Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / Frankenstein

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FriendlyFandoms: With {{Dracula}}. Both the books have been compared to one another from the time ''Dracula'' was published, as both of them are {{Scrapbook Stor|y}}ies that took old-school horror tropes and placed them in modern (at the time) settings with modern (at the time) technologies, to great effect. Adding in the [[Franchise/UniversalHorror Universal]] and [[Film/HammerHorror Hammer]] movies, have ensured that the two works remain widely associated with each other to this day.

to:

* FriendlyFandoms: With {{Dracula}}. Both the books have been compared to one another from the time ''Dracula'' was published, as both of them are {{Scrapbook Stor|y}}ies that took old-school horror tropes and placed them in modern (at the time) settings with modern (at the time) technologies, to great effect. Adding in In addition to this is the [[Franchise/UniversalHorror Universal]] and [[Film/HammerHorror Hammer]] movies, have that has ensured that the two works remain widely associated with each other to this day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FriendlyFandoms: With {{Dracula}}. Both the books have been compared to one another from the time ''Dracula'' was published, as both of them are {{Scrapbook Stor|y}}ies that took old-school horror tropes and placed them in modern (at the time) settings with modern (at the time) technologies, to great effect. Adding in the [[Franchise/UniversalHorror Universal]] and [[Film/HammerHorror Hammer]] movies, have ensured that the two works remain widely associated with each other to this day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Despite being pretty insignificant to the overall story, Justine's meek personality and NiceGirl status has made her quite popular to the fans, who think her death is one of the most tragic parts of the book and the point at which Victor [[MoralEventHorizon crosses the line from self-absorbed and troubled to irredeemable and evil]].

to:

** Despite being pretty insignificant to the overall story, Justine's meek personality and NiceGirl status has made her quite popular to the fans, who think her death is one of the most tragic parts of the book and the point at which Victor [[MoralEventHorizon crosses the line from self-absorbed and troubled to irredeemable and evil]].evil]], since he makes no effort to save her and is arguably just as responsible for her execution as the Creature.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n** "Frankenstein was the monster"/"Frankenstein was the scientist"/"Frankenstein was the monster" [[labelnote:Explanation]]A common joke (usually involving increasing intelligence) playing on the [[AmbiguousSyntax ambiguity]] of saying "Frankenstein was the monster". The first use of the "Frankenstein was the monster" refers to the common [[IAmNotShazam mistake]] made by those unfamiliar with the work. The second use reflects the common view among those who have read the book that Victor Frankenstein was the [[HumansAreTheRealMonsters real monster]] rather than his creation.[[/labelnote]]

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Anvilicious}}: Creating life specifically is hubris and fundamentally flawed is heavy-handedly hammered into the reader.

to:

* {{Anvilicious}}: Creating Shelley's viewpoint that creating life specifically is hubris and fundamentally flawed is heavy-handedly hammered into the reader.

Added: 414

Changed: 341

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EnsembleDarkHorse: Despite being pretty insignificant to the overall story, Justine's meek personality and NiceGirl status has made her quite popular to the fans, who think her death is one of the most tragic parts of the book and the point at which Victor [[MoralEventHorizon crosses the line from self-absorbed and troubled to irredeemable and evil]].

to:

* EnsembleDarkHorse: EnsembleDarkHorse:
**
Despite being pretty insignificant to the overall story, Justine's meek personality and NiceGirl status has made her quite popular to the fans, who think her death is one of the most tragic parts of the book and the point at which Victor [[MoralEventHorizon crosses the line from self-absorbed and troubled to irredeemable and evil]].evil]].
** Henry is beloved for his cheerful personality and strong bond with Victor.



* AwesomeMusic: ''Frankenstein: A New Musical'' isn’t well known but has some gems:

to:

* AwesomeMusic: SugarWiki/AwesomeMusic: ''Frankenstein: A New Musical'' isn’t well known but has some gems:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AwesomeMusic: ''Frankenstein: A New Musical'' isn’t well known but has some gems:
** ''Birth Of My Creation'' makes Victor bringing The Creature to life epic.
** ''Amen'' is an amazing duet between Victor and the prisoner who will become The Creature.
** ''Why?'' makes the already heartbreaking scenes of William’s and Justine’s deaths even worse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Was Victor’s childhood truly idyllic, or is it just a combination of grief and NostalgiaFilter clouding his memories?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** More than one commentator has noted that the monster's threat when Victor won't make a mate for him, "I will be there on your wedding night", can be read in ''so'' many different ways.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MisaimedFandom: Possibly the most triumphant example in all of fiction. To this day, there are still people who view the Creature as NotEvilJustMisunderstood even after killing innocents, including children. Even the Creature himself recognizes what a monster he really became and is DrivenToSuicide.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Everyone "knows" that Victor sewed together bits and pieces of several corpses to make his creature and brought it to life with electricity. While Mary Shelley/Victor does make reference to galvanism and it quite likely inspired Shelley while writing her story, the book itself is vague on the exact process. Deliberately so; Victor outright says he's not going to explain how he did it, for fear of someone else duplicating his mistakes. The most the reader knows for sure is that he dug up bodies and cut up cadavers for research; whether or not he actually built the creature out of them is never made clear, as is how he actually brought the creature to life.

to:

** Everyone "knows" that Victor sewed together bits and pieces of several corpses to make his creature and brought it to life with electricity. While Mary Shelley/Victor does make reference to galvanism and it quite likely inspired Shelley while writing her story, the book itself is vague on the exact process. Deliberately so; Victor outright says he's [[AndSomeOtherStuff not going to explain explain]] how he did it, for fear of someone else duplicating his mistakes. The most the reader knows for sure is that he dug up bodies and cut up cadavers for research; whether or not he actually built the creature out of them is never made clear, as is how he actually brought the creature to life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[IAmNotShazam Everyone "knows" that Frankenstein is the creature]], or at least used to. Nowadays it's fairly common in fiction to hear one character snootily correct another about it being the name of the scientist and not the monster. This leads to the quip, "Knowledge is learning that Frankenstein isn't the monster -- wisdom is understanding that Frankenstein [[HumansAreTheRealMonsters is the monster]]". One could FanWank that the monster is effectively Victor's son, therefore inherits his surname, and therefore Frankenstein ''is'' the monster's name -- but whether this implication was intentional or not, the text never actually refers to him as such.

to:

** [[IAmNotShazam Everyone "knows" that Frankenstein is the creature]], or at least used to. Nowadays it's fairly common in fiction to hear one character snootily correct another about it being the name of the scientist and not the monster. This leads to the quip, "Knowledge is learning that Frankenstein isn't the monster -- wisdom is understanding that Frankenstein ''[[ParentalAbandonment is]]'' [[HumansAreTheRealMonsters is the monster]]". One could FanWank that the monster is effectively Victor's son, therefore inherits his surname, and therefore Frankenstein ''is'' the monster's name -- but whether this implication was intentional or not, the text never actually refers to him as such.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* JerksAreWorseThanVillains: It's not hard to find fans who see Victor Frankenstein as worse than The Monster he created. The Monster may have killed a number of innocent people, but given that he only became homicidal after being abandoned by his "father" and ostracized from society just because of his appearance, many viewers end up feeling sorry for him. Meanwhile, Victor is the one who created The Monster and then abandoned him in the first place, kept The Monster's existence secret from his friends and family even after he knew that The Monster was hunting them down, allowed an innocent woman to take the fall for The Monster's first murder, and then had the audacity to insist to Robert Walton that ''he'' was the primary victim in all of this. If you mention that [[IAmNotShazam Frankenstein isn't the monster]] on any online forum nowadays, you're likely to quickly get a response from someone insisting that, [[HumansAreTheRealMonsters actually, Frankenstein]] ''[[HumansAreTheRealMonsters was]]'' [[HumansAreTheRealMonsters the monster]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:



Added DiffLines:

* MemeticMutation: "Dude! Let me in! I'm a fairy! Don't you believe in fairies?"[[labelnote:Explanation]]An edited pair of panels from the Creator/JunjiIto manga adaptation of the novel, specifically the scene where the Creature taunts Victor after the deaths of Elizabeth and Alphonse. The tonal contrast between the grotesque, gothic imagery and the flippant dialogue resulted in the edit becoming a popular subject of parody online, usually swapping out Victor and the Creature with characters from other works.[[/labelnote]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[IAmNotShazam Everyone "knows" that Frankenstein is the creature]], or at least used to. Nowadays it's fairly common in fiction to hear one character snootily correct another about it being the name of the scientist and not the monster. This leads to the quip, "Knowledge is realizing that Frankenstein isn't the monster -- wisdom is realizing that Frankenstein [[HumansAreTheRealMonsters is the monster]]". One could FanWank that the monster is effectively Victor's son, therefore inherits his surname, and therefore Frankenstein ''is'' the monster's name -- but whether this implication was intentional or not, the text never actually refers to him as such.

to:

** [[IAmNotShazam Everyone "knows" that Frankenstein is the creature]], or at least used to. Nowadays it's fairly common in fiction to hear one character snootily correct another about it being the name of the scientist and not the monster. This leads to the quip, "Knowledge is realizing learning that Frankenstein isn't the monster -- wisdom is realizing understanding that Frankenstein [[HumansAreTheRealMonsters is the monster]]". One could FanWank that the monster is effectively Victor's son, therefore inherits his surname, and therefore Frankenstein ''is'' the monster's name -- but whether this implication was intentional or not, the text never actually refers to him as such.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DracoInLeatherPants: The Creature/Adam Frankenstein/The Monster, whatever you want to call him. In most adaptations of Mary Shelley's novel, he often does get treated much more sympathetically, most notably in the original film, which makes him into a clueless monster that doesn't know its own strength. In the novel itself, while he is a ultimately a tragic figure who feels remorse by the end and commits suicide, he is much smarter and uses said intelligence to willingly commit several premeditated murders and frame an innocent for one of them.

to:

* DracoInLeatherPants: The Creature/Adam Frankenstein/The Monster, whatever you want to call him. In most adaptations of Mary Shelley's novel, he often does get treated much more sympathetically, most notably in the original film, which makes him into a clueless monster that doesn't know its own strength. In the novel itself, while he is a ultimately a tragic figure who feels remorse by the end and commits suicide, he is much smarter and uses said intelligence to willingly commit several premeditated murders and frame an innocent for one of them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Who is the real monster? Is it Victor for being irresponsible and neglectful towards his creation and then refusing to create a companion for him, inadvertently leading to the monster killing his friends and family? Or is it the monster, for actually causing the deaths?

to:

** Who is the real monster? Is it Victor for being irresponsible and neglectful towards his creation and then refusing to create a companion for him, inadvertently leading to the monster killing his friends and family? Or is Is it the monster, for actually causing the deaths?deaths? Or are they both to blame for being unwilling to accept the consequences of their actions?



* DracoInLeatherPants: The Creature/Adam Frankenstein/The Monster, whatever you want to call him. In most adaptations of Mary Shelley's novel, he often does get treated much more sympathetically, most notably in the original film, which makes him into a clueless monster that doesn't know its own strength. In the novel itself, he is much smarter and uses said intelligence to commit premeditated murders and frame an innocent for one of them. To be fair, he does feel rather bad at the end, and decides to commit suicide.

to:

* DracoInLeatherPants: The Creature/Adam Frankenstein/The Monster, whatever you want to call him. In most adaptations of Mary Shelley's novel, he often does get treated much more sympathetically, most notably in the original film, which makes him into a clueless monster that doesn't know its own strength. In the novel itself, while he is a ultimately a tragic figure who feels remorse by the end and commits suicide, he is much smarter and uses said intelligence to willingly commit several premeditated murders and frame an innocent for one of them. To be fair, he does feel rather bad at the end, and decides to commit suicide.them.



* MainstreamObscurity: The work has had a lot of influence in pop culture. However, only a small portion of those who have quoted or referenced the character have read the novel.

to:

* MainstreamObscurity: The work has had a lot of influence in pop culture. However, only a small portion of those who have quoted or referenced the character have read the novel.novel, and the Universal movie adaptations and their several modifications became the first thing associated with the story in the minds of a large part of the public.

Top