Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / WhyWomenKill

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OoohMeAccentsSlipping: In-universe, later when [[spoiler: her life starts falling apart, Rita's cultured accent gives way to show her Texas twang.]]

to:

* OoohMeAccentsSlipping: OohMeAccentsSlipping: In-universe, later when [[spoiler: her life starts falling apart, Rita's cultured accent gives way to show her Texas twang.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OoohMeAccentsSlipping: In-universe, later when [[spoiler: her life starts falling apart, Rita's cultured accent gives way to show her Texas twang.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IgnorantOfTheirIgnorance: Rita [[spoiler: had long believed her abusive first husband was shot dead by Isabel and she ran off. It takes Catherine to let her know Harry is very much alive and since they were never divorced, that means Rita's marriage to Carlo was never legal and thus she inherits nothing.]]

to:

* IgnorantOfTheirIgnorance: IgnorantOfTheirOwnIgnorance: Rita [[spoiler: had long believed her abusive first husband was shot dead by Isabel and she ran off. It takes Catherine to let her know Harry is very much alive and since they were never divorced, that means Rita's marriage to Carlo was never legal and thus she inherits nothing.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IgnorantOfTheirIgnorance: Rita [[spoiler: had long believed her abusive first husband was shot dead by Isabel and she ran off. It takes Catherine to let her know Harry is very much alive and since they were never divorced, that means Rita's marriage to Carlo was never legal and thus she inherits nothing.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Irony}}: As the narration for Episode 8 notes, [[spoiler: Rita has cheated, murdered her abusive husband and worked as a prostitute but is now in jail for a crime she ''didn't'' commit.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HypocrisyNod: Any time Bertram tries to bring up Alma creating lies or playing sneaky games, she can fire right back that he has no room to talk, given he kept quiet on murdering two dozen people during their marriage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* INeverSaidItWasPoison: When Rita brings up "the old woman who cleans for you," Scooter muses he never told her he had a cleaning lady. Luckily, he's too dumb to think much of it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PopularityCycle:
** The Garden Club. Initially, Rita is in charge, and she makes a point to scorn and disparage Alma. Then Alma fights back, and gets [[spoiler:Rita's]] life ruined: [[spoiler:she gets locked up, she loses her friends, family, and house; she gets thrown out of the club; Alma even kills her cousin and only true friend Isabel.]] But then [[spoiler:Alma goes too far, and Grace takes revenge on her.]]
** GoldDigger Scooter is nice, but he's quick to replace Rita for Catherine when Catherine is poised to inherit all of Carlos's money. He does, however, make some effort to be kind to Rita still, risking his own position to give her money and clothes.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not the trope, they take deliberate action here to cause the murder


* MurderByInaction: [[spoiler:How Beth Ann kills her husband. She and Mary hatch a plan to get rid of their husbands by making Ralph think Mary had an affair with Rob, igniting a fight between them. Then when the guns come out, Beth Ann tosses Rob a gun with [[ItWorksBetterWithBullets all the bullets removed]], letting him be gunned down by Ralph.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not a Justified Trope trope, that's just THE TROPE


* InformedJudaism: Aside from Eli mentioning it, there's no real sign that he's Jewish (aside from this being a common Jewish male first name). [[JustifiedTrope Justified]] as he seems to be a cultural/secular Jew.

to:

* InformedJudaism: Aside from Eli mentioning it, there's no real sign that he's Jewish (aside from this being a common Jewish male first name). [[JustifiedTrope Justified]] as he seems to be a cultural/secular Jew.Jewish.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ConvenientPhotograph: Of sorts. [[spoiler:Vern's photograph of Catherine and Scooter having sex conveniently implicates Alma in the background, who's hiding in the house. This is very ''inconvenient'' for Bernard and Alma, but very helpful for Isabella.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoreDiverseSequel: Season 1 had two significant characters of color: Simone in the 1980s, and Taylor in 2019. 1949 replaces this with a Latina family: the Castillos (Catherine, her father Carlos, Carlos's wife Rita, and [[spoiler:her cousin]] Isabella), and a black LoveInterest (Vern), who is also disabled.

to:

* MoreDiverseSequel: Season 1 had two significant characters of color: Simone in the 1980s, and Taylor in 2019. 1949 replaces this with a Latina family: the Castillos (Catherine, her father Carlos, Carlos's wife Rita, and [[spoiler:her cousin]] Isabella), and a black LoveInterest (Vern), who is also disabled. It also has ClosetGay supporting characters, [[spoiler:Joan and Grace.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DramaticIrony:
** Dee is dating Vern, the private investigator [[spoiler:who is inadvertently trying to figure out if Rita is innocent (she is). In fact, Dee's father Bertram killed Carlos, and Alma frames Rita for the crime.]]
** Scooter is moved in by Catherine as her lover, while she tries to figure out who Rita's lover is/was with Scooter's help. It's Scooter himself.


Added DiffLines:

* MoreDiverseSequel: Season 1 had two significant characters of color: Simone in the 1980s, and Taylor in 2019. 1949 replaces this with a Latina family: the Castillos (Catherine, her father Carlos, Carlos's wife Rita, and [[spoiler:her cousin]] Isabella), and a black LoveInterest (Vern), who is also disabled.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Power Walk was renamed by TRS to Team Power Walk. Removing or reworking misuse when necessary. Removing because the trope only applies to a group walking, not just one person.


*** Karl met Simone at a high-society benefit. She made a grand entrance, wearing a PimpedOutDress and diamonds, and [[PowerWalk strutted her heart out, letting the whole world know how fabulous she was.]]

to:

*** Karl met Simone at a high-society benefit. She made a grand entrance, wearing a PimpedOutDress and diamonds, and [[PowerWalk strutted her heart out, letting the whole world know how fabulous she was.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Why Women Kill'' premiered its first season on Creator/CBSAllAccess on August 15, 2019. The second season aired on June 3, 2021. In January 2022, it was canceled despite initial reports that it had been renewed for Season 3, and will not be made.

to:

''Why Women Kill'' premiered its first season on Creator/CBSAllAccess Creator/ParamountPlus on August 15, 2019. The second season aired on June 3, 2021. In January 2022, it was canceled despite initial reports that it had been renewed for Season 3, and will not be made.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ForcedEuthanasia: When he was a kid, Bertram Filcott performed a MercyKill on his mother at her request. This set him on the path to becoming an "Angel of Death", a SerialKiller of people who are incredibly sick and in pain, reasoning that it's better than letting them suffer. [[AntiVillain He does this with truly altruistic intentions in mind]], viewing it as a sad but ultimately merciful act. The problem is, he never ''asks'' if people want this "kindness", and it genuinely doesn't occur to him that he should.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CerebusCallBack: Simone is comically furious with Karl after he fakes a suicide attempt with pills to stop her from leaving him. [[spoiler:She's devastated when he steals pills to kill himself due to having [=AIDS=], then she voluntarily euthanizes him when she sees how truly bad things can get.]]

Added: 805

Changed: 254

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MrsRobinson: Simone reciprocates Tommy's affections (though he's just eighteen and she's already 40, if not past it). Later, [[spoiler:we see that she also has a personal assistant/masseuse who's also decades younger whom it's heavily implied she also has sex with]].

to:

* MrsRobinson: MrsRobinson:
**
Simone reciprocates Tommy's affections (though he's just eighteen and she's already 40, if not past it). Later, [[spoiler:we see that she also has a personal assistant/masseuse who's also decades younger whom it's heavily implied she also has sex with]].with]].
** Naomi's husband was clearly a lot older than his (now widowed) wife.


Added DiffLines:

* NothingNiceAboutSugarAndSpice:
** Beth Ann is a perfectly '50s housewife with perfectly coiffed hair, a {{Housewife}} background, and an UnlimitedWardrobe. She's also [[spoiler:the only wife to commit cold-blooded murder.]]
** Naomi is a garish update to the 1980s, as a ProperLady country club member who [[spoiler:tries to kill Simone when she learns that she's sleeping with Tommy.]]
** Jade is a conventionally attractive ManicPixieDreamGirl and [[spoiler:a serial killer.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DramaticIrony: There are a lot of flashbacks to happier times in the three marriages, such as Karl and Simone declaring their love for each other in their new house and Simone meeting the (very young) Tommy, who gives her a compliment.

Added: 117

Changed: -6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RedIsViolent: Emily's ball, the gate, and the door of Beth Ann's house are all red in flashbacks to Emily's death.



** Simone has has three husbands, including Karl, none of which truly loved her. Tommy, while much younger than she is, truly adores her. At first, she only sleeps with him to get back at his mom for knowing that Karl was cheating (though not with men) and keeping it a secret. But over time, she develops real feelings for him, and they even make plans for a life together [[spoiler: before it’s all derailed by Karl’s illness]].

to:

** Simone has has had three husbands, including Karl, none of which truly loved her. Tommy, while much younger than she is, truly adores her. At first, she only sleeps with him to get back at his mom for knowing that Karl was cheating (though not with men) and keeping it a secret. But over time, she develops real feelings for him, and they even make plans for a life together [[spoiler: before it’s all derailed by Karl’s illness]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MalingeringRomancePloy: Beth lies to her husband Rob that she has cancer after finding out that his mistress April is pregnant, as she knows he'll never leave her while she's sick.

Added: 176

Changed: 54

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Blackmail}}: Karl gets out of Simone threatening to throw him out by saying that he'll go to her friends and come out, humiliating her.

to:

* {{Blackmail}}: Karl gets out of Simone threatening to throw him out by saying that he'll go to her friends and come out, humiliating her. [[spoiler:This changes with his [=AIDS=] diagnosis.]]
* BlondeBrunetteRedhead: In 1963, Beth Ann is a redhead, her best friend and neighbor Sheila has dark brown hair, and her new friend and Rob's mistress, April, has blonde hair.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MoreDiverseSequel: In-universe due to the numerous {{time skip}}s:
** The earliest segment is set in 1963, and every character is white. The closest thing to diversity is Sheila and Leo, Beth Ann's Italian-American neighbors.
** Then it's 1984. The protagonist is Simone, an Asian woman, though everyone else is white, including her husband (with the exception of Simone's daughter Amy and one of Karl's briefly-appearing lovers, Hector).
** Then, in 2019, black woman Taylor is bisexual and in an open relationship with her husband and the (also bisexual) Jade.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MyBelovedSmother: Naomi Harte, Simone's friend worries that Tommy is doing drugs and she coddles him. [[spoiler: She almost goes so far as to kill Simone, only failing due to Tommy pushing her out of the way and Naomi getting injured]]. Naomi even tries to rip open his diary, only to be stopped by Simone, and later goes full [[ObnoxiousEntitledHousewife Karen]].

to:

* MyBelovedSmother: Naomi Harte, Simone's friend worries that Tommy is doing drugs and she coddles him. [[spoiler: She almost goes so far as to kill Simone, try to run Simone down with her car, only failing due to Tommy pushing her out of the way and Naomi getting injured]]. Naomi even tries to rip open his diary, only to be stopped by Simone, and later goes full [[ObnoxiousEntitledHousewife Karen]].



** Simone starts out as a demanding diva, only to reform as a person and focus on the needs of others. Her friend Naomi is a straight example, trying to intrude on her son's personal space and spreading rumors about Karl's health condition and sexuality and falsely saying Simone is molesting her Tommy (not true). These get Simone banned from the hospital and both the Groves banned from the Country Club they frequented.

to:

** Simone starts out as a demanding diva, only to reform as a person and focus on the needs of others. Her friend Naomi is a straight example, trying to intrude on her son's personal space and spreading rumors about Karl's health condition and sexuality and falsely saying alleging that Simone is molesting her Tommy (not true). These get Simone banned from the hospital and both the Groves banned from the Country Club country club they frequented.



* {{Polyamory}}: Taylor and her husband have an open marriage, with two basic rules: no getting emotionally invested in their hookups, and no bringing their hookups back to the house. Both rules are broken within the first episode.

to:

* {{Polyamory}}: Taylor and her husband Eli have an open marriage, with two basic rules: no getting emotionally invested in their hookups, and no bringing their hookups back to the house. Both rules are broken within the first episode.



** Tommy's father and Naomi's late husband talks about how unpleasant Naomi is and how she needs to lay off of Tommy because he's a grown man now. He hopes his son will push back against Naomi's smothering.

to:

** Edmund Harte, Tommy's father and Naomi's late husband husband, talks about how unpleasant Naomi is and how she needs to lay off of Tommy because he's a grown man now. He hopes his son will push back against Naomi's smothering.



* SassyBlackWoman: April's sisters, good Lord. They are snappy and funny and say sassy, cutting lines about Eli and their mother. Averted with the smart ass but more logical Taylor.

to:

* SassyBlackWoman: April's Taylor's sisters, good Lord. They are snappy and funny and say sassy, cutting lines about Eli and their mother. Averted with the smart ass but more logical Taylor.



* BaitAndSwitch: Bertram's SerialKiller reveal. Initially, it looked like he would be pursuing an affair but as soon as Maisie felt faint and sedated he began to make the same euthanasia speech he gave on the dogs...

to:

* BaitAndSwitch: Bertram's SerialKiller reveal. Initially, it looked looks like he would he'll be pursuing an affair but as soon as Maisie felt feels faint and sedated sedated, he began begins to make the same euthanasia speech he gave on the earlier about dogs...



** Alma has no problem disposing of Mrs. Host’s remains and planning an alibi. She's increasingly [[spoiler: violent and has a simmering rage]].

to:

** Alma has no problem disposing of Mrs. Host’s Yost’s remains and planning an alibi. She's increasingly [[spoiler: violent and has a simmering rage]].



* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler: Scooter and Bertram survive their wounds via Catherine, who ran off back to Texas with her father's fortune. But Rita gets murdered by Alma before Scooter can reconcile with her, Bertram commits suicide, Alma about gives up and let's the police arrest her, she is disgraced for her crimes, Scooter starts a new life being able to move on from Rita's tragic death and achieved popularity through his almost being framed by Alma, Dee and Vern have a happy family life with a baby boy and Mrs. Yost's dog, and Alma loses her sanity imagining she is at a premiere of her own movie with adoring fans and not reporters and onlookers jeering at her as she is walked off to a likely death sentence.]]

to:

* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler: Scooter and Bertram survive their wounds via Catherine, who ran off back to Texas with her father's fortune. But Rita gets murdered by Alma before Scooter can reconcile with her, Bertram commits suicide, Alma about gives up and let's lets the police arrest her, she is disgraced for her crimes, Scooter starts a new life being able to move on from Rita's tragic death and achieved achieves popularity through his almost being framed by Alma, Dee and Vern have a happy family life with a baby boy and Mrs. Yost's dog, and Alma loses her sanity sanity, imagining she is at a premiere of her own movie with adoring fans and not reporters and onlookers jeering at her as she is walked off to a likely death sentence.]]



** Rita's maid [[spoiler:and cousin]] Isabel tries to blackmail Alma and Bertram with one of the aforementioned photos, which show Alma's presence the night Carlo as murdered. This also backfired on her [[spoiler:resulting since Alma murdered her when Isabel breaks their deal]].

to:

** Rita's maid [[spoiler:and cousin]] Isabel tries to blackmail Alma and Bertram with one of the aforementioned photos, which show Alma's presence the night Carlo as murdered. This also backfired backfires on her her, [[spoiler:resulting since in Alma murdered murdering her when Isabel she breaks their deal]].



* DespairEventHorizon: Bertram in the penultimate episode, drinking himself day in and out for weeks. At this point, his wife worries far more about the garden club and her new lifestyle than him and their marriage (the last seen interaction between them is a shot of them arguing quietly in the kitchen and the final shot is Bertram reading the newspaper in the silence while Alma looks cautious); his daughter is avoiding them and he has his suspicions confirmed when she came to confront him. He sees through the lies his wife told their daughter and just takes the fall because the love of his daughter matters more now than his wife who is willing to throw him under the bus, pinning all the blame on him. He wants to protect his wife but at the same time, Alma is incredibly gleeful about throwing him to the wolves to protect her new lifestyle.

to:

* DespairEventHorizon: Bertram in the penultimate episode, drinking himself day in and out for weeks. At this point, his wife worries far more about the garden club and her new lifestyle than him and their marriage (the last seen interaction between them is a shot of them arguing quietly in the kitchen and the final shot is Bertram reading the newspaper in the silence while Alma looks cautious); his daughter is avoiding them and he has his suspicions confirmed when she came comes to confront him. He sees through the lies his wife has told their daughter and just takes the fall because the love of his daughter matters more now than his wife who is willing to throw him under the bus, pinning all the blame on him. He wants to protect his wife but at the same time, Alma is incredibly gleeful about throwing him to the wolves to protect her new lifestyle.



* FreudianExcuse: It turns out that Bertram was told to euthanize his mother at her instruction. Ever since, he's felt it was his duty to do the same for everyone with a painful, incurable disease (not bothering to ask if they want this though). His priest telling him he could be forgiven as well was taken by Bertram as his ''carte blanche'' afterward (although that wasn't the priest's intention).

to:

* FreudianExcuse: It turns out that As a child, Bertram was told to euthanize his mother at her instruction. Ever since, he's felt it was his duty to do the same for everyone with a painful, incurable disease (not bothering to ask if they want this though). His priest telling him he could be forgiven as well for this was taken by Bertram as his ''carte blanche'' afterward (although that wasn't the priest's intention).



** Father Tim Keegan, Bertram's former priest, is horrified to learn that when he told Bertram as a child that euthanizing his mother could be forgiven, Bertram took it to mean that (involuntary) euthanasia of other people was ''also'' okay, and he's killed ''26 people'' since.

to:

** Father Tim Keegan, Bertram's former priest, is horrified to learn that when he told Bertram as a child that he could be forgiven for euthanizing his mother could be forgiven, mother, Bertram took it to mean that (involuntary) euthanasia of other people was ''also'' okay, and he's killed ''26 people'' since.

Added: 36

Changed: 125

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Why Women Kill'' premiered its first season on Creator/CBSAllAccess on August 15, 2019. The second season aired on June 3, 2021. A CharacterSheet is now in progress.

to:

''Why Women Kill'' premiered its first season on Creator/CBSAllAccess on August 15, 2019. The second season aired on June 3, 2021. In January 2022, it was canceled despite initial reports that it had been renewed for Season 3, and will not be made.

A CharacterSheet is now in progress.

Added: 223

Changed: 259

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
trope merge with TALIK


* JerkToNiceGuyPlot: Simone starts out as a haughty, shallow woman who's very rude to most people. However, over the course of the series she grows into a much nicer person, and even [[spoiler:becomes a philanthropist]].
* KarmaHoudini: [[spoiler:Played with. On the one hand, Ralph does get the death penalty for murdering Rob and Jade is killed by Taylor in their fight after trying to kill Eli, and it's revealed that Simone "killed" Karl with his full consent. But all three of the wives murder someone and have no legal consequences, because they either weren't directly involved, it was the victim's wish, or it was self-defense.]]

to:

* JerkToNiceGuyPlot: Simone starts out as a haughty, shallow woman who's very rude to most people. However, over the course of the series she grows into a much nicer person, and even [[spoiler:becomes a philanthropist]].
* KarmaHoudini:
KarmaHoudini:
**
[[spoiler:Played with. On the one hand, Ralph does get the death penalty for murdering Rob and Jade is killed by Taylor in their fight after trying to kill Eli, and it's revealed that Simone "killed" Karl with his full consent. But all three of the wives murder someone and have no legal consequences, because they either weren't directly involved, it was the victim's wish, or it was self-defense.]]



* NiceToTheWaiter: Played with. When Karl collapses in the front yard, none of the neighbors will help Simone bring him to the car because he has AIDS, but a gardener does. Simone thanks the man profusely and offers to hire him to work for them... only for Karl to inform her he ''does'' work for them, and has for six years. [[JerkToNiceGuyPlot Simone caring enough to notice "the help" is a rather recent development]].

to:

* NiceToTheWaiter: Played with. When Karl collapses in the front yard, none of the neighbors will help Simone bring him to the car because he has AIDS, but a gardener does. Simone thanks the man profusely and offers to hire him to work for them... only for Karl to inform her he ''does'' work for them, and has for six years. [[JerkToNiceGuyPlot [[TookALevelInKindness Simone caring enough to notice "the help" is a rather recent development]].development.]]


Added DiffLines:

* TookALevelInKindness: Simone starts out as a haughty, shallow woman who's very rude to most people. However, over the course of the series she grows into a much nicer person, and even [[spoiler:becomes a philanthropist.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* '''1963''': Beth Ann Stanton (Creator/GinniferGoodwin) is a docile housewife content with her role in society until she learns that her husband Rob (Sam Jaeger) is having an affair with a young waitress named April Warner (Sadie Calvano). Beth Ann finds herself becoming more assertive as she works to end her husband's infidelity through befriending his mistress.

to:

* '''1963''': Beth Ann Stanton (Creator/GinniferGoodwin) is a docile housewife content with her role in society until she learns that her husband Rob (Sam Jaeger) (Creator/SamJaeger) is having an affair with a young waitress named April Warner (Sadie Calvano).(Creator/SadieCalvano). Beth Ann finds herself becoming more assertive as she works to end her husband's infidelity through befriending his mistress.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhereAreTheyNowEpilogue: A unique variation: in the final scene, it's shown how [[spoiler: Simone meets an older Beth Ann when buying the house in 1974. With Beth Ann is April's daughter, who she's helped raise as April is now becoming a singer on Broadway with Beth Ann joining her. Then in 2014, an older, wheelchair bound Simone gives the keys to Eli and Taylor, revealing she's let go of her material obsessions and dedicating her life to AIDS research while Tommy is now a famous painter. Finally, in 2020, Eli and Taylor give the keys to a new couple as they head off to a quieter life.]]

to:

* WhereAreTheyNowEpilogue: A unique variation: in the final scene, it's shown how [[spoiler: Simone meets an older Beth Ann when buying the house in 1974. With Beth Ann is April's daughter, who she's helped raise as April is now becoming a singer on Broadway with Beth Ann joining her. Then in 2014, an older, wheelchair bound Simone gives the keys to Eli and Taylor, revealing she's let go of her material obsessions and dedicating her life to AIDS research while Tommy is now a famous painter. Finally, in 2020, Eli and Taylor give the keys to a new couple as they head off to a quieter life.]]

Top