Follow TV Tropes

Following

History YMMV / BeautyandtheBeast

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The initial idea behind the story wast to get girls used to the idea of ArrangedMarriage. This meaning has mostly been lost and arranged marriages generally aren't agreed with these days.

to:

** The initial idea behind the story wast was to get girls used to the idea of ArrangedMarriage. This meaning has mostly been lost and arranged marriages generally aren't agreed with these days.

Added: 970

Changed: 1203

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FandomRivalry: Belle vs [[WesternAnimation/TheLittleMermaid1989 Ariel]] given that they are the first two 'modern' Disney Princesses. Arguments would frequently hold Belle up as a better attempt at a feminist princess than Ariel. But as time has gone on, arguments have gone the other way - criticizing Belle for seeming unrealistically perfect and not really growing or changing throughout the film, and Ariel's fans saying that she's flawed but still a good character who is more initiative-based. If an argument about whether Ariel is feminist or not starts, expect her to be compared to Belle in some way.
** It's worth pointing out that Paige O'Hara wrote the foreword for Jodi Benson's memoir, so this does not extend to the creators even in the slightest.

to:

* FandomRivalry: FandomRivalry:
**
Belle vs [[WesternAnimation/TheLittleMermaid1989 Ariel]] given that they are the first two 'modern' Disney Princesses. Arguments would frequently hold Belle up as a better attempt at a feminist princess than Ariel. But as time has gone on, arguments have gone the other way - criticizing Belle for seeming unrealistically perfect and not really growing or changing throughout the film, and Ariel's fans saying that she's flawed but still a good character who is more initiative-based. If an argument about whether Ariel is feminist or not starts, expect her to be compared to Belle in some way.
** *** It's worth pointing out that Paige O'Hara wrote the foreword for Jodi Benson's memoir, so this does not extend to the creators even in the slightest.slightest.
** Sometime overlaps with FriendlyFandoms, fans of [[Film/BeautyAndTheBeast1946 Cocteau's 1946 movie]] and [[WesternAnimation/BeautyAndTheBeast Disney's take]] can have heated debate each other over which version is better. As mentioned below, Cocteau fans prefer this movie for its poeticism and greater influence in cinematic history (as mentioned below) and sees the Disney version as being [[AnimationAgeGhetto too commercial]] and [[SweetnessAversion saccharine]]. Disney fans, on the other hand, while some respects the older version for what its merits, thought the Cocteau version to be worn-out, boring, and pretentious. This rivalry could be (half-jokingly) summed up in this bit of skit in WebVideo/BrowsHeldHigh's [[https://youtu.be/5XdGK2lHye4?feature=shared&t=618 three-part review of Cocteau's movie]].

Added: 455

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The initial idea behind the story wast to get girls used to the idea of ArrangedMarriage. This meaning has mostly been lost and arranged marriages generally aren't agreed with these days.



** In the original de Villeneuve version, Beauty's father uses some of the gold that Beast have him to buy slaves. Which is portrayed as a good thing because it makes the family's lives easier.

to:

** In the original de Villeneuve version, Beauty's father uses some of the gold that Beast have gave him to buy slaves. Which is portrayed as a good thing because it makes the family's lives easier.easier.
** In the de Villeneuve version, the Queen initially won't let Beast marry Beauty due to her low class status but happily relents when she finds out that they're cousins. These days people are less likely to care about status and be more grossed out by the incest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In the original de Villeneuve version, Beauty's father uses some of the gold that Beast have him to buy slaves. Which is portrayed as a good thing because it makes the family's lives easier.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HesJustHiding: There are still a great many people (even his ''voice actor'', of all people) who believe that Gaston could still be alive, even after WordOfGod confirmed (well, mostly confirmed, at least, [[WordOfSaintPaul since his voice actor begs to differ]]) that he did, in fact, perish.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** "And every last inch of me's covered in hair!"

to:

** "And every last inch of me's covered in hair!"hair!" Given Gaston's sly wink to the camera, it's questionable if it's even accidental...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DracoInLeatherPants: Gaston has a large fanbase who are willing to overlook the fact that he is a sexist, arrogant, jealous and eventually murderous man who intends to force Belle into a loveless marriage, with his ''second'' scene in the film having him set up a ''wedding ceremony'' outside Belle's house and pressuring Belle into accepting his proposal. Some of his fans even think Belle is either crazy for rejecting him, or a stupid bitch who didn't deserve him anyway. Also many say that Gaston is a saint compared to the Beast (who in turn gets the RonTheDeathEater treatment), even overlooking the whole 'forcing Belle's father to be committed to an insane asylum to blackmail Belle into marrying him' plot.

to:

* DracoInLeatherPants: Gaston has a large fanbase who are willing to overlook the fact that he is a sexist, arrogant, jealous and eventually murderous man who intends to force Belle into a loveless marriage, with his ''second'' scene in the film having him set up a ''wedding ceremony'' outside Belle's house and pressuring Belle into accepting his proposal.proposal, and then getting angry and sulking when she (unwittingly) publically humiliates him. Some of his fans even think Belle is either crazy for rejecting him, or a stupid bitch who didn't deserve him anyway. Also many say that Gaston is a saint compared to the Beast (who in turn gets the RonTheDeathEater treatment), even overlooking the whole 'forcing Belle's father to be committed to an insane asylum to blackmail Belle into marrying him' plot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The film was nominated for an UsefulNotes/AcademyAward for Best Picture, but ultimately lost.[[note]]It didn't help that many critics and fans claimed it deserved a nomination... until it actually was nominated. Then came hundreds of jokes about how embarrassing it would be if "real" movies lost the award to a [[AnimationAgeGhetto cartoon]].[[/note]] Not that terrible, considering it lost to ''Literature/TheSilenceOfTheLambs'', another acclaimed movie of a genre usually underappreciated by the Academy (not to mention "Lambs" has a similar "Beauty and the Beast" theme).

to:

** The film was nominated for an UsefulNotes/AcademyAward MediaNotes/AcademyAward for Best Picture, but ultimately lost.[[note]]It didn't help that many critics and fans claimed it deserved a nomination... until it actually was nominated. Then came hundreds of jokes about how embarrassing it would be if "real" movies lost the award to a [[AnimationAgeGhetto cartoon]].[[/note]] Not that terrible, considering it lost to ''Literature/TheSilenceOfTheLambs'', another acclaimed movie of a genre usually underappreciated by the Academy (not to mention "Lambs" has a similar "Beauty and the Beast" theme).



* TestosteroneBrigade: While most fans of ''[=BatB=]'' are Disney and/or princess/fairytale fans in general, [[TestosteronePoisoning Gaston]] [[MemeticMutation and his]] VillainSong have been known to attract male non-fans of the genre. To a lesser extent, some of these fans are drawn in by Belle[[note]]who they view as a MsFanservice, along with the more conventionally-sexy Bimbettes and the Feather-duster maid[[/note]] and/or Beast[[note]]who is a badass character in his own right[[/note]]; in the latter case, a boy-oriented tie-in game called ''Roar of the Beast'' was released in TheNineties, which downplayed Belle's presence and the whole Franchise/DisneyPrincess aspect and [[https://gamefabrique.com/images/posters/medium/beauty-and-the-beast-roar-of-the-beast.jpg was advertised in a bizarrely "edgy" manner]].

to:

* TestosteroneBrigade: While most fans of ''[=BatB=]'' are Disney and/or princess/fairytale fans in general, [[TestosteronePoisoning Gaston]] [[MemeticMutation and his]] VillainSong have been known to attract male non-fans of the genre. To a lesser extent, some of these fans are drawn in by Belle[[note]]who they view as a MsFanservice, along with the more conventionally-sexy Bimbettes and the Feather-duster maid[[/note]] and/or Beast[[note]]who is a badass character in his own right[[/note]]; in the latter case, a boy-oriented tie-in game called ''Roar of the Beast'' was released in TheNineties, The90s, which downplayed Belle's presence and the whole Franchise/DisneyPrincess aspect and [[https://gamefabrique.com/images/posters/medium/beauty-and-the-beast-roar-of-the-beast.jpg was advertised in a bizarrely "edgy" manner]].

Top