Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / DinosaurPlanet

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AluminumChristmasTrees: It's been claimed that the dwarf dromaeosaurs and abelisaurs of Hateg Island were completely made up. In reality, [[https://www.dinosauria.org/documents/2002/csiki_grigorescu_1998_oryctos1_87-104.pdf they were based on then-recently described theropod material from Hateg]], the raptors being based on isolated teeth and cranial fragments, and the abelisaurs on a distal femur, [[ScienceMarchesOn though the latter was reinterpreted as the distal metatarsal of a hadrosaur only two years after the show aired]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CommonKnowledge: It’s occasionally claimed that the dwarf dromaeosaurs in “Pod’s Travels” were based on ''Balaur bondoc''. Except they weren't. Firstly, ''Balaur'' was only known from its arms back in 2003 and was considered to be an ''oviraptorosaur'' of some kind. It wasn’t until 2009 that a more complete skeleton was found (though still lacking a skull) and it was named and described as a stocky, double-clawed raptor the following year [[note]] it has since been reclassified as a flightless and likely herbivorous basal bird [[/note]]. Secondly, at around 2 meters in length, ''Balaur'' would have been a pretty standard-sized dromaeosaur and about the same size as ''Pyroraptor'' (and certainly heavier), not a cat-sized dwarf. The mini-raptors were actually based on previously found and very fragmentary remains (mainly just isolated teeth) attributed to diminutive Hateg dromaeosaurs.

to:

* CommonKnowledge: It’s occasionally claimed that the dwarf dromaeosaurs in “Pod’s Travels” were based on ''Balaur bondoc''. Except they weren't. Firstly, ''Balaur'' was only known from its arms back in 2003 and was considered to be an ''oviraptorosaur'' of some kind. It wasn’t until 2009 that a more complete skeleton was found (though still lacking a skull) and it was named and described as a stocky, double-clawed raptor the following year [[note]] it has since been reclassified as a flightless and likely herbivorous basal bird [[/note]]. Secondly, at around 2 meters in length, ''Balaur'' would have been a pretty standard-sized dromaeosaur and about the same size as ''Pyroraptor'' (and certainly heavier), not a cat-sized dwarf. [[https://www.dinosauria.org/documents/2002/csiki_grigorescu_1998_oryctos1_87-104.pdf The mini-raptors were actually based on previously found and very fragmentary remains (mainly just isolated teeth) teeth and cranial fragments) attributed to diminutive Hateg dromaeosaurs.dromaeosaurs]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** There's also the cry of the ''Oviraptor'', which only adds to its ominous presence. It's actually slowed-down goose honks combined with walrus bellows.

to:

** There's also the cry of the ''Oviraptor'', which only adds to its ominous presence. It's actually slowed-down goose honks combined with walrus bellows.bellows and horse screams.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v9BYCKQViRA The score for "Little Das' Hunt"]] stands out for as the action-paced and intense of it, especially "Buck and Blaze" which could easily work in a Western film.

to:

** [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v9BYCKQViRA The score for "Little Das' Hunt"]] stands out for as the action-paced and intense of it, especially "Buck and Blaze" which could easily work in a Western film.film, which is fitting considering the episode takes place in Montana.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The ''Oviraptors''. Forget [[EvilEggEater the cowardly egg thieves]] you may know them as, these guys in [[WhiteAndRedAndEerieAllOver silvery grey/red colours]] and cacophonic goose and walrus sounds andare every bit as active, aggressive hunters as ''Velociraptor'', with one's JumpScare of it ambushing a Shuuvia from offscreen being a highlight.

to:

** The ''Oviraptors''. Forget [[EvilEggEater the cowardly egg thieves]] you may know them as, these guys in with their [[WhiteAndRedAndEerieAllOver silvery grey/red colours]] and cacophonic goose and walrus sounds andare are every bit as active, aggressive hunters as ''Velociraptor'', with one's JumpScare of it ambushing a Shuuvia from offscreen being a highlight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* FairForItsDay: To modern viewers, Pod and White Tip’s designs come across as very outdated and conservative, since discoveries made after the series showed us that dromaeosaurs were even more bird-like than previously thought, to the point that they were effectively flightless [[ToothyBird Toothy Birds]]. But for the early 2000s, back when other documentaries such as ''Series/ChasedByDinosaurs'' were still clinging on to scaly depictions of ''Velociraptor'' and kin, [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sinornithosaurus#/media/File:Dave-Geological_Museum_of_China.jpg despite evidence]] [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Sinosauropteryxfossil.jpg to the contrary]], ''Dinosaur Planet'' and its predecessor ''WesternAnimation/WhenDinosaursRoamedAmerica'' were quite revolutionary and nuanced for highlighting the avian affinities of dromaeosaurs as much as possible given the available evidence and the still relatively radical notion of feathered non-avian dinosaurs at the time, and helped introduce the concept to a much wider audience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not what that trope is for


* FairForItsDay: To modern viewers, Pod and White Tip’s designs come across as very outdated and conservative, since discoveries made after the series showed us that dromaeosaurs were even more bird-like than previously thought, to the point that they were effectively flightless [[ToothyBird Toothy Birds]]. But for the early 2000s, back when other documentaries such as ''Series/ChasedByDinosaurs'' were still clinging on to scaly depictions of ''Velociraptor'' and kin, [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sinornithosaurus#/media/File:Dave-Geological_Museum_of_China.jpg despite evidence]] [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Sinosauropteryxfossil.jpg to the contrary]], ''Dinosaur Planet'' and its predecessor ''WesternAnimation/WhenDinosaursRoamedAmerica'' were quite revolutionary and nuanced for highlighting the avian affinities of dromaeosaurs as much as possible given the available evidence and the still relatively radical notion of feathered non-avian dinosaurs at the time, and helped introduce the concept to a much wider audience.

to:

* %%* FairForItsDay: To modern viewers, Pod and White Tip’s designs come across as very outdated and conservative, since discoveries made after the series showed us that dromaeosaurs were even more bird-like than previously thought, to the point that they were effectively flightless [[ToothyBird Toothy Birds]]. But for the early 2000s, back when other documentaries such as ''Series/ChasedByDinosaurs'' were still clinging on to scaly depictions of ''Velociraptor'' and kin, [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sinornithosaurus#/media/File:Dave-Geological_Museum_of_China.jpg despite evidence]] [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Sinosauropteryxfossil.jpg to the contrary]], ''Dinosaur Planet'' and its predecessor ''WesternAnimation/WhenDinosaursRoamedAmerica'' were quite revolutionary and nuanced for highlighting the avian affinities of dromaeosaurs as much as possible given the available evidence and the still relatively radical notion of feathered non-avian dinosaurs at the time, and helped introduce the concept to a much wider audience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Critical Research Failure is a disambiguation page


* CommonKnowledge: It’s occasionally claimed that the dwarf dromaeosaurs in “Pod’s Travels” were based on ''Balaur bondoc''. [[CriticalResearchFailure Except they weren't]]. Firstly, ''Balaur'' was only known from its arms back in 2003 and was considered to be an ''oviraptorosaur'' of some kind. It wasn’t until 2009 that a more complete skeleton was found (though still lacking a skull) and it was named and described as a stocky, double-clawed raptor the following year [[note]] it has since been reclassified as a flightless and likely herbivorous basal bird [[/note]]. Secondly, at around 2 meters in length, ''Balaur'' would have been a pretty standard-sized dromaeosaur and about the same size as ''Pyroraptor'' (and certainly heavier), not a cat-sized dwarf. The mini-raptors were actually based on previously found and very fragmentary remains (mainly just isolated teeth) attributed to diminutive Hateg dromaeosaurs.

to:

* CommonKnowledge: It’s occasionally claimed that the dwarf dromaeosaurs in “Pod’s Travels” were based on ''Balaur bondoc''. [[CriticalResearchFailure Except they weren't]].weren't. Firstly, ''Balaur'' was only known from its arms back in 2003 and was considered to be an ''oviraptorosaur'' of some kind. It wasn’t until 2009 that a more complete skeleton was found (though still lacking a skull) and it was named and described as a stocky, double-clawed raptor the following year [[note]] it has since been reclassified as a flightless and likely herbivorous basal bird [[/note]]. Secondly, at around 2 meters in length, ''Balaur'' would have been a pretty standard-sized dromaeosaur and about the same size as ''Pyroraptor'' (and certainly heavier), not a cat-sized dwarf. The mini-raptors were actually based on previously found and very fragmentary remains (mainly just isolated teeth) attributed to diminutive Hateg dromaeosaurs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not YMMV


* FollowTheLeader: One of a number of dinosaur documentary series made after ''Series/WalkingWithDinosaurs''' meteoric success. It takes its own deviations, however, like its focus on narrative over science.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodCharacter: The ''Deltatheridium'' in “White Tip’s Journey”. Deltatheridiids were predators and ''Deltatheridium'' might have attacked small dinosaurs, as workers found its toothmarks on the jaw bones of a small troodontid called ''Archaeornithoides'', [[https://i.redd.it/m88s31rhul031.png which was still larger than the mammal]], suggesting ''Deltatheridium'' might have been a PintSizedPowerhouse akin to extant mustelids. With White Tip being a mother, it could have been an antagonist trying to eat her young, but instead, it’s relegated to a generic Cretaceous mammal who is only there to briefly distract White Tip while Broken Arm attacks her brood.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v9BYCKQViRA The score for "Little Das' Hunt"]] stans out for as the action-paced and intense of it, which could easily work in a Western film.

to:

** [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v9BYCKQViRA The score for "Little Das' Hunt"]] stans stands out for as the action-paced and intense of it, especially "Buck and Blaze" which could easily work in a Western film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The ''Oviraptors''. Forget [[EvilEggEater the cowardly egg thieves]] you may know them as, these guys are every bit as active, aggressive hunters as ''Velociraptor'', with one's JumpScare of it ambushing a Shuuvia from offscreen being a highlight. Making thing worse is that 1) they're even bigger then the velociraptors, and 2) their cacophonic goose and walrus sounds, and 3) [[WhiteAndRedAndEerieAllOver silvery grey/red colours]].

to:

** The ''Oviraptors''. Forget [[EvilEggEater the cowardly egg thieves]] you may know them as, these guys are in [[WhiteAndRedAndEerieAllOver silvery grey/red colours]] and cacophonic goose and walrus sounds andare every bit as active, aggressive hunters hunters as ''Velociraptor'', with one's JumpScare of it ambushing a Shuuvia from offscreen being a highlight. Making thing worse is that 1) they're even bigger then the velociraptors, and 2) their cacophonic goose and walrus sounds, and 3) [[WhiteAndRedAndEerieAllOver silvery grey/red colours]].highlight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v9BYCKQViRA The score for "Little Das' Hunt"]] stans out for as the action-paced and intense of it, which could easily work in a Western film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HilariousInHindsight: [[Series/PrehistoricPlanet As it turns out, this wouldn't be the last paleo-doc to both use a "Planet" suffix and focus exclusively on life in the Late Cretaceous]].

Top