Follow TV Tropes

Following

History TearJerker / OnceUponATime

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[AC: Episode 15 - Breadcrumbs]]

to:

[[AC: Episode 15 16 - Breadcrumbs]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[AC: Deleted Scenes]]
* Now knowing Ivy's true identity as Drizella, Lucy expresses hope that she can make a HeelFaceTurn... [[InnocentlyInsensitive while she is in the middle of grieving her mother]]. When Ivy rejects her, Lucy tells her that [[ShipSinking she will never be with Henry]] and be with Jacinda instead before storming off. Afterwards, Lucy calls Henry.
* While attempting to find Anastasia, Ivy assumes Gothel trapped her into the same well she pushed her in [[CainAndAbel (and tried to push Anastasia in herself)]], but Gothel reveals that Anastasia is safe with her and rebukes and taunts Ivy [[KickTheDog (over her mother's death no less)]]. After Gothel wins the argument, Ivy tells her this isn't over.
* Ivy finds Gothel and Anastasia and attempts to make amends with the latter while trying to get her {{Revenge}} on the former, but just when it looks like Ana will return to Ivy and reject Gothel, [[BaitAndSwitch she chooses neither Ivy nor Gothel]] and pushes them away before fleeing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[OmicidalManiac Got]][[WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds hel]]'s backstory. She was a tree nymph in the Land Without Magic [[TimeAbyss thousands of years ago]] and was curious about humans. The first human she meets, [[AlphaBitch Is]][[BitchInSheepsClothing la]], [[FalseFriend pretends to befriend her]], before humiliating her by [[KickTheDog pouring a bucket of mud on her head]] and [[FantasticRacism calling her an "abomination"]] even going as far as to [[LackOfEmpathy destroy Gothel's home and murder her entire family/species]]. Gothel manages to get revenge on Isla by killing her and the rest of humanity except for a magical girl named Seraphina before leaving to the New Enchanted Forest with her, vowing revenge on humanity once they evolve again. In the present, she seems '''far''' too wounded to learn the error of her ways and make a HeelFaceTurn, unlike Victoria and Ivy.

to:

* [[OmicidalManiac [[OmnicidalManiac Got]][[WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds hel]]'s backstory. She was a tree nymph in the Land Without Magic [[TimeAbyss thousands of years ago]] and was curious about humans. The first human she meets, [[AlphaBitch Is]][[BitchInSheepsClothing la]], [[FalseFriend pretends to befriend her]], before humiliating her by [[KickTheDog pouring a bucket of mud on her head]] and [[FantasticRacism calling her an "abomination"]] even going as far as to [[LackOfEmpathy destroy Gothel's home and murder her entire family/species]]. Gothel manages to get revenge on Isla by killing her and the rest of humanity except for a magical girl named Seraphina before leaving to the New Enchanted Forest with her, vowing revenge on humanity once they evolve again. In the present, she seems '''far''' too wounded to learn the error of her ways and make a HeelFaceTurn, unlike Victoria and Ivy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* [[OmicidalManiac Got]][[WoobieDestroyerOfWorlds hel]]'s backstory. She was a tree nymph in the Land Without Magic [[TimeAbyss thousands of years ago]] and was curious about humans. The first human she meets, [[AlphaBitch Is]][[BitchInSheepsClothing la]], [[FalseFriend pretends to befriend her]], before humiliating her by [[KickTheDog pouring a bucket of mud on her head]] and [[FantasticRacism calling her an "abomination"]] even going as far as to [[LackOfEmpathy destroy Gothel's home and murder her entire family/species]]. Gothel manages to get revenge on Isla by killing her and the rest of humanity except for a magical girl named Seraphina before leaving to the New Enchanted Forest with her, vowing revenge on humanity once they evolve again. In the present, she seems '''far''' too wounded to learn the error of her ways and make a HeelFaceTurn, unlike Victoria and Ivy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The whole slew of {{Montage}}s at the end. For anyone who's been a fan of this show throughout all the years, through its ups and downs (of story quality as well as actual events), it's quite the moving and overwhelming thing, getting to see so many memorable and iconic shots, as well as all the love stories and families displayed one last time, and especially all the deaths and losses. Even seeing all the realms together, and all the places and things in Storybrooke one last time, can be enough to set off the waterworks. (Though one wonders what will happen to the pawnshop now--[[CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming will one or several of the Henrys run it? Perhaps with the help of Alice?]])

to:

* The whole slew of {{Montage}}s at the end. For anyone who's been a fan of this show throughout all the years, through its ups and downs (of story quality as well as actual events), it's quite the moving and overwhelming thing, getting to see so many memorable and iconic shots, as well as all the love stories and families displayed one last time, and especially all the deaths and losses. Even seeing all the realms together, and all the places and things in Storybrooke one last time, can be enough to set off the waterworks. (Though one wonders what will happen to the pawnshop now--[[CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming will one or several of the Henrys run it? Or Gideon (as seen under Fiona's Dark Curse)? Perhaps with the help of Alice?]])
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This requires a little more unpacking. [[spoiler:Several times before this Emma had thought she'd lost Neal, or that he was dead, only for him to turn up all right and often helping save the day. Now after thinking he might have become a Winged Monkey, she instead learns he gave his life to bring his father back from the dead, that the only thing keeping him alive is being trapped inside Gold's body--and he insists she use her magic to separate them so that Gold can tell them how to stop the Wicked Witch. So ''she'' is forced to commit the act that finally ends his life. Then she and Gold get to both [[DiedInYourArmsTonight hold him in their arms as he dies]], while he insists his HeroicSacrifice is worth it so they can save everyone and tells his father he finally taught him what was important, about sacrifice. Then we get her giving the news to Snow, the MomentOfSilence where Snow and David tell Belle and Hook--Belle breaks down and even Hook is shedding ManlyTears--and finally Emma has to break the news to Henry... who still doesn't even remember Neal or their time together.]] It's utterly, utterly heartbreaking.

to:

** This requires a little more unpacking. [[spoiler:Several times before this Emma had thought she'd lost Neal, or that he was dead, only for him to turn up all right and often helping save the day. Now after thinking he might have become a Winged Monkey, she instead learns he gave his life to bring his father back from the dead, that the only thing keeping him alive is being trapped inside Gold's body--and he insists she use her magic to separate them so that Gold can tell them how to stop the Wicked Witch. So ''she'' is forced to commit the act that finally ends his life. Then she and Gold get to both [[DiedInYourArmsTonight hold him in their arms as he dies]], dies]] ([[HistoryRepeats exactly the way she held Graham!]]), while he insists his HeroicSacrifice is worth it so they can save everyone and tells his father he finally taught him what was important, about sacrifice. Then we get her giving the news to Snow, the MomentOfSilence where Snow and David tell Belle and Hook--Belle breaks down and even Hook is shedding ManlyTears--and finally Emma has to break the news to Henry... who still doesn't even remember Neal or their time together.]] It's utterly, utterly heartbreaking.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler:Red's a werewolf, she's killed and half eaten her true love Peter, the villagers are coming to kill her, she has to go on the run and leave Granny behind, and all this while she's still reeling, confused and horrified at what's happened to her.]]

to:

* [[spoiler:Red's a werewolf, she's killed and half eaten her true love Peter, the villagers are coming to kill her, she has to go on the run and leave Granny behind, and all this while she's still reeling, confused and horrified at what's happened to her.what she is and what she's done.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Abigail having tried to get over Frederick but failed.

to:

** Abigail having tried to get over recover Frederick but failed.failed (because she couldn't give him true love's kiss through the grill of a helmet, but tried anyway, over and over again).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* King George's fate is sad, no matter how much you end up hating him.

to:

* King George's fate is sad, no matter how much you end up hating him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Tinged with a slightly heartwarming tear-jerk when Archie told Emma to get Henry out first,not bothering to try and save him too, clearly willing to fall to his death to give Henry a slightly better chance of being rescued in time.

to:

** Tinged with a slightly heartwarming tear-jerk when Archie told Emma to get Henry out first,not bothering first, instead of trying to try and save him too, them both, clearly willing to fall to his death die to give Henry a slightly better chance of being rescued in time.
surviving.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* And what's Archie doing the next time we see him? [[DrowningMySorrows Having a drink.]]
* That moment in the climax when it seemed certain Archie was going to die when the mine elevator was about to collapse with him still in it. Definitely makes it turn to tears of relief when it's revealed that he saved himself at the last second with his umbrella.

to:

* ** And what's Archie doing Archie, the next time we see him? him, [[DrowningMySorrows Having a drink.is drowning his sorrows.]]
* That moment in the climax when it seemed certain Archie was going to die when the mine elevator was about to collapse with him still in it. Definitely makes it turn to tears of relief when it's revealed that he saved himself at the last second with his umbrella.
umbrella.
** Tinged with a slightly heartwarming tear-jerk when Archie told Emma to get Henry out first,not bothering to try and save him too, clearly willing to fall to his death to give Henry a slightly better chance of being rescued in time.

Added: 345

Changed: 41

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Queen's struggle then ultimate decision to kill her ''own'' father. There's no going back for her after that.

to:

* The Queen's struggle then ultimate decision to kill her ''own'' father. There's no going back
** It seems almost worse when you see that her father seems genuinely torn between his obvious desire
for her after that.to turn away from the path of self-destructive vengeance (along with a small amount of fear for his own life), and his desire to do whatever it takes to make her as happy as he can, even if that means dying for the sake of her revenge.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The playground scene, especially the part near the end where Emma, close to tears, tells Henry how she was left by the freeway and later rejected by her foster parents and that he's lucky to have someone who wants him never mind loves him.

to:

* The playground scene, especially the part near the end where Emma, close to tears, tells Henry how she was left by the freeway and later rejected by her foster parents and that he's lucky to have someone who wants him never mind and loves him.

Added: 705

Changed: 413

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Made even worse when he finds out [[spoiler:about Bae's/Neal's fate.]]

to:

** Made even worse when he finds out [[spoiler:about Bae's/Neal's fate.]] Further emphasized by a DeletedScene where, after examining the cannery and discovering Regina has been rescued, he gets caught by Greg and Tamara and asks the latter about "trouble in paradise" when Neal found out her true nature. [[spoiler:Although he tries to brush it off as nothing, both his initial reaction when she says no because she killed him, and the look on his face as he turns away, says it all.]]


Added DiffLines:


It's not made clear which episode it would have been in (most likely "We are Both"), but a DeletedScene after things start getting back to normal in Storybrooke again involves Archie stopping outside the window of Gold's pawn shop and seeing ''those puppets''. The look on his face is indescribable, and makes the scene an important acknowledgement of something otherwise glossed over throughout the show, that not only are Geppetto's parents still there, they're apparently stuck like that forever since there are plenty of times Gold would have restored them if he could have. It's no wonder this is never revisited and Archie is never seen confronting Gold or being anything but a good friend to Marco.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Rumple recalling his love with Belle, describing it as "a shimmer of light in his darkness". Charming asks what happened, to which Rumple replies that [[spoiler:she died. He says it in his usual sing-song voice, but you can tell he's still hurt.]]

to:

* Rumple recalling his love with Belle, describing it as "a shimmer brief flicker of light in his amidst an ocean of darkness". Charming asks what happened, to which Rumple replies that [[spoiler:she died. He says it in his usual sing-song voice, but you can tell he's still hurt.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** A DeletedScene which takes place right before this, when Emma comes to tell Mary Margaret that Regina hid the shovel and there's no evidence to prove she framed her. Mary Margaret breaks down, noting how she could have escaped but she came back because she believed in Emma, that Emma could save her...and now she's failed. Not only is Mary Margaret's pain quite clear, but so is Emma's as she desperately apologizes. By the time Mary Margaret demands she leave, both women are in tears. Knowing they are mother and daughter just adds an even more tragic subtext to the scene.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ivy's palpable fear of being the next victim of the Candy Killer.

to:

* Ivy's palpable fear of being the next victim of the Candy Killer.
Killer, especially since it leaves her open to being manipulated into doing the wrong thing ''again'' (this time by Dr. Facilier) and almost ruining all of her [[TheAtoner attempts at atonement.]]

Added: 687

Changed: 116

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Gold giving Emma Graham's things. Not only does he genuinely seem to care about Graham as a good man who didn't deserve his fate, he insists Emma take something to remember him by. And then there's what he says when he offers her the walkie-talkies...especially when you consider what ends up happening between him and Bae in Season 3.
-->'''Gold''': Please...they grow up so fast. ... You enjoy these with your boy. Your time together is precious, you know? That's the thing about children...before you know it, you lose them.
** And Emma not only does take them (and use them with Henry for quite some time to come), but she eventually takes Graham's jacket at the end of the episode.




to:

* Emma, forced to watch Henry from a distance because of her mistake in trusting Sidney and trying to expose Regina.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* That moment in the climax when it seemed certain Archie was going to die when the mine elevator was about to collapse with him still in it.

to:

* That moment in the climax when it seemed certain Archie was going to die when the mine elevator was about to collapse with him still in it.
it. Definitely makes it turn to tears of relief when it's revealed that he saved himself at the last second with his umbrella.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* It's a brief moment, and played for BlackHumor, but when Wish!Rumple has the Blue Fairy dragged in to see the effects of Regina's blood and Prince Henry's darkened heart on his storybooks, he comments that fairies always make for good torture and experimentation. Which, since this version of him never learned the truth about Fiona, means he's still acting out of his rage and hate toward the mother he believes he abandoned him (and the fact that without the Dark Curse, he never got reunited with Bae, who also still died, and he blames this on Blue as well).

to:

* It's a brief moment, and played for BlackHumor, but when Wish!Rumple has the Blue Fairy dragged in to see the effects of Regina's blood and Prince Henry's darkened heart on his storybooks, he comments that fairies always make for good torture and experimentation. Which, since this version of him never learned the truth about Fiona, means he's still acting out of his rage and hate toward the mother he believes he abandoned him (and the fact that without the Dark Curse, he never got reunited with Bae, who also still died, and he blames this on Blue as well).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Well, [[spoiler:Alice ''does'' have a thing for shiny things. She'd be in paradise...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Hook, eyes full of tears, saying "Goodbye, old friend" [[spoiler: over Rumple's dead body, a callback to when Rumple called him the closest thing to a friend he ever had.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Zelena's guilt over what she did to Nick, [[spoiler: aka Hansel]] in the past and wanting to make up for it now.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The fact that Anastasia and Drizella used to have a great sisterly bond that held them through tough times but the fact that Drizella was made TheUnfavorite by her mother made her hate Anastasia. [[spoiler:Luckily, their sisterly bond is eventually restored and they return to the New Enchanted Forest together.]]
* Drizella's regret over [[spoiler:killing Gretel]]. Gothel then congratulates her and welcomes her into the Coven, but Drizella says that she didn't want to do it.

to:

* The fact that Anastasia and Drizella used to have a great sisterly bond that held them through tough times but the fact that Drizella was made TheUnfavorite by her mother made her hate Anastasia. Anastasia, and Anastasia's recent apprenticeship under Gothel has made her hate Drizella. ManipulativeBastard Dr. Facilier [[KickTheDog only makes this worse between them.]] [[spoiler:Luckily, their sisterly bond is eventually restored and they return to the New Enchanted Forest together.]]
* Drizella's regret over [[spoiler:killing Gretel]].Gretel, even if it was out of self-defense]]. Gothel then congratulates her and welcomes her into the Coven, but Drizella says that she didn't want to do it.
* Ivy's palpable fear of being the next victim of the Candy Killer.

Added: 486

Changed: 541

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In a different sense, [[spoiler: Wish!Rumple's death, as deserved as it was. Wish!Rumple still has the same background that made Rumple a TragicVillain, but was never able to overcome it and stayed evil to the end. As he dies, he reveals himself as the coward he is, even whimpering "No more Rumple?" as he turns to dust. If that wasn't bad enough, the dust blows into the fireplace, a clear visual showing that he's ''not'' going to be reuniting with Wish!Belle in the afterlife.]]

to:

** The fact that Alice ''squeaks in shock and reaches out to stop him'' before he [[spoiler:tears out his heart.]] She knows the goodness in him, has seen the man behind the beast, knows everything - and she doesn't want her friend to die.
***
In a different sense, [[spoiler: Wish!Rumple's death, as deserved as it was. Wish!Rumple still has the same background that made Rumple a TragicVillain, but was never able to overcome it and stayed evil to the end. As he dies, he reveals himself as the coward he is, even whimpering "No more Rumple?" as he turns to dust. If that wasn't bad enough, the dust blows into the fireplace, a clear visual showing that he's ''not'' going to be reuniting with Wish!Belle in the afterlife.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In a different sense, [[spoiler: Wish!Rumple's death, as deserved as it was. Wish!Rumple still has the same background that made Rumple a TragicVillain, but was never able to overcome it and stayed evil to the end. As he dies, he reveals himself as the coward he is, even whimpering "No more Rumple?" as he turns to dust. If that wasn't bad enough, the dust blows into the fireplace, a clear visual showing that he's ''not'' going to be reuniting with Wish!Belle in the afterlife.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler:Rumple's death. After all these years, seeing him finally do the right thing, not be a coward, and save everyone (and having it stick), it's both very sad and extremely moving for him to truly sacrifice himself. The fact he does it for (a version of) Hook and Alice, that it lets him be TogetherInDeath with Belle, and that Regina thanks him for his last lesson about darkness and light as she kisses his forehead, is the icing on the cake. The only way it could have been better is if he'd gotten to be reunited with Neal/Bae too, but then everything had been about his romantic love with Belle, and presumably Michael James-Raymond wasn't available.]]

to:

* [[spoiler:Rumple's death. After all these years, seeing him finally do the right thing, not be a coward, and save everyone (and having it stick), it's both very sad and extremely moving for him to truly sacrifice himself. The fact he does it for (a version of) Hook and Alice, that it lets him be TogetherInDeath with Belle, and that Regina thanks him for his last lesson about darkness and light as she kisses his forehead, is the icing on the cake. The only way it could have been better is if he'd gotten to be reunited with Neal/Bae too, but then everything had been about his romantic love with Belle, and presumably Michael James-Raymond Raymond James wasn't available.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[spoiler:Rumple's death. After all these years, seeing him finally do the right thing, not be a coward, and save everyone {and having it stick), it's both very sad and extremely moving for him to truly sacrifice himself. The fact he does it for (a version of) Hook and Alice, that it lets him be TogetherInDeath with Belle, and that Regina thanks him for his last lesson about darkness and light as she kisses his forehead, is the icing on the cake. The only way it could have been better is if he'd gotten to be reunited with Neal/Bae too, but then everything had been about his romantic love with Belle, and presumably Michael James-Raymond wasn't available.]]

to:

* [[spoiler:Rumple's death. After all these years, seeing him finally do the right thing, not be a coward, and save everyone {and (and having it stick), it's both very sad and extremely moving for him to truly sacrifice himself. The fact he does it for (a version of) Hook and Alice, that it lets him be TogetherInDeath with Belle, and that Regina thanks him for his last lesson about darkness and light as she kisses his forehead, is the icing on the cake. The only way it could have been better is if he'd gotten to be reunited with Neal/Bae too, but then everything had been about his romantic love with Belle, and presumably Michael James-Raymond wasn't available.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


[[AC: Episode 22 - Leaving Storybrooke]]
* [[spoiler:Rumple's death. After all these years, seeing him finally do the right thing, not be a coward, and save everyone {and having it stick), it's both very sad and extremely moving for him to truly sacrifice himself. The fact he does it for (a version of) Hook and Alice, that it lets him be TogetherInDeath with Belle, and that Regina thanks him for his last lesson about darkness and light as she kisses his forehead, is the icing on the cake. The only way it could have been better is if he'd gotten to be reunited with Neal/Bae too, but then everything had been about his romantic love with Belle, and presumably Michael James-Raymond wasn't available.]]
* It's a brief moment, and played for BlackHumor, but when Wish!Rumple has the Blue Fairy dragged in to see the effects of Regina's blood and Prince Henry's darkened heart on his storybooks, he comments that fairies always make for good torture and experimentation. Which, since this version of him never learned the truth about Fiona, means he's still acting out of his rage and hate toward the mother he believes he abandoned him (and the fact that without the Dark Curse, he never got reunited with Bae, who also still died, and he blames this on Blue as well).
* More TearsOfJoy, but getting to see everyone together at the end, celebrating and happy, both Hooks with their daughters, Emma there to see Regina get her happy ending, and Regina [[spoiler:becoming the Good Queen she was meant to be, and would have been if not for Cora]]... All the people we've grown to love are finally together, all with a role (albeit offscreen in many cases), all working together for their common good. And it's ''so'' satisfying.
* The whole slew of {{Montage}}s at the end. For anyone who's been a fan of this show throughout all the years, through its ups and downs (of story quality as well as actual events), it's quite the moving and overwhelming thing, getting to see so many memorable and iconic shots, as well as all the love stories and families displayed one last time, and especially all the deaths and losses. Even seeing all the realms together, and all the places and things in Storybrooke one last time, can be enough to set off the waterworks. (Though one wonders what will happen to the pawnshop now--[[CrowningMomentOfHeartwarming will one or several of the Henrys run it? Perhaps with the help of Alice?]])
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In order to free Merlin, Emma needs to use a tear of lost love. How does she try to get one? [[spoiler: Regina chooses to re-live the memory of watching her mother kill her first love, Daniel. Even after all those years and having managed to find love again with Robin Hood, it's clear that Regina never forgot how much she misses her stable boy.]]

to:

** * In order to free Merlin, Emma needs to use a tear of lost love. How does she try to get one? [[spoiler: Regina chooses to re-live the memory of watching her mother kill her first love, Daniel. Even after all those years and having managed to find love again with Robin Hood, it's clear that Regina never forgot how much she misses her stable boy.]]

Top