Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WesternAnimation / TheReturnOfTheKing

Go To

OR

Added: 677

Changed: 133

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalNiceGuy: While the Mouth of Sauron is still definitely one of the villains, he doesn't taunt Aragorn over Frodo's supposed capture/death here.

to:

* AdaptationalNiceGuy: AdaptationalNiceGuy:
** Downplayed with the Whipper Orc. Unlike the book, where he forces Frodo and Sam to march in the first three files, after mistaking them for orc deserters lest he report them, he simply orders the pair to get in line.
**
While the Mouth of Sauron is still definitely one of the villains, he doesn't taunt Aragorn over Frodo's supposed capture/death here.


Added DiffLines:

* SkewedPriorities: Invoked by Sam when Frodo expresses relief at being mistaken for orcs. From Sam's perspective, the two of them will be marching back to Cirith Ungol, undoing their journey. To Frodo, it's better to be mistaken for orcs trying to desert than being caught for the hobbits they are and killed on the spot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FunnyBackgroundMoment: During the Breaking of the Gate of Minas Tirith, one of the orc drummers is shown with a joyous expression, as if his life's purpose were being fulfilled.

to:

* FunnyBackgroundMoment: FunnyBackgroundEvent: During the Breaking of the Gate of Minas Tirith, Gate, one of the orc drummers is shown with a huge, joyous expression, smile, as if his life's purpose were being fulfilled.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FunnyBackgroundMoment: During the Breaking of the Gate of Minas Tirith, one of the orc drummers is shown with a joyous expression, as if his life's purpose were being fulfilled.

Added: 202

Changed: 130

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FlamingSword: During Sam's ImagineSpot while the One Ring is [[TheFinalTemptation tempting him]], he envisions himself wielding a burning sword.

to:

* FlamingSword: FlamingSword:
** The Witch-King enflames his sword when facing off against Gandalf.
**
During Sam's ImagineSpot while the One Ring is [[TheFinalTemptation tempting him]], he envisions himself wielding a burning sword.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StockSoundEffects: The Witch-King's ride oddly makes random cries of various monsters from ''{{Series/Ultraman}}''.

to:

* StockSoundEffects: The Witch-King's ride oddly makes random cries of various monsters from ''{{Series/Ultraman}}''. (Rankin-Bass had worked with Ultraman's producers, Creator/TsuburayaProductions, on some live-action projects in the 1970s, which may explain how they were used here.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigOlEyebrows: Sam has a pair of these, as well as Gandalf whose unibrow had already been seen in ''The Hobbit''.

to:

* BigOlEyebrows: Sam has a pair of these, these (they're mainly what differentiates him from Merry), as well as Gandalf whose unibrow had already been seen in ''The Hobbit''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnimatedAdaptation: Of the last part of ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings''. It has its own interesting history as it's technically the sequel of the [[WesternAnimation/TheLordOfTheRings Ralph Bakshi's work, which covered the previous two books]] before several issues led to that production being left unfinished and [[Creator/RankinBassProductions Rankin-Bass]] completed the adaptation of the last book.p, even though it differs from the previous movie in both tone and art style.

to:

* AnimatedAdaptation: Of the last part of ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings''. It has its own interesting history as it's technically the sequel of the [[WesternAnimation/TheLordOfTheRings Ralph Bakshi's work, which covered the previous two books]] before several issues led to that production being left unfinished and [[Creator/RankinBassProductions Rankin-Bass]] completed the adaptation of the last book.p, book, even though it differs from the previous movie in both tone and art style.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Gonk}}: Pippin has an unusual character design completely different from any other hobbit. He looks sort of like Franchise/LupinIII if Lupin looked more like a monkey than he already does.

to:

* {{Gonk}}: Pippin has an unusual character design completely different from any other hobbit. He He's the tallest of the hobbits, and he looks sort of like Franchise/LupinIII if Lupin looked even more like a monkey than he already does.

Added: 192

Changed: 28

Removed: 49

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Gonk}}: Pippin has an unusual character design completely different from any other hobbit. He looks sort of like Franchise/LupinIII if Lupin looked more like a monkey than he already does.



-->'''Minstrel:''' ''Why does he have nine fingers?''
-->'''Minstrel:''' ''Where is the ring of doom?''

to:

-->'''Minstrel:''' ''Why does he have nine fingers?''
-->'''Minstrel:''' ''Where
fingers? Where is the ring of doom?''



-->''Just a garden and seed, and the love to pursue it."''

to:

-->''Just a garden and seed, and the love to pursue it."''''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AnimatedAdaptation: Of the last part of ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings''. It has its own interesting history as it's technically the sequel of the [[WesternAnimation/TheLordOfTheRings Ralph Bakshi's work, which covered the previous two books]] before several issues led to that production being left unfinished and [[Creator/RankinBassProductions Rankin-Bass]] complete the adaptation of the last book. Even though it differs from the previous movie in both tone and art style.

to:

* AnimatedAdaptation: Of the last part of ''Literature/TheLordOfTheRings''. It has its own interesting history as it's technically the sequel of the [[WesternAnimation/TheLordOfTheRings Ralph Bakshi's work, which covered the previous two books]] before several issues led to that production being left unfinished and [[Creator/RankinBassProductions Rankin-Bass]] complete completed the adaptation of the last book. Even book.p, even though it differs from the previous movie in both tone and art style.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The reason why the Mouth of Sauron show up is left unexplained in the film due to the scene being truncated to him appearing them being sent off. In the book he's acting on Sauron's orders,taunting them with the knowledge they have one of the hobbits in captivity and purposing extreme terms of surrender that are rejected.

to:

** The reason why the Mouth of Sauron show up is left unexplained in the film due to the scene being truncated to him appearing them being sent off. In the book he's acting on Sauron's orders,taunting orders, taunting them with the knowledge they have one of the hobbits in captivity and purposing extreme terms of surrender that are rejected.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BigOlEyebrows: Sam has a pair of these, as well as Gandalf whose unibrow had already been seen in ''The Hobbit''.


Added DiffLines:

* FramingDevice: In Rivendell, Frodo and Gandalf have commissioned the Troubador of Gondor to sing the ballad of "Frodo of the Nine Fingers and the Ring of Doom" to Bilbo and Elrond.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FatAndSkinny: The four hobbits form two such pairs -- Sam is fat and Frodo is skinny, and Merry is fat and Pippin is skinny.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
crosswicking

Added DiffLines:

* WhipOfDominance: As Frodo and Sam make their way across Mordor, they encounter an army of SlaveMooks Orcs singing a marching song "[[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YdXQJS3Yv0Y Where There's a Whip, There's a Way]]" [[note]]Which is based on a similar quote from the source material "Where there's a whip, there's a will"[[/note]]. The lyrics have the orcs lamenting that they don't want to march off to battle but their commander's whip, which cracks at the end of each line, [[ForcedIntoEvil compels them forward]]. At one point they even refer to themselves as the slaves of the Dark Lord. While the song is very goofy, it serves to illustrate the oppressive hierarchy of orc society.
-->We don't want to go to war today,\\
But the Lord of the Lash says, "Nay, nay, nay"!\\
We're gonna march all day, all day, all day!\\
For where there's a whip, there's a way!

Added: 611

Changed: 404

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalJerkass: As mention in the YMMV page, Aragorn is more rude in this version of events.

to:

* AdaptationalDumbass: After the Ring is destroyed and Sauron's forces break their assault at the Black Gate, Aragorn asks Gandalf what happened, as if he does not know about Frodo's quest to destroy the ring.
* AdaptationalJerkass: As mention in the YMMV page, Aragorn is more rude in displays none of the wisdom of his book counterpart. After winning the battle for Pelennor Fields, he declares to take the war to Sauron, intending to try to defeat him by force of arms, despite Gandalf's protests. The Aragorn from the books was fully aware this version of events.was folly and only did so to buy Frodo time to destroy the Ring.



* AdaptationalWimp: Denethor appears as a decrepit and crazed old man. In the books, he was described as a wise lord, who appeared almost as wizardly as Gandalf and only went mad after enduring too much pressure. In this film, only his downfall is seen.



* LighterAndSofter: In comparison with the book and the previous adaptation of The Lord of the Rings done by Ralph Bakshi.

to:

* LighterAndSofter: In comparison with the book and the previous adaptation of The Lord of the Rings done by Ralph Bakshi. The cruelty of the orcs, for example, has been toned down significantly and whenever characters, even orcs, die, it is never another character who kills them. They almost always die by falling.

Added: 83

Changed: 2

Removed: 83

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
alphabetical order


* ATasteOfTheLash: The orcs ''sing a song'' about how much they hate being whipped.



* ATasteOfTheLash: The orcs ''sing a song'' about how much they hate being whipped.



* TheXOfY: Twice over, just like the book; ''The '''Lord''' of '''the Rings,''' '' and ''The '''Return''' of '''the King.'''''

to:

* TheXOfY: Twice over, just like the book; book: ''The '''Lord''' of '''the Rings,''' '' and ''The '''Return''' of '''the King.'''''
Tabs MOD

Removed: 205

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
No Pronunciation Guide is now a disambig. Dewicking


* NoPronunciationGuide: Subverted. There IS a pronunciation guide, as in, a literal guide to the pronunciations, in the back of the book, but that didn't stop the movie from getting several of them wrong.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptedOut: Due to large portions of [[Literature/TheLordOfTheRings The Two Towers]] being skipped over, Shelob does not appear despite being hinted at by Gollum at the end of Ralph Bakshi's ''WesternAnimation/TheLordOfTheRings'' although we do see a few webs in the tunnel. Likewise Frodo's mithril shirt is absent from the film.

to:

* AdaptedOut: Due to large portions of [[Literature/TheLordOfTheRings ''[[Literature/TheLordOfTheRings The Two Towers]] Towers]]'' being skipped over, Shelob does not appear despite being hinted at by Gollum at the end of Ralph Bakshi's ''WesternAnimation/TheLordOfTheRings'' ''WesternAnimation/TheLordOfTheRings'', although we do see a few webs in the tunnel. Likewise Likewise, Frodo's mithril shirt is absent from the film.



** Somehow the orcs manage to lose everything important Frodo had on him. In the book Sam takes Sting and the Ring, before the orcs find his body.
** The orcs fighting over Frodo's cloak(that they don't even have) stretches disbelief. In the book they're fighting over his mithril shirt which they have and is sufficiently valuable to warrant such a brawl.
** Somehow the battle of the Pelennor Fields drags on for several days, long enough for Frodo and Sam to reach Mt. Doom.

to:

** Somehow the orcs manage to lose everything important Frodo had on him. In the book book, Sam takes Sting and the Ring, before the orcs find his body.
body.
** The orcs fighting over Frodo's cloak(that cloak (that they don't even have) stretches disbelief. In the book book, they're fighting over his mithril shirt shirt, which they have and is sufficiently valuable to warrant such a brawl.
** Somehow Somehow, the battle of the Pelennor Fields drags on for several days, long enough for Frodo and Sam to reach Mt. Doom.



* TravellingAtTheSpeedOfPlot: A rather glaring example, thanks to mangling Tolkien's timetables so Frodo and Sam manage to reach Mount Doom before the Battle of the Pelennor Fields ends, Sam somehow spends several days wandering inside Orodruin so Aragorn can get to the Black Gate in time

to:

* TravellingAtTheSpeedOfPlot: A rather glaring example, thanks to mangling Tolkien's timetables so Frodo and Sam manage to reach Mount Doom before the Battle of the Pelennor Fields ends, Sam somehow spends several days wandering inside Orodruin so Aragorn can get to the Black Gate in timetime.

Added: 1817

Changed: 100

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Add inconsistencies I noticed on rewatch


* AdaptedOut: Due to large portions of [[Literature/TheLordOfTheRings The Two Towers]] being skipped over, Shelob does not appear despite being hinted at by Gollum at the end of Ralph Bakshi's ''WesternAnimation/TheLordOfTheRings''.

to:

* AdaptedOut: Due to large portions of [[Literature/TheLordOfTheRings The Two Towers]] being skipped over, Shelob does not appear despite being hinted at by Gollum at the end of Ralph Bakshi's ''WesternAnimation/TheLordOfTheRings''.''WesternAnimation/TheLordOfTheRings'' although we do see a few webs in the tunnel. Likewise Frodo's mithril shirt is absent from the film.
* AdaptationInducedPlotHole: Comes up a few times thanks to CompressedAdaptation.
** Somehow the orcs manage to lose everything important Frodo had on him. In the book Sam takes Sting and the Ring, before the orcs find his body.
** The orcs fighting over Frodo's cloak(that they don't even have) stretches disbelief. In the book they're fighting over his mithril shirt which they have and is sufficiently valuable to warrant such a brawl.
** Somehow the battle of the Pelennor Fields drags on for several days, long enough for Frodo and Sam to reach Mt. Doom.
** For all his power, Sauron somehow misses Frodo putting on the One Ring in the heart of his stronghold for several days! In the book and the Jackson films, Sauron notices immediately and promptly sends the Ringwraiths towards Mt. Doom.
* AdaptationExplanationExtrication:
** Why Gollum is calling Frodo master goes unexplained in the film if you didn't see the previous one.
** The Phial of Galadriel shows up with no explanation to where it came from aside from Frodo giving the name and claiming he can't say anything more. In the book its simply one of Galadriel's gifts, something cut from Ralph Bakshi's ''WesternAnimation/TheLordOfTheRings''
** The reason why the Mouth of Sauron show up is left unexplained in the film due to the scene being truncated to him appearing them being sent off. In the book he's acting on Sauron's orders,taunting them with the knowledge they have one of the hobbits in captivity and purposing extreme terms of surrender that are rejected.


Added DiffLines:

* TravellingAtTheSpeedOfPlot: A rather glaring example, thanks to mangling Tolkien's timetables so Frodo and Sam manage to reach Mount Doom before the Battle of the Pelennor Fields ends, Sam somehow spends several days wandering inside Orodruin so Aragorn can get to the Black Gate in time
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Visually, they look noticeably different from the [[{{Cephalothorax}} Goblins]] in ''The Hobbit'', a case of ArtShift. A few of the old-style goblins are mixed in, suggesting this is simply a more diverse force.

to:

** Visually, they look noticeably different from the [[{{Cephalothorax}} Goblins]] in ''The Hobbit'', a case of ArtShift. A few of the old-style goblins are mixed in, suggesting this is simply a more diverse force. The diversity of their builds is actually a plot point at one point: This version of the orcs has so many odd builds that an orc slavedriver mistook Frodo and Sam for orcs even up close.

Added: 352

Changed: 197

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OurOrcsAreDifferent: Than the [[{{Cephalothorax}} Goblins]] in ''The Hobbit'', a case of ArtShift.
** A few of the old-style goblins are mixed in, suggesting this is simply a more diverse force.

to:

* OurOrcsAreDifferent: Than OurOrcsAreDifferent:
** Visually, they look noticeably different from
the [[{{Cephalothorax}} Goblins]] in ''The Hobbit'', a case of ArtShift.
**
ArtShift. A few of the old-style goblins are mixed in, suggesting this is simply a more diverse force. force.
** Thematically, they differ significantly from the "standard" Tolkien-inspired orcs in that they're more clearly PunchClockVillains rather than AlwaysChaoticEvil - there were hints of this in Tolkien, but the movie is much more explicit about it, even giving them a song about how they don't want to go to war but are being forced to by the Dark Lord.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DecoyProtagonist: While the lord of the rings books put the main focus on Frodo baggins, the animated adaptation instead puts the main focus on Samwise’s perspective, and making his decisions the ones that drive the story.

to:

* DecoyProtagonist: While the lord ''Lord of the rings Rings'' books put the main focus on Frodo baggins, Baggins, the animated adaptation instead puts the main focus on Samwise’s Samwise's perspective, and making his decisions the ones that drive the story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DecoyProtagonist: While the lord of the rings books put the main focus on Frodo baggins, the animated adaptation instead puts the main focus on Samwise’s perspective, and making his decisions the ones that drive the story.

Top