History Trivia / TheThreeInvestigators

** On the other hand...there was the company Kosmos based in Germany. Long and messy litigious story made short, said PredatoryBusiness attempted to infringe on Arthur's trademark (''and'' Random House's) through various shady and illegal means, whether going behind Ms. Arthur's back; [[BlatantLies claiming she'd given permission for them to continue the series]]; manipulating Random House's legal department after those members long familiar with the series had retired and been replaced by newbie lawyers who could be more easily hoodwinked; or even registering a UsefulNotes/{{Trademark}} for the question mark logo (back-dated to before Random House's contract ran out and the rights reverted to the Arthur estate) and using it to try and claim [[RefugeInAudacity they had sole ownership of the franchise and its characters]], as well as claiming that [[InsaneTrollLogic the different names for the boys in the German printings meant those books had never had any connection to Arthur's and did not belong to him or his daughter, but them]]. Needless to say Ms. Arthur and her lawyers (and those of Sony BMG, the company to which she had actually granted rights and which was properly using and defending them) have fought tooth and nail against all this, and while certain legal battles carry on even to this day, for the most part she has managed to retain sole ownership and rights to the series, protecting it from those who would attempt to make money off it by any means.

* DubNameChange: Jupiter Jones is called "Justus Jonas" in the (much more successful) German version.
** He is called "Hannibal Jones" in the French version, while Peter Crenshaw is renamed "Peter Crentch" and Bob Andrews became "Bob Andy".

* NamesTheSame: Jupiter Jones is also the name of the protagonist of ''Film/JupiterAscending''.

* TechnologyMarchesOn: Unavoidable for a series written mostly in the 60's and 70's, but offenders which stand out are the constant references to payphones, the speakerphone Jupiter invents, walkie talkies and directional finders, the colored chalk to leave trails or send messages when cell phone texting could accomplish the same thing, and the Ghost-to-Ghost Hookup (which would likely not tie up all circuits today and could again be accomplished quicker and easier with texting). What is unfortunate is that Robert Arthur, the original author who came up with most of these inventions, took great pains to [[ShownTheirWork show his work]] and be current with technology, including that which the police and detectives would have; as usual the passage of time turned the series into an UnintentionalPeriodPiece.

* DubNameChange: Jupiter Jones is called "Justus Jonas" in the (much more successful) German version

*** Actually, the case is even more complicated. Robert Arthur didn't leave the rights to his daughter, but to an university, though he did it under the understanding that said rights would revert back after a few years - which is the case under old American copyright, but not under German copyright. After the Random House lost the rights, Kosmos, who was publishing the books, wanted reassurance from Ms. Arthur that she is the actual owner of those rights, since it wanted to keep publishing the highly successful series Germany. While this was still going on Europa, the company which is releasing the equally successful audio dramas based on the books, bought the rights from the daughter, while Kosmos, after figuring out the content of the testament, bought them from the university. For a time Kosmos and Europa were fighting against each other in court. Kosmos rightly insisted on owning the trademark for the Three Investigators because said trademark is not based on the original books, but based on the German translation and the design by Aiga Rasch, both paid for by Kosmos (it's a very distinctive design with three question marks in white, red and blue on a black frame, which is one of the initial reasons for the success of the books in German). Kosmos also insisted that they owned the rights to use the German names of the Three Investigators because, again, they are based on their translation. For a while, the book series continued without an audio drama adaptation following, while Europa published its own audio dramas with the English name used and without the distinctive logo - much to the displeasure of the fans. Europa tried to push through a desist order against Kosmos publishing more books. After the judges had decided in favour of Kosmos interpretation of the law (since copyright cases are usually decided based on the laws of the country where a copyright is used, not based on the law of the country of the original creator), the parties came to an agreement, and everything reverted back to how it was beforehand, with Kosmos publishing the books and Europa doing the audio play adaptations of said books.

*** Actually, the case is even more complicated. Robert Arthur didn't leave the rights to his daughter, but to an university, though he did it under the understanding that said rights would revert back after a few years - which is the case under old American copyright, but not under German copyright. After the Random House lost the rights, Kosmos, who was publishing the books, wanted reassurance from Ms. Arthur that she is the actual owner of those rights, since it wanted to keep publishing the highly successful series Germany. While this was still going on Europa, the company which is releasing the equally successful audio dramas based on the books, bought the rights from the daughter, while Kosmos, after figuring out the content of the testament, bought them from the university. For a time Kosmos and Europa were fighting against each other in court. Kosmos rightly insisted on owning the trademark for the Three Investigators because said trademark is not based on the original books, but based on the German translation and the design by Aiga Rasch, both paid for by Kosmos (it's a very distinctive design with three question marks in white, red and blue on a black frame, which is one of the initial reasons for the success of the books in German). Kosmos also insisted that they owned the rights to use the German names of the Three Investigators because, again, they are based on their translation. For a while, the book series continued without an audio drama adaptation following, while Europa published its own audio dramas with the English name used and without the distinctive logo - much to the displeasure of the fans. After the judges had decided in favour of Kosmos interpretation of the law (since copyright cases are usually decided based on the laws of the country where a copyright is used, not based on the law of the country of the original creator), the parties came to an agreement, and everything reverted back to how it was beforehand, with Kosmos publishing the books and Europa doing the audio play adaptations of said books.

* TechnologyMarchesOn: Unavoidable for a series written mostly in the 60's and 70's, but offenders which stand out are the constant references to payphones, the speakerphone Jupiter invents, walkie talkies and directional finders, the colored chalk to leave trails or send messages when cell phone texting could accomplish the same thing, and the Ghost-to-Ghost Hookup (which would likely not tie up all circuits today and could again be accomplished quicker and easier with texting). What is unfortunate is that Robert Arthur, the original author who came up with most of these inventions, took great pains to [[ShownTheirWork show his work]] and be current with technology, including that which the police and detectives would have; as usual the passage of time turned the series into an UnintentionalPeriodPiece.

* RecycledScript: Either this or SelfPlagiarism (but from within the same series rather than the same writer), but in the case of ''Coughing Dragon'', Nick West included three different scenes which were extremely similar to ones from the early Arthur books. This might be considered a case of InternalHomage, except that the writing in the scenes are almost word-for-word the same: the beginning, where Jupiter muses about the possibility of committing a robbery so as to learn how to think like a criminal, is the same exact opening as ''Vanishing Treasure'' and the Rainbow Jewels; the creepy phone call they get warning them to stay away from the cave is almost identical to the one they received in ''Terror Castle''; and the article Bob reads about the death of Seaside is framed with some of the same language used for the article on the eponymous ''Fiery Eye'', from Bob being asked to work at the library where he happens to find the needed book out on a table, to the idea of being "plagued by ill fortune", to the passage of fifty years being involved (since Seaside died/since the ruby had been hidden to rid it of its curse) and the book being several years old. There's also another small one to the same book, where Pete asks for a vote only to have Blackbeard the mynah bird interrupt with, "Aye! Aye! Aye!" and Pete saying he doesn't count.

* RecycledScript: Either this or SelfPlagiarism (but from within the same series rather than the same writer), but in the case of ''Coughing Dragon'', Nick West included three different scenes which were extremely similar to ones from the early Arthur books. This might be considered a case of InternalHomage, except that the writing in the scenes are almost word-for-word the same: the beginning, where Jupiter muses about the possibility of committing a robbery so as to learn how to think like a criminal, is the same exact opening as ''Vanishing Treasure'' and the Rainbow Jewels; the creepy phone call they get warning them to stay away from the cave is almost identical to the one they received in ''Terror Castle''; and the article Bob reads about the death of Seaside is framed with some of the same language used for the article on the eponymous ''Fiery Eye'', from Bob being asked to work at the library where he happens to find the needed book out on a table, to the idea of being "plagued by ill fortune", to the passage of fifty years being involved (since Seaside died/since the ruby had been hidden to rid it of its curse) and the book being several years old.

* NamesTheSame: Jupiter Jones is also the name of the protagonist of ''Film/JupiterAscending''

** For now, however, she is rightfully keeping the books and all rights to them close to her chest, only allowing the filming of a few movies and the continuation of the book series overseas where they are still written and marketed respectfully--which means that [[WhyFandomCantHaveNiceThings for the foreseeable future, there won't be any new American books, or American reprints of the old ones]]. Details of all this can be found in [[http://www.rocky-beach.com/special/e_arthur/arthur_elizabeth2007-original.html this interview]].

** For now, however, she is rightfully keeping the books and all rights to them close to her chest, only allowing the filming of a few movies and the continuation of the book series overseas where they are still written and marketed respectfully--which means that [[WhyTheFandomCantHaveNiceThings for the foreseeable future, there won't be any new American books, or American reprints of the old ones]]. Details of all this can be found in [[http://www.rocky-beach.com/special/e_arthur/arthur_elizabeth2007-original.html this interview]].

[[labelnote Series titles]]

1. The Secret of Terror Castle
2. The Mystery of the Stuttering Parrot
3. The Mystery of the Whispering Mummy
4. The Mystery of the Green Ghost
5. The Mystery of the Vanishing Treasure
6. The Secret of Skeleton Island
7. The Mystery of the Fiery Eye
8. The Mystery of the Silver Spider
9. The Mystery of the Screaming Clock
10. The Mystery of the Moaning Cave
11. The Mystery of the Talking Skull
12. The Mystery of the Laughing Shadow
13. The Secret of the Crooked Cat
14. The Mystery of the Coughing Dragon
15. The Mystery of the Flaming Footprints
16. The Mystery of the Nervous Lion
17. The Mystery of the Singing Serpent
18. The Mystery of the Shrinking House
19. The Secret of Phantom Lake
20. The Mystery of Monster Mountain
21. The Secret of the Haunted Mirror
22. The Mystery of the Dead Man's Riddle
23. The Mystery of the Invisible Dog
24. The Mystery of Death Trap Mine
25. The Mystery of the Dancing Devil
26. The Mystery of the Headless Horse
27. The Mystery of the Magic Circle
28. The Mystery of the Deadly Double
29. The Mystery of the Sinister Scarecrow
30. The Secret of Shark Reef
31. The Mystery of the Scar-Faced Beggar
32. The Mystery of the Blazing Cliffs
33. The Mystery of the Purple Pirate
34. The Mystery of the Wandering Caveman
35. The Mystery of the Kidnapped Whale
36. The Mystery of the Missing Mermaid
37. The Mystery of the Two-Toed Pigeon
38. The Mystery of the Smashing Glass
39. The Mystery of the Trail of Terror
40. The Mystery of the Rogues' Reunion
41. The Mystery of the Creep-Show Crooks
42. The Mystery of Wrecker's Rock
43. The Mystery of the Cranky Collector

The Crimebusters Series

1. Hot Wheels
2. Murder to Go
3. Rough Stuff
4. Funny Business
5. An Ear for Danger
6. Thriller Diller
7. Reel Trouble
8. Shoot the Works
9. Foul Play
10. Long Shot
11. Fatal Error

The Find Your Fate Series

1. The Case of the Weeping Coffin
2. The Case of the Dancing Dinosaur
3. The Case of the House of Horrors
4. The Case of the Savage Statue[[/labelnote]]

** On the one hand there's Random House, which made it a habit of continually reprinting new editions of the series (in most cases, however, only the first eleven or so) solely to renew their copyright so that the rights would not revert to the estate of Robert Arthur (they didn't want to lose [[MoneyDearBoy their royalties]]). At the same time, because so many changes were made in personnel, executives, and even owners over the years, very few at Random House knew precisely how valuable ''The Three Investigators'' was as a franchise, let alone why. This resulted in [[ExecutiveMeddling a number of ill-considered moves]] such as attempting to age the boys up, [[DarkerAndEdgier injecting more action into the stories]], and creating new series runs which focused on being more modern and hip. It eventually got to the point that Elizabeth Arthur, Robert's daughter, had to sue before she could finally get Random House to let the copyright lapse, so that a) she could receive the royalties she had been rightfully owed due to her father's contract and b) she could, conceivably, find a new publisher and new authors who would do right by the series.

** On the other hand...there was the company Kosmos based in Germany. Long and messy litigious story made short, said PredatoryBusiness attempted to infringe on Arthur's trademark (''and'' Random House's) through various shady and illegal means, whether going behind Ms. Arthur's back; [[BlatantLies claiming she'd given permission for them to continue the series]]; manipulating Random House's legal department after those members long familiar with the series had retired and been replaced by newbie lawyers who could be more easily hoodwinked; or even registering a UsefulNotes/{{Trademark}} for the question mark logo (back-dated to before Random House's contract ran out and the rights reverted to the Arthur estate) and using it to try and claim [[RefugeInAudacity they had sole ownership of the franchise and its characters]], as well as claiming that [[InsaneTrollLogic the different names for the boys in the German printings meant those books had never had any connection to Arthur's and did not belong to him or his daughter, but them]]. Needless to say Ms. Arthur and her lawyers (and Random House's, once they finally realized the extent to which Kosmos had been using and stealing from them) have fought tooth and nail against all this, and while certain legal battles carry on even to this day, for the most part she has managed to retain sole ownership and rights to the series, protecting it from those who would attempt to make money off it by any means.

** On the other hand...there was the company Kosmos based in Germany. Long and messy litigious story made short, said PredatoryBusiness attempted to infringe on Arthur's trademark (''and'' Random House's) through various shady and illegal means, whether going behind Ms. Arthur's back, [[BlatantLies claiming she'd given permission for them to continue the series]], manipulating Random House's legal department after those members long familiar with the series had retired and been replaced by newbie lawyers who could be more easily hoodwinked, or even registering a UsefulNotes/{{Trademark}} for the question mark logo (back-dated to before Random House's contract ran out and the rights reverted to the Arthur estate) and using it to try and claim [[RefugeInAudacity they had sole ownership of the franchise and its characters]]. Needless to say Ms. Arthur and her lawyers (and Random House's, once they finally realized the extent to which Kosmos had been using and stealing from them) have fought tooth and nail against all this, and while certain legal battles carry on even to this day, for the most part she has managed to retain sole ownership and rights to the series, protecting it from those who would attempt to make money off it by any means.
** For now, however, she is rightfully keeping the books and all rights to them close to her chest, only allowing the filming of a few movies and the continuation of the book series overseas where they are still written and marketed respectfully--which means that [[WhyTheFandomCantHaveNiceThings for the foreseeable future, there won't be any new American books, or American reprints of the old ones]].

** On the other hand...there was the company Kosmos based in Germany. Long and messy litigious story made short, said PredatoryBusiness attempted to infringe on Arthur's trademark (''and'' Random House's) through various shady and illegal means, whether going behind Ms. Arthur's back, [[BlatantLies claiming she'd given permission for them to continue the series]], manipulating Random House's legal department after those members long familiar with the series had retired and been replaced by newbie lawyers who could be more easily hoodwinked, or even registering a [[UsefulNotes/{{Trademark}}]] for the question mark logo (back-dated to before Random House's contract ran out and the rights reverted to the Arthur estate) and using it to try and claim [[RefugeInAudacity they had sole ownership of the franchise and its characters]]. Needless to say Ms. Arthur and her lawyers (and Random House's, once they finally realized the extent to which Kosmos had been using and stealing from them) have fought tooth and nail against all this, and while certain legal battles carry on even to this day, for the most part she has managed to retain sole ownership and rights to the series, protecting it from those who would attempt to make money off it by any means.

** On the other hand...there was the company Kosmos based in Germany. Long and messy litigious story made short, said PredatoryCompany attempted to infringe on Arthur's trademark (''and'' Random House's) through various shady and illegal means, whether going behind Ms. Arthur's back, [[BlatantLies claiming she'd given permission for them to continue the series]], manipulating Random House's legal department after those members long familiar with the series had retired and been replaced by newbie lawyers who could be more easily hoodwinked, or even registering a [[UsefulNotes/{{Trademark}}]] for the question mark logo (back-dated to before Random House's contract ran out and the rights reverted to the Arthur estate) and using it to try and claim [[RefugeInAudacity they had sole ownership of the franchise and its characters]]. Needless to say Ms. Arthur and her lawyers (and Random House's, once they finally realized the extent to which Kosmos had been using and stealing from them) have fought tooth and nail against all this, and while certain legal battles carry on even to this day, for the most part she has managed to retain sole ownership and rights to the series, protecting it from those who would attempt to make money off it by any means.