere public with lots of people around.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AssPull: After Batiuk announced he would be ending the strip in late 2022, he introduced the character of Mr. Davidson, the school janitor, as a time-traveling observer whose mission has been to guide the timeline of the town of Westview in the proper direction. This reveal might have worked had the character of the janitor been seen in the strip even once before.

Top