Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / Cryptonomicon

Go To

OR

Added: 707

Changed: 86

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JustHereForGodzilla: The scenes where Shaftoe and Root encounter submariner Bischoff and the Pacific theater WarIsHell odyssey of Goto Dengo are beloved sequences that some readers will skip past other scenes to get to.



* OneSceneWonder: Two scenes, specifically; UsefulNotes/DouglasMacArthur, an unflappable DeadpanSnarker.

to:

* OneSceneWonder: Two OneSceneWonder:
** With just two
scenes, specifically; UsefulNotes/DouglasMacArthur, an unflappable DeadpanSnarker.DeadpanSnarker and ReasonableAuthorityFigure, absolutely steals the show.
** Several of Goto's supporting characters (such as the unnamed soldiers from Okinawa and Tokyo who brave OceanMadness with him after a shipwreck and Filipino slave laborer and ShootTheBuilder scenario survivor Bong) only appear in one chapter apiece but make much bigger impressions than many secondary characters in the {{Doorstopper}} book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StrawmanHasAPoint: G.E.B. Kivistik is basically a gag character, but once he's actually challenged on his statements, he stops being pretentious and points out that Internet access is a privilege not easily given to, say, the poor, and the advantages it can confer can leave large groups of society behind rapidly while granting enormous advantages to others, which depending on who you ask, has pretty much been what's happened in the ten years since the book was released. Even Stephenson, who is probably trying to load the deck, refers to Randy's defense as "an uncontrollable urge to be a prick."

to:

* StrawmanHasAPoint: G.E.B. Kivistik is basically a gag character, but once he's actually challenged on his statements, he stops being a stereotypical pretentious left-wing intellectual and points out that Internet access is a privilege not easily given to, say, the poor, and the advantages it can confer can leave large groups of society behind rapidly while granting enormous advantages to others, which depending others. Depending on who you ask, that has pretty much been what's happened in the ten years since the book was released. released in 1999. Even Stephenson, who is probably trying to load the deck, refers to Randy's defense as says Randy later thought his retort was motivated by "an uncontrollable urge to be a prick."prick".



** Randy argues that he is not privileged because he had to work hard through college and read books for self-training. He doesn't seem to consider how both of those are privileges.

to:

** Randy argues that he is not privileged because he had to work hard through college and read books for self-training. He doesn't seem to consider how both of those are privileges.privileges (by comparison to the developing people under discussion).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TakeThat: G.E.B.'s Kivisticks existance was clearly intended as a reference to the post-modernist side of the [[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_wars science wars]].

to:

* TakeThat: G.E.B.'s Kivisticks existance was clearly intended as a reference to the post-modernist side of the [[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_wars science wars]].

Changed: 62

Removed: 62

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TakeThat: G.E.B.'s Kivisticks existance was clearly intended as a reference to the post-modernist side of the then current
[[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_wars science wars]].

to:

* TakeThat: G.E.B.'s Kivisticks existance was clearly intended as a reference to the post-modernist side of the then current
[[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_wars science wars]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Ironically bundled in with the changes with accidental validity is an undermining of the privilege and left behind criticisms as availability of technology increases to the point where much of what was once the third world becomes an outsourcing destination. Demonstrating the true complexity often missed by attempting to predict the future.
* TakeThat: G.E.B.'s Kivisticks existance was clearly intended as a reference to the post-modernist side of the then current
[[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_wars science wars]].

Added: 182

Changed: 83

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* NightmareFuel: [[spoiler:Goto's escape from Golgotha. Swimming up a mine shaft, with occasional stops for air, with no light whatsoever, in the dark. One of them doesn't make it.]]



** Randy argues that he is not privileged because he had to work hard through college. He doesn't seem to consider the fact that getting to go to college is itself a privilege.

to:

** Randy argues that he is not privileged because he had to work hard through college. college and read books for self-training. He doesn't seem to consider the fact that getting to go to college is itself a privilege.how both of those are privileges.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StrawmanHasAPoint: G.E.B. Kivistik is basically a gag character, but once he's actually challenged on his statements, he stops being pretentious and points out that Internet access is a privilege not easily given to, say, the poor, and the advantages it can confer can leave large groups of society behind rapidly while granting enormous advantages to others, which depending on who you ask, has pretty much been what's happened in the ten years since the book was released. Even Stephenson, who is trying to load the deck, refers to Randy's defense as "an uncontrollable urge to be a prick."

to:

* StrawmanHasAPoint: G.E.B. Kivistik is basically a gag character, but once he's actually challenged on his statements, he stops being pretentious and points out that Internet access is a privilege not easily given to, say, the poor, and the advantages it can confer can leave large groups of society behind rapidly while granting enormous advantages to others, which depending on who you ask, has pretty much been what's happened in the ten years since the book was released. Even Stephenson, who is probably trying to load the deck, refers to Randy's defense as "an uncontrollable urge to be a prick."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MissingStepsPlan: Avi wants to create a secure Internet where even oppressed people are able to freely move money and information. Step one is to create an offshore data haven and cryptocurrency; the first adopters are at best extremely sketchy individuals and at worst are outright drug smugglers, organized crime figures and terrorist groups. "Geek with a scale" analogies aside, it's very unclear how Avi thinks he's going to get this system any sort of mainstream legitimacy after it's associated with this sort of activity, or how he'll avoid criminal liability for knowingly helping criminals launder money.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigLippedAlligatorMoment -- Big Lipped Alligator ''Erotic Short Story''.

to:

* BigLippedAlligatorMoment -- BigLippedAlligatorMoment: Big Lipped Alligator ''Erotic Short Story''.



* HoYay -- Alan Turing and Rudy. Or as Rudy put it, Alan would soon have an umlaut in him. Alan also propositioned Waterhouse, but was turned down politely.

to:

* HoYay -- HoYay: Alan Turing and Rudy. Or as Rudy put it, Alan would soon have an umlaut in him. Alan also propositioned Waterhouse, but was turned down politely.



* SciFiGhetto — The prologue to the Spanish translation makes it clear that "science fiction" also includes "fiction about science" (i.e. cryptography and information theory). The mass market paperback edition lists the book as "fiction" instead of "science fiction." Bookstores aren't convinced, however, and stock it in the "Science Fiction" section.

to:

* SciFiGhetto — SciFiGhetto: The prologue to the Spanish translation makes it clear that "science fiction" also includes "fiction about science" (i.e. cryptography and information theory). The mass market paperback edition lists the book as "fiction" instead of "science fiction." Bookstores aren't convinced, however, and stock it in the "Science Fiction" section.



* TearJerker -- [[spoiler:Bobby Shaftoe]]'s death.

to:

* TearJerker -- TearJerker: [[spoiler:Bobby Shaftoe]]'s death.



* TheWoobie -- Goto Dengo goes through arguably the worst the book can dish out. It helps that, unlike every other Japanese officer and soldier we meet in the book, he's not evil or holding the IdiotBall.

to:

* TheWoobie -- TheWoobie: Goto Dengo goes through arguably the worst the book can dish out. It helps that, unlike every other Japanese officer and soldier we meet in the book, he's not evil or holding the IdiotBall.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Randy argues that he is not privileged because he had to work hard through college. He doesn't seem to consider the fact that getting to go to college is itself a privilege.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OneSceneWonder: Two scenes, specifically; DouglasMacArthur, an unflappable DeadpanSnarker.

to:

* OneSceneWonder: Two scenes, specifically; DouglasMacArthur, UsefulNotes/DouglasMacArthur, an unflappable DeadpanSnarker.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Randy doesn't really refute Kivistik's point either; he simply argues that his analogy is invalid because a network is not physically the same as a highway. Kivistik's 'ad hominem' attack, while smug, was in service of pointing out that Randy has lived all his life in a situation where advanced technology has always been available and can't really comprehend that the situation is different for others who have not had his advantages.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OneSceneWonder: Two scenes, specifically; DouglasMacArthur, an unflappable DeadpanSnarker.

Changed: 666

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Kivistik said that being able to understand technical books is a privilege conferred on members of an "elite class" of technocrats. Randy pointed out that he went to a public school, a state college, and was self-trained; hardly out of reach of your average American. At no point did he ever clarify his original metaphor, and only called Randy a "technocrat" by way of ad hominem. He only described what a technocrat even was ''after'' Randy said how he gained his knowledge. By his own definition, being poor has ''nothing'' to do with whether one can understand a technical manual. People learn a lot of that stuff by going down to the ''library''.

to:

** Kivistik said that being able to understand technical books is a privilege conferred on members of an "elite class" of technocrats. Randy pointed out that Except for the part where he went to a public school, a state college, and was self-trained; hardly out of reach of your average American. At no point did he ever clarify his original never actually explained himself, when challenged just used another metaphor, and only called Randy a "technocrat" by way of ad hominem. He only described what a technocrat even was ''after'' Randy said how then began trying to AdHominem Randy's arguments when he gained his knowledge. By his own definition, being poor has ''nothing'' to do with whether one can understand a technical manual. People learn a lot of that stuff by going down to the ''library''.spoke up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Kivistik said that being able to understand technical books is a privilege conferred on members of an "elite class" of technocrats. Randy pointed out that he went to a public school, a state college, and was self-trained; hardly out of reach of your average American. At no point did he ever clarify his original metaphor, and only called Randy a "technocrat" by way of ad hominem. He only described what a technocrat even was ''after'' Randy said how he gained his knowledge. By his own definition, being poor has ''nothing'' to do with whether one can understand a technical manual. People learn a lot of that stuff by going down to the ''library''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
These aren\'t YMMV. Moving.


* AuthorTract: To almost Ayn Randian levels in some places, but most notable when Enoch Root becomes his mouthpiece.



* YellowPeril -- Granted that Stephenson is fully backed up by the research in terms of the behavior of Japanese soldiers during World War II, but it is somewhat awkward to realize that Goto Dengo is the only Japanese character during the World War II sections of the book who is not, at best, holding the IdiotBall and is not, at worst, an incredibly vile human being. Implying that their culture made them that way, while arguably somewhat true, [[UnfortunateImplications really doesn't help matters.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheWoobie -- Goto Dengo goes through arguably the worst the book can dish out. It helps that, unlike every other Japanese officer and soldier we meet in the book, he's not a CompleteMonster or holding the IdiotBall.

to:

* TheWoobie -- Goto Dengo goes through arguably the worst the book can dish out. It helps that, unlike every other Japanese officer and soldier we meet in the book, he's not a CompleteMonster evil or holding the IdiotBall.

Added: 429

Changed: 81

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HoYay -- Alan Turing and Rudy. Or as Rudy put it, Alan would soon have an umlaut in him. Alan also propositioned Waterhouse, but was turned down politely.
** Rudy and [[spoiler:Bischoff]], later in the book.



* TearJerker -- [[{{Taelor}} ThisTroper]] dares you to read the scene where [[spoiler:Bobby Shaftoe]] dies and not tear up.

to:

* TearJerker -- [[{{Taelor}} ThisTroper]] dares you to read the scene where [[spoiler:Bobby Shaftoe]] dies and not tear up.Shaftoe]]'s death.



* YellowPeril -- Granted that Stephenson is fully backed up by the research in terms of the behavior of Japanese soldiers during World War II, but it is somewhat awkward to realize that Goto Dengo is the only Japanese character during the World War II sections of the book who is not, at best, holding the IdiotBall and is not, at worst, an incredibly vile human being. Implying that their culture made them that way, while arguably somewhat true, [[UnfortunateImplications really doesn't help matters.]]

to:

* YellowPeril -- Granted that Stephenson is fully backed up by the research in terms of the behavior of Japanese soldiers during World War II, but it is somewhat awkward to realize that Goto Dengo is the only Japanese character during the World War II sections of the book who is not, at best, holding the IdiotBall and is not, at worst, an incredibly vile human being. Implying that their culture made them that way, while arguably somewhat true, [[UnfortunateImplications really doesn't help matters.]]]]
* TheWoobie -- Goto Dengo goes through arguably the worst the book can dish out. It helps that, unlike every other Japanese officer and soldier we meet in the book, he's not a CompleteMonster or holding the IdiotBall.
----

Added: 595

Changed: 246

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AuthorTract: To almost Ayn Randian levels in some places.

to:

* AuthorTract: To almost Ayn Randian levels in some places.places, but most notable when Enoch Root becomes his mouthpiece.



* StrawmanHasAPoint: G.E.B. Kivistik is basically a gag character, but once he's actually challenged on his statements, he stops being pretentious and points out that Internet access is a privilege not easily given to, say, the poor, and the advantages it can confer can leave large groups of society behind rapidly while granting enormous advantages to others, which depending on who you ask, has pretty much been what's happened in the ten years since the book was released. Even Stephenson, who is trying to load the deck, refers to Randy's defense as "an uncontrollable urge to be a prick."



* YellowPeril -- Granted that Stephenson is fully backed up by the research in terms of the behavior of Japanese soldiers during World War II, but it is somewhat awkward to realize that Goto Dengo is the only Japanese character during the World War II sections of the book who is not, at best, holding the IdiotBall.

to:

* YellowPeril -- Granted that Stephenson is fully backed up by the research in terms of the behavior of Japanese soldiers during World War II, but it is somewhat awkward to realize that Goto Dengo is the only Japanese character during the World War II sections of the book who is not, at best, holding the IdiotBall.IdiotBall and is not, at worst, an incredibly vile human being. Implying that their culture made them that way, while arguably somewhat true, [[UnfortunateImplications really doesn't help matters.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Cantrell's explanation of his feelings towards guns arguably counts.

to:

** Cantrell's explanation of his feelings towards guns arguably counts.counts.
* YellowPeril -- Granted that Stephenson is fully backed up by the research in terms of the behavior of Japanese soldiers during World War II, but it is somewhat awkward to realize that Goto Dengo is the only Japanese character during the World War II sections of the book who is not, at best, holding the IdiotBall.

Added: 665

Changed: 169

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AuthorTract: To almost Ayn Randian levels in some places.



** Also the fact that the book occasionally stops to preach about how masturbation ruins any chance at true happiness and love. Avi never masturbates, Lawrence discovers masturbation is meaningless after he's fallen in love, and Randy doesn't wind up finding true love until he's forcibly kept from masturbating for a few months. It makes you wonder if it's just a lengthy gag or an AuthorTract on the subject.



* TearJerker -- [[{{Taelor}} ThisTroper]] dares you to read the scene where [[spoiler:Bobby Shaftoe]] dies and not tear up.

to:

** What's funny is that this forces them to stock the entire Baroque Cycle in the SF section, leading to considerable confusion.
* TearJerker -- [[{{Taelor}} ThisTroper]] dares you to read the scene where [[spoiler:Bobby Shaftoe]] dies and not tear up.up.
** Cantrell's explanation of his feelings towards guns arguably counts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SciFiGhetto — The prologue to the Spanish translation makes it clear that "science fiction" also includes "fiction about science" (i.e. cryptography and information theory). The mass market paperback edition lists the book as "fiction" instead of "science fiction." Bookstores aren't fooled, however, and stock it in the "Science Fiction" section.

to:

* SciFiGhetto — The prologue to the Spanish translation makes it clear that "science fiction" also includes "fiction about science" (i.e. cryptography and information theory). The mass market paperback edition lists the book as "fiction" instead of "science fiction." Bookstores aren't fooled, convinced, however, and stock it in the "Science Fiction" section.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SciFiGhetto — The prologue to the Spanish translation makes it clear that "science fiction" also includes "fiction about science" (i.e. cryptography and information theory). The mass market paperback edition lists the book as "fiction" instead of "science fiction." Bookstores aren't fooled, however, and stock it in the "Science Fiction" section.

Top