Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / TurnaboutStorm

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When she was asked if she had anything to do with the murder, no Psyche-Locks appeared at all. It isn't like the case with [[spoiler: Matt Engarde, who was able to bypass the locks only because Phoenix asked worded his question badly]], the fact is that Rainbow Dash could not have been lying when she said she had ''nothing'' to do with Ace Swift's murder, especially since Phoenix worded his question as such.

to:

** When she was asked if she had anything to do with the murder, no Psyche-Locks appeared at all. It isn't like the case with [[spoiler: Matt Engarde, who was able to bypass the locks only because Phoenix asked worded his question badly]], the badly]]. The fact is that Rainbow Dash could not have been lying when she said she had ''nothing'' to do with Ace Swift's murder, especially since Phoenix worded his question as such.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** [[spoiler: [[EpilepticTrees Unless that's not a channeled Mia, but a reincarnation]]. There's a mystery that Part 1 left hanging, that's how did Twilight know Phoenix's name. What if she didn't summon the best defense attorney, but instead summoned Phoenix intentionally, following the advice of a ''peculiar'' pony?]]

to:

*** [[spoiler: [[EpilepticTrees Unless that's not a channeled Mia, but a reincarnation]]. There's a mystery that Part 1 left hanging, that's how did namely hoe Twilight know Phoenix's name. What if she didn't summon the best defense attorney, but instead summoned Phoenix intentionally, following the advice of a ''peculiar'' pony?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Which could lead to some interesting FridgeBrilliance, considering that the cross examination theme playing during those moments was ''Apollo Justice's''.

to:

** Which could lead to some interesting FridgeBrilliance, considering that the cross examination theme playing during those moments was from ''Apollo Justice's''.
Justice: Ace Attorney''.

Added: 43

Changed: 996

Removed: 59

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** That or...

[[WMG: Phoenix will explain to Twilight why he did what he did]]
* This might seem like the logical thing to do as Twilight might start calling him out, only until he explains to her why he did it.

[[WMG:The one case in Justice For All will be brought up.]]

to:

** That or...


[[WMG: Phoenix will explain to Twilight why he did what he did]]
did.]]
* This might seem like the logical thing to do do, as Twilight might start calling him out, only until he explains to her why he did it.

[[WMG:The one case in [[PhoenixWrightJusticeForAll Justice For All All]] will be brought up.]]



* This is as of yet unsubstantiated, but still a valid guess.

to:

* This is as of yet unsubstantiated, but still a valid guess.
guess. Many theories seem to revolve around Gilda or Trixie being the culprit, but this would make the case far too simple. A more likely answer is that numerous individuals are involved, with one [[BigBad central figure]] that is ultimately responsible.



[[WMG:The culprit is Trixie]]

to:

[[WMG:The culprit is Trixie]]Trixie.]]




[[WMG: Rainbow Dash really ''did'' do it]]

to:

\n** This seems to be a prevailing opinion, but it appears far too obvious of an answer to create an interesting case. See the above WMG that suggests more than one pony was involved.

[[WMG: Rainbow Dash really ''did'' do it]]it.]]



** '''''[[color:red:OBJECTION!]]''''' When she was asked if she had anything to do with the murder, no Psyche-Locks appeared at all! It isn't like the case with [[spoiler: Matt Engarde, who was able to bypass the locks only because Phoenix asked worded his question badly]], the fact is that Rainbow Dash could not have been lying when she said she had ''nothing'' to do with Ace Swift's murder!

to:

** '''''[[color:red:OBJECTION!]]''''' When she was asked if she had anything to do with the murder, no Psyche-Locks appeared at all! all. It isn't like the case with [[spoiler: Matt Engarde, who was able to bypass the locks only because Phoenix asked worded his question badly]], the fact is that Rainbow Dash could not have been lying when she said she had ''nothing'' to do with Ace Swift's murder!murder, especially since Phoenix worded his question as such.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler: That or Fluttershy]]. How shocking would ''that'' be?

to:

* [[spoiler: That or Fluttershy]]. How shocking would ''that'' be?be?
** '''''[[color:red:OBJECTION!]]''''' When she was asked if she had anything to do with the murder, no Psyche-Locks appeared at all! It isn't like the case with [[spoiler: Matt Engarde, who was able to bypass the locks only because Phoenix asked worded his question badly]], the fact is that Rainbow Dash could not have been lying when she said she had ''nothing'' to do with Ace Swift's murder!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Rainbow Dash [[spoiler: Or Fluttershy]] really ''did'' do it]]
* How shocking would ''that'' be?

to:

[[WMG: Rainbow Dash [[spoiler: Or Fluttershy]] really ''did'' do it]]
* [[spoiler: That or Fluttershy]]. How shocking would ''that'' be?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* She's an attorney? Check. She can summon thunderclouds? Check. Likes to spite Twilight's Friends in revenge for being shown off? Check. The fact that Manfred, the character most people seem to compare her to in this fanfic, [[spoiler: pulled off a murder with a similar motive?]] Check.

to:

* She's an attorney? Check. She can summon thunderclouds? Check. Likes to spite Twilight's Friends in revenge for being shown off? Check. The fact that Manfred, the character most people seem to compare her to in this fanfic, [[spoiler: pulled off a murder with a similar motive?]] Check.Check.

[[WMG: Rainbow Dash [[spoiler: Or Fluttershy]] really ''did'' do it]]
* How shocking would ''that'' be?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Compare the burnt object that Phoenix and Twilight found with the Equestrian attorney badge. There is somewhat of a resemblance, although still not confirmed in any way. This is [[WildMassGuessing Wild Mass Guessing]], after all.

to:

* Compare the burnt object that Phoenix and Twilight found with the Equestrian attorney badge. There is somewhat of a resemblance, although still not confirmed in any way. This is [[WildMassGuessing Wild Mass Guessing]], after all.all.

[[WMG:The culprit is Trixie]]
* She's an attorney? Check. She can summon thunderclouds? Check. Likes to spite Twilight's Friends in revenge for being shown off? Check. The fact that Manfred, the character most people seem to compare her to in this fanfic, [[spoiler: pulled off a murder with a similar motive?]] Check.

Added: 196

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** That or...

[[WMG: Phoenix will explain to Twilight why he did what he did]]
* This might seem like the logical thing to do as Twilight might start calling him out, only until he explains to her why he did it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Wait... [[ComicallyMissingThePoint so you can go for trial for killing someone's innocence?]] I should have known sooner! I'm contacting a prosecutor!

to:

*** Wait... [[ComicallyMissingThePoint so you can go for trial for killing someone's innocence?]] I should have known sooner! I'm contacting a prosecutor!prosecutor!

[[WMG:There is more than one culprit involved in the murder.]]
* This is as of yet unsubstantiated, but still a valid guess.

[[WMG:The culprit was an Equestrian attorney.]]
* Compare the burnt object that Phoenix and Twilight found with the Equestrian attorney badge. There is somewhat of a resemblance, although still not confirmed in any way. This is [[WildMassGuessing Wild Mass Guessing]], after all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Wait... [[ComicallyMissingThePoint so you can go for trial for killing someone's innocence?]] I should have known sooner! I'm contacting a prosecutor!

to:

*** Wait... [[ComicallyMissingThePoint so you can go for trial for killing someone's innocence?]] I should have known sooner! I'm contacting a prosecutor!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Maybe [[ProphecyTwist someone's innocence]]?

to:

*** Maybe [[ProphecyTwist someone's innocence]]?innocence]]?
*** Wait... [[ComicallyMissingThePoint so you can go for trial for killing someone's innocence?]] I should have known sooner! I'm contacting a prosecutor!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** With the autopsy report and a crime scene complete with ChalkOutline and everything, I highly doubt that. Even if he didn't die, they got Phoenix Wright, ace MysteryMagnet and video game poster boy of AlwaysMurder, taken to Ponyville. Something will die at some point.

to:

** With the autopsy report and a crime scene complete with ChalkOutline and everything, I highly doubt that. Even if he didn't die, they got Phoenix Wright, ace MysteryMagnet and video game poster boy of AlwaysMurder, taken to Ponyville. Something will die at some point.point.
*** Maybe [[ProphecyTwist someone's innocence]]?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Which could lead to some interesting FridgeBrilliance, considering that the cross examination theme playing during those moments was ''Apollo Justice's''

to:

** Which could lead to some interesting FridgeBrilliance, considering that the cross examination theme playing during those moments was ''Apollo Justice's''
Justice's''.

Added: 44

Changed: 519

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The feather that Phoenix presented in court may or may not be Gilda's. If it were Gilda's, though, she would be the viewer's immediate target for suspicion. Considering the plot twists that are so common to Ace Attorney cases, the viewer's initial suspicions may not necessarily be correct. Thus, it is not out of the question to think that Gilda might be making an appearance in the game without turning out to be the culprit herself.

to:

* The feather that Phoenix presented in court may or may not be Gilda's. If it were Gilda's, though, she would be the viewer's immediate target for suspicion. Considering the plot twists that are so common to Ace Attorney cases, the viewer's initial suspicions may not necessarily be correct. Thus, it is not out of the question to think that Gilda might be making an appearance in the game without turning out to be the culprit herself.
herself. Trixie's comments about a witness with an "attitude" might also point circumstances in this direction.




[[WMG: Ace Swift isn't exactly dead to begin with.]]

to:

\n* Might never be revealed to the audience at all. It might be that the fact that the photos exist, and were in Ace Swift's possession, that might be the most important thing in this case rather than what the photos were of. It would certainly explain why Rainbow Dash was so reluctant to tell why she was at the forest - she was being blackmailed.

[[WMG: Ace Swift isn't exactly dead to begin with.]]



** With the authopsy report and a crime scene complete with ChalkOutline and everything I highly doubt that. Even if he didn't die, they got Phoenix Wright, ace MysteryMagnet and video game poster boy of AlwaysMurder, taken to Ponyville. Something will die anyway.

to:

** With the authopsy autopsy report and a crime scene complete with ChalkOutline and everything everything, I highly doubt that. Even if he didn't die, they got Phoenix Wright, ace MysteryMagnet and video game poster boy of AlwaysMurder, taken to Ponyville. Something will die anyway.at some point.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** [[spoiler: [[EpilepticTrees Unless that's not a channeled Mia, but a reincarnation]]. There's a mystery that Part 1 left hanging, that's how did Twilight know Phoenix's name. What if she didn't summon the best defense attorney, but instead summoned Phoenix intentionally, following the advice of a ''peculiar'' pony?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** [[spoiler: All but confirmed seeing as though the audition video's [[TheStinger stinger]] shows a ponified version of Mia for a split second.]]

Added: 264

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Call this a hunch, but in a [[SugarBowl setting like]] MyLittlePony, [[LikeYouWouldReallyDoIt it's hard to imagine a murder taking place]] other than [[SweetAppleMassacre snuff]] [[{{Cupcakes}} fics]].

to:

* Call this a hunch, but in a [[SugarBowl setting like]] MyLittlePony, [[LikeYouWouldReallyDoIt it's hard to imagine a murder taking place]] other than [[SweetAppleMassacre snuff]] [[{{Cupcakes}} fics]].fics]].
** With the authopsy report and a crime scene complete with ChalkOutline and everything I highly doubt that. Even if he didn't die, they got Phoenix Wright, ace MysteryMagnet and video game poster boy of AlwaysMurder, taken to Ponyville. Something will die anyway.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Are of the previous girly Rainbow Dash, or otherwise this Rainbow Dash "dressing in style", as her namesake put it. Considering her reputation as a {{tomboy}}, having those around is not good for her.

to:

* Are of the previous girly Rainbow Dash, or otherwise this Rainbow Dash "dressing in style", as her namesake put it. Considering her reputation as a {{tomboy}}, having those around is not good for her.her.

[[WMG: Ace Swift isn't exactly dead to begin with.]]
Call this a hunch, but in a [[SugarBowl setting like]] MyLittlePony, [[LikeYouWouldReallyDoIt it's hard to imagine a murder taking place]] other than [[SweetAppleMassacre snuff]] [[{{Cupcakes}} fics]].

Added: 474

Changed: 156

Removed: 269

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** Which could lead to some interesting FridgeBrilliance, considering that the cross examination theme playing during those moments was ''Apollo Justice's''



[[WMG: The embarrassing pictures are from Rainbow Dash's time in the Junior Speedsters.]]
* I agree with the previous WMG that Gilda may not be the murderer but she definitely has a part in this whole mess and that part being that she provided the embarrassing pictures.



* Let's assume that the murder was premeditated. The fact that Rainbow Dash and Ace Swift were both in the same area of the Everfree Forest at the same time suggests that Rainbow Dash could have been just as likely a target as Ace Swift. Granted, there is still not enough evidence that proves the act was premeditated, but this is still a reasonable guess considering what has already been shown in court.

to:

* Let's assume that the murder was premeditated. The fact that Rainbow Dash and Ace Swift were both in the same area of the Everfree Forest at the same time suggests that Rainbow Dash could have been just as likely a target as Ace Swift. Granted, there is still not enough evidence that proves the act was premeditated, but this is still a reasonable guess considering what has already been shown in court.court.

[[WMG: The embarrassing pictures...]]
* Are from Rainbow Dash's time in the Junior Speedsters. I agree with the previous WMG that Gilda may not be the murderer but she definitely has a part in this whole mess and that part being that she provided the embarrassing pictures.
* Are of the previous girly Rainbow Dash, or otherwise this Rainbow Dash "dressing in style", as her namesake put it. Considering her reputation as a {{tomboy}}, having those around is not good for her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Rainbow Dash was meant to be killed, not Ace Swift.]]

to:

[[WMG: The culprit tried to kill Rainbow Dash was meant to be killed, Dash, not Ace Swift.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*** Interestingly, this also calls to mind Case 1-5 from the original [[PhoenixWrightAceAttorney Phoenix Wright game]], where [[spoiler: Lana forfeits her right to an attorney and dismisses Phoenix in the middle of the trial, before Edgeworth is able to turn the tide back into Phoenix's favor]]. It's possible that Rainbow Dash, especially since she is the Element of Loyalty and [[spoiler: Phoenix has accused her friend Fluttershy of the murder]], might do exactly the same thing before someone else intervenes on Phoenix's behalf.

Added: 466

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG:Phoenix Wright will be conducting the second day of investigation alone]]

to:

[[WMG:Phoenix Wright will be conducting the second day of investigation alone]]alone.]]



[[WMG:The one case in Justice For All will be brought up]]

to:

[[WMG:The one case in Justice For All will be brought up]]up.]]



[[WMG: The embarrassing pictures are from Rainbow Dash's time in the Junior Speedsters]]
I agree with the previous WMG that Gilda may not be the murderer but she definitely has a part in this whole mess and that part being that she provided the embarrassing pictures.

to:

[[WMG: The embarrassing pictures are from Rainbow Dash's time in the Junior Speedsters]]
Speedsters.]]
*
I agree with the previous WMG that Gilda may not be the murderer but she definitely has a part in this whole mess and that part being that she provided the embarrassing pictures.pictures.

[[WMG: Rainbow Dash was meant to be killed, not Ace Swift.]]
* Let's assume that the murder was premeditated. The fact that Rainbow Dash and Ace Swift were both in the same area of the Everfree Forest at the same time suggests that Rainbow Dash could have been just as likely a target as Ace Swift. Granted, there is still not enough evidence that proves the act was premeditated, but this is still a reasonable guess considering what has already been shown in court.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


I agree with the previous WMG that Gilda may not be the murderer but she definitely has a part in this whole mess and that part being that she provided the pictures embarrassing pictures.

to:

I agree with the previous WMG that Gilda may not be the murderer but she definitely has a part in this whole mess and that part being that she provided the pictures embarrassing pictures.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Phoenix is bound to be confronted by at least Twilight on the stunt he pulled in court. At which point, he'd explain his reasoning for [[spoiler: accusing Fluttershy]], as well as pointing out that he needs no help from Twilight in hating himself for it, partially explaining the one case.

to:

* Phoenix is bound to be confronted by at least Twilight on the stunt he pulled in court. At which point, he'd explain his reasoning for [[spoiler: accusing Fluttershy]], as well as pointing out that he needs no help from Twilight in hating himself for it, partially explaining the one case.case.
** Although I agree with that, I think initially Twilight will not want to talk to him and walks out on him as mentioned in the above WMG. He will, however, bring it up to Fluttershy in the Detention Center and she will probably have the kindness to forgive him, maybe even saying that if it means helping Rainbow Dash, she's happy to help in any way she can.

[[WMG: The embarrassing pictures are from Rainbow Dash's time in the Junior Speedsters]]
I agree with the previous WMG that Gilda may not be the murderer but she definitely has a part in this whole mess and that part being that she provided the pictures embarrassing pictures.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Considering [[spoiler: [[TheStinger the Stinger]] at the end of Part 2, where we hear Phoenix calling out Mia's name]], as well as the mysterious Magatama glow before the trial, this one is not an unreasonable guess.

to:

* Considering [[spoiler: [[TheStinger the Stinger]] at the end of Part 2, where we hear Phoenix calling out Mia's name]], as well as the mysterious Magatama glow before the trial, this one is not an unreasonable guess.guess.

[[WMG:Phoenix Wright will be conducting the second day of investigation alone]]
* After Phoenix Wright [[spoiler: pointed out that Fluttershy is a potential suspect]], I doubt Twilight will be willing to stay with him, at least at first. Therefore, he'd be left to try and gather evidence and possibly even face everyone's criticism (ESPECIALLY ponies like Applejack and Rarity).

[[WMG:The one case in Justice For All will be brought up]]
* Phoenix is bound to be confronted by at least Twilight on the stunt he pulled in court. At which point, he'd explain his reasoning for [[spoiler: accusing Fluttershy]], as well as pointing out that he needs no help from Twilight in hating himself for it, partially explaining the one case.

Added: 264

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG:Gilda will be appear as a witness, but will not be the actual murderer.]]
* The feather that Phoenix presented in court may or may not be Gilda's. If it were Gilda's, though, she would be the viewer's immediate target for suspicion. Considering the plot twists that are so common to Ace Attorney cases, the viewer's initial suspicions may not necessarily be correct. Thus, it is not out of the question to think that Gilda might be making an appearance in the game without turning out to be the culprit herself.

to:

[[WMG:Gilda Griffon will be appear appearing as a witness, but will not be the actual murderer.]]
* The feather that Phoenix presented in court may or may not be Gilda's. If it were Gilda's, though, she would be the viewer's immediate target for suspicion. Considering the plot twists that are so common to Ace Attorney cases, the viewer's initial suspicions may not necessarily be correct. Thus, it is not out of the question to think that Gilda might be making an appearance in the game without turning out to be the culprit herself.herself.

[[WMG:Twilight Sparkle will channel Mia Fey.]]
* Considering [[spoiler: [[TheStinger the Stinger]] at the end of Part 2, where we hear Phoenix calling out Mia's name]], as well as the mysterious Magatama glow before the trial, this one is not an unreasonable guess.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Consider the fact that Twilight, in the words of Phoenix Wright, keeps "randomly looking at Trixie" throughout the trial, but when she was asked about it earlier, she brushed it off as unimportant. Also consider how the Magatama emitted a strange glow before the trial started. Isn't it possible that Twilight has gained the ability to sense tension when others lie in court, as Apollo Justice can?

to:

* Consider the fact that Twilight, in the words of Phoenix Wright, keeps "randomly looking at Trixie" throughout the trial, but when she was asked about it earlier, she brushed it off as unimportant. Also consider how the Magatama emitted a strange glow before the trial started. Isn't it possible that Twilight has gained the ability to sense tension when others lie in court, as Apollo Justice can?can?

[[WMG:Gilda will be appear as a witness, but will not be the actual murderer.]]
*The feather that Phoenix presented in court may or may not be Gilda's. If it were Gilda's, though, she would be the viewer's immediate target for suspicion. Considering the plot twists that are so common to Ace Attorney cases, the viewer's initial suspicions may not necessarily be correct. Thus, it is not out of the question to think that Gilda might be making an appearance in the game without turning out to be the culprit herself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Consider the fact that Twilight, in the words of Phoenix Wright, keeps "randomly looking at Trixie" throughout the trial. Also consider how the Magatama emitted a strange glow before the trial started. Isn't it possible that Twilight has gained the ability to sense tension as Apollo Justice can?

to:

* Consider the fact that Twilight, in the words of Phoenix Wright, keeps "randomly looking at Trixie" throughout the trial.trial, but when she was asked about it earlier, she brushed it off as unimportant. Also consider how the Magatama emitted a strange glow before the trial started. Isn't it possible that Twilight has gained the ability to sense tension when others lie in court, as Apollo Justice can?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG:Twilight Sparkle has the [[ApolloJustice Perceive Ability.]]]]
*Consider the fact that Twilight, in the words of Phoenix Wright, keeps "randomly looking at Trixie" throughout the trial. Also consider how the Magatama emitted a strange glow before the trial started. Isn't it possible that Twilight has gained the ability to sense tension as Apollo Justice can?

Top