History YMMV / FrigidWindsAndBurningHearts

3rd Oct '16 9:39:00 AM Ferot_Dreadnaught
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* BrokenBase:
** Chapter 8, big time. Most of the chapter is used in order to make Braveheart look like a hero that most of the Royal Guard likes, Equestria loses all of its SugarBowl nature, the Government falls apart even though Celestia has only been gone for less than a day, [[spoiler: and Luna didn't even come up with the idea of trying to "save" Celestia; she was just manipulated by the power-hungry nobles and turned into their puppet]].

to:

* BrokenBase:
**
%%* BrokenBase: needs other side
%%**
Chapter 8, big time. Most of the chapter is used in order to make Braveheart look like a hero that most of the Royal Guard likes, Equestria loses all of its SugarBowl nature, the Government falls apart even though Celestia has only been gone for less than a day, [[spoiler: and Luna didn't even come up with the idea of trying to "save" Celestia; she was just manipulated by the power-hungry nobles and turned into their puppet]].
3rd Oct '16 9:28:38 AM Crossover-Enthusiast
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Chapter 8, big time. Most of the chapter is used in order to make Braveheart look like a hero that most of the Royal Guard likes, Equestria loses all of its SugarBowl nature, the Government falls apart because Celestia has been gone for less than a day, [[spoiler: and Luna didn't even come up with the idea of trying to "save" Celestia; she was just manipulated by the power-hungry nobles and turned into their puppet]].

to:

** Chapter 8, big time. Most of the chapter is used in order to make Braveheart look like a hero that most of the Royal Guard likes, Equestria loses all of its SugarBowl nature, the Government falls apart because even though Celestia has only been gone for less than a day, [[spoiler: and Luna didn't even come up with the idea of trying to "save" Celestia; she was just manipulated by the power-hungry nobles and turned into their puppet]].
3rd Oct '16 9:28:02 AM Crossover-Enthusiast
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Chapter 8, big time. Most of the chapter is used in order to make Braveheart look like a hero that most of the Royal Guard likes, Equestria loses all of its SugarBowl nature, The Government falling apart because Celestia has been gone for less than a day, [[spoiler: and Luna didn't even come up with the idea of trying to "save" Celestia; she was just manipulated by the power-hungry nobles and turned into their puppet]].

to:

** Chapter 8, big time. Most of the chapter is used in order to make Braveheart look like a hero that most of the Royal Guard likes, Equestria loses all of its SugarBowl nature, The the Government falling falls apart because Celestia has been gone for less than a day, [[spoiler: and Luna didn't even come up with the idea of trying to "save" Celestia; she was just manipulated by the power-hungry nobles and turned into their puppet]].
3rd Oct '16 9:27:34 AM Crossover-Enthusiast
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** Chapter 8, big time. Most of the chapter is used in order to make Braveheart look like a hero that most of the Royal Guard likes. Equestria losing all of its SugarBowl nature. The Government falling apart because Celestia has been gone for less than a day. [[spoiler: And Luna didn't even come up with the idea of trying to "save" Celestia; she was just manipulated by the power-hungry nobles and turned into their puppet.]]

to:

** Chapter 8, big time. Most of the chapter is used in order to make Braveheart look like a hero that most of the Royal Guard likes. likes, Equestria losing loses all of its SugarBowl nature. nature, The Government falling apart because Celestia has been gone for less than a day. day, [[spoiler: And and Luna didn't even come up with the idea of trying to "save" Celestia; she was just manipulated by the power-hungry nobles and turned into their puppet.]]puppet]].
3rd Oct '16 9:26:47 AM Crossover-Enthusiast
Is there an issue? Send a Message


%%** Chapter 6.
** Chapter 8 big time. Most of the chapter is used in order to make Braveheart look like a hero that most of the Royal Guard likes. Equestria losing all of its SugarBowl nature. The Government falling apart because Celestia has been gone for less than a day. [[spoiler: And Luna didn't even come up with the idea of trying to "save" Celestia; she was just manipulated by the power-hungry nobles and turned into their puppet.]]

to:

%%** Chapter 6.
** Chapter 8 8, big time. Most of the chapter is used in order to make Braveheart look like a hero that most of the Royal Guard likes. Equestria losing all of its SugarBowl nature. The Government falling apart because Celestia has been gone for less than a day. [[spoiler: And Luna didn't even come up with the idea of trying to "save" Celestia; she was just manipulated by the power-hungry nobles and turned into their puppet.]]
5th Sep '16 6:01:26 PM Theriocephalus
Is there an issue? Send a Message


*** As of his reediting Nightmare's Night is never mention, and even if it was, Luna would have just used it to bash Celestia anyway.

to:

*** As of his reediting Nightmare's Nightmare Night is never mention, mentioned, and even if it was, Luna would have just used it to bash Celestia anyway.
5th Sep '16 5:37:17 PM Theriocephalus
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* SeinfeldIsUnfunny: When it started, the central idea of this story was rather new and interesting, however, over time, the fandom started seeing Celestia asthe more sympathetic of the two sisters. Now this is just another "Celestia is evil" story among many.

to:

* SeinfeldIsUnfunny: When it started, the central idea of this story was rather new and interesting, however, over time, the fandom started seeing Celestia asthe as the more sympathetic of the two sisters. Now this is just another "Celestia is evil" story among many.
5th Sep '16 5:36:43 PM Theriocephalus
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** In a meta way the writer back when it just started would go on rants about how his version of Luna is better than others because she doesn't whine, act sorry for herself or begs Celestia for forgiveness. Minus the last part that sums up what his Luna becomes.

to:

** In a meta way way, the writer writer, back when it just started started, would go on rants about how his version of Luna is better than others because she doesn't whine, act sorry for herself or begs beg Celestia for forgiveness. Minus the last part that sums up what his Luna becomes.



* SeinfeldIsUnfunny: When it started the ideal of this story was rather new and interesting, however over time the Fandom started seeing as Celestia the more sympathetic of the two sisters. Now this is just another "Celestia is evil" stories.
** Speaking of which this version of Luna was once praised for being so different then other fandom version, now she's a borderline Scrappy.

to:

* SeinfeldIsUnfunny: When it started started, the ideal central idea of this story was rather new and interesting, however however, over time time, the Fandom fandom started seeing as Celestia the asthe more sympathetic of the two sisters. Now this is just another "Celestia is evil" stories.
story among many.
** Speaking of which which, this version of Luna was once praised for being so different then from other fandom version, versions, but now she's a borderline Scrappy.



* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: Luna having difficulty reconnecting with Celestia because she fears her sister may be abusing their station, showing how fear and good intentions can lead one to leap to all the wrong conclusions? Sounds promising, until it gets stifled by everypony falling out of character.

to:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodPlot: Luna having difficulty reconnecting with Celestia because she fears her sister may be abusing their station, showing how fear and good intentions can lead one to leap leaping to all the wrong conclusions? Sounds promising, until it gets stifled by everypony falling out of character. character.
5th Sep '16 5:22:09 PM Theriocephalus
Is there an issue? Send a Message


** The Author himself; is he just a member of the New Lunar Republic and claims of being balance is a cover, or a true Celestia fan who's just too green a fanfic writer to show it.

to:

** The Author himself; is he just a member of the New Lunar Republic and claims of being balance is a cover, or a true Celestia fan who's just too green a fanfic writer to show it.it?
14th Jul '16 2:32:48 PM Ferot_Dreadnaught
Is there an issue? Send a Message


* RealWomenDontWearDresses: The only reason why Rarity isn't "a model feminist" (in her own words) is because she runs her own dress making shop, it seems. At least, according to career soldier Storm Cloud. Rarity only seems to agree with her point of view on her profession in order to drive home her overall point: [[spoiler:that she ''chose'' to become a dressmaker instead of taking her cutie mark's meaning (finding gems) at face value and becoming a miner or something that more precisely fits. She didn't see her destiny as set in stone, but uses her talents to support a career she ''really'' enjoys.]]
** Then FridgeLogic kicks in when you remember [[spoiler: Rarity ''didn't'' get her cutie mark until seeing her outfits in the play, which was hours or even days ''after'' finding the gems, thus it really means "makes dresses dazzle like gems"]].



* Thankfully the basic ideals of the story have been done better in other fanfics.

to:

* ** Thankfully the basic ideals of the story have been done better in other fanfics.
This list shows the last 10 events of 99. Show all.
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/article_history.php?article=YMMV.FrigidWindsAndBurningHearts