Follow TV Tropes

Following

History WMG / FantasticBeastsAndWhereToFindThem

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Many Americans have complained that, based on the trailers and worldbuilding notes on Pottermore, this take on Wizarding America seems rife with poorly researched generalizations and a lack of the same nuance that made the original seven books shine. The reason? While in the US, Newt Scamander left New York City, where he encountered TheJerseyDevil. The experience was so traumatic that Newt blacked out nearly all memories of his visit to the US. Unfortunately, when he returned to the UK, the Ministry demanded a full report. Newt panicked and made up a story based on vague memories, assumptions, and occasionally offensive generalizations, which he submitted to the Ministry. Since he didn't remember any of his visit and wasn't keen to return, Newt soon came to believe his own story. Since he was the expert and few British witches and wizards were interested in visiting the US, his wildly inaccurate vision of Wizarding America stuck.

to:

Many Americans have complained that, based on the trailers and worldbuilding notes on Pottermore, this take on Wizarding America seems rife with poorly researched generalizations and a lack of the same nuance that made the original seven books shine. The reason? While in the US, Newt Scamander left New York City, where he encountered TheJerseyDevil. The experience was so traumatic that Newt blacked out nearly all memories of his visit to the US. Unfortunately, when he returned to the UK, the Ministry demanded a full report. Newt panicked and made up a story based on vague memories, assumptions, and occasionally offensive generalizations, which he submitted to the Ministry. Since he didn't remember any most of his visit and wasn't keen to return, Newt soon came to believe his own story. Since he was the expert and few British witches and wizards were interested in visiting the US, his wildly inaccurate vision of Wizarding America stuck.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Many Americans have complained that, based on the trailers and worldbuilding notes on Pottermore, this take on Wizarding America seems rife with poorly researched generalizations and a lack of the same nuance that made the original seven books shine. The reason? While in the US, Newt Scamander left New York City, where he encountered TheJerseyDevil. The experience was so traumatic that Newt blacked out nearly all memories of his visit to the US. Unfortunately, when he returned to the UK, the Ministry demanded a full report. Newt panicked and made up a story based on vague memories, assumptions, and inaccurate generalizations, which he submitted to the Ministry. Since he didn't remember any of his visit and wasn't keen to return, Newt soon came to believe his own story. Since he was the expert and few British witches and wizards were interested in visiting the US, his wildly inaccurate vision of Wizarding America stuck.

to:

Many Americans have complained that, based on the trailers and worldbuilding notes on Pottermore, this take on Wizarding America seems rife with poorly researched generalizations and a lack of the same nuance that made the original seven books shine. The reason? While in the US, Newt Scamander left New York City, where he encountered TheJerseyDevil. The experience was so traumatic that Newt blacked out nearly all memories of his visit to the US. Unfortunately, when he returned to the UK, the Ministry demanded a full report. Newt panicked and made up a story based on vague memories, assumptions, and inaccurate occasionally offensive generalizations, which he submitted to the Ministry. Since he didn't remember any of his visit and wasn't keen to return, Newt soon came to believe his own story. Since he was the expert and few British witches and wizards were interested in visiting the US, his wildly inaccurate vision of Wizarding America stuck.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


And it will be about the sheer madness that was the Quidditch world cup of 1492. And it will be '''''glorious'''''.

to:

And it will be about the sheer madness that was the Quidditch world cup of 1492. And it will be '''''glorious'''''.'''''glorious'''''.

[[WMG: Wizarding America is actually a lot cooler than this movie makes it look. Unfortunately, Newt doesn't remember any of it.]]
Many Americans have complained that, based on the trailers and worldbuilding notes on Pottermore, this take on Wizarding America seems rife with poorly researched generalizations and a lack of the same nuance that made the original seven books shine. The reason? While in the US, Newt Scamander left New York City, where he encountered TheJerseyDevil. The experience was so traumatic that Newt blacked out nearly all memories of his visit to the US. Unfortunately, when he returned to the UK, the Ministry demanded a full report. Newt panicked and made up a story based on vague memories, assumptions, and inaccurate generalizations, which he submitted to the Ministry. Since he didn't remember any of his visit and wasn't keen to return, Newt soon came to believe his own story. Since he was the expert and few British witches and wizards were interested in visiting the US, his wildly inaccurate vision of Wizarding America stuck.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


And it will be about the fantastic certified madness that was the Quidditch world cup of 1492. And it will be '''''glorious'''''.

to:

And it will be about the fantastic certified sheer madness that was the Quidditch world cup of 1492. And it will be '''''glorious'''''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This will explain [[GodCreatedCanonForeigner why we've never seen it before]].

to:

This will explain [[GodCreatedCanonForeigner why we've never seen it before]].before]].

[[WMG: If this movie is successful, ''Quidditch Through the Ages'' will be made into a movie next.]]
And it will be about the fantastic certified madness that was the Quidditch world cup of 1492. And it will be '''''glorious'''''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[spoiler: Gellert Grindelwald. According to people attending screenings of footage from the film, the film opens with an attack on Grindelwald's hideout where we see Grindelwald from behind (now why would they hide his face?). A newspaper headline reveals Grindelwald has disappeared after this attack. In the trailers, Seraphina notes the events occurring are similar to Grindelwald's attacks and the trailers also confirm Graves will be the villain in this film. Graves is actually Grindelwald who has gone into hiding and is pretending to be an American wizard named Percival Graves (mass Confundus/Imperius spells has allowed him to act like he was always there). Grindelwald has in fact been plotting how to tip the volatile tensions in America between the magical and non-magical communities in his favour and Newt's creatures have given him a way to do so (mass sightings of beasts and attacks to start an all out war). This is further supported by the Deathly Hallows necklace appearing on Graves's character poster (Grindelwald adopted the symbol as his banner) and by Rowling confirming the films will build up to the final confrontation between Dumbledore and Grindelwald, pretty much confirming Grindelwald (and possibly Dumbledore) will appear in this film.]]

to:

[[spoiler: Gellert Grindelwald. According to people attending screenings of footage from the film, the film opens with an attack on Grindelwald's hideout where we see Grindelwald from behind (now why would they hide his face?). A newspaper headline reveals Grindelwald has disappeared after this attack. In the trailers, Seraphina notes the events occurring are similar to Grindelwald's attacks and the trailers also confirm Graves will be the villain in this film. Graves is actually Grindelwald who has gone into hiding and is pretending to be an American wizard named Percival Graves (mass Confundus/Imperius spells has allowed him to act like he was always there). Grindelwald has in fact been plotting how to tip the volatile tensions in America between the magical and non-magical communities in his favour and Newt's creatures have given him a way to do so (mass sightings of beasts and attacks to start an all out war). This is further supported by the Deathly Hallows necklace appearing on Graves's character poster (Grindelwald adopted the symbol as his banner) and by Rowling confirming the films will build up to the final confrontation between Dumbledore and Grindelwald, pretty much confirming Grindelwald (and possibly Dumbledore) will appear in this film.]]]]

[[WMG: The Swooping Evil will go extinct at some point during the franchise.]]
This will explain [[GodCreatedCanonForeigner why we've never seen it before]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[spoiler: Gellert Grindlewald. According to people attending screenings of footage from the film, the film opens with an attack on Grindlewald's hideout where we see Grindlewald from behind (now why would they hide his face?). A newspaper headline reveals Grindlewald has disappeared after this attack. In the trailers, Seraphina notes the events occurring are similar to Grindlewald's attacks and the trailers also confirm Graves will be the villain in this film. Graves is actually Grindlewald who has gone into hiding and is pretending to be an American wizard named Percival Graves (mass Confundus/Imperius spells has allowed him to act like he was always there). Grindlewald has in fact been plotting how to tip the volatile tensions in America between the magical and non-magical communities in his favour and Newt's creatures have given him a way to do so (mass sightings of beasts and attacks to start an all out war). This is further supported by the Deathly Hallows necklace appearing on Graves's character poster (Grindlewald adopted the symbol as his banner) and by Rowling confirming the films will build up to the final confrontation between Dumbledore and Grindlewald, pretty much confirming Grindlewald (and possibly Dumbledore) will appear in this film.]]

to:

[[spoiler: Gellert Grindlewald. Grindelwald. According to people attending screenings of footage from the film, the film opens with an attack on Grindlewald's Grindelwald's hideout where we see Grindlewald Grindelwald from behind (now why would they hide his face?). A newspaper headline reveals Grindlewald Grindelwald has disappeared after this attack. In the trailers, Seraphina notes the events occurring are similar to Grindlewald's Grindelwald's attacks and the trailers also confirm Graves will be the villain in this film. Graves is actually Grindlewald Grindelwald who has gone into hiding and is pretending to be an American wizard named Percival Graves (mass Confundus/Imperius spells has allowed him to act like he was always there). Grindlewald Grindelwald has in fact been plotting how to tip the volatile tensions in America between the magical and non-magical communities in his favour and Newt's creatures have given him a way to do so (mass sightings of beasts and attacks to start an all out war). This is further supported by the Deathly Hallows necklace appearing on Graves's character poster (Grindlewald (Grindelwald adopted the symbol as his banner) and by Rowling confirming the films will build up to the final confrontation between Dumbledore and Grindlewald, Grindelwald, pretty much confirming Grindlewald Grindelwald (and possibly Dumbledore) will appear in this film.]]

Added: 1324

Changed: 329

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*Alternatively, Jacob is a witness and there's something he knows that Newt and co need before erasing his memory, possibly seeing someone (the true culprit for releasing Newt's creatures?)that they will later need him to identify. At the end of the film, Newt, having grown fond of Jacob, will only pretend to erase his memory.



Namely, at the end he will be banned for eternity to enter the EEUU or write anything about it, with Tina and possibly Jacob and Queenie accompaning him in his exile.

to:

Namely, at the end he will be banned for eternity to enter the EEUU or write anything about it, with Tina and possibly Jacob and Queenie accompaning him in his exile.exile.

[[WMG: The true identity of Percival Graves is...]]
[[spoiler: Gellert Grindlewald. According to people attending screenings of footage from the film, the film opens with an attack on Grindlewald's hideout where we see Grindlewald from behind (now why would they hide his face?). A newspaper headline reveals Grindlewald has disappeared after this attack. In the trailers, Seraphina notes the events occurring are similar to Grindlewald's attacks and the trailers also confirm Graves will be the villain in this film. Graves is actually Grindlewald who has gone into hiding and is pretending to be an American wizard named Percival Graves (mass Confundus/Imperius spells has allowed him to act like he was always there). Grindlewald has in fact been plotting how to tip the volatile tensions in America between the magical and non-magical communities in his favour and Newt's creatures have given him a way to do so (mass sightings of beasts and attacks to start an all out war). This is further supported by the Deathly Hallows necklace appearing on Graves's character poster (Grindlewald adopted the symbol as his banner) and by Rowling confirming the films will build up to the final confrontation between Dumbledore and Grindlewald, pretty much confirming Grindlewald (and possibly Dumbledore) will appear in this film.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* Alternately, they could keep the "Fantastic" but vary the theme for each of the five films, ''a la'' "Fantastic Beings and How to Meet Them", "Fantastic Spirits and How to Calm Them", "Fantastic Objects and How to Craft Them", or "Fantastic Realms and How to Visit Them".

Added: 276

Changed: 292

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


It's the only reason I can think about why American Wizarkind would allow him to colaborate with Scamander to retrieve the magical creatures.

to:

It's the only reason I can think about why American Wizarkind would allow him a muggle to colaborate with Scamander to retrieve the magical creatures.creatures. If he can NoSell memory charms the wizards would have only two options: to kill him to protect TheMasquerade o treath him like a squib. It would also explain why he and Queenie seem to close in the final trailer, since if a witch married a squib it wouldn´t be against MACUSA's law.

[[WMG: This movie will give an explanation about how Scamander didn´t wrote about American magical creatures]]
Namely, at the end he will be banned for eternity to enter the EEUU or write anything about it, with Tina and possibly Jacob and Queenie accompaning him in his exile.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One or both of them is/are TheMole, Credence for MACUSA and the other one for the Scourers. Credence is starting to crack/[[BecomingTheMask believe he really is a Scourer]].

to:

* One or both of them is/are TheMole, Credence for MACUSA and the other one for the Scourers. Credence is starting to crack/[[BecomingTheMask believe he really is a Scourer]].Scourer]].

[[WMG: Jacob Kowalsky is inmune to Obliviations]]
It's the only reason I can think about why American Wizarkind would allow him to colaborate with Scamander to retrieve the magical creatures.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Credence was kidnapped from his family by the Barebones and his brother went into law enforcement in the vain hope of finding him. He's become "troubled" because memories of his life as a wizard child are returning.
* Credence is the agent's [[AbsurdlyYouthfulMother son]] he never knew about, or was unable to find until Newt & Co. run into the Barebones.
* One or both of them is/are TheMole, Credence for MCUSA and the other one for the Scourers. Credence is starting to crack/[[BecomingTheMask believe he really is a Scourer]].

to:

* Credence was kidnapped from his family by the Barebones Bareboneses and his brother went into law enforcement in the vain hope of finding him. He's become "troubled" because memories of his life as a wizard child are returning.
* Credence is the agent's [[AbsurdlyYouthfulMother son]] he never knew about, or was unable to find until Newt & Co. run into the Barebones.
Bareboneses.
* One or both of them is/are TheMole, Credence for MCUSA MACUSA and the other one for the Scourers. Credence is starting to crack/[[BecomingTheMask believe he really is a Scourer]].

Added: 764

Changed: 105

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG:Creator/HPLovecraft will be mentioned, or make an appearence.]]

to:

[[WMG:Creator/HPLovecraft will be mentioned, or make an appearence.appearance.]]







to:

** He also had an overbearing mother (named Suzie).... New thoery: Credence Barebone is HP Lovecraft.



All of the trailers focus on Wizard Vs. Wizard action and not a single beast had been shown. And it would be an amazing SequleHook

to:

All of the trailers focus on Wizard Vs. Wizard action and not a single beast had been shown. And it would be an amazing SequleHook
SequelHook



* His true name is Credence, but he will be "obliviated" at some point and make a new identity for himself becoming a character we know.

to:

* His true name is Credence, but he will be "obliviated" at some point and make a new identity for himself becoming a character we know.know.

[[WMG: Credence is related to Colin Farrel's character]]
They look ''awfully'' similar in [[http://www.ew.com/sites/default/files/styles/tout_image_612x380/public/i/2016/08/10/fb-ew-000232283_0_1.jpg?itok=_a3V8dKE this photo]]. Ideas:
* Credence was kidnapped from his family by the Barebones and his brother went into law enforcement in the vain hope of finding him. He's become "troubled" because memories of his life as a wizard child are returning.
* Credence is the agent's [[AbsurdlyYouthfulMother son]] he never knew about, or was unable to find until Newt & Co. run into the Barebones.
* One or both of them is/are TheMole, Credence for MCUSA and the other one for the Scourers. Credence is starting to crack/[[BecomingTheMask believe he really is a Scourer]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* He's an existing character who's in hiding for some reason and is posing as Mary Lou's adopted son (Mary Lou is under a Confundus Charm) to hide his true identity, reasoning no one would suspect the son of the leader of the New Salem Philanthropic Society would be a wizard. Or

to:

* He's an existing character who's in hiding for some reason and is posing as Mary Lou's adopted son (Mary Lou is under a Confundus Charm) Charm to make her think Credence is her son) to hide his true identity, reasoning no one would suspect the son of the leader of the New Salem Philanthropic Society would be a wizard. Or
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: Ilvermorny will be important in the films, and several wizards and witches from the school will appear.]]

to:

[[WMG: Ilvermorny will be important in the films, and several wizards and witches from the school will appear.]]]]

[[WMG: Who is Credence?]]
He reportedly becomes a "notable" character in the Harry Potter universe, which raises the question as to who he is.
*He's an existing character who's in hiding for some reason and is posing as Mary Lou's adopted son (Mary Lou is under a Confundus Charm) to hide his true identity, reasoning no one would suspect the son of the leader of the New Salem Philanthropic Society would be a wizard. Or
*His true name is Credence, but he will be "obliviated" at some point and make a new identity for himself becoming a character we know.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Perhaps he will be part of the AntiMagicalFaction. It would fit as the real life Lovecraft was incredibly racist and xenophobic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Perhaps Luna will ask him to tell her about his grandfather.

to:

Perhaps Luna will ask him to tell her about his grandfather.grandfather.

[[WMG: Ilvermorny will be important in the films, and several wizards and witches from the school will appear.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG:HPLovecraft will be mentioned, or make an appearence.]]

to:

[[WMG:HPLovecraft [[WMG:Creator/HPLovecraft will be mentioned, or make an appearence.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


All of the trailers focus on Wizard Vs. Wizard action and not a single beast had been shown. And it would be an amazing SequleHook

to:

All of the trailers focus on Wizard Vs. Wizard action and not a single beast had been shown. And it would be an amazing SequleHookSequleHook

[[WMG: Rolf will appear at some point in the films]]
Perhaps Luna will ask him to tell her about his grandfather.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Probably jossed. It's been stated on Pottermore that most of the witch hunters are actually descended from wizard vigilantes who began to hate wizards once an actual government meant that there was no room for them anymore.

to:

* Probably jossed. It's been stated on Pottermore that most of the witch hunters are actually descended from wizard vigilantes who began to hate wizards once an actual government meant that there was no room for them anymore.anymore.

[[WMG: The sequel s will keep the "Fantastic Beasts and" title]]
The second will be Fantastic Beasts and How to Catch Them.
The third will be Fantastic Beasts andHow to Tame them.

[[WMG: The beasts won't escape until near the end of the movie]]
All of the trailers focus on Wizard Vs. Wizard action and not a single beast had been shown. And it would be an amazing SequleHook
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


He joined the witch hunters out of resentment towards his magical peers and relatives.

to:

He joined the witch hunters out of resentment towards his magical peers and relatives.relatives.
*Probably jossed. It's been stated on Pottermore that most of the witch hunters are actually descended from wizard vigilantes who began to hate wizards once an actual government meant that there was no room for them anymore.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This is more or less the right time and place for him to be around somewhere.

to:

This is more or less the right time and place for him to be around somewhere.somewhere.

[[WMG: One of the witch hunters is a Squib.]]
He joined the witch hunters out of resentment towards his magical peers and relatives.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG:There might be a recapture montage or a sequel hook at the end]]

to:

[[WMG:There might be a recapture montage or a sequel hook at the end]]end]]

[[WMG:HPLovecraft will be mentioned, or make an appearence.]]
This is more or less the right time and place for him to be around somewhere.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%% Lets try to keep speculation to a minimum before the film comes out. Otherwise WMG pages become disproved speculation and not a lot of real Wild Mass Guessing about the actual film which becomes REALLY dated after the film comes out.

to:

%% Lets try to keep speculation to a minimum before the film comes out. Otherwise WMG pages become disproved speculation and not a lot of real Wild Mass Guessing about the actual film which becomes REALLY dated after the film comes out.out.


[[WMG:Lethifolds are going to be in this movie]]
The textbook did kinda imply that they may appear in the Harry Potter series but didn't.
Also Newt Scamander did include them in the textbook

[[WMG:There might be a recapture montage or a sequel hook at the end]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None





%% Lets try to keep speculation to a minimum before the film comes out. Otherwise WMG pages become disproved speculation and not a lot of real Wild Mass Guessing about the actual film.

to:

%% Lets try to keep speculation to a minimum before the film comes out. Otherwise WMG pages become disproved speculation and not a lot of real Wild Mass Guessing about the actual film.film which becomes REALLY dated after the film comes out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%% Lets try to keep speculation to a minimum before the film comes out. Otherwise WMG pages become disproved speculation and not a lot of real Wild Mass Guessing.

to:

%% Lets try to keep speculation to a minimum before the film comes out. Otherwise WMG pages become disproved speculation and not a lot of real Wild Mass Guessing.Guessing about the actual film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC: For the film:]]

to:

[[AC: For the film:]]film:]]
%% Lets try to keep speculation to a minimum before the film comes out. Otherwise WMG pages become disproved speculation and not a lot of real Wild Mass Guessing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC: For the book:]]


Added DiffLines:

[[AC: For the film:]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[WMG: diricawls are divided into magical and non-magical.]]

to:

[[WMG: diricawls Diricawls are divided into magical and non-magical.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[WMG: diricawls are divided into magical and non-magical.]]
* So only the ''muggle'' dodos went extinct.

Top