History YMMV / EromangaSensei

** [[DirtyKid Megumi and her love for dicks]], which is also commonly compared to [[WebVideo/FilthyFrank Lord Chin Chin's]] CatchPhrase "Ore wa ochinchin ga daisuki dayo!".

* AudienceAlienatingPremise: Parts of the Western audiences were already negatively tuned to this show, since it repeated many elements of the previous work of the author, including BrotherSisterIncest as a major plot thread; though it is not a blood relationship this time, the lower ages of the cast more than compensates. Even among those inclined towards the show, a few dislike the repetition.

** In a very obvious way with ''LightNovel/{{Oreimo}}'', having the same author, (NotBloodRelated) BrotherSisterIncest as a main storyline, the duet between NiceGuy older brother protagonist and the sister studying in middle school, etc. Moreover, both [=LNs=] have many references to Otaku culture. The main difference is that ''Eromanga Sensei'' is dedicated to unrelated siblings and an adjacent literature community plot.

* HypeBacklash: Given the {{Moe}} nature of this show and its popularity as a source for memes, it's no wonder that the growth of its popularity has become the object of criticism among alledged purists from the anime community. Add to this the popularity of the original novel and the dislike of the incest plot among some Western viewers, and you will understand how mixed attitudes have developed about its popularity.

* PeripheryHatedom: The mere fact that this series features implied BrotherSisterIncest, which is NotBloodRelated, brings out the same people who hated [[LightNovel/{{Oreimo}} the author's previous work]] on principle when it was in publication, [[ComplainingAboutShowsYouDontWatch no matter the actual quality of the work in question.]]

* {{Squick}}: Some think the 15-year-old protagonist developing a romantic relationship with his 12-year-old stepsister and discussing dicks with her classmate is off-putting. Others think it's hilarious.

* AudienceAlienatingPremise: Western audiences were already negatively tuned to this show, since it repeated many elements of the previous work of the author, including BrotherSisterIncest as a major plot thread; though it is not a blood relationship this time, the lower ages of the cast more than compensates. Even those inclined towards the show dislike the repetition
* AmericansHateTingle: Although the show is the most popular in its season in Japan and had high ratings, many in the west dismiss it at best because of the author's past reputation and the incestuous relationship between a 12 year old girl and 15 year old boy.

* BrokenBase: Is this a new, full-fledged work with an original storyline, or is it an attempt to rewrite LightNovel/{{Oreimo}}, removing IncestSubtext and the ending that angered many? As the adaptation began, this was accentuated as it repeats the style of the previous work.

** In a very obvious way with LightNovel/{{Oreimo}}, having the same author, BrotherSisterIncest as a main storyline, the duet between NiceGuy older brother protagonist and the sister studying in middle school, etc. Moreover, both [=LNs=] have many references to Otaku culture. The main difference is that Eromanga is dedicated to unrelated siblings and an adjacent literature community plot.
** With Imouto sae Ireba Ii, which also has a combination of Imouto with the theme light novel, however more oriented to the fanservice and the real IncestSubtext.
* HypeBacklash: Given the moe nature of this show and its popularity as a source for memes, it's no wonder that the growth of its popularity has become the object of criticism among purists from the anime community. Add to this the popularity of the original novel and the dislike of the incest plot among Western viewers, and you will understand how mixed attitudes have developed about its popularity.

* PeripheryHatedom: The very fact that this series features implied BrotherSisterIncest brings out the same people who hated on [[LightNovel/{{Oreimo}} the author's previous work]] when it was in publication.
* SignatureScene: Sagiri draws in his underwear on the bed and dialogue about the dicks between Masamune and Megumi.
* {{Squick}}: The 15-year-old protagonist develops a romantic relationship with his 12-year-old stepsister and discusses dicks with her classmate.

* AudienceAlienatingPremise: Part of the western audience was already pre-negatively tuned to this show, since it repeated many elements of the previous work of the author and had the next BrotherSisterIncest as a plot, from which many viewers are simply tired, despite the fact that it is now a question of a non-native brother and sister.
* AmericansHateTingle: Despite the fact that the show was the most popular in its season in Japan and had rather high ratings, many in the west seem to genuinely hate this show because of the author's past reputation and his next pandering of incest in this work. Made even worse that the said sister happens to be a child not even in her teens.

* BestKnownForTheFanservice: Many people are more aware of the fact that this show has some very nice little girls in main cast than what it tells about the literary community or different kind of relationship between brothers and sisters.
* BrokenBase: Is this a new, full-fledged work with an original storyline, or is it an attempt to rewrite LightNovel/{{Oreimo}}, removing IncestSubtext and angered many ending? With the beginning of adaptation, everything becomes even more embarrassing when it turns out that it repeats the style of the previous work.

** In a very obvious way with LightNovel/{{Oreimo}}, having the same author, some BrotherSisterIncest as the main storyline, the duet between NiceGuy older brother-protagonist and the sister studying in middle school, etc. Moreover, both [=LNs=] have many references to Otaku culture. The main difference is that Eromanga is dedicated to unrelated siblings and has a much softer and more accessible story.

* HypeBacklash: Given the moe-nature of this show and its popularity as a source for memes, it's no wonder that the growth of its popularity has become the object of criticism among purists from the anime community. Add to this the great popularity of the original novel and the apparent dislike of the incest among Western viewers and you will understand how mixed attitude has developed to its popularity.
* GeniusBonus: One of the main reasons for the success of this series an image of many nuances of work on light novels, including a discussion of concepts or the creation of illustrations, which makes it quite popular among people from the literary and artistic community.

* PeripheryHatedom: The very fact that this series features implied BrotherSisterIncest brings out the same kinds of people who hated on [[LightNovel/{{Oreimo}} the author's previous work]] when it was in publication.

* WinBackTheCrowd: This series marked the return of popularity to its author, after the end of his previous work caused a scandal in the anime community.

* AmericansHateTingle: Despite the fact that the show was the most popular in its season in Japan and had rather high ratings, many in the west seem to genuinely hate this show because of the author's past reputation and his next pandering of incest in this work.

** [[DirtyKid Megumi and her love for dicks.]]

* ReferenceOverdosed: Not so hard as in ''Oreimo'', but be prepared for the fact that each episode will contain at least three or four references to other ''Dengeki Bunko'' light novels.

* BestKnownForTheFanservice: Many people are more aware of the fact that this show has some very nice little girls in main cast than what it tells about the literary community or different kind of relationship between brothers and sisters.

** In a very obvious way with LightNovel/{{Oreimo}}, having the same author, some BrotherSisterIncest as the main storyline, the duet between NiceGuy older brother-protagonist and the sister studying in middle school, etc. Moreover, both LNs have many references to Otaku culture. The main difference is that Eromanga is dedicated to unrelated siblings and has a much softer and more accessible story.

* {{Squick}}: The 15-year-old protagonist develops a romantic relationship with his 12-year-old stepsister and discusses dicks with her classmate.

* ReferenceOverdosed: Not so hard as in Oreimo, but be prepared for the fact that each episode will contain at least three or four references to the other works of Dengeki Bungo.

** Sagiri as an object for jokes on incestuous topics, especially her ReluctantFanserviceGirl image and the shot with her from the first episode, where [[https://i.imgflip.com/1npbeq.jpg#ActualImage her pose]] resembles a meme [[http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/roll-safe Roll Safe]].

** Sagiri as an object for jokes on incestuous topics, especially her ReluctantFanserviceGirl image and the frame with her from the first episode, where [[https://i.imgflip.com/1npbeq.jpg#ActualImage her pose]] resembles a meme [[http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/roll-safe Roll Safe]].
* SignatureScene: Sahiri draws in his underwear on the bed and dialogue about the dicks between Masamune and Megumi.
* WinBackTheCrowd: This series marked the return of popularity to its author, after the end of his previous work caused a scandal in the anime community.

http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/roll-safe

** Sagiri as an object for jokes on incestuous topics, especially the frame with her from the first episode, where [[https://i.imgflip.com/1npbeq.jpg#ActualImage her pose]] resembles a mem [http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/roll-safe Roll Safe]] and ReluctantFanserviceGirl image.

** Sagiri as an object for [[https://i.imgflip.com/1npbeq.jpg#ActualImage jokes on incestuous topics]], especially her words "Nii-san, now I will wash my panties myself" and ReluctantFanserviceGirl image.

* WinBackTheCrowd: This series marked the return of popularity to its author, after the end of his previous work caused a scandal in the anime community.

** Sagiri as an object for jokes on incestuous topics, especially her words "Nii-san, now I will wash my panties myself" and ReluctantFanserviceGirl image.

** Sagiri as an object for jokes on incestuous topics, especially her words "Nii-san, now I will wash my panties myself."

** Sagiri as an object for jokes on incestuous topics, especially her words "Nii-san, now I will wash my own panties myself."

* MemeticMutation: [[DirtyKid Megumi and her love for dicks.]]

* MemeticMutation: [[DirtyKid Megumi and her love for dicks.]]

* AwsomeMusic: It's hard not to like the opening and ending theme, especially when combined with a rather catchy video performance.

* BrokenBase: Is this a new, full-fledged work with an original storyline, or is it an attempt to rewrite LightNovel/{{Oreimo}}, removing IncestSubtext and angered many ending?