History WMG / ScreamTheTVSeries

[[WMG: The original choice for Piper's accomplice was Maggie Duval, Emma's mother]]

[[/folder]]

* [[spoiler: Jossed as of the season one finale.]]

** {{Jossed}}. [[spoiler: There were two killers, but they were working together the whole time.]]

He and [[spoiler: Riley]] are the only ones of the teens who are not in major promotional material and since [[spoiler: she's]] dead now, Jake can't last much longer.

* As of the season 1, [[spoiler: ''massively'' {{Jossed}}. Jake survives]]
* [[spoiler: Ironically, this is {{Jossed}} in season 1 and then confirmed in season 2, where Jake is killed in the first episode.]]

* [[spoiler: Brooke survived, but she's not the final girl. They played that trope straight.]]

* As of Season 1, [[spoiler: {{Jossed}}. Though it is possible they'll continue the mystery next year.]]

* This might be helped by the (as yet uncomfirmed) rumors that [[spoiler: Bella Thorne will be returning next season]]. They might want to reuse some of the actors from the first season in different roles.

* [[spoiler:Confirmed. Audrey was the second killer, working with Piper.]]
* [[spoiler:{{Jossed}} in Season 2. Audrey and Piper did correspond with one another, but Audrey actually just wanted Piper's help to make a documentary about Brandon James.]]

* [[spoiler:Confirmed, and this is indeed her motivation for the murders.]]

* [[spoiler:{{Jossed}}. While Branson isn't his real last name, he's not related to Brandon James. He turns out to be a RedHerring, with Piper being Brandon's illegitimate daughter.]]

* [[spoiler:{{Jossed}}. Piper and Kieran are the killers, and Piper in fact tries to kill Maggie during the first season finale.]]

* [[spoiler:{{Jossed}}. He's related to neither -- the story about him changing his name after an inappropriate relationship with a student in another state turns out to be true.]]

[[WMG: The killer is [[spoiler: Kieran]]]]
I got this theory from an IMDB message board, but I thought it was a good one. It turns out he was lying and [[spoiler: he actually slept with Nina]]. When she revealed her true age, she blackmailed him. Unless the DawsonCasting is strong with this series, [[spoiler: Kieran definitely looks over 18]].
* [[spoiler:{{Jossed}}. He's not the killer.]]
* [[spoiler:Un-Jossed and confirmed]] in Season 2, where [[spoiler:Kieran is revealed as Piper's accomplice.]]

[[WMG: The killer is [[spoiler: Mrs. James, Brandon's mother]]]]
It's more than likely that the killer has a huge grudge against Emma and Maggie, especially Maggie. The killer blames Maggie for the death of Brandon James and may even believe / know that Brandon James was innocent of the killings back then. Either [[spoiler: Emma's dad]] was the real killer back then or [[spoiler: Mrs. James herself]] did the killings. If the former, then the reason for the mind games was to make Emma feel the guilt that [[spoiler: her father]] should've felt. If the latter, then it's to finish the job by proxy.
* [[spoiler:{{Jossed}}. The killer is Piper, Brandon's daughter.]]

It's been hinted at that Audrey has a fascination with Brandon James based on the picture she keeps on her wall. Since she and Rachel made films together, it's possible that they once decided to re-enact a slasher scene using a Ghostface mask with Audrey playing as masked killer. The prop was then unknowingly stolen by the real killer and [[spoiler: placed on Tyler's head]]. This would explain how Audrey's [[spoiler: DNA got on the inside of the mask]].
* [[spoiler:{{Jossed}}. Audrey's DNA was in the mask because she was in fact the second killer.]]
** [[spoiler:As of Season 2, Audrey being the second killer has officially been {{Jossed}}.]]

* {{Jossed}}. [[spoiler: Audrey wasn't Piper's accomplice.]]

* {{Jossed}}. [[spoiler: Audrey was GoodAllAlong, and Piper's surprise was that ''Kieran'' was her accomplice.]]

* {{Jossed}}. [[spoiler: Audrey was not Piper's accomplice and didn't even suspect her of being the killer.]]

Given that [[spoiler: Clark Hudson was murdered in the Season 1 finale]], it seems obvious that Lorraine would step in to take his place as Sheriff of Lakewood.

[[WMG: When Noah finds out that [[spoiler: Audrey helped Piper]] He will fan boy out.]]

* {{Jossed}}. Noah is shocked when he finds out is trying to investigate, though he seems willing to give [[spoiler: Audrey]] the benefit of the doubt.

* [[spoiler: Jossed]].

* Confirmed, though not in the way this guesser probably meant. Audrey was motivated by loneliness, anger, and heartbreak, [[spoiler: but all she actually did was invite Piper to help her make a documentary about Brandon James and lie to Emma about how much she knew about Piper.]]

* [[spoiler: Since she was murdered in Season 2, it's likely this can be Jossed]].

Not only does she take a weirdly intense interest in the Lakewood Five (providing Emma and Brooke with psychological advice even though she isn't a licensed psychologist), [[spoiler: the reveal that she was lying about being with Branson the night Jake died]] means she also doesn't have an alibi. She also locks Emma in her office, and soon after Ghostface taunts Emma just outside the office. She hasn't been viewed super suspiciously, indicating revealing her to be the killer would be the "shocking twist" this type of show goes for. As [[TV/TheOffice Dwight Schrute]] would say, "It's the person I most medium suspect."
* [[spoiler: Jossed]].

[[WMG: Either Audrey is [[spoiler: lying about not helping Piper with the murders]]]]
...or Piper had another accomplice. Otherwise, who attacked her and Will in episode 6 of season 1? Noah is pretty sure she had one anyway, but pretty abandons the theory after [[spoiler: Audrey confesses to bringing Piper to Lakewood]] ignoring all the evidence. That accomplice is the killer in season 2.
* [[spoiler: Confirmed. Audrey was never Piper's accomplice and the real accomplice was indeed the killer]].

Noah could have purposefully sent the sex tape in season 1, hacked Audrey's computer and found out she was corresponding with piper. He did try to find a family connection with Brandon James pre show, and if he knew about Audrey, then he could have set up the hotel guy to die since he would know they talked. He could have also faked the evidence that Zoe leaked the Audrey confession he "accidentally" recorded. He's done a lot of things that go against horror convention which he could have done without fear of he was the killer. Plus the actor himself is more buff than he was last season, but still doesn't have the fighting skills, as evidenced by his slow reaction times for his last two attacks. Plus, after "finding out" about Audrey, he doesn't mention Riley... But then no one has.
* [[spoiler: Jossed]].

* [[spoiler: Seemingly confirmed. Flashbacks show that Maggie and Miguel helped hide Brandon after he seemingly "died" and he took off into the woods. The season 2 finale has Maggie's message to Brandon telling him to stay away from Emma returned with a knife through it and Kieran receiving a phone call from someone using the voice we associate with the killers asking "Who gave you permission to wear my mask?" perhaps confirming Brandon is still alive and he's back in Lakewood.]]
** [[spoiler: The Halloween special further supports this as someone dressed as Ghostface breaks into the courthouse and kills Kieran just after his trial. At the end of the special, an unknown man checks into a hotel in Lakewood under the name "Mr. James".]]

* [[spoiler: Jossed and Confirmed. Will was attacked by the new killer but the killer was Kieran. The jossed part is that this heavily implied that Audrey is a killer which she isn't]].

* [[spoiler: Jossed Audrey is not the killer]].

* [[spoiler: Jossed Brooke gets with Gustavo]].

* [[spoiler: Jossed. By the end of Season 2, it appears that she's moved in with the Acostas]].

* [[spoiler: Jossed]].

[[WMG: Eli [[spoiler: is still alive]]]].
We never get any solid confirmation that [[spoiler: Eli died from his gunshot wounds and there's the possibility he wore a bullet proof vest to go confront Kieran]]. Plus, there's the fact that [[spoiler: he survived being shot by Emma]], so he may just be hospitalized.

[[WMG: [[spoiler: Kieran]]will be released from jail.]]
Due to insufficient evidence, [[spoiler: Kieran]] will be pronounced not guilty by Judge and/or Jury and released by the time Season 3 (or the two-part Halloween special) rolls around. This will make the Season 2 killer the primary suspect and scapegoat once the killings start up all over again.
* [[spoiler: Jossed. He was killed by the new Ghostface killer at the beginning of the Halloween special]].
** [[spoiler: And just before this, he was sentenced to life in prison.]]

* [[spoiler: Potentially Jossed by Kieran being murdered in the opening of the Halloween special. But since there's a time gap between the Season 2 finale and the Special, there's the possibility there will be flashbacks to the gang's previous visits with Kieran]].

Brandon will be revealed as innocent all along, with the original killer being Emma's father. When he found out Brandon and Maggie were having an affair, something in him snapped, and he began a killing spree ending with Brandon, forcing Maggie to watch. He'll then begin targeting Kieran as revenge for going after his daughter. This is also supported by the fact that [[spoiler: the end of the Halloween special seems to heavily imply that Kevin was the one who killed Kieran]].

* Could of set up Piper with Kieran.

* Noah is the one to connect all the characters and always knew Emma's mom was Daisy. He may of secretly dared or payed Nina to film Audrey and Heather (being Audrey's best friend he could of figured out her relationship) and even Nina to dare Will to have sex with Emma knowing it would make Emma one of the cool girls and the popular girls future murder victims.

* He knows that and who Maggie is because Brandon's brother told him who he admits he met in season 1 and could of told him about Brandon's and Maggie's tree that a brother would find out about.

* Noah is

*

[[WMG: Noah is the killer.]]

The series is being renewed for a second season. If they don't decide to go the route of the original movies by continuing the survivors' stories in a new environment, they could do what HarpersIsland initially planned on doing, by creating a new mystery with new characters each season.

[[WMG: The T.V. Series will be a horror anthology, in the style of AmericanHorrorStory]]

[[WMG: Though YMMV, The show will make us feel sorry for Audrey, at the end.]]

** Half-confirmed. [[spoiler: The killers were working together, but Audrey betrays and frames Piper for everything.]]