Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / Titanic1996

Go To

OR

Added: 455

Changed: 450

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DirtyCoward: Like other ''Titanic'' films, Ismay is portrayed as cowardly trying to sneak into a lifeboat in order to escape. This miniseries really hammers it in by having the other people in the lifeboat noticing and calling him a coward.

to:

* DirtyCoward: DirtyCoward:
**
Like other ''Titanic'' films, Ismay is portrayed as cowardly trying to sneak into a lifeboat in order to escape. This miniseries really hammers it in by having the other people in the lifeboat noticing and calling him a coward.



* NoHistoricalFiguresWereHarmed: The large Jack family are a thinly veiled stand-in for the Goodwins, all of whom perished in the disaster. (Oddly enough, the characters WERE named Goodwin in the original script, so the name change is a bit of a mystery.)

to:

* NoHistoricalFiguresWereHarmed: NoHistoricalFiguresWereHarmed:
**
The large Jack family are a thinly veiled stand-in for the Goodwins, all of whom perished in the disaster. (Oddly enough, the characters WERE named Goodwin in the original script, so the name change is a bit of a mystery.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Mr. Foley (who cons his way into the boat using a baby) and Simon (who dresses up as a woman) qualify as well.


Added DiffLines:

** Mr. and Mrs. Foley are loosely based on Sir Cosmo and Lady Lucile Duff-Gordon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Bruce Ismay berates the officers for loading the boats half-full, which was something Thomas Andrews did.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DemotedToExtra: The ship's orchestra only appear in the background and don't get any lines.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DirtyCoward: Like other ''Titanic'' films, Ismay is portrayed as cowardly trying to sneak into a lifeboat in order to escape. This miniseries really hammers it in by having the other people in the lifeboat noticing and calling him a coward.

Added: 2998

Changed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Renaming the artistic license page to artistic license history. Will put the original page to be cut.


* ArtisticLicense: ''Far'' too many to list here. If you want to see the extensive list, [[ArtisticLicense/Titanic1996 go here]].

to:

* ArtisticLicense: ArtisticLicenseHistory: ''Far'' too many to list here. If you want to see the extensive list, [[ArtisticLicense/Titanic1996 [[ArtisticLicenseHistory/Titanic1996 go here]].here]].
* ArtisticLicenseReligion: Near the end, Captain Smith makes a sanctimonious speech about how the Titans in Greek mythology challenged the gods and were cast down for it. In fact, they ''were'' gods, and were overthrown by the Olympians.[[note]]The fate of the defeated Titans had a more apt parallel with ''Titanic'''s; they were condemned to spend an eternity in Tartarus, a dark and damp abyss in the lowest depths of the world.[[/note]]
* ArtisticLicenseShips:
** Quartermaster Robert Hichens takes the ship out of Southampton, when actually this was the job of the harbor pilot[[note]]a navigator who specialized in that one specific harbor[[/note]], who disembarked once the ship had cleared the harbor.
** Captain Smith is seen at the ship's wheel, when this task would be the duty of a lower ranking sailor, such as a quartermaster. Furthermore, he allows a passenger to take the wheel, which would never be permitted in reality. Indeed, under White Star Line rules, passengers were not even allowed on the Bridge.
** Many officers are depicted observing military protocol (saluting, saying "Captain on deck," etc.). This is an aversion, as it was common for sailors and officers in Britain to switch between military duty and merchant marine service. Indeed, the officers of ''Titanic'' were members of the Royal Navy Reserve.
** Smith complains that the distress rockets should be red. In fact, at the time there was no designated colour for distress rockets (this was one reason for the confusion on the ''Californian'' that night), and white would have been acceptable.
** On the bridge, Lightoller casually informs Smith that the ship has increased speed on Ismay's orders. The notion that an unqualified civilian could give navigation orders to the engineers and officers on any vessel without even the captain's knowledge or consent is absurd.
** When Captain Smith decides to retire to his quarters, he tells Lightoller he's "going below." However, the captain's quarters were right behind the bridge. The proper term would be "going off deck."
** In the aftermath of the collision, Captain Smith gives Murdoch a WhatWereYouThinking speech for not just ramming the iceberg head-on, claiming this would have only flooded one watertight compartment with minimal casualties. Firstly, the prevailing wisdom prior to the incident was that the ''Titanic'' (and, indeed, most similar ships) should have easily survived a glancing blow with an iceberg, and no competent sailor would have ordered their ship to ram an iceberg or any similar object. Secondly, such a collision would actually have flooded at least ''three'' watertight compartments and crushed the ship's bow for a distance of around 75-100ft; such an outcome would technically have been better than what actually unfolded in that the ship would have stayed afloat, but there would still have been hundreds of fatalities -- mostly among the steerage passengers and engineering crew -- instead of the minimal number that Smith implies.

Added: 390

Changed: 205

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HeroicBSOD: Surprisingly, averted. Captain Smith, who by many accounts became distant and indecisive upon realizing the gravity of the situation, is remarkably coherent. He criticizes Murdoch on his handling of avoiding the iceberg like someone a century later would.

to:

* HeroicBSOD: Surprisingly, averted.downplayed. Captain Smith, who by many accounts became distant and indecisive upon realizing the gravity of the situation, is remarkably coherent. He criticizes Murdoch on his handling of avoiding the iceberg like someone a century later would. It's only in the very final minutes before sinking that Smith succumbs to this, refusing a lifejacket and quietly cursing man's hubris as a junior officer tries to persuade him to save himself.


Added DiffLines:

* SurroundedByIdiots: Possibly the only ''Titanic''-related work to go with this interpretation of Captain Smith, who is depicted as a good, competent man who gets undermined by the decisions of others around him, namely Ismay's ordering more boilers to be lit without informing Smith, and then Murdoch's supposed error in trying to go around the iceberg instead of just ramming it head on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A full year before Creator/JamesCameron's ''Film/{{Titanic|1997}}'' broke box office records, Robert Lieberman directed a TV miniseries about the [[UsefulNotes/RMSTitanic ill-fated liner]]. Boasting an AllStarCast which included Creator/CatherineZetaJones, Creator/PeterGallagher, Creator/TimCurry, and Creator/GeorgeCScott, the film was aired in two parts on Creator/{{CBS}} in November 1996.

to:

A full year before Creator/JamesCameron's ''Film/{{Titanic|1997}}'' broke box office records, Robert Lieberman directed Hallmark Entertainment produced a TV miniseries about the [[UsefulNotes/RMSTitanic ill-fated liner]]. Boasting an AllStarCast which included Creator/CatherineZetaJones, Creator/PeterGallagher, Creator/TimCurry, and Creator/GeorgeCScott, the film was aired in two parts on Creator/{{CBS}} in November 1996.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: Benjamin Guggenheim is pointed out by Mrs Foley, who notes his scandalous backstory (despite being married, he was travelling back to America with his mistress), but he is never seen again. Not even for the real Guggenheim, when he declined to wear a lifejacket and put on his best clothes, declaring that he would go down like a gentleman. Everyone else mentioned by Mrs Foley - the Astors, Molly Brown, the Strausses - at least gets some screen time.

to:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: Benjamin Guggenheim is pointed out by Mrs Foley, who notes his scandalous backstory (despite being married, (a married man, he was travelling back to America with his mistress), but he is never seen again. Not even for the real Guggenheim, Guggenheim's famous decision to FaceDeathWithDignity, when he declined to wear a lifejacket and put on his best clothes, declaring that he would go down like a gentleman. Everyone else mentioned by Mrs Foley - the Astors, Molly Brown, the Strausses - at least gets some screen time.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** On April 9th, there was a tour for the press and photographers aboard the ship.[[labelnote:*]]In fact, many of the surviving photographs of ''Titanic'''s interior were taken during this tour.[[/labelnote]] However, it was not a press conference, with reporters grilling Ismay about the lack of lifeboats.

to:

*** On April 9th, there was a tour for the press and photographers aboard the ship.[[labelnote:*]]In fact, many of the surviving photographs of ''Titanic'''s interior were taken during this tour.[[/labelnote]] However, it was not a press conference, with reporters grilling Ismay about the lack of lifeboats.lifeboats or questioning Captain Smith about his impending retirement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllThereInTheManual: Tim Curry’s character is never formally introduced or named at any point in the minaeries. His name is stated to be “Simon Doonan” only in the original press materials by CBS.

to:

* AllThereInTheManual: Tim Curry’s character is never formally introduced or named at any point in the minaeries.miniseries. His name is stated to be “Simon Doonan” only in the original press materials by CBS.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A full year before Creator/JamesCameron's ''Film/{{Titanic|1997}}'' broke box office records, Robert Lieberman directed a TV miniseries about the [[UsefulNotes/RMSTitanic ill-fated liner]]. Boasting an AllStarCast which included Creator/CatherineZetaJones, Peter Gallagher, Creator/TimCurry, and Creator/GeorgeCScott, the film was aired in two parts on Creator/{{CBS}} in November 1996.

to:

A full year before Creator/JamesCameron's ''Film/{{Titanic|1997}}'' broke box office records, Robert Lieberman directed a TV miniseries about the [[UsefulNotes/RMSTitanic ill-fated liner]]. Boasting an AllStarCast which included Creator/CatherineZetaJones, Peter Gallagher, Creator/PeterGallagher, Creator/TimCurry, and Creator/GeorgeCScott, the film was aired in two parts on Creator/{{CBS}} in November 1996.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AgeLift: Loraine Allison was a two year old toddler at the time of the sinking, but in the miniseries she's portrayed as a bratty seven year old.

to:

* AgeLift: Loraine Allison was a an innocent two year old toddler at the time of the sinking, but in the miniseries she's portrayed as a bratty rude and nasty spoiled brat who is seven year years old.



* BrattyHalfPint: Loraine Allison is portrayed as an insufferable, loud, and {{spoiled brat}}. Presumably so the audience wouldn't get too attached to her once the final scenes of episode two roll around.

to:

* BrattyHalfPint: Loraine Allison is portrayed as an insufferable, loud, rude and nasty {{spoiled brat}}. Presumably so the audience wouldn't get too attached to her once the final scenes of episode two roll around.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:340:[[ArtisticLicenseHistory Even the poster is wrong.]][[labelnote:*]]No, the ''Titanic'' did not go down in flames.[[/labelnote]]]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:340:[[ArtisticLicenseHistory Even the poster is wrong.]][[labelnote:*]]No, the ''Titanic'' did not go down in flames. Also, if the smoke is supposed to be coming from the boilers, there should be none pouring from the dummy fourth funnel.[[/labelnote]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AllThereInTheManual: Tim Curry’s character is never formally introduced or named at any point in the minaeries. His name is stated to be “Simon Doonan” only in the original press materials by CBS.

Added: 176

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ScreenShake: Everyone throws themselves against something when ''Titanic'' hits the iceberg, even though the impact was barely felt as anything more than a slight shudder through most of the ship.

to:

* ScreenShake: Everyone throws themselves against something when ''Titanic'' hits the iceberg, even though though, in reality, the impact was barely felt as anything more than a slight shudder through most of the ship. ship.
* ShowerScene: Arguably one of the most infamous moments in the miniseries; Aase is raped by Simon Doonan while taking a shower in the fictitious Third Class communal washroom.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Chief Engineer Bell also seems to be working as leading fireman, combining his role with that of Fred Barrett, who was on duty in Boiler Room 6 when it flooded.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GenderLift: John Jacob Astor had two children from his previous marriage, an adult son and a preadolescent daughter. When Madeleine Astor is seen being picked up by them in New York after being rescued, both of John's children are shown to be men.

to:

* GenderLift: John Jacob Astor had two children from his previous marriage, an adult son and a preadolescent daughter. When Madeleine Astor is seen being picked up by them in New York after being rescued, both of John's children are shown to be adult men.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MaidAndMaiden: Mrs. Miller acts as a protective maternal figure to the pregnant 18 year old Madeleine Astor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WouldHurtAChild: Miss Miller recognizes Alice Cleaver as a woman who murdered her baby several years prior.

to:

* WouldHurtAChild: Miss Mrs. Miller recognizes Alice Cleaver as a woman who murdered her baby several years prior.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WouldAHurtAChild: Miss Miller recognizes Alice Cleaver as a woman who murdered her baby several years prior.

to:

* WouldAHurtAChild: WouldHurtAChild: Miss Miller recognizes Alice Cleaver as a woman who murdered her baby several years prior.

Added: 110

Changed: 24

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DarkerAndEdgier: This miniseries somewhat stands apart from other dramatizations of the ''Titanic'' disaster due to its inclusion of sexual violence and themes of mental illness and infanticide.

to:

* DarkerAndEdgier: This miniseries somewhat stands apart from other dramatizations of the ''Titanic'' disaster due to its inclusion of sexual violence and violence, themes of mental illness illness, and infanticide.[[DeathOfAChild infanticide]].


Added DiffLines:

* WouldAHurtAChild: Miss Miller recognizes Alice Cleaver as a woman who murdered her baby several years prior.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DatedHistory: Alice Cleaver being portrayed as a child murderer. In defense of the miniseries, it was widely believed in the early 90s, during the resurgence of interest in ''Titanic'', that Alice was indeed a convicted murderer. At least two books even accepted this as fact, including Don Lynch and Ken Marschall's otherwise exhaustive ''Titanic: An Illustrated History''. Only in recent years it was confirmed that the woman who murdered her baby in 1909 was Alice ''Mary'' Cleaver, completely unrelated to Alice ''Catherine'' Cleaver, the Allison family nurse.

to:

* DatedHistory: Alice Cleaver being portrayed as a child murderer. In defense of the miniseries, it was widely believed in the early 90s, during the resurgence of interest in ''Titanic'', that Alice was indeed a convicted murderer. At least two books even accepted this as fact, including Don Lynch and Ken Marschall's otherwise exhaustive volume ''Titanic: An Illustrated History''. Only in recent years it was confirmed that the woman who murdered her baby in 1909 was Alice ''Mary'' Cleaver, completely unrelated to Alice ''Catherine'' Cleaver, the Allison family nurse.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ScreenShake: Everyone throws themselves against something when ''Titanic'' hits the iceberg, even though the impact was barely felt as anything more than a slight shudder through most of the ship.

Added: 567

Changed: 443

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HopeSpot: The film likes to play up the close proximity between the ''Titanic'' and ''Californian'' as this. One of the ''Californian''’s Officers offers to listen in on the ''Titanic''’s wireless traffic for a while, but the power runs out just as the distress signal is being sent. Later, they try to signal each other via Morse lamp, but the crew is either too stupid or too tired to think about turning the wireless back on to communicate directly.

to:

* HopeSpot: HopeSpot:
**
The film likes to play up the close proximity between the ''Titanic'' and ''Californian'' as this. One of the ''Californian''’s Officers offers to listen in on the ''Titanic''’s wireless traffic for a while, but the power runs out just as the distress signal is being sent. Later, they try to signal each other via Morse lamp, but the crew is either too stupid or too tired to think about turning the wireless back on to communicate directly.directly.
** The Jack family finally manage to break down the gate, but by the time they get on deck, all of the lifeboats are gone.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Astor's daughter was just shy of 10 when he died


* GenderLift: John Jacob Astor had two adult children from his previous marriage, a son and a daughter. When Madeleine Astor is seen being picked up by them in New York after being rescued, both of John's children are shown to be men.

to:

* GenderLift: John Jacob Astor had two adult children from his previous marriage, a an adult son and a preadolescent daughter. When Madeleine Astor is seen being picked up by them in New York after being rescued, both of John's children are shown to be men.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicked trope


* AdultFear: A madwoman who murdered her own child in the past has run off with your baby while you and your family are in the middle of one of the deadliest shipwrecks in history.
** The Jack family spend hours navigating the bowels of the ship, through endless companionways and locked gates to get to the boat deck, only to find that all the lifeboats have been launched and now they, and their children, have minutes left to live.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A rather strange minor example with Loraine Allison. Instead of showing her as an innocent two year old toddler, she is portrayed as a rude and nasty spoiled brat.

to:

** A rather strange minor example with Loraine Allison. Instead of showing her as an innocent two year old toddler, she is portrayed as a rude and nasty spoiled brat.brat who is seven years old.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdultFear: A madwoman who murdered her own child in the past has run off with your baby while your family are in the middle of one of the deadliest shipwrecks in history.

to:

* AdultFear: A madwoman who murdered her own child in the past has run off with your baby while you and your family are in the middle of one of the deadliest shipwrecks in history.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DramaticShattering: Part One of the movie ends shortly after the collision with a unattended glass sliding out of the frame and onto the deck.

to:

* DramaticShattering: Part One of the movie ends shortly after the collision with a an unattended glass sliding out of the frame and onto the deck.



* DutchAngle: The sinking is done in near-total Dutch angles, trying to show the sinking without moving the sets. It gets a bit comical when actors are trying to be off-balance when they're on level ground, not to mention it's used soon after the collision (when the tilt was not apparent yet), with along with varying between scenes and even giving the impression that the ship is heavily listing (beyond what was reported).

to:

* DutchAngle: The sinking is done in near-total Dutch angles, trying to show the sinking without moving the sets. It gets a bit comical when actors are trying to be off-balance when they're on level ground, not to mention it's used soon after the collision (when the tilt was not apparent yet), with along with varying between scenes and even giving the impression that the ship is heavily listing (beyond what was reported).



** He also gets a small HistoricalHeroUpgrade. One scene has him berating officers for lowering boats half-full and demands that they be filled, even though this was something that Thomas Andrews did. He's also depicted suggesting that Isidor Straus join his wife in a lifeboat, as no one would object to an elderly gentleman having a seat (though it was one of the officers who actually said this.)

to:

** He also gets a small HistoricalHeroUpgrade. One scene has him berating officers for lowering boats half-full and demands demanding that they be filled, even though this was something that Thomas Andrews did. He's also depicted suggesting that Isidor Straus join his wife in a lifeboat, as no one would object to an elderly gentleman having a seat (though it was one of the officers who actually said this.)



*** Phillips did communciate with the wireless operator on the ''Californian'', Cyril Evans, shortly before the collision. Evans was relaying to ''Titanic'' that his own ship had stopped for the night due to ice, but Phillips was trying to clear a huge backlog of messages for Cape Race and angrily told him to "shut up" and "keep out". With that, Evans [[MissedHimByThatMuch shut off his wireless and went to bed]].

to:

*** Phillips did communciate communicate with the wireless operator on the ''Californian'', Cyril Evans, shortly before the collision. Evans was relaying to ''Titanic'' that his own ship had stopped for the night due to ice, but Phillips was trying to clear a huge backlog of messages for Cape Race and angrily told him to "shut up" and "keep out". With that, Evans [[MissedHimByThatMuch shut off his wireless and went to bed]].



* YouAreTooLate: Captain Rostron and the ''Carpathia'' were among the [[BigDamnHeroes heroes of the night]], but they arrived too late to help 1500 of the 2200 aboard ''Titanic''.

to:

* YouAreTooLate: Captain Rostron and the ''Carpathia'' were among the [[BigDamnHeroes heroes of the night]], but they arrived too late to help 1500 of the 2200 passengers aboard ''Titanic''.

Top