Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Series / MrSunshine2018

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BottomlessMagazines: Ae-sin is shown training with what explicitly looks like a single-shot matchlock rifle (one of the oldest types of handheld guns, and the most common firearm in pre-1900 East Asia), and yet she's able to fire ''multiple shots'', in sequence, in the same (camera) shot, at a bunch of pottery targets. It might be plausible if there was only gunpowder without a bullet in the chamber, but she's shown actually destroying some of the targets.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When Ae Shin was born in Japan in the 1880's, her parents use Mauser C96 pistols when they fend of the Japanese instead of era-appropriate guns like the Smith and Wesson Model 1871, Colt 1860 or SAA revolver, or British Bulldog revolver.
** the Japanese were guilty of this. while they used Arisaka Rifles during the series, they use Gewehr 88s during the 1880's flashback instead of the Mauser 1871. they also used Gatling guns when they attacked the Royal Military Academy in the late 1900's instead of Maxim machine guns which they used during the UsefulNotes/RussoJapaneseWar.

to:

** When Ae Shin was born in Japan in the 1880's, her parents use Mauser C96 pistols when they fend of the Japanese instead of era-appropriate guns like the Smith and Wesson Model 1871, Colt 1860 or 1860, Colt SAA revolver, or British Bulldog revolver.
** the Japanese were guilty of this. while they used Arisaka Rifles during the series, they use Gewehr 88s during the 1880's flashback instead of the Mauser 1871. they also used Gatling guns when they attacked the Royal Military Academy in the late 1900's instead of Maxim or Hotchkiss machine guns which they used during the UsefulNotes/RussoJapaneseWar.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Foil

to:

* Foil{{Foil}}
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BlueBlood: Ae Shin and Hui Seong are of the Joseon aristocracy.


Added DiffLines:

* Foil
** Eugene and Dong-mae have almost perfectly parallel stories, except that they ended up loyal to opposing countries, and the actions of both reflect the nature of the people that took them in.
** [[FemmeFatale Hina]] and [[TheIngenue Ae Shin]] may seem like polar opposite personalities, but both women use their public personas to hide their political activism, both rebel against the roles society has handed them, and neither is afraid to use violence when necessary.


Added DiffLines:

* SelfMadeMan: Eugene and Dong-mae both clawed their way out of the oppression and persecution they faced in Joseon to become powerful men each in their right.

Changed: 113

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[TheStarscream Lee Wan-Ik]] is one of the powerful court officials but came from landowning middle-class family, which often resulted in the aristocracy's blocking the upward mobility that led him to [[StartOfDarkness align with Japan]].

to:

** [[TheStarscream Lee Wan-Ik]] is one of the powerful court officials but came from landowning middle-class family, which often resulted in his request for promotions being blocked by the aristocracy's blocking jealous aristocracy to the upward mobility that led point of him to [[StartOfDarkness align aligning with Japan]].Japan as an alternative mean]].

Added: 241

Changed: 94

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Slavery in Joseon was so institutionalized that slave hunters were hired to find escapees. Even after slavery was abolished and modernization appeared in Joseon, social and gender stratifications linger on.

to:

** Slavery in Joseon was so institutionalized that slave hunters were hired to find escapees.escapees, who would be put to death along with their families once they were returned to their owners. Even after slavery was abolished and modernization appeared in Joseon, social and gender stratifications linger on.



** [[TheStarscream Lee Wan-Ik]] is one of the powerful court officials but came from landowning middle-class family, which often resulted in the aristocracy's blocking the upward mobility that led him to [[StartOfDarkness align with Japan]].



* ShaggyDogStory: The story follows the rebels who first wanted government reform, and then resisted the Japanese colonization of Korea. See ForgoneConclusion.

to:

* ShaggyDogStory: The story follows the rebels who first wanted government reform, and then resisted the Japanese colonization of Korea. See ForgoneConclusion.ForegoneConclusion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HistoricalDomainCharacter: Emperor Gojong, many members of his cabinet, and “The Seven Traitors of 1907” were real people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AluminumChristmasTrees: It may seem ridiculous to suggest that Eugene would be accepted to the Naval Academy, and commissioned into the Marines, given the prejudice against non-whites in the service at the time. But while Asian Americans in the military were certainly the exception, not the norm, but they have been documented as serving in the U.S. military at various times and places since the War of 1812. As early as 1860, foreign nationals from Japan and China attended U.S. military academies. So while there is no specific historical example, it is plausible that a smart young Korean could, with a wealthy and influential patron, get a commission at that time in history.

to:

* AluminumChristmasTrees: It may seem ridiculous to suggest that Eugene would be accepted to the Naval Academy, and commissioned into the Marines, given the prejudice against non-whites in the service at the time. But But, while Asian Americans in the military were certainly the exception, not the norm, but they have been documented as serving in the U.S. military at various times and places since the War of 1812. As early as 1860, foreign nationals from Japan and China attended U.S. military academies. So while there is no specific historical example, it is plausible that a smart young Korean could, with a wealthy and influential patron, get a commission at that time in history.

Added: 685

Removed: 153

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AluminumChristmasTrees: It may seem ridiculous to suggest that Eugene would be accepted to the Naval Academy, and commissioned into the Marines, given the prejudice against non-whites in the service at the time. But while Asian Americans in the military were certainly the exception, not the norm, but they have been documented as serving in the U.S. military at various times and places since the War of 1812. As early as 1860, foreign nationals from Japan and China attended U.S. military academies. So while there is no specific historical example, it is plausible that a smart young Korean could, with a wealthy and influential patron, get a commission at that time in history.



* ArtisticLicenseHistory: There is no way Eugene would be accepted into military, let alone serve, as a Korean in a white-exclusive military institution.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ShaggyDogStory: The story follows the rebels who first wanted government reform, and then resisted the Japanese colonization of Korea. See ForgoneConclusion.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Foreshawdowing}}: The first English words Ae Sin learns are “gun,” “love,” and “sad ending.”

to:

* {{Foreshawdowing}}: {{Foreshadowing}}: The first English words Ae Sin learns are “gun,” “love,” and “sad ending.”
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Foreshawdowing}}: The first English words Ae Sin learns are “gun,” “love,” and “sad ending.”
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* MagnificentBastard: Mrs. Logan is a snob who talks down to Joseon people, but she’s the perfect person to put Lee Wan Ik in his place. While everyone else is tiptoeing around him, she cuts off his condescending speech, critcizes his English, calls him stupid, and tells him hurry up and sign the title. He is left speechless, while it’s all Eugene and Dong-mae can do to keep from laughing.

Added: 406

Changed: -1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Eagleland}}: As a collective, the nation is seen as rather boorish, having sent troops to Korea in pursuit of its colonial ambitions, and exploiting Joseon economically. The show also makes an effort to fairly represent that numerous nation-states of the time had similar imperial ambitions—particularly Japan and Russia.
** Major Moore is an excellent example of the dichotomy, with his cheery ignorance prompting him to ask dumb and often offensive questions (“Eugene, how do Joseon women see color with black eyes?”), but his inherent sense of fair play prompting him to help Joseon at great personal inconvenience and risk, in their hour of need.

to:

* {{Eagleland}}: As a collective, the nation is seen as rather boorish, having sent troops to Korea in pursuit of its colonial ambitions, and exploiting Joseon economically. The show also makes an effort to fairly represent that numerous nation-states of the time had similar imperial ambitions—particularly Japan and Russia.
** Major Moore is an excellent example of the dichotomy, with his cheery ignorance prompting him to ask dumb and often offensive questions (“Eugene, how do Joseon women see color with black eyes?”), but his inherent sense of fair play prompting him to help Joseon at great personal inconvenience and risk, in their hour of need.



* EvilChancellor: Gojong's regent is loyal, but fatally stubborn and arrogant. He exhorts the court to be hawkish and ignores the words of more [[OnlySaneMan realistic-minded bureaucrats]] who recognize that their "inferior barbarian" invaders have military and technological superiority. When their "defense" ended with [[CurbStompBattle massive casualties]], he condemns the surviving soldiers for "cowardice.” He withholds information from Hina about her mother’s whereabouts [[ManipulativeBastard in order to extort her cooperation for longer]].

to:

* EvilChancellor: {{Downplayed}}. Gojong's regent is loyal, but fatally stubborn and arrogant. He exhorts the court to be hawkish and ignores the words of more [[OnlySaneMan realistic-minded bureaucrats]] who recognize that their "inferior barbarian" invaders have military and technological superiority. When their "defense" ended with [[CurbStompBattle massive casualties]], he condemns the surviving soldiers for "cowardice.” He withholds information from Hina about her mother’s whereabouts [[ManipulativeBastard in order to extort her cooperation for longer]].


Added DiffLines:

* SinsOfTheFather: It eventually comes to light that a great deal of Hui Seong’s apathy comes from the terrible burden of guilt he feels for his grandfather’s deeds and the suffering they caused, and the way he personally has benefited from those sins. When he finally realizes that Eugene bears a grudge against his family, he does not ask what or why but simply asks if it was his father or grandfather.

Added: 328

Changed: 325

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Eagleland}}: The United States in 1871 was portrayed as both types of the Eagleland trope. As a collective, the nation is seen as rather boorish, having sent troops to Korea in pursuit of its colonial ambitions, and exploiting Joseon economically. But individuals like Eugene and Major Moore are shown to be fundamentally good people, willing to go a long way to help many Koreans. This despite Eugene’s brutal childhood, and Moore’s duty to advance U.S. interests. The show also shows that numerous nation-states of the time had similar imperial ambitions—particularly Japan and Russia.

to:

* {{Eagleland}}: The United States in 1871 was portrayed as both types of the Eagleland trope. As a collective, the nation is seen as rather boorish, having sent troops to Korea in pursuit of its colonial ambitions, and exploiting Joseon economically. But individuals like Eugene and Major Moore are shown to be fundamentally good people, willing to go a long way to help many Koreans. This despite Eugene’s brutal childhood, and Moore’s duty to advance U.S. interests. economically. The show also shows makes an effort to fairly represent that numerous nation-states of the time had similar imperial ambitions—particularly Japan and Russia.Russia.
** Major Moore is an excellent example of the dichotomy, with his cheery ignorance prompting him to ask dumb and often offensive questions (“Eugene, how do Joseon women see color with black eyes?”), but his inherent sense of fair play prompting him to help Joseon at great personal inconvenience and risk, in their hour of need.

Added: 248

Changed: 278

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvilChancellor: Downplayed. Gojong's regent is moral, but fatally stubborn and arrogant. He exhorts the court to be hawkish and ignores the words of more [[OnlySaneMan realistic-minded bureaucrats]] who recognize that their "inferior barbarian" invaders have military and technological superiority. The Joseon military is busy with quelling unrest and has difficulty sparing soldiers for foreign defense. And when their "defense" ended with [[CurbStompBattle massive casualties]], he condemns the surviving soldiers for "cowardice," which directly results in Seung-goo and other prisoners joining the revolutionaries.

to:

* EvilChancellor: Downplayed. Gojong's regent is moral, loyal, but fatally stubborn and arrogant. arrogant. He exhorts the court to be hawkish and ignores the words of more [[OnlySaneMan realistic-minded bureaucrats]] who recognize that their "inferior barbarian" invaders have military and technological superiority. The Joseon military is busy with quelling unrest and has difficulty sparing soldiers for foreign defense. And when When their "defense" ended with [[CurbStompBattle massive casualties]], he condemns the surviving soldiers for "cowardice," which directly results "cowardice.” He withholds information from Hina about her mother’s whereabouts [[ManipulativeBastard in Seung-goo and other prisoners joining the revolutionaries.order to extort her cooperation for longer]].


Added DiffLines:

* TheIngenue: Ae sin asks Eugene to do “love” with her, not knowing what it means in Korean, only that it is supposedly better than a title, and that it must be very difficult. Eugene is extremely bemused and agrees—-without explaining what it is.

Added: 828

Changed: 1176

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Making spelling of names consistent, and other edits


* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler: Ae Shin]] finally leads The Righteous Army in Manchuria, but at the cost of the lives of [[spoiler: Dong Mae, Hina/Yang Hwa, Hee Sung, and Eugene/Yoo Jin]], Joseon being conquered by Japan in 1910, and leaving her countrymen at home behind.

to:

* BittersweetEnding: [[spoiler: Ae Shin]] finally leads The Righteous Army in Manchuria, but at the cost of the lives of [[spoiler: Dong Mae, Hina/Yang Hwa, Hee Hui Sung, and Eugene/Yoo Jin]], Joseon being conquered by Japan in 1910, and leaving her countrymen at home behind.



** Hee Sung is nice enough, but he’s a dilettante and a womanizer with no real ambition.

to:

** Hee Hui Sung is nice enough, but he’s a dilettante and a womanizer with no real ambition.



* DeliberateValuesDissonance: The series tends to portray the less-ideal part of Joseon Dynasty, especially before the arrival of foreign powers. One example is Dong Mae's DarkAndTroubledPast as a child of butcher family who were ostracized due to their "unclean" nature of their work. Another being Joseon's slavery that had been widespread to the point that slave hunters were hired to find escapees who would be brought to be executed for their crimes. Finally, Go Ae Shin had to deal with restrictions on the account as a noblewoman by her traditional grandfather who would have her stay at home rather than being informed about worldly matters, though this also may have to do with the fact that her parents were killed by Japanese soldiers for their activism. Even when slavery was abolished and modernization appeared in Joseon, many citizens still linger on social and gender stratification with a major example being Ae Shin's servant discouraging her from visiting a school meant for commoners.

to:

* DeliberateValuesDissonance: The series tends to portray portrays the less-ideal part less-romantic side of life during the Joseon Dynasty, especially before the arrival of foreign powers. One example is Dynasty.
**
Dong Mae's DarkAndTroubledPast as a the child of butcher family who shows how people were ostracized due to their "unclean" nature of their work. Another being Joseon's slavery that had been widespread to the point work.
** Slavery in Joseon was so institutionalized
that slave hunters were hired to find escapees who would be brought to be executed for their crimes. Finally, Go Ae Shin had to deal with restrictions on the account as a noblewoman by her traditional grandfather who would have her stay at home rather than being informed about worldly matters, though this also may have to do with the fact that her parents were killed by Japanese soldiers for their activism. escapees. Even when after slavery was abolished and modernization appeared in Joseon, many citizens still linger on social and gender stratification stratifications linger on.
** Go Ae Sin has to deal
with a major example being Ae Shin's restrictions placed on noblewomen. Her grandfather would have her stay at home rather than learn about worldly matters, and is appalled when she attempts to oppose her arranged marriage. Her servant discouraging discourages her from visiting attending a school meant for commoners.commoners.
** Despite how powerful and respected Eugene has become, everyone who cares for Ae Sin tries to end their romance when they discover he was born a slave, fearing she will be ostracized.



* EvilOldFolks: Hee Sung's grandfather is a major example as he almost killed Eugene as a [[SinsOfTheFather group-punishment for his parent's escape even if he was not informed about it]]. Furthermore, he sold off the land of a desperate farmer just to buy a watch for his grandson.

to:

* EvilOldFolks: Hee Hui Sung's grandfather is a major example as he almost killed Eugene as a [[SinsOfTheFather group-punishment for his parent's escape even if he was not informed about it]]. Furthermore, he sold off the land of a desperate farmer just to buy a watch for his grandson.



* IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy: Realizing that Ae Shin loves Eugene, [[spoiler: Dong Mae (later Hee Sung)]] finally gives up on Ae Shin.

to:

* IWantMyBelovedToBeHappy: Realizing that Ae Shin loves Eugene, [[spoiler: Dong Mae (later Hee Sung)]] finally gives Mae--and eventually Hui Sung too--]]gives up on Ae Shin.Shin. Despite very much wanting the marriage to happen, Hui Sung joins Ae Sin to formally beg her grandfather to allow them to break the engagement, even claiming it is his wish.



* LoveDodecahedron: Hoo, boy. Eugene loves Ae Shin and she loves him, but he was born as a slave and she was a noble. To complicate matters, Hee Sung is Ae Shin's Fiance, Dong Mae has feelings towards Ae Shin since they were kids, and Hina falls in love with Eugene, but after realizing that Eugene and Ae Shin are meant for each other, she falls again for Dong Mae. It still fails since Dong Mae has no interest towards her. Poor girl, she really wanted a hug.

to:

* LoveDodecahedron: Hoo, boy. Eugene loves Ae Shin and she loves him, but he was born as a slave and she was a noble. To complicate matters, Hee Hui Sung is Ae Shin's Fiance, Dong Mae has feelings towards Ae Shin since they were kids, and Hina falls in love with Eugene, but after realizing that Eugene and Ae Shin are meant for each other, she falls again for Dong Mae. It still fails since Dong Mae has no interest towards her. Poor girl, she really wanted a hug.

Added: 249

Changed: 468

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EvilChancellor: Though more towards stubborn and arrogant, Gojong's regent basically advise entire court to be more hawkish while ignoring the words of [[OnlySaneMan realistic-minded bureaucrats]] that their "inferior barbarian" invaders have superiority in military and technology. Also the fact that entire country's military is too busy with quelling unrest didn't help the matters of sparing additional soldiers for foreign defense. After their "defense" ended with massive casualties in a CurbStompBattle, he intends to condemn the surviving soldiers for "cowardice", which Seung-goo and other prisoners were disillusioned with their government after they were spared by an American commander and the news of the regent's words were shared.

to:

* EvilChancellor: Though more towards stubborn and arrogant, Downplayed. Gojong's regent basically advise entire is moral, but fatally stubborn and arrogant. He exhorts the court to be more hawkish while ignoring and ignores the words of more [[OnlySaneMan realistic-minded bureaucrats]] who recognize that their "inferior barbarian" invaders have superiority in military and technology. Also the fact that entire country's technological superiority. The Joseon military is too busy with quelling unrest didn't help the matters of and has difficulty sparing additional soldiers for foreign defense. After defense. And when their "defense" ended with [[CurbStompBattle massive casualties in a CurbStompBattle, casualties]], he intends to condemn condemns the surviving soldiers for "cowardice", "cowardice," which directly results in Seung-goo and other prisoners were disillusioned with their government after they were spared by an American commander and joining the news of the regent's words were shared. revolutionaries.


Added DiffLines:

* WorthyOpponent: The Americans abandon their invasion and return their prisoners with elaborate apologies and compliments for the courage and skill of the defenders. Since they had no reason to fear retaliation, one could assume they were sincere.

Added: 381

Changed: 5

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MoralityPet: Dong-mae has a pretty-but-mute fortune-teller living with him named Hotaru; she is slavishly devoted to him, and he treats her with uncharacteristic gentleness. Similarly, he has a strangely Platonic friendship with the beautiful Hina. They consult with each other on their business ventures, and are comfortable enough to walk into each other's rooms unannounced.



* NeverLearnedToRead: DownplayedTrope, Eugene only know how to read and write in English but lack the same ability in Korean due to his upbringing as a slave. In fact, he only learned basic literacy in Korean later in the series.
* PairTheSpares: Subverted. [[spoiler:A more conventional story would have had Dong-mae and Kudo Hina live happily ever after. Instead, Hina confesses her unrequited love [[EveryoneDies shortly before both die]].]]

to:

* NeverLearnedToRead: DownplayedTrope, Eugene only know how to read and write in English but lack lacks the same ability in Korean due to his upbringing as a slave. In fact, he only learned basic literacy in Korean later in the series.
* PairTheSpares: Subverted. [[spoiler:A more conventional story would have had Dong-mae and Kudo Hina live happily ever after. Instead, Hina confesses her unrequited love [[EveryoneDies shortly before both ''both'' die]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PiratesWhoDontDoAnything: Averted. A lighter show might've softened the depiction of The Musin Society's shadier activities--especially since Dong-mae is a member of the main love triangle--but nope! We see them committing murder, extorting protection money, running brothels, blackmailing widows...the list goes on.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AristocratsAreEvil: Although exceptions like [[ActionGirl Ae Shin]] and few other level-headed courtiers exists, the majority of Korean aristocrats generally ranged from callous, corrupt, backstabbing, and/or reactionary as the Joseon Dynasty came to a close.

to:

* AristocratsAreEvil: Although exceptions like [[ActionGirl Ae Shin]] and the few other level-headed courtiers exists, seem to be the exception that proves the rule. The majority of Korean aristocrats generally ranged from are some combination of callous, corrupt, backstabbing, and/or and reactionary as the Joseon Dynasty came comes to a close.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Eugene is noble and brave but his cruel experiences have made him pragmatic and cold. He clearly feels empathy but rarely puts it to use.
** Dong-mae is the most problematic to like: he’s unequivocally done some very bad things, but he frequently goes out of his way to help others, or avoid harming them. It’s not always clear if it’s his affection for Ae Sin that brings out his better nature, or if he’s fighting a naturally good nature in order to survive amongst bad people.

to:

** Eugene is noble and brave but his cruel experiences have made him pragmatic and cold. He clearly feels empathy but rarely puts it to use.
** Dong-mae is the most problematic to like: he’s unequivocally done some very bad things, but he frequently goes out of his way to help others, or avoid harming them. It’s not always clear if it’s his affection for Ae Sin that brings out his better nature, or if he’s fighting a naturally good nature in order to survive amongst bad people.



* {{Eagleland}}: The United States in 1871 was portrayed as both types of the Eagleland trope. As a collective, the nation is seen as rather boorish, having sent troops to Korea in pursuit of its colonial ambitions, and exploiting Joseon economically. But individuals like Eugene and Major Moore are shown to be fundamentally good people, willing to go a long way to help many Koreans. This despite Eugene’s brutal childhood, and Moore’s duty advance U.S. interests. The show also shows that numerous nation-states of the time had similar imperial ambitions—particularly Japan and Russia.

to:

* {{Eagleland}}: The United States in 1871 was portrayed as both types of the Eagleland trope. As a collective, the nation is seen as rather boorish, having sent troops to Korea in pursuit of its colonial ambitions, and exploiting Joseon economically. But individuals like Eugene and Major Moore are shown to be fundamentally good people, willing to go a long way to help many Koreans. This despite Eugene’s brutal childhood, and Moore’s duty to advance U.S. interests. The show also shows that numerous nation-states of the time had similar imperial ambitions—particularly Japan and Russia.



* PairTheSpares: Subverted. [[spoiler:A more conventional story would have had Dong-mae and Kudo Hina live happily ever after. Instead, Kudo Hina confesses her unrequited love [[EveryoneDies shortly before ‘’both’’ die]].]]

to:

* PairTheSpares: Subverted. [[spoiler:A more conventional story would have had Dong-mae and Kudo Hina live happily ever after. Instead, Kudo Hina confesses her unrequited love [[EveryoneDies shortly before ‘’both’’ both die]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Eugene is noble and brave but his cruel experiences have made him pragmatic and cold. He clearly feels empathy but rarely puts it to use.
** Dong-mae is the most problematic to like: he’s unequivocally done some very bad things, but he frequently goes out of his way to help others, or avoid harming them. It’s not always clear if it’s a case of NotAsEvilAsYouCouldHaveBeen, or if he’s fighting a naturally good nature in order to survive amongst bad people.

to:

** Eugene is noble and brave but his cruel experiences have made him pragmatic and cold. He clearly feels empathy but rarely puts it to use.
** Dong-mae is the most problematic to like: he’s unequivocally done some very bad things, but he frequently goes out of his way to help others, or avoid harming them. It’s not always clear if it’s a case of NotAsEvilAsYouCouldHaveBeen, his affection for Ae Sin that brings out his better nature, or if he’s fighting a naturally good nature in order to survive amongst bad people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ByronicHero: All three of Ae Sin’s suitors, each in their own way.
** Hee Sung is nice enough, but he’s a dilettante and a womanizer with no real ambition.
** Eugene is noble and brave but his cruel experiences have made him pragmatic and cold. He clearly feels empathy but rarely puts it to use.
** Dong-mae is the most problematic to like: he’s unequivocally done some very bad things, but he frequently goes out of his way to help others, or avoid harming them. It’s not always clear if it’s a case of NotAsEvilAsYouCouldHaveBeen, or if he’s fighting a naturally good nature in order to survive amongst bad people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PairTheSpares: Subverted. [[spoiler:A more conventional story would have had Dong-mae and Kudo Hina live happily ever after. Instead, Kudo Hina confesses her unrequited love [[EveryoneDies shortly before ‘’both’’ die]].]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FriendlyEnemies: Despite the fact that Eugene and Dong-mae are natural enemies, being from rival countries and in love with the same woman, their conversations always instantly de-escalate from “menacing subtext” to sounding more like [[VitriolicBestBuds two old friends just taking the piss out of each other]].

Added: 1184

Changed: 510

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Eagleland}}: The United States in 1871 was portrayed as a somewhat Boorish-leaning mixed example as it sent troops to Korea in its colonial ambitions and diplomatic connections after the Spanish-American War, but Eugene is a Beautiful example who help many Koreans despite his mixed opinions on Joseon Dynasty as it experienced its downfall. Though in fairness, every powerful nation states--especially Japan-- have [[NotSoDifferent similar goals towards imperial ambitions]].

to:

* DevelopingDoomedCharacters: [[spoiler:All but one of the main characters die, and most of the supporting characters as well.]]
* {{Eagleland}}: The United States in 1871 was portrayed as both types of the Eagleland trope. As a somewhat Boorish-leaning mixed example collective, the nation is seen as it rather boorish, having sent troops to Korea in pursuit of its colonial ambitions ambitions, and diplomatic connections after the Spanish-American War, but exploiting Joseon economically. But individuals like Eugene is and Major Moore are shown to be fundamentally good people, willing to go a Beautiful example who long way to help many Koreans Koreans. This despite his mixed opinions on Joseon Dynasty as it experienced its downfall. Though in fairness, every powerful nation states--especially Japan-- have [[NotSoDifferent Eugene’s brutal childhood, and Moore’s duty advance U.S. interests. The show also shows that numerous nation-states of the time had similar goals towards imperial ambitions]].ambitions—particularly Japan and Russia.
* EvenEvilHasLovedOnes: The Musin Society are brutal gangsters who commit extortion and murder as a matter of course. But they are fiercely loyal to each other and to their leader, Dong-Mae. Dong-Mae calls them “family” at one point.


Added DiffLines:

* FemmeFatale: Kudo Hina, beautiful young widow of a wealthy old man. She doesn’t go out of her way to look like she’s mourning the man who cruelly abused her, and then dropped dead one day of mysterious circumstances. Instead, she spends her time manipulating the Japanese occupiers and influencing political events. Oh, and getting richer by the minute.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NeverLearnedToRead: DownplayedTrope, Eugene only know how to read and write in English but lack the same ability in Korean due to his upbringing as a slave. In fact, he only learned basic literacy in Korean later in the series.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Lee Se-Hoon accidentally shot one of his servants when he tried to use a Japanese pistol while being attacked by a marksman.

to:

** Lee Se-Hoon accidentally shot one of his servants when he tried attempted to figure out how to use a Japanese pistol while being attacked by a marksman.

Added: 146

Changed: 130

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GreyAndGrayMorality: Everyone in the show basically had its flaws and strengths. Eugene only felt loyalty to [[{{Eagleland}} the United States]] since he had a bad childhood as a child born to a family of slaves, but he is nonetheless willing to help Joseon if possible. Joseon Dynasty is defending their culture and independence but they suffered from general divide among the nobility (some influential aristocrats being pro-Japanese) and many commoners on the Righteous Army only had ties with them as an EnemyMine situation. While the series portrayed Imperial Japan as villainous, many characters ranged from generally kind people to sociopaths. In addition, many LesCollaborateurs characters--especially lower-ranking people like Dong-Mae--founded Japan as for a chance to advance their stations restricted by their home country.

to:

* GreyAndGrayMorality: Everyone in the show basically had its flaws and strengths. Eugene only felt loyalty to [[{{Eagleland}} the United States]] since he had a bad childhood in Joseon-era Korea as a child born to a family of slaves, but he is nonetheless willing to help Joseon if possible. Joseon Dynasty is defending their culture and independence but they suffered from general divide among the nobility (some influential aristocrats being pro-Japanese) and many commoners on the Righteous Army only had ties with them as an EnemyMine situation.situation since they dislike the court aristocracy and the king but only shared in their goals of their own sovereignty. While the series portrayed Imperial Japan as villainous, many characters ranged from generally kind people to sociopaths. In addition, many LesCollaborateurs characters--especially lower-ranking people like Dong-Mae--founded Japan as for a chance to advance their stations restricted by their home country.


Added DiffLines:

* RecklessGunUsage:
** Lee Se-Hoon accidentally shot one of his servants when he tried to use a Japanese pistol while being attacked by a marksman.

Top