Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / DoctorWhoS30E3PlanetOfTheOod

Go To

OR

Added: 1185

Removed: 395

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AuthorsSavingThrow: After "The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit" was criticized for having the Doctor not caring about the Ood being enslaved to the point of being perfectly happy to leave the slaves to die at the climax, this episode has him fighting against the instutionalized enslavement of the Ood and admitting that he probably should have tried to help them in the aforementioned story.


Added DiffLines:

* MagnificentBastard: The [[HiveMind Ood Brain]] is the conduit for the Ood's telepathic network, that will commandeer Oodkind in dire times, with its main representative being [[TheFace Ood Sigma]]. After the Ood were [[SlaveRace enslaved by humanity]], for 200 years the Ood Brain was left helpless and unable to act. The Ood Brain finally got its chance for revenge when a human Ood activist lowered the telepathic force-field and started the Ood Rebellion. The Ood Brain transmitted a HatePlague to all Ood in range which afflicted them with "[[RedEyesTakeWarning Red-eye]]", turning the usually peaceful Ood murderous and vengeful. The Red-eyed Ood began killing the humans they once served, going from discreet murders to escalating into all out war. Eventually only Ood Sigma remains, where he [[TheMole feigns loyalty to]] CorruptCorporateExecutive Klineman Halpen, preparing him for the ultimate punishment of feeding him Ood graft and turning him into an Ood himself. With the root cause of Ood enslavement neutralized, the Doctor assisted in "breaking the circle" of the telepathic force-field, reestablishing the Ood Brain's connection and freeing Oodkind from enslavement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In spite of the assumption of broadcast order and early intentions to bring back Ida Scott, [[AudioPlay/BigFinishDoctorWho Big Finish's]] ''[[Series/{{Torchwood}} Torchwood]]'' audios curiously went on to date the events of ''[[Recap/DoctorWhoS28E8TheImpossiblePlanet The Impossible Planet]]'' ''*after*'' those of this episode (the former's given date of 43K2.1 being later explained as another dating system's version of 4221, while ''Planet of the Ood'' is set in 4126). Which means that despite the implied happy ending here, [[FridgeHorror not all Ood slaves were returned to the Ood Sphere after all, be it through ignorance or malicious defiance of their revolution...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AuthorsSavingThrow: After "The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit" was criticized for having the Doctor not caring about the Ood being enslaved to the point of being perfectly happy to leave the slaves to die at the climax, this episode has him fighting against the instutionalized enslavement of the Ood and admitting that he probably should have tried to help them in the aforementioned story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Doctor compares the severance of the Ood's hind brains as akin to a lobotomy, and then furthers the point by saying that Donna would be like a processed Ood if someone took her memory and emotions, just as he would have to do her in the season finale.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** It can also be interpreted as "revolutionary violence against an evil system is morally justified".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HarsherInHindsight: It's sad for Donna to hear the song of the captured Ood, but it's even sadder [[spoiler:for the viewers who have seen the end of the season. Donna can't handle something humans are not supposed to experience, and the Doctor blocks it for her]].

to:

* HarsherInHindsight: It's sad for Donna to hear the song of the captured Ood, but it's even sadder [[spoiler:for for the viewers who have seen the end of the season. Donna can't handle something humans are not supposed to experience, and the Doctor blocks it for her]].her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HarsherInHindsight: It's sad for Donna to hear the song of the captured Ood, but it's even sadder [[spoiler:for the viewers who have seen the end of the season. Donna can't handle something humans are not supposed to experience, and the Doctor blocks it for her]].

Added: 237

Changed: 92

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There's a slightly more subtle Aesop at work as well. At one point when Donna's railing against the institutionalised slavery represented by the Ood, the Doctor points out that most of the clothes she's wearing at that very moment were manufactured in sweatshops by people living only a few steps above slavery. It suggests that although people in the west intellectually know slavery is bad and wouldn't tolerate it when they're directly exposed to it, if it's out of sight and they benefit from it they're likely to not give it much thought.

to:

** There's a slightly more subtle Aesop at work as well. At one point when Donna's railing against the institutionalised slavery represented by the Ood, the Doctor points out that most of the clothes she's wearing at that very moment were manufactured in sweatshops by people living only a few steps above slavery. It suggests that although people in the west intellectually know slavery is bad and wouldn't tolerate it when they're directly exposed to it, if it's out of sight and they benefit from it they're likely to not give it much thought. The people overseeing the Ood Operations plant even say the same is applicable for the Ood.
* HilariousInHindsight: The wristwatch communicators that some of the characters are shown using don't seem too far fetched now that Apple and Google have introduced smartwatches capable of making phone calls independent of a smartphone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The " the anvilicious "slavery's bad, mmmmkay?" aesop seems to have been a deliberate attempt at amends for the FridgeHorror of the Doctor basically saying "okie dokie" when he discovered the Ood slaves in "The Impossible Planet"/"The Satan Pit" and ''left them to die at the end of the episode''. This is the main reason they made "Planet of The Ood", to address that fact. It's even lampshaded when Donna points out how uncharacteristic it is for the Doctor to not help the Ood. The Doctor points out he was battling Satan at the time and thus a little busy. Then he admits that he owes them one.

to:

** The " the anvilicious "slavery's bad, mmmmkay?" aesop seems to have been a deliberate attempt at amends for the FridgeHorror of the Doctor basically saying "okie dokie" when he discovered the Ood slaves in "The Impossible Planet"/"The Satan Pit" and ''left them to die at the end of the episode''. This is the main reason they made "Planet of The Ood", to address that fact. It's even lampshaded when Donna points out how uncharacteristic it is for the Doctor to not help the Ood. The Doctor points out he was battling Satan at the time and thus a little busy. Then he admits that he owes them one.

Changed: 665

Removed: 239

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ArtisticLicence-Biology: The Ood don't look like the sort of species which would have evolved in an icy climate. Surely all that bald skin (including a delicate tangle of fronds and even an '''exposed brain''') would quickly freeze over.



* LostAesop: Donna doesn't quite know how to feel about Halpen being turned into an Ood and comments that she doesn't feel she knows right from wrong anymore. The Doctor replies, "It's better that way. People who know for certain tend to be like Mr. Halpen," which sounds a lot like AnAesop -- and in no way applies to the episode we just watched. Halpen was an [[CorruptCorporateExecutive amoral businessman who only cares about his profit]], not some kind of dogmatic KnightTemplar (whereas fighting against him ''was'' presented as a matter of plain right vs. wrong, and the Doctor and Donna certainly never seemed conflicted as to which side they should be on).

to:

* LostAesop: Donna doesn't quite know how to feel about Halpen being turned into an Ood and comments that she doesn't feel she knows right from wrong anymore. The Doctor replies, "It's better that way. People who know for certain tend to be like Mr. Halpen," which sounds a lot like AnAesop -- and in no way applies to the episode we just watched. Halpen was an [[CorruptCorporateExecutive amoral businessman who only cares about his profit]], not some kind of dogmatic KnightTemplar (whereas fighting against him ''was'' presented as a matter of plain right vs. wrong, and the Doctor and Donna certainly never seemed conflicted as to which side they should be on).----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicence-Biology: The Ood don't look like the sort of species which would have evolved in an icy climate. Surely all that bald skin (including a delicate tangle of fronds and even an '''exposed brain''') would quickly freeze over.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AccidentalAesop: In light of "Recap/DoctorWhoS9E2TheCurseOfPeladon The Curse of Peladon]]" being a pro-EU tract, the timeline here established turns this episode into a Brexit tract.

to:

* AccidentalAesop: In light of "Recap/DoctorWhoS9E2TheCurseOfPeladon "[[Recap/DoctorWhoS9E2TheCurseOfPeladon The Curse of Peladon]]" being a pro-EU tract, the timeline here established turns this episode into a Brexit tract.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AccidentalAesop: In light of ''The Curse of Peladon'' being a pro-EU tract, the timeline here established turns this episode into a Brexit tract.

to:

* AccidentalAesop: In light of ''The "Recap/DoctorWhoS9E2TheCurseOfPeladon The Curse of Peladon'' Peladon]]" being a pro-EU tract, the timeline here established turns this episode into a Brexit tract.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There's a slightly more subtle Aesop at work as well. At one point when Donna's railing against the institutionalised slavery represented by the Ood, the Doctor points out that most of the clothes she's wearing at that very moment were manufactured in sweatshops by people living only a few steps above slavery. It suggests that although people in the west intellectually know slavery is bad and wouldn't tolerate it when they're directly exposed to it, if it's out of sight and they benefit from it they're likely to not give it much thought.

to:

** There's a slightly more subtle Aesop at work as well. At one point when Donna's railing against the institutionalised slavery represented by the Ood, the Doctor points out that most of the clothes she's wearing at that very moment were manufactured in sweatshops by people living only a few steps above slavery. It suggests that although people in the west intellectually know slavery is bad and wouldn't tolerate it when they're directly exposed to it, if it's out of sight and they benefit from it they're likely to not give it much thought.thought.
* LostAesop: Donna doesn't quite know how to feel about Halpen being turned into an Ood and comments that she doesn't feel she knows right from wrong anymore. The Doctor replies, "It's better that way. People who know for certain tend to be like Mr. Halpen," which sounds a lot like AnAesop -- and in no way applies to the episode we just watched. Halpen was an [[CorruptCorporateExecutive amoral businessman who only cares about his profit]], not some kind of dogmatic KnightTemplar (whereas fighting against him ''was'' presented as a matter of plain right vs. wrong, and the Doctor and Donna certainly never seemed conflicted as to which side they should be on).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* AccidentalAesop: In light of ''The Curse of Peladon'' being a pro-EU tract, the timeline here established turns this episode into a Brexit tract.

Changed: 1

Removed: 89

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hey Its That Guy cut by TRS decision. Ditto for Hey Its That Voice.


** There's a slightly more subtle Aesop at work as well. At one point when Donna's railing against the institutionalised slavery represented by the Ood, the Doctor points out that most of the clothes she's wearing at that very moment were manufactured in sweatshops by people living only a few steps above slavery. It suggests that although people in the west intellectually know slavery is bad and wouldn't tolerate it when they're directly exposed to it, if it's out of sight and they benefit from it they're likely to not give it much thought.
* HeyItsThatGuy: [[Series/{{Blackadder}} Lord Percy/Capt. Kevin Darling]] is the CEO.
----

to:

** There's a slightly more subtle Aesop at work as well. At one point when Donna's railing against the institutionalised slavery represented by the Ood, the Doctor points out that most of the clothes she's wearing at that very moment were manufactured in sweatshops by people living only a few steps above slavery. It suggests that although people in the west intellectually know slavery is bad and wouldn't tolerate it when they're directly exposed to it, if it's out of sight and they benefit from it they're likely to not give it much thought. \n* HeyItsThatGuy: [[Series/{{Blackadder}} Lord Percy/Capt. Kevin Darling]] is the CEO.\n----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeyItsThatGuy: [[{{Blackadder}} Lord Percy/Capt. Kevin Darling]] is the CEO.

to:

* HeyItsThatGuy: [[{{Blackadder}} [[Series/{{Blackadder}} Lord Percy/Capt. Kevin Darling]] is the CEO.

Added: 208

Changed: 376

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "Slavery is a bad thing." How many of the audience didn't already know that is unclear. An alternative one, only slightly less obvious (but in some quarters probably still necessary) might be: "Even if a people doesn't look like you, and seems more primitive than you, that gives you no right to exploit them." Also, the anvilicious "slavery's bad, mmmmkay?" aesop seems to have been a deliberate attempt at amends for the FridgeHorror of the Doctor basically saying "okie dokie" when he discovered the Ood slaves in "The Impossible Planet"/"The Satan Pit" and ''left them to die at the end of the episode''. This is the main reason they made "Planet of The Ood", to address that fact. It's even lampshaded when Donna points out how uncharacteristic it is for the Doctor to not help the Ood. The Doctor points out he was battling Satan at the time.

to:

** "Slavery is a bad thing.**The " How many of the audience didn't already know that is unclear. An alternative one, only slightly less obvious (but in some quarters probably still necessary) might be: "Even if a people doesn't look like you, and seems more primitive than you, that gives you no right to exploit them." Also, the anvilicious "slavery's bad, mmmmkay?" aesop seems to have been a deliberate attempt at amends for the FridgeHorror of the Doctor basically saying "okie dokie" when he discovered the Ood slaves in "The Impossible Planet"/"The Satan Pit" and ''left them to die at the end of the episode''. This is the main reason they made "Planet of The Ood", to address that fact. It's even lampshaded when Donna points out how uncharacteristic it is for the Doctor to not help the Ood. The Doctor points out he was battling Satan at the time.time and thus a little busy. Then he admits that he owes them one.
**One only slightly less obvious (but in some quarters probably still necessary) might be: "Even if a people doesn't look like you, and seems more primitive than you, that gives you no right to exploit them."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeyItsThatGuy: [[Blackadder Lord Percy/Capt. Kevin Darling]] is the CEO.

to:

* HeyItsThatGuy: [[Blackadder [[{{Blackadder}} Lord Percy/Capt. Kevin Darling]] is the CEO.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* HeyItsThatGuy: [[Blackadder Lord Percy/Capt. Kevin Darling]] is the CEO.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

'''WARNING! THERE MAY BE UNMARKED SPOILERS!'''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving to proper recap title.

Added DiffLines:

* CaptainObviousAesop:
** "Slavery is a bad thing." How many of the audience didn't already know that is unclear. An alternative one, only slightly less obvious (but in some quarters probably still necessary) might be: "Even if a people doesn't look like you, and seems more primitive than you, that gives you no right to exploit them." Also, the anvilicious "slavery's bad, mmmmkay?" aesop seems to have been a deliberate attempt at amends for the FridgeHorror of the Doctor basically saying "okie dokie" when he discovered the Ood slaves in "The Impossible Planet"/"The Satan Pit" and ''left them to die at the end of the episode''. This is the main reason they made "Planet of The Ood", to address that fact. It's even lampshaded when Donna points out how uncharacteristic it is for the Doctor to not help the Ood. The Doctor points out he was battling Satan at the time.
** There's a slightly more subtle Aesop at work as well. At one point when Donna's railing against the institutionalised slavery represented by the Ood, the Doctor points out that most of the clothes she's wearing at that very moment were manufactured in sweatshops by people living only a few steps above slavery. It suggests that although people in the west intellectually know slavery is bad and wouldn't tolerate it when they're directly exposed to it, if it's out of sight and they benefit from it they're likely to not give it much thought.

----

Top